Trump's pope image brings condemnation from some; others call it a jest
Snapshot of US President Donald Trump's post of an AI-based image depicting him as the pope on Truth Social. (Photo: @realDonaldTrump / Truth Social)
By Kate Scanlon, OSV News
President Donald Trump posted an image that appeared to be created by artificial intelligence depicting himself as the pope just days after he had commented to reporters that he would like to become the next pope.
The image drew condemnation from some church leaders and commentators, while some defended it as a jest.
Trump posted the AI image of himself in what appeared to be the traditional vestments of the pope late in the evening on May 2 on his website, Truth Social, with no caption. However, the image sparked controversy when it was shared on the official White House X account.
Bishop Thomas J. Paprocki of Springfield, Illinois, said Trump should apologize for the image, which he called "deeply offensive to Catholics, especially during this sacred time that we are still mourning the death of Pope Francis and praying for the guidance of the Holy Spirit for the election of our new Pope."
"He owes an apology," Bishop Paprocki said, arguing, "'Make no mistake: God is not mocked' (Galatians 6:7). The Pope is the Vicar of Christ. By publishing a picture of himself masquerading as the Pope, President Trump mocks God, the Catholic Church, and the Papacy."
Joshua Mercer, vice president of CatholicVote, a right-leaning political advocacy organization that endorsed Trump's presidential bid, argued in a statement, "Trump's joking meme depicting himself as the pope was obviously intended to be humorous."
"There is no need to imagine that he believes he could be pope, or that he intended to mock the papacy," Mercer said. "Memes depicting famous people as the new pope have been playfully circulating on social media everywhere for the past week."
But the New York State Catholic Conference wrote on X, "There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr. President."
"We just buried our beloved Pope Francis, and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St. Peter," the conference's post said. "Do not mock us."
Asked for comment, Dennis Poust, executive director of that organization, said, "It is difficult to say what the president's intent was in posting the photo, but a reasonable person would easily conclude that it would likely be offensive to Catholics, especially as we are still mourning Pope Francis."
"I don't believe President Trump is anti-Catholic, but the post was definitely shocking and offensive to many, and I hope he pulls it down and stops this peculiar line of trolling or whatever it is he is doing," Poust said.
"The fact that the official White House X account shared it made the whole thing worse in my mind, since it gave the post the weight of the Office of President, as opposed to just being perhaps a crude joke by Donald Trump, the individual."
The post came a few days after Trump was asked by a reporter who he would like to see become the next Catholic pope. In reply, he appeared to joke, "I'd like to be pope. That would be my No. 1 choice."
But then Trump said he had no preference, adding, "I must say, we have a cardinal that happens to be out of a place called New York who's very good, so we'll see what happens," in reference to Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan of New York, whom Trump named to a religious liberty commission the same week.
In his statement, Mercer argued, "Today's loudest critics were shamefully silent for four years as President (Joe) Biden, himself a Catholic, was a manifest scandal to the Church."
"That said, this is a solemn time of prayer and discernment for the whole Catholic Church that should not be diminished," Mercer said. "The Church has survived far worse over the past two millennia."
Vice President JD Vance defended Trump on X, arguing, "As a general rule, I'm fine with people telling jokes and not fine with people starting stupid wars that kill thousands of my countrymen," Vance wrote in response to a post from Bill Kristol, editor-at-large of The Bulwark, asking whether Vance was "fine with this disrespect and mocking of the Holy Father."
But Bishop Daniel E. Flores of Brownsville, Texas, wrote on X in an apparent reference to the controversy, "Just when you thought it was safe to go back to checking your timeline once in a while."
"Read a good book, folks, go visit an elderly relative, anything to keep the algorithms from eating your soul," he said.
