
Jury finds Oliphant guilty of murder
Guilty verdicts were returned at 8:30 p.m. Friday, three hours after deliberations began, on two charges of murder and two counts of felonious assault. Jurors got a late start deliberating Friday after a morning that included a rebuttal witness from the state and an extended conversation that ultimately led to the removal of one juror from the panel.
Oliphant, 23, of Lima, was charged with murder in connection with Perine's death and also faced charges of felonious assault for allegedly firing a weapon in the direction of two employees of Feltz Chiropractic that same afternoon. Firearm specifications were attached to all four counts.
A Beretta 9mm pistol said to have been used in both shootings was found by police in an alley behind 211 N. Kenilworth Ave., near the murder scene, and was sent to the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation for analysis. A forensic scientist from that agency testified that DNA matching Oliphant's was found on four separate areas of the weapon.
The 59-year-old Perine was found by police inside a white Buick in the 100 block of North Rosedale Avenue. He had suffered a gunshot wound and was pronounced dead at the scene. The fatal bullet had been fired from outside the vehicle and passed through the front passenger-side window, investigators said.
Sentencing will be held at a later date.
On Thursday, jurors watched video of an interview with the Lima man while he was in custody at the Lima Police Department on the evening of the shooting. When advised by LPD Detective Matt Boss that he was under arrest on a charge of murder, Oliphant appeared stunned.
"I killed someone? Who?" he asked emphatically. "I didn't mean to kill anyone."
Insanity defense
Attorneys Steve Chamberlain and Ken Sturgill from the Allen County Public Defenders Office early in the case had filed a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity on behalf of their client. By law that plea requires that evidence be presented by the defense that proves Oliphant was unable to distinguish right from wrong at the time of the offense.
The defense called just one witness in its portion of the case. Dr. Bob Stinson, a licensed psychologist who did an extensive review of Oliphant's mental health history, cited a diagnosis from doctors at Mercy Health-St. Rita's Medical Center in May 2020 and again in December of 2022 — two months before the death of Perine — that said Oliphant suffered from paranoia and bipolar disorder and was exhibiting psychotic behavior and was "completely unstable and grossly psychotic."
That convinced Stinson that Oliphant was legally insane at the time of the shootings. He said Dr. Massimo DeMarchis, who performed an initial psychological evaluation of the defendant at the request of the court, wrote that he found no evidence that Oliphant had a mental defect at the time of the incident.
"That's just wrong," Stinson said. "There were three years of evidence."
DeMarchis supported his findings during testimony Friday. He said Oliphant, during an evaluation at the Forensic Psychiatry Center of Western Ohio in Dayton, claimed to have been "hearing voices" and believed he was being pursued by "shadowy demonic figures" on the afternoon in question.
DeMarchis said he believed those stories to be "fabricated and untrue." His formal findings included an opinion that "despite suffering from severe mental health disease," Oliphant did "understand the wrongfulness of his actions" on Feb. 15, 2023.
Juror excused
An alternate juror was summoned into action Friday after Judge Terri Kohlrieser dismissed one male jury member from the panel prior to closing arguments.
An issue arose Thursday concerning a juror who had contact outside the courtroom with members of the defendant's family on successive days. The male juror — the lone person of color on the panel — was seen on court security video approaching Oliphant's father and sister during breaks in the trial.
Questioned by the judge, the man said he was merely asking the two individuals for cigarettes, a claim disputed by prosecutors. Prosecutor Destiny Caldwell asked Kohlrieser to remove the man from the jury, based on his acceptance of "gifts" from people he knew to be family members of the defendant. Chamberlain objected and asked Kohlrieser to deny the motion. The judge allowed the jurist to remain seated throughout the day on Thursday.
Kohlrieser on Friday said she had researched the matter overnight but allowed lawyers to make additional comments. Chief Assistant Prosecutor Kyle Thines repeated the state's assertion that the juror had compromised his integrity and reliability by reaching out to known members of the defendant's family.
"The state has grave concerns about his fairness and impartiality ... and feels this juror should be removed," Thines said.
Chamberlain argued there was no evidence of misconduct by the juror, only an unfounded suspicion by the state that additional conversation had taken place.
"And frankly the belief of the state doesn't hold much weight," he said.
Kohlrieser disagreed, saying the juror had demonstrated he was "no longer able to perform his duties."
