logo
'Noise sensitive' woman blows her entire £100,000 inheritance in 'sad, wasteful and expensive' court fight with her sisters over their mother's £420,000 home

'Noise sensitive' woman blows her entire £100,000 inheritance in 'sad, wasteful and expensive' court fight with her sisters over their mother's £420,000 home

Daily Mail​09-07-2025
A 'noise sensitive' woman who took her sisters to court in a bid to keep their late mother's home for herself has been warned she has likely blown her entire £100,000-plus inheritance on a 'wasteful' legal fight.
Sharon Duggan, 49, was left a third of the share of her mother's £420,000 home, but dramatically sparked a bitter inheritance battle after claiming she needed the house for her and her two emotional support dogs.
The 'hyper-vigilant' and sound sensitive' woman sued her sisters, Ann and Brenda Duggan, claiming she needed their mother's house because she could not bear living in a noisy flat.
However, her case was kicked out at Central London County Court last month - and she now faces having to pay all of the lawyers' bills for the 'extremely wasteful and expensive' dispute.
Ordering her to stump up for the costs - yet to be calculated exactly - Judge Alan Johns KC said the 'grim reality' was that it would be 'highly likely' to wipe out the share of her mother's estate she is rightfully due.
'This marks a sad end to a sad case,' he said. 'It is likely that Sharon will be left with nothing of the £100,000 or more that otherwise would have been her inheritance.
'That is the heavy price to be paid by her for pursuing this litigation to trial.'
The court heard how Agnes Duggan left her house, thought to be worth about £420,000, to be split equally between her three daughters, former NHS worker Sharon, alternative therapist Brenda, 55, and oldest sister Ann, 60.
But Sharon - who said she 'is dyslexic and suffers from a variety of health issues, including chronic fatigue syndrome, migraine, fibromyalgia, depression, anxiety, insomnia, PTSD, and Adjustment Disorder (and) also has long Covid' - claimed the house for herself and her therapeutic rescue dogs.
She sued her sisters under the 1975 Inheritance Act, claiming 'reasonable provision' above her one-third share of her mother's fortune.
She claimed her special sensitivity and medical ailments mean she should get at least a life interest in the property in Lyndhurst Close, Crawley.
She insisted that her needs outweighed her sisters' right to get the inheritance they are due, also arguing that it would be hard to find alternative accommodation for both her and her two dogs, which 'help with her mental and emotional well-being'.
Sharon claimed she 'sacrificed' her career to move in and help out her mother in 2014, also claiming her mother was planning to change her will to ensure the house was left to her.
As well as helping her mother out with her daily needs, she claimed to have spent £30,000 of her own money on funding Agnes' hefty vet bills for her beloved Jack Russell/Chihuahua cross, Lady.
In her written arguments to the court, Sharon insisted that 'psychologically she could not cope with living in a flat again,' adding: 'She is anxious that neighbours may cause disturbances and impact upon her ability to sleep.
'She now has two rescue dogs, which help with her mental and emotional well-being, but which makes finding suitable alternative accommodation difficult.'
In the witness box, she insisted that downsizing to a flat would be too much for her, telling the court: 'I have two dogs to consider and I am hyper-vigilant and sound-sensitive.'
She argued she should be allowed to buy out her sisters for a small sum to be raised by a mortgage or alternatively the right to stay there for life.
Although Ann remained neutral in the dispute, Brenda - who formerly ran a bioresonance therapy company and a business providing gluten-free altar bread to food-intolerant Catholics - fought the case, insisting Sharon and her pets will be fine in a flat.
Giving judgment last month, Judge Johns accepted that Sharon has 'particular issues,' but ultimately ruled that a flat could not be ruled out as 'suitable' accommodation for her.
Ruling against Sharon, Judge Johns said: 'It's my judgment that there has been no failure to make reasonable financial provision for her.
'I am not satisfied there was any promise that the property would be Sharon's - and certainly not a promise that Sharon was confident would be carried out.
'This is a modest estate and Agnes had two other daughters to think of. Essentially, provision was made for Sharon by giving her one third of the estate.'
The decision left all three sisters due to inherit assets worth about £100,000 from their mother after estate costs, but Judge Johns last week said Sharon's share would almost definitely now be wiped out.
Returning to court to decide who should pay the costs of the trial, lawyers for Brenda and for their mother's estate argued that neither should be left out of pocket when it was Sharon who brought the case.
Brenda's barrister, Alex Findlay, told the judge that offers had been made to Sharon pre-trial which would have seen her receive extra money, but she had refused.
'This has been extremely wasteful and expensive litigation, to say nothing of the stress,' he said.
Giving judgment, Judge Johns said: 'It is submitted that Sharon should not be allowed to walk away without any costs order being made - I agree.'
He ordered that she pay the lawyers' bills of both Brenda and their mother's estate, with the sums to be assessed at a later date, but estimated at over the £100,000-plus she is due to inherit.
'The grim reality of this litigation is likely to be that all of Sharon's share will be burned up by the costs, so she will end up with nothing,' he said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The endometriosis symptoms women should look out for
The endometriosis symptoms women should look out for

The Independent

time27 minutes ago

  • The Independent

The endometriosis symptoms women should look out for

British singer and songwriter Ella Henderson announced she received an official diagnosis of endometriosis in January, describing it as a validating and empowering experience after years of struggling with physical pain and mental health. Endometriosis is a chronic inflammatory condition affecting one in 10 women and those assigned female at birth in the UK, where tissue similar to the uterine lining grows outside the uterus, often leading to significant pain. Key symptoms include painful periods, painful intercourse, bowel issues, and can also involve chest pain during menstruation, difficulty conceiving, and ovarian cysts. Diagnosis can be challenging as the condition may not always show on standard imaging, with experts advising individuals to consult their GP and keep a detailed symptom diary if they suspect they have the condition. Treatment options for endometriosis vary from hormonal therapies, such as the combined pill or progesterone-only pill, to surgical procedures like laparoscopy, which can both diagnose and excise the affected tissue.

