Greens release fiscal strategy that calls for more public investment
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
The Greens have made a case for more public investment, as they releases the party's fiscal strategy on Tuesday, saying the Finance Minister's "fiscal straight-jacket is junk".
Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick said the current government was "fixated on self-made constraints, while the real world crumbles around us".
Following the release of its Green Budget last month,
which was ridiculed by the coalition
, the party has released a discussion document outlining its case for a "transformed approach" to fiscal management it says would prioritise "real fiscal sustainability".
The co-leaders' foreword in the report said "if balancing the books can only be achieved by reducing our real economic capacity, then the books need to be rewritten".
Swarbrick said the party's fiscal strategy unpicked the daft 'computer says no' argument standing in the way of this critical investment.
"We show how 40 years of bad fiscal programming have produced devastating real-world results, as our hospitals, schools and infrastructure fall apart."
The document "demands recognition" that both excessive debt and insufficient investment are "equally unsustainable". It also said a "neoliberal logic" was embedded throughout New Zealand's fiscal management framework.
"However, the neoliberal prescription of privatisation, public-private partnerships and market liberalisation isn't just outdated - it's actively harming our ability to meet long-term needs."
It referenced the fiscal responsibility rules introduced in the 1980s as serving a legitimate purpose then, where constraints on borrowing and spending were an "urgent necessity", because the government had come close to defaulting on its debts.
"However, our emergency response to that debt crisis has become permanent policy and, for over 40 years, our fiscal culture has focused solely on the prevention of one type of crisis, while systematically creating others through chronic underinvestment."
The strategy document said political leaders called for ever-tighter fiscal restraint, and reminded voters of "rainy days" to come and the vulnerability of New Zealand's small open economy to natural disasters.
"However, investment to mitigate these vulnerabilities is only ever seen as a cost, while the vulnerabilities created by weakened public services are made to appear inevitable, rather than as political decisions."
The party argued public investment could enhance economic development, productivity and resilience, that would then improve, rather than undermine the country's long-term fiscal sustainability.
It also said the costs of underinvestment in things like infrastructure, climate resilience and human capital posed risks "as significant" as excessive debt.
"Both debt in excess of our real economic capacity to deliver investment and chronic underinvestment are failures of fiscal responsibility," the report said.
It said real economic constraints should guide investment decisions, rather than financial targets "divorced from their economic implications".
Responsible increases in public debt should be supported by "funding strategies", the paper went on, that "strengthen domestic financial institutions to hold that debt".
"We need to ensure that productive borrowing serves Aotearoa New Zealand's development, while maintaining greater economic sovereignty."
It argued this framework would enable the country to build enduring resilience to growing economic and environmental shocks, and create truly sustainable prosperity.
The party believed the current accounting-driven approach failed to acknowledge public investment in human, social and natural capital.
Swarbrick welcomed criticism, saying "let the government's latest round of name-calling ensue", but said the Greens were providing the most "comprehensive, real-world, evidence-based economic policy" of any party in parliament.
"They constitute the only serious plan to actually improve our economic and climate resilience, and create tens of thousands of good green jobs."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Thames MSD staff refuse to work at mould, sewage smelling office any longer
The temporary Ministry of Social Development office operated out of the Wintec Building in Queen Street, Thames until Monday. Photo: Googlemaps More than a dozen Ministry of Social Development staff walked off the job over what they say is an unsafe office with a ''strong mould and sewage smell". Staff stopped working in the ministry's Thames office on Monday, leaving 12,000 clients without a face-to-face service. The office was supposed to be a temporary space, after the Ministry of Social Development closed its main office in Pollen Street in November 2023 due to damage. But there's been ongoing issues with the temporary building. Staff moved out for a period of time last year, and last month it was closed for three days for security and privacy upgrades. The Public Service Association has now issued MSD with a Provisional Improvement Notice under the Health and Safety at Work Act, which requires the employer to address concerns about health and safety. MSD has redeployed staff to Paeroa which was 33km away. Thames Community Board chairperson Adrian Catran told Checkpoint the situation for clients trying to go to MSD was "terrible". "Twelve thousand clients in and around Thames and in the Coromandel Peninsula are unable to have face-to-face contact with MSD in Thames." Catran said it was "wrong" that clients wanting to visit MSD in person would have to travel to Paeroa. "There is no actual transport available to just travel to Paeroa at the moment, so that means they have to find their own way." MSD staff have been working in the temporary office for 18 months, despite the space originally being used as a solution for four weeks. Catran said the temporary office has had a number of issues over a long period of time. "The building is not really fit-for-purpose and had shortcomings anyway. Now it appears that has manifested itself to a point that staff won't work there. "It's had other problems in terms of the space is too small for 13 staff for example, client privacy is not available within the building to the extent that a lot of clients wanted." He said on a previous occasion the ceiling had collapsed in another room in the building. The original building had been vacated due to black mould and water leaks, but had now reopened as a fruit shop, Catran added. Last year local MP Scott Simpson issued a statement saying it was unacceptable for people to have to travel to Paeroa to see MSD staff in person, which Catran said was still relevant today. The Ministry of Social Development told Checkpoint the Thames Service Centre was temporarily closed on Monday and staff were redeployed to Paeroa Service Centre. They had access to vehicles for travel. Acting Regional Commissioner, Sharlene Horne, said MSD was working through concerns about the building in conjunction with the landlord, while also working on securing new long-term premises that met the ministry's requirements. Horne said MSD was working to reopen the Thames Service Centre as soon as possible but many of the client conversations in Thames already happened over the phone, and she expected clients should still be able to complete their appointments. PSA national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons told Checkpoint there had been long-standing issues with the working environment at the Thames office which was supposed to be a temporary site. These concerns came to a head on Monday and health and safety representatives at the office had since issued MSD with a Provisional Improvement Notice under the Health and Safety at Work Act. She said the PSA was working on ensuring workers were not disadvantaged by any alternative options proposed and that they would continue to support workers through this. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Iconic heritage-listed Cardrona Hotel goes on the market
Heritage-listed Cardrona Hotel is going on the market. Photo: Supplied to RNZ One of the country's most photographed pubs - and a fixture of the Central Otago landscape - is going on the market. Expressions of interest open on Friday for the 162-year-old, heritage-listed Cardrona Hotel. Cade Thornton, who has owned the pub with his partner Alexis and James and Fleur Jenneson since 2013, said the decision to sell was indescribably difficult. The group decided it was time to step back and focus on their young families, he said. "It's just such a friendly, happy place. It's a great environment to work and to be the custodian, the captain of that, is tremendously rewarding, and to see the place change in our time. It's defined my life, really." The hotel on the Crown Range Road between Wānaka and Queenstown included a restaurant, year-round beer garden, and 17 ensuite hotel rooms sleeping up to 44 guests. Its facade dated back to a now-vanished gold rush town that thrived in the 1860s, when Cardrona was a bustling settlement supporting thousands of Otago gold rush miners. Cade Thornton said it employed 40-50 staff, and the hotel was often fully booked. "The business is in really good stead. I've got some very long-term senior staff who love the pub and their jobs and their roles, and they want to see it through with the new owner," he said. He said the hotel attracted people from all walks of life. "We'll have guests arriving by helicopter, all dressed up for a nice meal, and then the local farmers will come in, leaving their gumboots by the door. I don't think there's any other place quite like it in New Zealand." The hotel on the Crown Range Road between Wānaka and Queenstown included a restaurant, year-round beer garden, and 17 ensuite hotel rooms sleeping up to 44 guests. Photo: Supplied to RNZ The Cardrona Hotel was being sold by private negotiation as a freehold going concern. Thornton said the owners would not be publicly disclosing a price, although in 2010, prior to expansion works, it was valued at $3 - 4 million. He hoped the next owner would have a "real passion" for the pub. "Fifty percent of buying it would be that you'd have to love it. You couldn't just look at it as a business opportunity. You'd have to be passionate about the business, the pub, its history, its potential," he said. "If someone's wanting it, who's got the means and the drive, I don't think they'd ever regret it," he said. Expressions of interest were open from Friday, 5 July until Friday, 15 August.
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
NZ-designed Apples Miss Trick By Omitting FernMark Branding In Canada
New Zealand's premium apples have been caught up in a Canadian consumer backlash of United States products. Canadian consumers have actively boycotted US products, since President Donald Trump launched his trade war, along with ongoing calls to make Canada the 51st state of America. T&G Global's premium Envy and Jazz apples exported to Canada were packaged in 2.27 kg (5lb) bags, with prominent 'product of USA' labelling, and were not immune to the consumer backlash. T&G chief operating officer for the apples business Shane Kingston said the brands were grown in more than 11 countries, across both hemispheres. "This also diversifies our geographical spread, and ensures varieties are grown in the right regions and close to markets," he said, adding that sales met expectations. "Currently, around 31 percent of T&G's apple supply is sourced from Aotearoa New Zealand, 37 percent from the Americas, 23 percent from Europe and the United Kingdom, and 9 percent from other markets." Still NZ apples While Envy and Jazz apples sold in Canada were imported from southern hemisphere locations and Washington State, they were designed in New Zealand and were eligible to carry the New Zealand Inc trademark. FernMark brand manager David Downs said the lack of New Zealand branding was a missed opportunity, given that it could be applied to any product designed, grown or made in New Zealand. "That intellectual property was developed here and there is definitely a connection to New Zealand that should be highlighted," said Downs, who was also the chief executive of NZ Story, which - a government agency tasked with helping market New Zealand to the world. "It's actually a great example of New Zealand innovation." Demand for FernMark grows "It's interesting, isn't it, that consumer sentiment can shift pretty quickly," Downs said, referring to the trade dispute in North America. "Someone in Canada suddenly being suspicious of not wanting to buy products from the United States or from another country, because of their perceived activities." He said the FernMark had been independently valued at more than US$290 billlion (NZ$478b), although the licence to use it cost relatively little for qualifying companies. "What the FernMark does is basically visibly allow you to connect your brand with the brand of New Zealand, and that visible connection and association allows you to get that value from the hundreds of millions of dollars' worth of brand value that we have as a country." He said the number of companies using New Zealand's FernMark to promote their products had more than doubled over the past couple of years and featured on products in more than 40 countries. More than 600 companies used the FernMark on some two billion products, with food products one of the biggest users. "Some of those companies are very, very big, with tens of thousands of SKU's [stock items]." Recent research indicated 46 percent of international consumers recognised the FernMark, and 44 percent said they were more likely or a lot more likely to buy a product because it. "More and more in this disrupted world, reputation is what matters," Downs said. "For us, for a relatively small economy like New Zealand, it's important we protect our reputation. "That's not the job of just politicians. It's also the job of exporters and all of us."
