logo
Chris Selley: Canada's refugee system — and the world's — is overdue for an overhaul

Chris Selley: Canada's refugee system — and the world's — is overdue for an overhaul

National Post17-07-2025
Article content
The simple fact is, Canada is not equipped to handle as many refugee claims as we currently accept. If we were, there wouldn't be African migrants sleeping on Toronto sidewalks. There wouldn't have been 281,000 pending asylum cases as of March 31.
Article content
Prime Minister Mark Carney's Liberal government is certainly aware of the issue. Bill C-2 proposes a one-year deadline after arriving in Canada for claiming asylum — so people with expired or revoked visas couldn't apply, for example — and to eliminate a loophole in the Safe Third Country Agreement that allows illegal border-crossers who evade capture for two weeks to apply for asylum nevertheless.
Article content
Both are entirely reasonable. But the current issue of The Economist, cover headline 'Scrap the refugee system,' suggests the sort of wholesale changes to the global refugee system that I have been arguing for forever. It's interesting not so much as a piece of journalism as it is to know that liberal (and Liberal) policymakers very much tend to read The Economist.
Article content
Article content
'About 123 million people have been displaced by conflict, disaster or persecution. … All these people have a right to seek safety,' the magazine's editorial observes. 'But 'safety' does not mean access to a rich country's labour market. Indeed, resettlement in rich countries will never be more than a tiny part of the solution.'
Article content
The goal, the august organ argues, should be for refugees to receive asylum closer to home — ideally in culturally and linguistically similar countries whose population will tend to be more sympathetic. For the money that rich countries spend processing everyone who manages to make it to their shores — who are generally by definition not the world's most imperilled or downtrodden, else they wouldn't be able to get here — they could help vastly more people to safety, even if not First World prosperity. (The latter was never the goal of the current system.)
Article content
This is an idea that would require multilateral co-operation to achieve full bloom, of course. But many First World countries are far more hostile to asylum-seekers, if not immigrants in general, than Canada is. If Canada significantly restricted refugee claims made on Canadian soil, and instead refocused its efforts on helping people find refuge closer to home, it would set a useful example — not least because we have been so welcoming, to a fault, in the past.
Article content
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

City fines Montreal church for hosting MAGA-affiliated singer Sean Feucht concert
City fines Montreal church for hosting MAGA-affiliated singer Sean Feucht concert

CTV News

time28 minutes ago

  • CTV News

City fines Montreal church for hosting MAGA-affiliated singer Sean Feucht concert

Christian musician Sean Feucht of California preaches to the crowd during a rally at the National Mall in Washington, Sunday, Oct. 25, 2020. (Jose Luis Magana/The Associated Press) The City of Montreal has fined a local church $2,500 for hosting a concert Friday night by the U.S.-based Christian musician Sean Feucht. The city says the church did not have a permit to organize the concert, which it says ran counter to Montreal's values of inclusion, solidarity and respect. Officials have cancelled Feucht's scheduled concerts in several Canadian cities in recent days, including Halifax, Charlottetown and Quebec City. Feucht has spoken out against 'gender ideology,' abortion and the LGBTQ+ community and his religious and political views have grabbed the attention of U.S. President Donald Trump's administration. Montreal police arrested a 38-year-old man during a protest Friday night outside the church. They also say a smoke bomb was set off inside the church during Feucht's performance. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 26, 2025. The Canadian Press

Majority of Canadians see progress a decade after Truth and Reconciliation report: poll
Majority of Canadians see progress a decade after Truth and Reconciliation report: poll

National Post

timean hour ago

  • National Post

Majority of Canadians see progress a decade after Truth and Reconciliation report: poll

Article content The survey also suggests respondents who said they are proud of Canada's history are more likely to report Canada is making good progress on reconciliation with Indigenous Peoples, at 68 per cent. Of those who reported they're not proud of Canada's history, just 39.3 per cent said they believe Canada is making good progress. Article content Pride in Canada's history seems to be strongly correlated with the age of respondents. Just 36 per cent of respondents aged 18 to 24 reported feeling proud of that history, while 78 per cent of those 65 and older said the same. Article content Francophone youth reported being more proud of Canada's history (59 per cent) than anglophones (35 per cent) — a finding Jedwab said he was surprised by, given the persistence of the province's separatist movement. Article content Jedwab said while the poll found most Indigenous respondents reported feeling pride in Canadian history, it can't be taken at face value because the sample size was so small. Article content 'There's a need to actually pursue further research in this area to get a better idea of how Indigenous Peoples feel,' he said. Article content 'We need to be more attentive to that diversity in terms of drawing conclusions about the views of Indigenous Peoples … We do need to better understand what the nature of the relationship is right now, how people feel about whether progress is being achieved or not and how we go forward together.' Article content

Canada condemns Hong Kong arrest warrants targeting pro-democracy activists
Canada condemns Hong Kong arrest warrants targeting pro-democracy activists

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

Canada condemns Hong Kong arrest warrants targeting pro-democracy activists

FILE - A pedestrian looks at the police reward notices for the arrest warrants issued for eight pro-democracy activists living in the United States, Britain, Canada and Australia for alleged national security offenses in Hong Kong, Friday, July 14, 2023. (AP Photo/Louise Delmotte, File) The Canadian government on Saturday condemned Hong Kong authorities issuing arrest warrants for pro-democracy activists based overseas. 'The individuals targeted yesterday under the Beijing-imposed National Security Law in Hong Kong include Canadians and people with close ties to Canada,' the government said in a statement. 'This attempt by Hong Kong authorities to conduct transnational repression abroad, including by issuing threats, intimidation or coercion against Canadians or those in Canada, will not be tolerated.' Hong Kong's national security police announced arrest warrants for 19 activists based overseas, accusing them of subversion under a stringent law, marking the largest such tally yet. Reporting by Bhargav Acharya in Toronto; editing by Diane Craft

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store