Trump attended the funeral of the late Pope Francis on April 26.--ucanews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
11 minutes ago
- The Star
India shifts to damage control after Trump ramps up threats
NEW DELHI: India's government is scrambling to contain the economic fallout from President Donald Trump's threatened tariff action, which has left officials in New Delhi reeling on how to respond. Trump's latest tirade caught officials in India's capital off guard. The president's language - calling India's economy "dead,' its tariff barriers "obnoxious' and saying India is indifferent to the plight of Ukrainians - has been very atypical and akin to a verbal slap in the face, an official in New Delhi said, asking not to be identified as the discussions are private. Officials have no template to deal with these kinds of public assaults, the person said, adding that the latest turn of events has put a strain on India's relationship with the US. Trump said Tuesday (Aug 5) he'll increase the 25 per cent tariff on Indian exports to the US "substantially over the next 24 hours,' citing the Asian nation's high barriers to trade and its purchases of Russian oil. India was "fuelling the war machine, and if they're going to do that, I'm not going to be happy,' Trump told CNBC. India's government is now bracing for high tariffs and seeking to limit the possible economic damage. The Ministry of Commerce and Industry is discussing ways to help exporters who would be hardest hit, such as in the gems and jewellery and textile sectors. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been urging Indians to buy local goods to offset any slump in global demand. And officials say they will continue to seek back-channel talks to help ease the tensions. India has been a target of Trump for weeks now because of its Russian ties. Trump's aides say energy purchases by countries like India and China are helping to keep Russia's economy afloat as its leader Vladimir Putin wages war with Ukraine. The US president has given Putin until Aug. 8 to reach a truce in the conflict. Modi's government is so far holding its ground, saying it's being unreasonably targeted by the US for its ties to Russia - its biggest supplier of oil and military equipment. Officials have signaled they won't instruct refiners to halt Russian crude purchases, while Modi has urged Indians to buy more local goods to bolster Asia's third-largest economy. For months trade officials had been negotiating with the Trump administration on a deal that both sides had been signalling was close to being finalised, with a tariff rate possibly below 20 per cent. The US president's tone appeared to change last month, when he threatened India with higher duties alongside others in the BRICS bloc of nations for what he said was the group's anti-US stance. He then followed up several days later with warnings about financial penalties on countries like India for buying oil from Russia. India has been buying Russian crude at a rate of about 1.7 million barrels a day so far this year, all of it from seaborne imports, while China has purchased an average of about two million barrels, comprising both seaborne imports as well as oil that's transported via an inland pipeline. To offset the tariff hikes, officials in New Delhi are now considering expediting an export promotion plan, first outlined in the February budget, which set aside 22.5 billion rupees (US$256 million) to support exporters. The budgeted amount may be increased to help businesses offset potential losses resulting from greater competition with regional rivals, who have secured lower tariff rates of around 15-20 per cent, a person familiar with the matter said. The discussions are still ongoing and the government hasn't made any decision on what kind of support it will provide, the person said. India's Ministry of Commerce and Industry and Ministry of Finance didn't immediately respond to emails seeking further information. New Delhi is also weighing easing some dairy market access rules for the US in order to placate Trump, officials familiar with the matter said. The government is discussing whether it can allow limited imports of some dairy products, such as cheese not made in India and condensed milk with clear labelling of the animal feed used in manufacturing, they said. India maintains tariffs of as high as 60 per cent on dairy products to protect its local industry and enforces strict rules to ensure imported dairy products aren't from cattle fed animal-based in order to adhere to religious sensitivities. Any easing of restrictions in the dairy sector would represent a significant concession by India, which didn't grant the UK any similar market access in a recently concluded free trade agreement. Economists estimate that a 25 per cent tariff could cut India's gross domestic product growth by 0.3 percentage point. Pranjul Bhandari, chief India economist at HSBC Holdings Plc., said an additional penalty would curb growth further, resulting in lower capital inflows and investment. An internal assessment by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry shows that a 25 per cent tariff would impact about 10 per cent of India's exports in July to September. Modi's rivals have criticised his previously friendly ties with Trump and called him out for his silence on the US leader's comments. "We are receiving threats - that there will be more than 25 per cent tariffs and we are being told that we should not buy oil from Russia. This friendship has turned out to be expensive,' Jairam Ramesh, a senior leader in the main opposition Indian National Congress, told reporters Tuesday. Trump's actions will push India to react, although it's unlikely to retaliate and will more likely seek further talks with the US, said Indrani Bagchi, chief executive officer at Ananta Centre, a Delhi-based think tank. "My sense is the government will contain this and will not take this forward, will not escalate,' she said. India will want to continue the trade deal negotiations in spite of Trump's "personal anger,' she said. The US president likely wants to have Modi call him and "fold in the way that other countries have,' she said. "That is not India's style.' - Bloomberg