Wes Streeting orders his officials to turn their focus to keeping patients safe during doctors strikes after peace talks with the British Medical Association broke down
Wes Streeting orders his officials to turn their focus to keeping patients safe during doctors strikes after peace talks with the British Medical Association broke down

Daily Mail​

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mail​

Wes Streeting orders his officials to turn their focus to keeping patients safe during doctors strikes after peace talks with the British Medical Association broke down

Wes Streeting has ordered his officials to turn their focus to keeping patients safe during doctors strikes after union peace talks broke down. The health secretary has told the British Medical Association that 'all areas of engagement' with its leaders will now 'cease' so mandarins can 'prioritise minimising the impact of the strike action'. He said it is clear they have 'chosen a path of full dispute', showing 'scant regard for patients' and and accused them of failing to act in 'good faith'. Up to 50,000 resident doctors - formerly known as junior doctors - will walkout for five days from 7am on Friday in pursuit of a 29 per cent pay rise. They have already received above inflation pay rises for the past three years, worth an extra 28.9 per cent in total, following previous strikes. The BMA and Department of Health and Social Care held talks over the weekend with the aim of negotiating a settlement. But the BMA's resident doctors committee rejected the proposal on Tuesday and said it would plough ahead with industrial action. Mr Streeting responded to the leaders of the RDC today criticising them for turning their back on a deal in favour of a 'reckless and irresponsible' walkout. In a letter, seen by the Daily Mail, he wrote: 'The decision taken by your committee to commence strike action this week is reckless and irresponsible. 'Strike action should always be a last resort. 'Instead, it seems to be the BMA RDC's weapon of choice, with scant regard for patients or other NHS staff who will be left picking up the pieces of your actions.' He said he had been clear he could not offer higher pay rises but was willing to negotiate on other areas that would improve their finances and working conditions. 'There have been multiple discussions in which it is now clear that you have not engaged in the same good faith,' he added. 'Strike action costs the NHS in so many ways, and there are significant implications not only to patients but on the improvements that this government can deliver to the NHS for everyone. 'With strikes going ahead, I cannot in good conscience let patients, or other NHS staff pay the price for your decision. 'You have clearly chosen a path of full dispute, and this has consequences for the whole of the NHS system. 'I will therefore be asking my department to prioritise minimising the impact of the strike action and all areas of engagement with the BMA RDC will, by virtue of your decision, now cease.' Mr Streeting said he came into office with a 'genuine desire' to work with the resident doctors to improve their lives but they have 'squandered that opportunity and exhausted our good will'. He finished by urging them to reconsider their position and said resident doctors on the frontline would have a 'better path to a brighter future' if they had 'better leadership'. Membership groups representing NHS managers have warned the strikes will cause widespread disruption and put patients at risk of harm. Opinion polls show the public is opposed to the industrial action, which could see consultant members of the BMA cashing in by charging £6,000 to cover on-call rotas over the weekend. The union says the pay of resident doctors has been cut in real terms since 2008 and it wants to achieve full pay restoration.

Doctors offered cheaper lunches in last-ditch effort by Wes Streeting to avoid five-day strike but rejected deal
Doctors offered cheaper lunches in last-ditch effort by Wes Streeting to avoid five-day strike but rejected deal

The Sun

time2 hours ago

  • The Sun

Doctors offered cheaper lunches in last-ditch effort by Wes Streeting to avoid five-day strike but rejected deal

WES Streeting offered resident doctors cheaper lunches in a last-ditch effort to avert strike action - but they still rejected a deal. The Sun can reveal the Health Secretary's final snubbed offer to the British Medical Association ahead of tomorrow's five-day walkout. 1 While warning he 'cannot move on pay', he proposed to reduce the costs of exams, equipment, and even 'food and drink costs experienced by doctors'. Mr Streeting also stressed a £100million investment in post-graduate training places in 2027/28. A letter sent on Monday - since rejected - said: 'We can resolve this dispute without the need for strike action, and I urge you to seriously consider my offer for a way forward. 'Postponing your strike action to allow discussions to take place does not cost you anything, and your mandate to undertake strike action remains intact.' Striking doctors could be heading for their lowest picket line turnout since the pay row began. Just 27,000 voted 'yes' to walkouts - the lowest so far. The strongest turnout was in March 2023 as 29,000 downed tools each day, after 36,000 voted to. 'If the turnout is the same as the first strike, there will be 21,000 at the picket line. Those who voted 'no' quadrupled to 2,956. Sean Phillips, of the Policy Exchange think tank, said: 'The indications are this turnout will be lower, given a reduced mandate for strikes.' Hospitals have this time refused to cancel appointments. But the BMA's Ross Nieuwoudt said if hospital chiefs fail to cover A&E by doing so it could be 'a dereliction of duty'. BMA chair Dr Tom Dolphin was criticised after appearing to compare US murder suspect Luigi Mangione to Jesus in an online post.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store