logo
Ottawa weighing plans on AI and copyright as OpenAI fights Ontario court jurisdiction

Ottawa weighing plans on AI and copyright as OpenAI fights Ontario court jurisdiction

OTTAWA – Canada's artificial intelligence minister is keeping a close watch on ongoing court cases in Canada and the U.S. to determine next steps for the government's regulatory approach to AI.
Some AI companies have claimed early wins south of the border and OpenAI is now fighting the jurisdiction of an Ontario court to hear a lawsuit by news publishers.
Evan Solomon's office said in a statement he plans to address copyright 'within Canada's broader AI regulatory approach, with a focus on protecting cultural sovereignty and how [creators] factor into this conversation.'
But there are no current plans for a stand-alone copyright bill, as Solomon's office is 'closely monitoring the ongoing court cases and market developments' to help chart the path forward.
It's unclear how long it will take for those court cases to determine whether artificial intelligence companies can use copyrighted content to train their AI products.
The sole Canadian case to pose the question was launched late last year by a coalition of news publishers, and the Ontario Superior Court is set to hear a jurisdictional challenge in September.
The coalition, which includes The Canadian Press, Torstar, the Globe and Mail, Postmedia and CBC/Radio-Canada, is suing OpenAI for using news content to train its generative artificial intelligence system.
The news publishers argue OpenAI is breaching copyright by scraping large amounts of content from Canadian media, then profiting from the use of that content without permission or compensation.
They said in court filings that OpenAI has 'engaged in ongoing, deliberate, and unauthorized misappropriation of [their] valuable news media works.'
'Rather than seek to obtain the information legally, OpenAI has elected to brazenly misappropriate the News Media Companies' valuable intellectual property and convert it for its own uses, including commercial uses, without consent or consideration.'
OpenAI has denied the allegations, and previously said its models are trained on publicly available data and 'grounded in fair use and related international copyright principles.'
The company, which is headquartered in San Francisco, is challenging the jurisdiction of the Ontario court to hear the case.
It argued in a court filing it's not located in Ontario and it does not do business in the province.
'There is no real or substantial connection to Ontario as between the defendants and the issues alleged in the statement of claim,' the company said.
OpenAI also argued the Copyright Act doesn't apply outside of Canada.
OpenAI is asking the court to seal some documents in the case. The court is scheduled to hold a hearing on the sealing motion on July 30, according to a schedule outlined in court documents.
It asked the court to seal documents containing 'commercially sensitive' information, including information about its corporate organization and structure, its web crawling and fetching processes and systems, and its 'model training and inference processes, systems, resource allocations and/or cost structures.'
'The artificial intelligence industry is highly competitive and developing at a rapid pace. Competitors in this industry are many, and range from large, established technology companies such as Google and Amazon, to smaller startups seeking to establish a foothold in the industry,' says an affidavit submitted by the company.
'As recognized leaders in the artificial intelligence industry, competitors and potential competitors to the defendants would benefit from having access to confidential information of the defendants.'
A lawyer for the news publishers provided information on the court deadlines but did not provide comment on the case.
Numerous lawsuits dealing with AI systems and copyright are underway in the United States, some dating back to 2023. In late June, AI companies won victories in two of those cases.
In a case launched by a group of authors, including comedian Sarah Silverman, a judge ruled AI systems' use of published work was fair use, and that the authors didn't demonstrate that use would result in market dilution.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
But the judge also said his ruling affects only those specific authors — whose lawyers didn't make the right arguments — and does not mean Meta's use of copyrighted material to train its systems was legal. Judge Vince Chhabria noted in his summary judgment that in 'the grand scheme of things, the consequences of this ruling are limited.'
In a separate U.S. case, a judge ruled that the use by AI company Anthropic of published books without permission to train its systems was fair use. But Judge William Alsup also ruled that Anthropic 'had no entitlement to use pirated copies.'
Jane Ginsburg, a professor at Columbia University's law school who studies intellectual property and technology, said it would be too simplistic to just look at the cases as complete wins for the AI companies.
'I think both the question of how much weight to give the pirate nature of the sources, and the question of market dilution, are going to be big issues in other cases,' Ginsburg said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 19, 2025.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Canada's premiers meetings: Kinew seeks federal fire response; shares advice on Trump
Canada's premiers meetings: Kinew seeks federal fire response; shares advice on Trump

Winnipeg Free Press

timean hour ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Canada's premiers meetings: Kinew seeks federal fire response; shares advice on Trump

