Law firms jockey over stake in Disney consumer antitrust settlement
Disney in June agreed to pay an undisclosed amount to settle a class action lawsuit by YouTube TV, DirecTV Stream and FuboTV subscribers represented by law firm Bathaee Dunne who claimed the company harmed competition for live-streamed paid television through agreements with providers.
Rival plaintiffs' lawyers at law firms DiCello Levitt and Lite DePalma Greenberg & Afanador, who represent Fubo consumers in a related lawsuit against Disney, complained in a Tuesday court filing, opens new tab that they were excluded from the negotiations.
The filing accused Bathaee Dunne, which sued first in 2022, of allowing Disney to engage in a 'reverse auction' by agreeing to an inadequate settlement at the expense of other plaintiffs.
The Bathaee Dunne firm has denied allowing a lowball settlement and said in court filings, opens new tab that the deal is contingent on the firm being appointed as lead counsel for classes of YouTube TV, DirecTV Stream and Fubo subscribers.
Bathaee Dunne said the rival attorneys are 'newly-arrived' and that their jockeying for a bigger seat at the table could derail the settlement.
Disney, which has denied any wrongdoing, and a lawyer for the company did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The lead plaintiffs' attorneys in both cases also did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Disney controls live-stream provider Hulu and the sports network ESPN. Disney has required streaming providers such as YouTube TV to include ESPN as part of a base package. The consumer lawsuits contend Disney's business agreements artificially increased consumer prices across the market for livestreamed television.
The proposed Disney settlement features a monetary component and other benefits, but the terms have not been publicly disclosed.
Disney in a recent filing said the proposed settlement is not open to renegotiation.
The cases are Biddle v. The Walt Disney Co and Unger v. The Walt Disney Co, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, Nos. 5:22-cv-07317 and 5:25-cv-01163.
For Biddle: Yavar Bathaee and Brian Dunne of Bathaee Dunne
For Unger: Joseph DePalma and Steven Greenfogel of Lite DePalma Greenberg & Afanador; Greg Asciolla and Carrie Syme of DiCello Levitt
For Disney: Daniel Petrocelli of O'Melveny & Myers
Read more:
Disney's Hulu + Live TV business to combine with Fubo, clearing way for Venu Sports
US Justice Dept, states back FuboTV in lawsuit over streaming sports venture
Disney must face consumer antitrust claims in TV streaming lawsuits
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Zillow CEO reveals what he thinks is the cause of America's 'housing crisis'
Americans everywhere are struggling to purchase homes, with sales reaching a 30 year low in 2024. Despite the tribulations of the housing market itself, the number one real estate site in the country - Zillow - is thriving. CEO Jeremy Wacksman sat down with The New York Times to discuss what may be causing the dip in the housing market and what keeps Zillow afloat amidst it all. The Seattle resident was appointed as CEO a year ago, but has been with the company since 2009. Wacksman added that the major issue with homebuying in the United States is that there is an availability problem. 'We have an affordability crisis, which is driven by an availability crisis. It is a supply-side problem,' he said. While many complain about increasing mortgage rates, he said that it's only a small factor. 'The real problem for a home buyer is home prices are up 30, 50, 70, 100 percent, depending on the market, from pre-pandemic levels. Incomes are not up that much.' According to the US Social Security Office, the average yearly income in 2023 was $66,621, only increasing 4 percent from the year prior. Wacksman noted that if the housing industry had continued to build new properties to keep up with buyer demand, it may not have become the 'crisis' it is today. 'We have been chronically under-building since, really, the global financial crisis,' he said. 'Less supply and a lot of demand is going to keep home prices elevated.' According to Zillow, the average home value is almost $370,000 with just 1.3 million homes in the for-sale inventory. Despite the dip in purchasing and sky-high prices, Zillow is seeing hundreds of millions of unique visitors every month. The company has seen a jump in revenue and its stock is up more than 60 percent. The top site for real-estate listings in the country attracts what the internet has dubbed 'Zillow Surfers.' Those with little to no intention of purchasing a home browse on the website everyday. Wacksman welcomes such browsers. ''Zillow Surfing' is pretty pervasive, regardless of if it's a buyer's market or a seller's market,' he said. 'You spend all this time window shopping and escaping and dreaming. You are getting a little smarter about what you might want, and then something happens and you pull the trigger. 'As a marketer, I don't think you could have a stronger brand endorsement than all of the usage you get from people escaping on your platform.' The way Zillow makes money is by selling ads to real estate companies who want to reach those endlessly scrolling Zillow-surfers. The company requires agents to post listings within 24 hours of being on the market. If not, it's never allowed on the site at all. Real estate companies like Compass have grown wary of Zillow, and even filed a lawsuit claiming they maintain a monopoly, calling it a 'Zillow ban.' But Wacksman said that the lawsuit itself speaks to the larger issues of seller transparency within the United States housing market. 'The heart of the issue is the U.S. real estate market currently exists with a unique amount of transparency,' he said. 'So you and I, as a buyer and seller, can see all available listings, and that empowers us to shop on our own. There are a few companies that are looking to put the internet back in a box and hide inventory and force you to pay them. 'The lawsuit is about challenging that consumer benefit and that transparency.' Now, Zillow is trying to shift toward a 'super app' structure that allows buyers to be connected with any resources that they may need. That includes mortgage providers and rental properties as well as any other related services. The service even offers a three dimensional walk through option to help buyers completely view each property. Wacksman said that marketing a home 'in the broadest sense' is the best way for agents to get the most out of Zillow. Amidst a market low, that may be the best way to break through. 'That's why we spend so much time on the software to help agents do their job well.'