Featured Local Savings
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Dominion Post
3 days ago
- Dominion Post
Vehicle smashes through multiple Pinecrest Plaza storefronts
The Monongalia County Sheriff's Department is investigating how a vehicle ended up driving through roughly 100 feet of storefronts off Point Marion Road on Thursday. According to information shared by MCSD, deputies were alerted to an accident at Pinecrest Plaza at 11:40 arrived to find a vehicle completely inside the mixed-use building owned by RDR Properties, which falls under Metro Property Management. Two vehicles in the parking lot were hit and received heavy damage before the wayward Buick struck the building at a shallow angle and plowed through multiple vacant storefronts before partially exiting the building approximately 100 feet away. Dave Biafora, representing Metro Property Management, said he believes a medical issue caused the driver to lose control. Both the driver and passenger of the vehicle received on-scene treatment before being transported to J.W. Ruby Memorial Hospital for further care, according to the MCSD. 'Luckily, nobody got really hurt,' Biafora said, explaining the storefronts to the right of the entry point are occupied, while those that ended up in the line of travel are not. 'There was damage to the building, obviously, and all the storefronts – drywall, interior walls, ceiling lights. He basically took out the left half of the building,' Biafora said. 'That type of structure, the basement and lower level is all concrete and metal and steel. The top floor is all wood. The way the car actually went in the middle of the storefronts and came out almost at the end was absolutely amazing, truly.' According to Biafora, tenants in the 18 second-floor apartments were not required to relocate as the apartments were not damaged and the building remains structurally sound. He said facilities personnel with MPM had the site cleaned up by 4 p.m. or so. 'You go back up and look and you'll just think someone took the doors and windows out. It's all cleaned up, everything is stabilized, the building's inspected, the fire alarms checked, the power company came through and everything's good,' he said. In addition to the sheriff's department, Mon EMS, Cheat Lake Fire Rescue and Brookhaven Fire Rescue responded to the scene.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Highway 14 crash with big rig claims life of man in Huron
A Miller, South Dakota man died in a two-vehicle 7:45 a.m. crash Monday, July 21, in Huron. Preliminary crash information indicates Caleb William Schuette, the driver of a 2001 Buick LeSabre, was traveling northbound on West Park Avenue and failed to yield at the stop sign, entering the intersection at U.S. Highway 14, according to the South Dakota Highway Patrol. A 2007 Kenworth Construction T800 semitruck, driven by Jeremy Elmer Getscher, was traveling eastbound on Highway 14 and collided with the Buick, the release stated. The incident took place at U.S. Highway 14, mile marker 344, near West Park Avenue, in Huron. The Buick came to rest in the northwest ditch and the semi came to rest in the eastbound lanes of US 14, the release stated. The incident closed the highway for approximately five 31, of Miller died on the scene, the release stated. Getscher, 34, of Wolsey, was not injured. Both men were wearing seat South Dakota Highway Patrol is investigating the crash. All information released so far is only Highway Patrol is an agency of the South Dakota Department of Public Safety. This article originally appeared on Watertown Public Opinion: Driver killed in Highway 14 crash with semitruck in Huron, SD Solve the daily Crossword


Miami Herald
5 days ago
- Miami Herald
Mystified driver finds fur in car's grille. Creature was still alive, FL cops say
A thick layer of fur found in the grille of a Buick proved to be a wild animal — and it was still alive, according to deputies in southwest Florida. The potentially dangerous discovery was made Thursday, July 17, at a busy intersection in Port Charlotte, the Charlotte County Sheriff's Office says. 'We responded to a call and found an animal had run out in front of a vehicle, got hit, and became stuck in the front portion of the bumper,' the sheriff's office said in a Facebook post. 'That animal turned out to be a coyote, which we appropriately named Wile E.' Coyotes weigh between 20 and 30 pounds and have been known to attack humans. Photos show two men wearing elbow-length gloves worked to remove the coyote. The sheriff's office didn't say if it tried to bite its rescuers. 'Wile E. needed medical attention (apparently anvils don't hurt, but vehicles do), so Wildlife Center of Southwest Florida Rescue and Transport was contacted, who came to get him,' the sheriff's office said. Two of the male coyote's legs were broken in the collision, but he 'is now safe in our care and expected to make a full recovery,' Southwest Florida Rescue reports. The department's July 21 Facebook post had more than 6,000 reactions and comments within a day, many wondering if the coyote was cooperative. 'So you can pull a whole coyote, with two (broken) legs but no tranquilizer, out of a car bumper and not get bit?' Kim Carlisle wrote. 'Don't try this at home!' the department responded.