Premier Wab Kinew says he's taken up a request from Manitoba fire chiefs to ask his fellow premiers to consider national co-ordination for local fire departments to prepare for future wildfire seasons. Kinew said he shared with his counterparts gathered in Huntsville, Ont. a request from the Manitoba Association of Fire Chiefs to make sure they're equipped to respond to the next summer's wildfires. 'I think there's general interest from the other premiers,' Kinew said late Tuesday. Nathan Denette / THE CANADIAN PRESS Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, right, greets Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew, left, as Nova Scotia Premier Tim Houston looks on, during the 2025 summer meetings of Canada's Premiers at Deerhurst Resort in Huntsville, Ont., on Tuesday. On June 30, the chiefs wrote to Kinew on behalf of counterparts across the country asking for support for a 'National Fire Administration' to ensure expertise from fire departments is integrated into federal policy and decision making. The letter noted there are 14 federal departments and more than 50 task groups involved in determining policies with fire, life safety, and emergency management implications for fire departments. A national co-ordinating body would help to modernize Canada's emergency response system and benefit the Manitoba fire service in protecting homes, businesses, and the economy, it said. The premier said he thanked all his provincial and territorial colleagues for their help during Manitoba's wildfire emergency. He praised firefighters from across the province for saving the city of Flin Flon that was threatened by a 300,000 hectare blaze. Premier Wab Kinew said his special advisor on U.S. trade and former ambassador to the U.S., Gary Doer, offered some 'great advice' to Canada's first ministers on how to deal with the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump: 'Give him a bumper sticker.' Kinew said Tuesday that the former NDP premier and David McNaughton, who served as Canada's ambassador to the U.S. during the first Trump administration, joined the premiers for lunch when they gathered in Huntsville, Ont. to grapple with how to respond to the trade war launched by the second Trump administration. Doer's suggestion was to 'give the president an easy-to-understand win that he can communicate in a line and, of course, to do that within our national interest in standing up for ourselves,' Kinew said. Weekday Mornings A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day. Kinew said the federal government is wise not to rush into a trade deal with the U.S. by Trump's Aug. 1 deadline — after which he's promised to raise tariffs on Canadian imports to 35 percent. 'I think future generations are to look back at this moment and they're going to say that 'Our country, at that time, stood up for its independence, stood up for its economy'. When the stakes are that big, we can't rush.' Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Orla Mining Reports Pit Wall Event at Camino Rojo
Orla Mining Reports Pit Wall Event at Camino Rojo

Cision Canada

time5 hours ago

  • Cision Canada

Orla Mining Reports Pit Wall Event at Camino Rojo

VANCOUVER, BC, /CNW/ - Orla Mining Ltd. (TSX: OLA; NYSE: ORLA) ("Orla" or the "Company") reports that an uncontrolled material movement event occurred today on the pit wall at its Camino Rojo Oxide Mine in Zacatecas, Mexico. The event occurred along the temporary north wall of the open pit, which included ore material expected to be mined as part of the ultimate open pit. There were no injuries or equipment damage as a result of the material movement, which was detected early by the pit monitoring systems. The event was caused by significant rain. There was no environmental damage resulting from the incident; however, rainwater diversion channels will need to be re-established to prevent further material subsidence in the pit. While the main access throughout the pit was not affected, mining in the pit has been temporarily suspended. Pit access has been restricted to the necessary technical and operating personnel to support the appropriate geotechnical assessments required for safe remediation and resumption of mining activities. Crushing and stacking of stockpiled material onto the heap leach will continue in the interim. The Company is currently assessing any potential impact of the pit wall event on its full-year production guidance for Camino Rojo. The relevant authorities are being notified as appropriate, and Orla is implementing appropriate remediation measures. The safety of all personnel remains the Company's top priority as it undertakes a comprehensive analysis to ensure the ongoing stability of mining operations. About Orla Mining Ltd. Orla's corporate strategy is to acquire, develop, and operate mineral properties where the Company's expertise can substantially increase stakeholder value. The Company has three material projects, consisting of two operating mines and one development project, all 100% owned by the Company: (1) Camino Rojo, in Zacatecas State, Mexico, an operating gold and silver open-pit and heap leach mine. The property covers over 139,000 hectares which contains a large oxide and sulphide mineral resource, (2) Musselwhite Mine, in Northwestern Ontario, Canada, an underground gold mine that has been in operation for over 25 years and produced over 6 million ounces of gold, with a long history of resource growth and conversion, and (3) South Railroad, in Nevada, United States, a feasibility-stage, open pit, heap leach gold project located on the Carlin trend in Nevada. The technical reports for the Company's material projects are available on Orla's website at and on SEDAR+ and EDGAR under the Company's profile at and respectively. Forward-looking Statements This news release contains certain "forward-looking information" and "forward-looking statements" within the meaning of Canadian securities legislation and within the meaning of Section 27A of the United States Securities Act of 1933, as amended, Section 21E of the United States Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, the United States Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, or in releases made by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, all as may be amended from time to time, including, without limitation, statements regarding the impact of the pit wall event on the Company's operations, the Company's ability to remediate the same, and the Company's ability to continue crushing and stacking stockpile material. Forward-looking statements are statements that are not historical facts which address events, results, outcomes or developments that the Company expects to occur. Forward-looking statements are based on the beliefs, estimates and opinions of the Company's management on the date the statements are made and they involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Certain material assumptions regarding such forward-looking statements were made, including without limitation, assumptions regarding the impact of the pit wall event on the Company's operations at Camino Rojo; the Company's ability to carry on mining activities; tonnage of ore to be mined and processed; ore grades and recoveries; that all conditions of the Company's credit facility will be met; that political and legal developments will be consistent with current expectations; the timely receipt of required approvals and permits, including those approvals and permits required for operation of projects; the Company's ability to operate in a safe, efficient, and effective manner; that the Company's activities will be in accordance with the Company's public statements and stated goals; and that there will be no material adverse change or disruptions affecting the Company or its properties. Consequently, there can be no assurances that such statements will prove to be accurate and actual results and future events could differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. Forward-looking statements involve significant known and unknown risks and uncertainties, which could cause actual results to differ materially from those anticipated. These risks include, but are not limited to, the Company's ability to remediate the pit wall event, risks associated with mining operations, risks associated with receipt and compliance with government permits, reclamation costs, environmental and other regulatory requirements; as well as those risk factors discussed in the Company's most recently filed management's discussion and analysis, as well as its annual information form dated March 18, 2025, which are available on and Except as required by the securities disclosure laws and regulations applicable to the Company, the Company undertakes no obligation to update these forward-looking statements if management's beliefs, estimates or opinions, or other factors, should change. SOURCE Orla Mining Ltd.