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Amber Heard thanks her 'supporters' as she wraps latest acting project after Johnny Depp trial fallout
Amber Heard took to Instagram on Saturday to thank her fans as she wraps her final performance of her play Spirit of the People. The 39-year-old superstar — who showed off her toned physique on Friday — posed with multiple bouquets of flowers and added a sentimental caption. 'Thank you to all of my fans and supporters for making this already unforgettable weekend so much more beautiful,' she wrote to her five million followers. Amber added: 'The flowers won't last forever but the memories of all the love and support I received through this will.' She has spent the past several weeks performing at the Williamstown Theater Festival in Massachusetts. Earlier this week the Texas-bred star was showered with support from fans on Instagram as she shared a glowing selfie. Reflecting on her imminent final performance, she captioned the image, 'Lucky to be stealing one final breath before this weekend's final performances. Last chance to see Spirit of the People at @wtfestival!' Her fans expressed their excitement about her comeback in her comments section. 'Amber! We're so proud of you!!!', wrote one person, while another said, 'Wish I could see the play again! You were absolutely incredible in it ❤️❤️❤️ I hope you have a great final weekend with the festival!' Another person gushed, 'Getting to see you live was literally one of the best moments of my life, you're amazing!!' Other notes read, 'Our queen is THRIVING', and 'Beautiful as always and mastering your craft. Keep glowing and growing. ❤️' Three years ago Amber resolved her bitter court case with ex-husband Johnny Depp. She made a sensational return to acting last month, following the birth of her twins in May and her widely publicized defamation trial with ex Johnny. After stepping back into the spotlight, the Hollywood siren was cast as Genevieve in Jeremy O. Harris' play. Amber was previously wed to Pirates of The Caribbean star Johnny from 2015 to 2017, and they were involved in a high-profile defamation trial in 2022. She was ordered to pay the actor $10 million in compensatory damages and $350,000 in punitive damages, which she argued she didn't have. The jury awarded the actress $2 million in compensatory damages for her countersuit against Johnny. She is now a mother-of-three, as she has four-year-old daughter Oonagh in addition to her newborn twins — daughter Agnes and son Ocean.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Hulk Hogan's devastated son Nick appears to fight back tears during emotional WWE tribute to late icon
Hulk Hogan 's son Nick appeared to fight back tears following an emotional tribute to his late father at SummerSlam 2025. The wrestling legend died at the age of 71 last month after suffering a cardiac arrest at his home in Clearwater, Florida. Emergency services rushed him to a local hospital but the WWE icon was ultimately declared dead. In the days that followed, tributes from friends, family and fans poured in for Hogan - including a heartbreaking post from his son, Nick. Nick paid tribute to his 'best friend' in the statement and, in the days that followed, was seen front and center at WWE's Monday Night Raw. On Saturday night, Nick was once again seen in the front row at the WWE - this time for SummerSlam 2025 - and watched on as an emotional tribute for Hogan played. The tribute showcased photos of Hogan from throughout his WWE career and heaped praise on the 'larger than life' figure and his career inside the squared circle. WWE with a tribute to Hulk Hogan with Nick Hogan in attendance ❤️ #SummerSlam — FADE (@FadeAwayMedia) August 2, 2025 After the tribute was played, cameras immediately cut to Hogan's son, Nick, who was visibly emotional after watching the video. The WWE icon's son appeared to fight back tears as he put his hands together - in a 'prayer' gesture - before then clapping back to the audience who cheered him on. The WWE played Hogan's classic theme song 'Real American' at the conclusion of a video package - which was a real tearjerker for any wrestling fan. Just six days earlier, Nick stood alongside WWE stars past and present for a 10-bell salute to his father during the company's Monday Night RAW show.
