Billion-dollar money laundering case: 4 law firms linked to seized properties named, 2 more identified and reprimanded
In an update on Friday (Aug 1), the Ministry of Law (MinLaw) said it had completed the regulatory action related to the four law firms - Anthony Law Corporation, Fortis Law Corporation, Legal Solutions LLC and Malkin & Maxwell LLP.
As such, MinLaw added it was now able to furnish more details on their conveyancing of the real estate properties seized as part of the anti-money laundering operation in August 2023. Conveyancing refers to the legal process of transferring the ownership of a property from one person to another.
Their penalties were previously made known on Jul 15, but MinLaw then did not name the four firms.
It then said 24 law practices were involved in investigations by Singapore's director of legal services (DLS) Sarala Kumari Subramaniam, supported by MinLaw, and 11 of the probes had been concluded.
As of Jul 31, 13 of the 24 law practices had been dealt with, the ministry said on Friday.
Two more law firms - William Poh & Louis Lim, now known as Louis Lim & Partners, and Templars Law LLC were also named, as inquiries and regulatory action had concluded, it added.
With 13 of the probes having concluded, MinLaw also identified five lawyers involved in the conveyancing of the seized real estate properties.
They are: Mr Tan Chau Chuang, Mr Andrew Wong Wei Kiat, Mr Tan Tse Chia Patrick, Mr Ee Tian Huat Patrick and Mr Poh Tian Hock William.
All have been referred to the Law Society to "consider if there are grounds for further professional disciplinary action against these lawyers".
MinLaw previously said on Jul 15 that one lawyer had been referred to the Law Society for disciplinary action, without naming the individual. While a Law Society spokesperson then confirmed that the lawyer had been referred to it for disciplinary action, it was unable to reveal the identities of those involved.
"As the referral relates to disciplinary matters, such proceedings are confidential," it then said.
ENFORCEMENT ACTION TAKEN
All law practices and lawyers are subject to anti-money laundering obligations under the Legal Profession Act 1966.
These include performing an adequate analysis of the risks of money laundering in relation to each client and performing customer due diligence measures that are in line with a client's risk profile.
Lawyers and law firms also have to file a suspicious transaction report with the police if they have reasonable grounds to suspect that a client might be engaged in money laundering.
Expanding on the enforcement action taken, the ministry said Anthony Law Corporation had acted for nine clients to convey 25 properties valued at around S$135 million in total.
According to MinLaw, its breaches included inadequate scrutiny of the transactions, which was not commensurate with the clients' and transactions' money laundering risks.
"Anthony Law Corporation did not corroborate or verify the clients' explanations for why the transactions were being funded by seemingly unrelated third parties, even though these were red flags," it said.
The firm also failed to comply with documentation requirements.
If a law practice or lawyer decides to continue to act for the client despite suspicions of money laundering, they must substantiate and document the reasons for this and adopt commensurate risk mitigation measures, including enhanced customer due diligence and monitoring measures.
However, while Anthony Law retained and continued to undertake transactions for some of these clients despite filing suspicious transaction reports against them, it did not substantiate or document its reasons for why it had considered it appropriate to do so, said MinLaw.
The firm was ordered to pay a financial penalty of S$100,000. One of its lawyers, Mr Tan Chau Chuang, has since been referred to the Law Society.
Fortis Law Corporation acted for 16 clients to convey 55 properties valued at around S$398.7 million in total.
The firm did not conduct checks to verify the clients' claims that the payments for the transactions were indeed from legitimate remittance companies, said MinLaw.
As a result, it was handed a financial penalty of S$30,000 and two lawyers - Mr Wong and Mr Tan Tse Chia Patrick - were referred to the Law Society.
Mr Wong is no longer practising with Fortis Law.
Both Anthony Law and Fortis Law have paid the financial penalty, MinLaw noted.
Legal Solutions LLC, the third firm to receive a financial penalty, acted for two clients to convey 20 properties valued at around S$117 million in total.
'It did not adequately document the details of its analysis of the clients' money-laundering risks,' said the ministry.
"It also did not perform all the required enhanced customer due diligence measures after it filed a suspicious transaction report, such as documenting its internal discussions on, and reasons for, retaining the clients despite filing the suspicious transaction report."
Legal Solutions has been ordered by Ms Subramaniam to pay a financial penalty of S$70,000, while a lawyer, Mr Ee, has been referred to the Law Society. He no longer practices at the firm.
Meanwhile, Malkin & Maxwell LLP has been reprimanded to remind it to be mindful of its anti-money laundering obligations and responsibilities.
MinLaw said it was taken into consideration that the firm had acted for one client to convey one property valued at around S$40 million.
Inquiries revealed that while Malkin & Maxwell conducted checks into the client's source of funds, its independent checks were "not sufficiently in-depth".
Instead, it relied unduly on checks that it assumed third parties would have done on its client.
William Poh & Louis Lim and Templars Law LLC were also reprimanded by Ms Subramaniam to remind them to be mindful of their anti-money laundering obligations and responsibilities.