Antisemitism envoy says resignation prompted by frustration over 'not connecting' with anti-hate message
Antisemitism envoy says resignation prompted by frustration over 'not connecting' with anti-hate message

Vancouver Sun

time6 hours ago

  • Vancouver Sun

Antisemitism envoy says resignation prompted by frustration over 'not connecting' with anti-hate message

OTTAWA — Ottawa's outgoing envoy for tackling antisemitism is accusing Canada's business sector and civil society of failing to call out a rising tide of hate against Jews and other minorities. In an extensive interview with The Canadian Jewish News, Deborah Lyons also said she could not get a meeting with Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre during her nearly two-year term. In a statement sent to The Canadian Press, the Conservatives said that Lyons was 'powerless' in her job. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Lyons resigned early in her term as Canada's special envoy on preserving Holocaust remembrance and combating antisemitism. She said her decision reflected her 'despair' over the growing gulf in society over violence in the Middle East and the failure of many Canadians to find common ground against hate. 'People were listening and hearing on different frequencies, and so we just were not connecting,' said Lyons. 'That was where the big despair comes from.' She said her work wasn't made any easier by the silence of corporate leaders 'whom I asked many times to stand up,' and by faith leaders who seemed to keep quiet on the suffering of people from other religions. 'I was incredibly disappointed with business leaders,' she said. 'We have a tendency to want to blame politicians all the time, but where have the faith leaders been? Where have the priests and ministers and rabbis and imams and so forth (been)?' Lyons said that some community leaders did ask for her help in finding the right words to speak out against hate — because they feared that they would offend one community if they stood up for another. 'I've been really quite amazed — and often become quite despondent and despairing — about the fact that it was hard to get people to speak up. To speak with clarity, to speak with conviction,' she said. 'The mark of a country is not the courage of its military. It is the courage of its bystanders.' The Canadian Press has requested an interview with Lyons but has not yet had a response. Lyons told The Canadian Jewish News that Amira Elghawaby, the federal government's special representative on combating Islamophobia, tried to work with Lyons on fighting hate, citing an apparently shelved plan to visit provincial education ministers together. 'Neither my community, nor her community, were happy all the time to see us in pictures together,' Lyons said. 'There were often people who just simply didn't want me participating in respectful dialogues, or wouldn't come into the room.' She said that indicates a 'weakening' in the ability of both Canadian society and the broader western world to stand for common human values. Lyons said she lacked the energy at times to bridge that gap. 'I held back from having some discussions, because I knew there was going to be animosity, or I wasn't going to be welcome in the room. It disappoints me,' she said. Lyons said she could not get a meeting with Poilievre despite requesting one and having a cordial chat with him during an event. 'I tried to meet with Mr. Poilievre when I was in the job, and in the end I got a response that he was too busy to meet with me,' she said. In a statement attributed to Conservative deputy leader Melissa Lantsman, the party did not dispute Lyons' version of events. 'While communities face increasing threats, vandalism, intimidation and violence over the last 20 months, the Liberals deflected responsibility to a powerless envoy,' says the statement. 'We are ready to meet with the government at any point, because they're the only ones with the power, the tools and the responsibility to do something — and they have done absolutely nothing to date.' Statistics Canada reported this week a slight increase in police-reported hate crimes in 2024 compared with a year prior, and a very slight drop in those against Jewish people, who remain the most targeted group in Canada. Lyons accused all three levels of government of failing to adequately co-ordinate their responses to hate, saying that issues like car theft or tariffs are seen as more tangible. She said Prime Minister Mark Carney seemed engaged and requested a meeting with her, though she added it was not possible to meet with him before the July 8 date of her departure. Lyons said she is leaving her job three months early not for health reasons but rather to restore 'a little bit of the joy back into life' through retirement. She said she would have liked to continue, but described the envoy role as more difficult than her stints as ambassador to Afghanistan and Israel. 'It was without question the toughest job I ever did.' Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store