The Sun
11 minutes ago
- The Sun
US envoy Witkoff heads to Moscow amid Ukraine war tensions
MOSCOW: US envoy Steve Witkoff will hold meetings with Russian officials on Wednesday, a US source confirmed, as President Donald Trump's deadline to impose new sanctions over Russia's war in Ukraine approaches. The source did not clarify whether Witkoff would meet Russian President Vladimir Putin, though the two have held discussions multiple times before. Trump has set Friday as the cutoff for Russia to halt its offensive in Ukraine or face additional penalties. While the White House has not detailed specific measures, Trump previously warned of 'secondary tariffs' targeting Russia's trade partners, including China and India. Such a move could disrupt global trade while aiming to curb Russian exports. Despite international pressure, Russia's military campaign in Ukraine persists. Three rounds of peace talks in Istanbul have failed to bridge gaps between the warring sides. Moscow insists Ukraine must surrender more territory and abandon Western alliances, while Kyiv demands an immediate ceasefire. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky recently called for allies to pursue 'regime change' in Russia. Trump has grown increasingly critical of Putin's refusal to de-escalate. When asked about Witkoff's message to Moscow, Trump stated, 'Yeah, get a deal where people stop getting killed.' Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov described the upcoming talks as 'important, substantial, and helpful,' praising US efforts to resolve the conflict. Putin reiterated on Friday that his conditions for ending the war—including Ukraine's surrender of four annexed regions and abandonment of NATO aspirations—remain unchanged. Meanwhile, Trump's recent deployment of nuclear submarines near Russia has drawn cautious reactions from Moscow. Peskov urged restraint, emphasizing Russia's commitment to nuclear non-proliferation. - AFP
The Sun
11 minutes ago
- The Sun
Swiss president races to US to prevent 39% tariff hike
WASHINGTON: Switzerland's president was in Washington on Tuesday in a last-minute push to stop steep new tariffs, but with no appointment to plead her case to US President Donald Trump. Switzerland faces a 39-percent duty, one of the highest among the dozens of economies that will be hit by new tariffs expected to come into force from Thursday. President Karin Keller-Sutter and Economy Minister Guy Parmelin were visiting Washington 'to facilitate meetings with the US authorities at short notice and hold talks with a view to improving the tariff situation for Switzerland,' the government said in a statement. 'The aim is to present a more attractive offer to the United States in a bid to lower the level of reciprocal tariffs for Swiss exports, taking US concerns into account.' But a White House official told AFP there was 'no meeting with the President scheduled at this time.' Trump had originally threatened in April to slap a 31-percent tariff on Switzerland. But he surprised the export-driven country last week when he decided to hike the rate to 39 percent despite numerous discussions between Swiss and US officials aimed at reaching a deal. The Swiss government noted that the country will be hit by much higher tariffs than what other wealthy economies, such as Britain, Japan or the European Union, are facing. The government 'reaffirmed that it was keen to pursue talks with the United States on the tariff situation,' and the president and economy minister were visiting Washington 'for this reason,' Tuesday's statement said. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, however, told CBS television on Sunday that the tariffs on global trading partners, which are coming into force this week, 'are pretty much set.' Trump signaled that a separate initially 'small' tariff on imports of pharmaceuticals from around the world -- a key sector for Switzerland -- could come 'within the next week.' But the sector-specific tariff could rise to 150 percent in a year and eventually be as high as 250 percent, he added, saying the delay was to allow companies to shift production to the United States. Pharmaceuticals represented 60 percent of Swiss goods exports to the United States last year. Swiss surplus Keller-Sutter and Parmelin were accompanied by a small delegation, including the heads of the economy and international finance departments, a Swiss government official said. But the official declined to give details about the potential meetings. The government said it will 'issue a statement as soon as there are any relevant developments for the public.' The United States is a key trading partner for Switzerland, taking 18.6 percent of its total exports last year, according to Swiss customs data. Keller-Sutter has said Trump believes that Switzerland 'steals' from the United States by enjoying a trade surplus of 40 billion Swiss francs ($50 billion). Swiss companies have urged the government to negotiate a lower tariff. 'I am convinced that Donald Trump wants to make a deal and show it to his US voters,' Nik Hayek, the head of watch firm Swatch, told Le Temps newspaper in an interview published late Monday. But, Hayek added, 'President Karin Keller-Sutter has to react and find a solution in person there.' - AFP
