logo
Exclusive: 'Every Day Is a Fight for Survival in Gaza" says Genocide Scholar Dr. Melanie O'Brien

Exclusive: 'Every Day Is a Fight for Survival in Gaza" says Genocide Scholar Dr. Melanie O'Brien

India Today22-06-2025
In an exclusive interview, Dr. Melanie O'Brien, President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS), provides critical insights into the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the complex legal framework surrounding genocide prevention. Dr. O'Brien emphasises that understanding genocide requires a comprehensive historical perspective. "In genocide studies, we call genocide a process, not an event, and that's why we look beyond today, beyond yesterday, going back several years to see what has happened in terms of human rights abuses, and particularly persecution and discrimination of a particular targeted group," she explains.advertisement
The legal definition of genocide centers on specific intent, which Dr. O'Brien notes creates significant challenges in prosecution. "Genocide is defined as the destruction in whole or in part of a group... carried out through one of five different crimes including killing and causing serious bodily or mental harm," she states. "The intent to destroy a particular group is what makes genocide different and also quite difficult to prove in a court of law because you have to be able to prove that the perpetrators intended to destroy that people."Regarding the current situation in Gaza, Dr. O'Brien points to several concerning patterns. "We are seeing indiscriminate bombing, long-term indiscriminate bombing that is killing people, that is destroying livelihoods, that is destroying infrastructure, that is destroying healthcare facilities and healthcare workers," she observes. She particularly highlights the strategic use of humanitarian aid as a weapon: "Denial of humanitarian aid, including food, healthcare, and medicine, is leading to a high likelihood of death. Therefore, you have to say their intent must be to kill, to destroy, at least in part, the Palestinian people of Gaza."advertisementDr. O'Brien also discusses the psychological warfare tactics employed, noting that "Israeli military open firing on people queuing for food, resulting in deaths, is designed to create fear so that people don't even want to try and get food, because that is just another situation where they risk death."The scholar acknowledges the historical context whilst maintaining legal clarity: "The genocide convention came about in part as a result of the Holocaust... The Jewish people have an existential fear that someone will destroy their people because it happened to them." However, she firmly states that "even if Israel had a right to self-defense against an armed attack from Hamas, there is certainly no justification for the commission of genocide."Dr. O'Brien criticises the international community's response, particularly highlighting how "the Security Council system, with the veto power of the permanent five members including the United States, essentially prevents any action from being taken regarding this situation." She notes that while "there are arrest warrants that the International Criminal Court has issued against Benjamin Netanyahu and the former defense minister of Israel Yav Galant, waiting for implementation," meaningful enforcement remains elusive.The human cost remains paramount in Dr. O'Brien's analysis: "On the ground in Gaza, every individual is hoping they survive each day, not knowing where their food will come from or whether they will be bombed or shot at."Must Watch
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump blames Hamas for Gaza ceasefire collapse, signals Israel should 'finish the job'
Trump blames Hamas for Gaza ceasefire collapse, signals Israel should 'finish the job'

Time of India

time37 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Trump blames Hamas for Gaza ceasefire collapse, signals Israel should 'finish the job'

US President Donald Trump on Friday blamed Hamas for the breakdown of Gaza ceasefire talks, signalling support for Israel to escalate its military campaign, CNN reported. "I think they want to die, and it's very, very bad," Trump said of Hamas while speaking to reporters before departing for a weekend trip to Scotland. "It got to be to a point where you're gonna have to finish the job." Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Finance Public Policy Others Data Science Digital Marketing Technology Artificial Intelligence CXO others Cybersecurity Degree PGDM Project Management Management Healthcare Leadership Design Thinking MCA MBA Product Management Data Analytics healthcare Data Science Operations Management Skills you'll gain: Duration: 9 Months IIM Calcutta SEPO - IIMC CFO India Starts on undefined Get Details Skills you'll gain: Duration: 7 Months S P Jain Institute of Management and Research CERT-SPJIMR Fintech & Blockchain India Starts on undefined Get Details The comments marked a clear shift from just weeks ago when Trump appeared confident a deal was close that would end the conflict, release remaining hostages, and allow humanitarian aid into Gaza, CNN noted. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Inside NTUC Club's Mission to Make Golf Inclusive Golf Asia Read More This week, Trump's administration pulled back its negotiators from talks in Doha, citing concerns that Hamas was not "coordinated" or "acting in good faith." Steve Witkoff, Trump's Middle East envoy, said he was exploring "alternative options" to secure the release of hostages. Trump, asked about his recent interactions with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said only that they were "sort of disappointing." He added, "They're gonna have to fight and they're gonna have to clean it up. You're gonna have to get rid of 'em." Live Events While Trump placed blame squarely on Hamas, officials in Egypt and Qatar described the current pause in talks as "normal in the context of these complex negotiations." A senior Israeli official also said the talks had "not at all" collapsed. Trump claimed Hamas had little incentive to negotiate, noting the dwindling number of hostages still held. "Now we're down to the final hostages, and they know what happens after you get the final hostages, and basically, because of that, they really didn't want to make a deal," Trump said. US officials said the administration hopes Trump's firm rhetoric and Witkoff's withdrawal will pressure Hamas to return to the table, according to CNN. State Department spokeswoman Tammy Bruce said, "We've tried. The world has watched this. What the options are -- clearly there are many tools in President Trump's tool chest, many options that Special Envoy Witkoff has." At the White House, Trump also responded to criticism over US aid, saying, "People don't know this, and we didn't certainly get any acknowledgement or thank you, but we contributed $60 million to food and supplies and everything else. We hope the money gets there, because you know, that money gets taken. The food gets taken. We're going to do more, but we gave a lot of money." An internal US review has found no evidence of widespread theft of US-funded aid by Hamas in Gaza, CNN said. Trump is scheduled to meet British Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Scotland over the weekend. On Friday, Starmer called Israel's military escalation in Gaza "indefensible." French President Emmanuel Macron also drew global attention by announcing France would recognize a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly in September. Trump dismissed the move, telling reporters, "The statement doesn't carry any weight. He's a very good guy. I like him. But that statement doesn't carry weight."