Mr Poh, a lawyer who previously worked at William Poh & Louis Lim before joining Templars Law, has been referred to the Law Society.
According to MinLaw, Mr Poh was the managing partner and sole partner-in-charge of conveyancing matters at William Poh & Louis Lim until around May 2023.
During his time at the firm, he commenced transactions for six clients to convey 32 properties valued at around S$246.7 million in total.
Twenty-six of those property transactions concluded while Mr Poh was practising with William Poh & Louis Lim, said MinLaw.
The lawyer later left the firm in or around May 2023 to join Templars Law, and his previous firm amended its name to Louis Lim & Partners after his departure.
Mr Poh brought the remaining six property transactions to Templars Law and concluded the transactions soon after in June 2023, said MinLaw.
Some of the breaches observed by Ms Subramaniam included not obtaining certain documents as part of customer due diligence, not adequately scrutinising the clients' and transactions' money-laundering risks and not applying commensurate risk mitigation measures.
HOW REFERRALS TO THE LAW SOCIETY ARE HANDLED
A lawyer who breaches his or her anti-money laundering obligations is liable, among other things, to face disciplinary proceedings.
'Lawyers whom the director of legal services has referred to the Law Society will be subject to the disciplinary proceedings process and framework in the Legal Profession Act,' said MinLaw.
Under this framework, each lawyer's case will undergo further fact-finding by the relevant committee or tribunal to assess if there have been breaches, and if so, the lawyer's individual culpability and any appropriate disciplinary action and penalties against him or her.
This disciplinary process is separate from the director of legal services' inquiries and enforcement actions against the law practices.
'We urge the public to refrain from speculating or sharing unverified information while the process is ongoing,' said MinLaw.
The billion-dollar money-laundering case involved millions of dollars earned over the years from an illicit gambling ring with Southeast Asian bases, and that was aimed at punters in China.
Investigations into the transnational case date back to 2021 and culminated in islandwide police raids in August 2023.
Singapore police seized luxury cars, watches, jewellery, designer goods, cryptocurrency and cash.
More than 150 properties were also seized, including homes in Singapore's most upmarket neighbourhoods.
The fees that Anthony Law, Fortis Law, Legal Solutions, Malkin & Maxwell, William Poh & Louis Lim and Templars Law collected in total from acting for their clients for these property transactions ranged from S$15,000 to around S$170,000, said MinLaw.
"In imposing the financial penalties, alongside other regulatory measures that include following up with these law practices on their remedial measures to strengthen compliance with anti-money laundering obligations, the DLS aims to ensure that law practices in Singapore observe their anti-money laundering obligations and keep Singapore a clean and money-laundering-free business- and financial-hub," it added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
5 minutes ago
- Straits Times
US ETF becomes substantial shareholder of SGX-listed small-cap; has stakes in 30 S'pore stocks
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox AVDV ETF increased its stake in oil company Rex International to 5.3 per cent – or slightly over 69 million shares – on July 17 at $0.178 apiece. SINGAPORE - A US-based exchange-traded fund (ETF) has recently become a substantial shareholder of a Singapore-listed small-cap company. Avantis International Small Cap Value ETF (AVDV) increased its stake in oil company Rex International to 5.3 per cent – or slightly over 69 million shares – on July 17 at 17.8 cents apiece, according to a statement by the Singapore Exchange (SGX) on July 29. This transaction crossed the threshold of 5 per cent that qualifies it as a substantial shareholder under Singapore law. The fund is owned by American Century Investments, based in Kansas City, and focuses on a broad range of small-cap stocks listed in non-US developed markets, targeting those with low valuations and strong profitability. Industrials, materials, financials and energy sector stocks make up the bulk of its portfolio. Japan is the fund's largest market, while most of its other investments are in Europe and Australia. The ETF's year-to-date return as at July 31 is 25.26 per cent, and it closed at US$80.31 on Aug 1. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singapore launches review of economic strategy to stay ahead of global shifts Singapore A look at the five committees reviewing Singapore's economic strategy World Trump says he will 'substantially' raise tariffs on India over Russian oil purchases Singapore Strong S'pore-Australia ties underpinned by bonds that are continually renewed: President Tharman Singapore All recruits at BMTC will be trained to fly drones and counter them: Chan Chun Sing Sport Singaporean swimmer Gan Ching Hwee at 'crossroads' after World Aquatics C'ships display Singapore Ong Beng Seng to be sentenced on Aug 15, prosecution does not object to fine due to his poor health Singapore Pritam Singh had hoped WP would 'tip one or two more constituencies' at GE2025 It was established in 2019 and has been investing in SGX-listed stocks since then. American Century's investment in Rex International makes up 0.09 per cent of AVDV's assets under management, which are valued at close to US$11 billion (S$14.1 billion). This is also the first time an ETF has become a substantial shareholder of an SGX-listed small-cap company, said Mr Geoff Howie, market strategist at SGX. Small-cap stocks are valued at under $1 billion, while large-cap stocks are over $5 billion and mid-cap stocks are valued in between. 