logo
Grave policy gaps in sugar sector

Grave policy gaps in sugar sector

EDITORIAL: The Trading Corporation of Pakistan's (TCP) July 15 directive to slash its sugar import tender from 300,000 to just 50,000 metric tonnes is the latest twist in a saga that has completely exposed the confusion, lack of foresight and planning, and utter incompetence that has defined the government's handling of sugar export and import decisions in recent months.
More tellingly, it reveals a policy regime designed to reward rent-seeking behaviour rather than protecting the public interest and market stability.
As previously detailed in this space, the government, acting under the considerable, and dare one say, pernicious influence of powerful sugar barons, many of whom hold prominent positions within the political mileu, approved the export of roughly 765,000 metric tonnes of sugar during the last fiscal year.
The decision was ostensibly based on assurances that only surplus stocks would be exported, ensuring that domestic prices would remain stable. However, what ensued was a shortage of sugar domestically and a sharp price surge, solely benefitting trade. To rein in soaring domestic prices, the government recently decided to allow the tax-concessions on import of sugar.
The timing of the import decision, however, highlights a serious lack of planning and coordination among key stakeholders. By the time imported sugar enters the Pakistani market, the local crushing season will be in full swing, risking disruption to the domestic crop's market.
Even more critically, importing such large quantities raises questions regarding the pressures that will be brought to bear on our precarious foreign exchange reserves.
And given the tax waivers on these imports – wherein the FBR has exempted these from customs duty and reduced the sales tax rate from 18 percent to 0.25 percent – not only is this going to seriously burden the national exchequer, the country will also risk violating the $7 billion IMF programme that mandates it to not grant preferential tax treatments or engage in commodity purchases.
While the IMF has made no official comment, there are reports of it privately taking strong exception to the government's haphazard moves that deviate from agreed reforms. It is this pressure, ostensibly, that compelled the TCP to considerably scale back its sugar import tender.
The exorbitant prices Pakistani consumers have been forced to pay for sugar reveal not only the folly of the ill-conceived decision to export the commodity in the first place, it also points to deeper, systemic issues related to rampant price manipulation, hoarding, the entrenched political clout of sugar barons, their cartel-like behaviour and the collapse of regulatory oversight.
Over the last seven months, there has been a consistent rise in prices of the commodity from Rs140 per kg to around Rs210 per kg even as its international price at current exchange rate levels hovers around the Rs104 per kg mark. Now, despite the government reaching an agreement with mill owners that fixed the wholesale price at Rs165 per kg, media reports indicate that many wholesale outlets have openly defied the agreement, demanding prices far beyond the official rate.
As a result, consumers continue to face inflated retail prices that bear little relation to the official ex-factory cost. This encapsulates all that is wrong with the regime governing the trade of agricultural commodities: toothless oversight mechanisms, unchecked power and impunity of entrenched agro-industrial lobbies, and the complete marginalisation of the public interest.
It must be noted that sugar is not a staple crop nor does it have substantive strategic value. Given this, it is unacceptable that successive governments have essentially subsidised its growth at the cost of more vital commodities. The government must put an end to the mollycoddling of the sugar sector and enforce discipline and transparency in its regulation.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PM Shehbaz hails World Bank position on IWT
PM Shehbaz hails World Bank position on IWT

Express Tribune

time15 minutes ago

  • Express Tribune

PM Shehbaz hails World Bank position on IWT

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday praised the World Bank for its support of Pakistan's position on the Indus Waters Treaty, criticising India's 'unilateral and illegal' actions that he said undermine the landmark agreement. Tensions between India and Pakistan escalated after the April 22 attack in Pahalgam, Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK), which killed 26 people. India blamed Pakistan for the attack but provided no evidence. Islamabad strongly denied the allegations. On April 23, India closed the Wagah border crossing, revoked Pakistani visas, and announced the suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty. Pakistan condemned the move as an 'act of war' and responded by sealing the Wagah border from its side. In a meeting with Ousmane Dione, World Bank Regional Vice President for the Middle East, North Africa, Afghanistan, and Pakistan, Shehbaz reiterated Pakistan's commitment to upholding international law, pursuing peaceful dialogue, and promoting regional prosperity. Regional Vice President of the World Bank Ousmane Dione called on Prime Minister Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif. — Government of Pakistan (@GovtofPakistan) July 24, 2025 The prime minister expressed appreciation for the World Bank's longstanding partnership and described its backing as aligned with Pakistan's lawful stance on water rights under the treaty. Shehbaz also acknowledged the strategic role of the Country Partnership Framework in supporting Pakistan's national priorities, particularly in the areas of energy, climate change, human development, and governance reform. Read: World Bank approves $194m for education, water security in Balochistan He thanked the Bank for its timely assistance during the 2022 floods, which enabled Pakistan to launch emergency relief and rehabilitation efforts for affected communities. Dione reaffirmed the World Bank's commitment to expanding collaboration with Pakistan and lauded the government's reform agenda aimed at ensuring macroeconomic stability and long-term sustainability. Both sides expressed a shared resolve to deepen cooperation in the coming years to accelerate development and improve livelihoods. Earlier, the World Bank reaffirmed its support for Pakistan's economic stability during a separate meeting held on Wednesday between Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Ahad Cheema and Ousmane Dione at the Ministry of Economic Affairs in Islamabad. According to an official statement from the Ministry of Economic Affairs, the Bank appreciated Pakistan's reform efforts and progress under the Country Partnership Framework. Both sides discussed avenues for deepening cooperation in critical sectors, with an emphasis on ensuring sustained recovery and long-term financial resilience.