Gaza: Hunger deaths rise to 122, UN food aid says a third of Gazans starving for days
Gaza: Hunger deaths rise to 122, UN food aid says a third of Gazans starving for days

First Post

time39 minutes ago

  • First Post

Gaza: Hunger deaths rise to 122, UN food aid says a third of Gazans starving for days

Warnings of starvation in Gaza have intensified this week. Nine more people died of malnutrition on Friday, according to the territory's Hamas-run health ministry - bringing the total such deaths since the war began to 122 read more Displaced Palestinian mother Samah Matar holds her malnourished son Youssef, who suffers from cerebral palsy, at a school where they shelter amid a hunger crisis, in Gaza City. Reuters Gaza is facing its worst humanitarian crisis, with the UN's World Food Programme saying, 'Malnutrition is surging with 90,000 women and children in urgent need of treatment.' Warnings of starvation in Gaza have intensified this week. Nine more people died of malnutrition on Friday, according to the territory's Hamas-run health ministry - bringing the total such deaths since the war began to 122. France and the UK have called on Israel to 'immediately lift restrictions on the flow of aid' into the territory. In a joint statement, the two countries said, 'Withholding essential humanitarian assistance to the civilian population is unacceptable.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD UN Chief Antonio Guterres said he could not 'explain the level of indifference and inaction we see by too many in the international community - the lack of compassion, the lack of truth, the lack of humanity'. Trump asks Israel to 'finish the job' Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump has called on Israel to escalate its military conflict to 'finish the job' against Hamas, days after withdrawing his Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, and other negotiators from ceasefire talks. 'I think they want to die, and it's very, very bad. It got to be to a point where you're gonna have to finish the job,' Trump said, referring to Hamas, as he embarked on his four-day private visit to Scotland. The president's comments signal a shift in his tone from negotiation to war mongering as ceasefire talks failed earlier this week. 'They're gonna have to fight and they're gonna have to clean it up. You're gonna have to get rid of 'em,' Trump told Israel. Gaza truce talks Indirect negotiations between Israel and Hamas for a ceasefire have reached an impasse, more than two weeks after they began. A Hamas official on Friday accused US envoy Steve Witkoff of reneging on Washington's positions and distorting reality after he announced the United States' withdrawal from Gaza truce talks and accused the group of blocking a deal. 'The negative statements of the US envoy Witkoff run completely counter to the context in which the last negotiations were held, and he is perfectly aware of this, but they come to serve the Israeli position,' said Hamas political bureau member Bassem Naim in an interview with AFP. With inputs from agencies STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD

‘Words don't feed hungry children': UN Chief urges for immediate action in Gaza to stem starvation
‘Words don't feed hungry children': UN Chief urges for immediate action in Gaza to stem starvation

Time of India

time39 minutes ago

  • Time of India

‘Words don't feed hungry children': UN Chief urges for immediate action in Gaza to stem starvation

United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres addressing the Amnesty International Global Assembly on Friday, called for immediate action in Gaza to stem starvation. Guterres reiterated his condemnation of the October 7th attacks by Hamas, but said that 'nothing can justify the explosion of death and destruction since.' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and U.S. President Donald Trump appeared on Friday to abandon Gaza ceasefire negotiations with Hamas, both saying it had become clear that the Palestinian militants did not want a deal. Show more Show less

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store