'Outside of large-cap stocks, we had not seen an ETF provider emerge as a substantial shareholder,' said Mr Howie. He added that no ETF has made similar investments to become a substantial shareholder in small-cap companies listed on other regional exchanges. Therefore, American Century's investment could spell a new positive trend for small-cap companies in Singapore, he noted. He said: 'Small-cap stocks could emerge as a new sector for investments, especially with more companies looking to capitalise on Singapore's reputation as a good place for doing business. 'There is a lot of potential for liquidity to come into the small and mid-cap sectors.' This would also bode well for the Monetary Authority of Singapore's Equity Market Development Programme (EQDP), aimed at boosting SGX-listed stocks and revitalising Singapore's stock market. Mr Vasu Menon, managing director of investment strategy at OCBC Bank, said American Century's investment in SGX-listed small-cap stocks is testament to the confidence that global institutional investors have in the EQDP. 'It is also a recognition that undiscovered gems can be found among small and mid-cap stocks here which have underperformed against large-cap stocks.' He added that AVDV's move would help to raise the profile of small-cap stocks and generate interest from other US and global institutional funds, which should augur well for such companies listed here. Mr Matthias Chan, head of equities research at SAC Capital, said: 'If more foreign-based ETFs are drawn to Singapore equities, it will more than likely target the small to mid-cap space, and for good reason. 'Although the FTSE ST Small Cap Index may have recovered over the past year in line with the market, it is still down 11 per cent over the past three years and 7 per cent over the past five years, suggesting further meaningful upside.' AVDV is currently invested in 30 stocks listed on SGX, which delivered a 42 per cent total return on average, according to SGX. Twenty-two of these stocks delivered a higher average daily turnover of $52.9 million to date in 2025 , compared with $29.3 million for the whole of 2024. The portfolio comprises a mix of Singapore and foreign companies, many of which are in the energy and industrials sectors. Mr Howie said that AVDV's investment in foreign companies listed on SGX is testament to Singapore's advantage as a financial centre in the region with a strong currency. 'If these companies were listed in emerging Asian markets instead, they would not be part of this ETF.' Chinese investment holding firm Yangzijiang Financial Holding – the financial arm of a Chinese shipbuilding company – which has a market cap of $3.27 billion, is the ETF's largest exposure to SGX stocks. It holds 89.6 million shares, or a 2.6 per cent interest, in the company, comprising 0.61 per cent of its stock weight. This investment is also the fund's ninth largest in its entire portfolio. Other SGX-listed stocks in the ETF's portfolio include Indonesian palm oil producer First Resources, with a 1 per cent stake or 15.5 million shares; Indonesian shipping company Samudera Shipping Line, with a 2.5 per cent stake or 13.5 million shares; and Hong Kong port operator Hutchison Port Holdings Trust, with a 0.6 per cent stake or 52 million shares. The portfolio also includes a number of Singapore companies, including construction company Wee Hur Holdings, with a 2.3 per cent stake or 21.4 million shares; industrial systems company CSE Global, with a 0.8 per cent stake or 5.7 million shares; and Keppel Infrastructure Trust, with a 0.1 per cent stake or 6.9 million shares. Other Singapore companies include The Hour Glass, Raffles Medical Group and Food Empire Holdings.
CNA
8 minutes ago
- CNA
Axon raises annual revenue forecast on strong security demand
TASER maker Axon Enterprise raised its full-year revenue forecast on Monday, betting on continued demand for its software products and security devices. Shares of Axon were up 3.5 per cent in aftermarket trading. The Arizona-based company — known for its law enforcement technology, including TASER energy weapons, body-worn cameras, and digital evidence management systems — has benefited from rising corporate spending on executive security and increased federal investment in immigration enforcement. Axon now expects 2025 revenue to be between $2.65 billion and $2.73 billion, up from its earlier forecast of $2.60 billion to $2.70 billion. Analysts on average expect $2.66 billion, according to data compiled by LSEG. For the quarter ended June 30, Axon reported adjusted earnings of $2.12 per share, well above analysts' average estimate of $1.46.
CNA
5 hours ago
- CNA
Hitachi mulling over sale of Japanese white goods business, Nikkei reports
Japanese conglomerate Hitachi is considering selling its domestic home appliance business as part of a continued effort to prioritize the group's social infrastructure and digital sectors, the Nikkei newspaper has reported. The deal could be worth around 100 billion yen ($679.49 million) or more, the report said. Hitachi has reached out to multiple companies to buy its white goods business, with South Korea's Samsung Electronics being one of its potential suitors, Nikkei said. However, the report added that Hitachi is keeping the option of retaining the business open as well due to its potential of contributing to the company's brand recognition among consumers. Hitachi and Samsung Electronics did not immediately respond to Reuters' request for a comment. ($1 = 147.1700 yen)