Rupee gains against US dollar amid reported crackdown
Rupee gains against US dollar amid reported crackdown

Business Recorder

timean hour ago

  • Business Recorder

Rupee gains against US dollar amid reported crackdown

Rupee's Performance Against US Dollar Since 04 March 2025 The Pakistani rupee strengthened against the US dollar, appreciating 0.19% in the inter-bank market on Thursday. At close, the currency settled at 284.22, a gain of Re0.54. On Wednesday, the currency settled at 284.76. Pakistan's law enforcement agencies have reportedly launched a crackdown against foreign currency smugglers, aiming to prevent the illegal outflow of currencies such as US dollars to neighbouring countries, including Afghanistan and Iran. The raids led to some appreciation of the rupee against US dollar on Wednesday, said Exchange Companies Association of Pakistan (ECAP) chairman Malik Muhammad Bostan on Wednesday. Internationally, the euro crept toward its highest level in nearly four years on Thursday while the yen held to gains following more progress on trade deals between the United States and its largest trading partners, which in turn lifted the broader market mood. Currencies mostly shrugged off news that US President Donald Trump, a vocal critic of Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, will visit the central bank on Thursday. It was not immediately clear whether Trump, who has lambasted Powell repeatedly for not cutting US interest rates more aggressively, would be meeting with the Fed chief. Markets were paying close attention to various tariff negotiations. The European Union and the US are moving towards a trade agreement that could include a 15% US baseline tariff on EU goods and possible exemptions, two European diplomats said on Wednesday. That came on the heels of Washington's trade deal with Tokyo that lowers tariffs on auto imports and spares the latter from punishing new levies on other goods in exchange for a $550 billion package of US-bound investment and loans. Global markets took to the latest developments positively, as risk assets rallied and investors sold the US dollar. The dollar index eased slightly to 97.15. Oil prices, a key indicator of currency parity, rose on Thursday, buoyed by optimism over US trade negotiations that would ease pressure on the global economy and a sharper-than-expected decline in US crude inventories. Brent crude futures gained 24 cents, or 0.4%, to $68.75 a barrel by 0032 GMT. US West Texas Intermediate crude futures climbed 25 cents, or 0.4%, to $65.50 per barrel. Both benchmarks were little changed on Wednesday as markets monitored developments in US-European Union trade talks, following President Donald Trump's tariff deal with Japan.

Reciprocal tariff: Pakistan officials to meet Trump administration, Bloomberg reports
Reciprocal tariff: Pakistan officials to meet Trump administration, Bloomberg reports

Business Recorder

time2 hours ago

  • Business Recorder

Reciprocal tariff: Pakistan officials to meet Trump administration, Bloomberg reports

A Pakistani delegation will soon meet the administration of US President Donald Trump in a bid to reach an agreement on a trade deal, Bloomberg quoted US State Department Spokesperson Tammy Bruce as saying. In a US Department of State press briefing a day ago, Bruce said she will attend the meeting between the Pakistani delegation and US officials. Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Senator Mohammad Ishaq Dar is currently visiting the United States to attend high-level signature events of Pakistan's UN Security Council (UNSC) presidency in New York, as well as for important bilateral engagements in Washington, as per the Foreign Office (FO). Islamabad is looking forward to the 29% reciprocal tariffs to be lifted that the Trump administration levied initially, Bloomberg said. The South Asian country has proposed to increase imports of soybeans and cotton, while it already is the second-largest buyer of US cotton by value, after China. Whereas, Pakistan's biggest export destination is the United States. Bilateral ties between Pakistan and US have improved in recent times, with Trump's holding a rare meeting with Field Marshal Asim Munir at the White House. The FO stated on July 19 that FM Dar's visit is an indication of Pakistan's increasing importance in both its relations with the US and the global landscape. Aurangzeb meets US Secy Commerce Moreover, in order to complete a trade agreement, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb has also visited the United States and met with US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick and US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer in Washington recently to advance economic cooperation, as per the Ministry of Finance. Reuters last week reported that the negotiations, focused on reciprocal tariffs, are part of a broader push to reset economic ties at a time of shifting geopolitical alignments and Pakistan's efforts to avoid steep US duties on exports.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store