Trump's tariffs haven't raised prices yet. That might be a bad sign
This week's inflation reports in both the United States and Canada were surprisingly benign, given we're in a trade war. In both countries, inflation ticked upwards, but just a bit: enough to keep central banks from cutting interest rates but not to ring the sort of alarm bells that the 'Liberation Day' tariff announcement set off.
On the face of it, therefore, Donald Trump has been vindicated. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt crowed, 'The data proves that President Trump is stabilizing inflation and the Panicans continue to be wrong about tariffs raising prices.' To underscore this point, much was made of a release showing Japanese car prices falling, apparent evidence that Mr. Trump's prediction that foreigners would pay the tariffs was being borne out.
But in fact, the data may be more troubling than the White House is letting on. The Japanese figures appear to have been a one-off, reflecting the large cushion Japanese automakers had accumulated: years of a weak yen having made their cars cheap in America, swelling their profits and thus allowing them to slash prices to hold market share.
U.S. Federal Reserve's inflation fears start to be realized with June CPI increase
But the broader data we're getting on import prices doesn't reveal any softening. On the contrary, a mild inflation continues. So on the whole, foreign exporters aren't eating the tariffs by lowering their prices. That means someone stateside is paying them, and they're paying a lot – US$64-billion in the second quarter alone, nearly US$50-billion more than the same time last year.
There are two candidates: businesses and consumers. The big surge in tariff revenues came in May, which confirms what was already suspected – that importers had got ahead of tariffs by stockpiling goods early in the year. Those stocks apparently began to run out only in May, which would account for the take-off of revenue collections then. Given the time between a good's arrival in port and its appearance on store shelves, we would not expect major price increases until perhaps the late summer, which explains some of the softness in prices.
In addition, we're getting anecdotal evidence that American companies are, for now, absorbing the hit from tariffs. Given the on-again-off-again character of Mr. Trump's trade war, it's still not clear if tariffs will be in place later this year. He may chicken out and suspend them again, as investors expect, or he may win the great trade deals he's trying to squeeze out of other countries, dropping his tariffs in response. Until more clarity emerges about the long-term status of tariffs, companies are choosing not to alienate their customers with price rises, and are hoping for better days.
That can't go on forever, though. Absorbing the tariffs is pressuring their bottom lines, which means they have less money left over for investments, pay rises or Christmas bonuses. This has been showing up in both the soft and hard data, with companies cutting back their hiring plans, job and wage growth slowing and future investment plans softening.
Opinion: The market is in denial. Trump wants higher tariffs, and he's getting them
Opinion: Trump's trade war madness won't last
The picture that emerges, therefore, is of an economy that is slowing as businesses absorb the tariffs. The slowing economy has reduced demand, which in turn has caused service-sector prices to rise more slowly. That disinflation has then counterbalanced the price rises we are seeing elsewhere in the economy, where the impact of tariffs is starting to materialize. For instance, food prices are trending back up in the U.S., which is to be expected since unlike durable goods, food can't be stockpiled, so the effect of tariffs shows up more quickly.
In other words, good news on inflation is bad news for the economy. That may be an omen of what lies ahead. If the economy continues slowing, falling demand may keep prices from rising too sharply, but it could also point to a coming recession. Hardly a vindication of the White House.
If instead the tax-cuts windfall from Mr. Trump's Big Beautiful Bill stokes sufficient demand to keep the economy out of recession, but the tariffs remain in place, companies will eventually pass along the price rises. That could begin happening in the autumn. The return of inflation, not least to food prices, would also augur ill for the White House, given that Mr. Trump ran for office promising to bring them down.
The worst scenario of all is that we get a bit of both, raising the prospect of the dreaded stagflation returning. Mr. Trump's get-out-of-jail card will be if America's trading partners cave and agree to trade deals which both boost U.S. export sales and allow tariffs to fall. So the next few weeks will be crucial, since the President has set Aug. 1 as a deadline for many of the tariffs to take effect.
He has until then to end his trade wars, with either victory or surrender. If neither happens, autumn could turn ugly.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
26 minutes ago
- National Post
Trump could crush Canada's softwood exports. Here's how a new crisis could play out
WASHINGTON, D.C. — The Canada-U.S. softwood lumber trade relationship has dealt with ups and downs, disputes and resolutions, for decades. Anxiety for Canadian exporters is reaching a fever pitch again as the U.S. threatens to more than double softwood lumber duties and add even steeper tariffs under a national security investigation. Article content Canadian foresters, mills, and governments that enjoy taxes, economic spinoffs and stumpage fees from Crown land will feel the pain if they lose too much access to the massive U.S. market. But larger producers have been preparing for just this kind of contingency and have cleverly hedged their bets, building capacity in the U.S., where they can sell as much as they want to Americans, tariff-free. Article content Article content Canadian firms will soon receive word from the U.S. Commerce Department's Sixth Administrative Review (AR6) of U.S. countervailing and anti-dumping duties on Canadian softwood lumber exports, with the rate expected to jump from around 14 per cent to roughly 34 per cent. For Canfor, the Vancouver-based lumber giant selected as a mandatory respondent in the AR6 review, it will be even worse. Its duties are calculated based on its own shipments and prices, not an industry average, like it is for other companies. Article content Article content Then there's the threat of tariffs from President Donald Trump's ongoing national security investigation of Canadian lumber imports under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act, which he ordered in March and is due late this year. Currently, lumber shipments are exempted from Trump's baseline tariffs, because they're covered by the U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade deal (USMCA), but that could soon change based on the findings of the 232 probe. Article content Article content National Post breaks down the position of the two countries, what the impacts could be, and how Canadian producers are trying to mitigate the potential damage of punitive trade barriers. Article content Article content The U.S. Lumber Coalition is playing for keeps. It backs higher anti-dumping duties and tariffs for what it sees as a subsidized domestic industry. It claims Canadian producers don't pay market rates for stumpage because their forests are publicly owned and provincial governments set the stumpage rates, while U.S. producers face higher market rates. But it doesn't stop there: the U.S. coalition also wants to see Canada's U.S. market share significantly chopped. Article content Miller isn't shy about the goals: 'A countrywide quota with no exemptions and no carveouts, and a single-digit market share' for Canadian lumber. Article content Today, Canada has a 25 per cent market share, with exports of 12 billion feet of softwood lumber to the U.S. each year, according to the coalition. Softwood lumber accounts for about 7.5 per cent of Canadian exports; in 2023, the U.S. was the destination for 68 per cent of those forestry products. The whole industry is worth about $33.4 billion in sales annually and employs more than 200,000 workers across Canada, according to a report this year from RBC.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
‘We can't stop there': Marking 20 years since same-sex marriage was legalized
Twenty years after same-sex marriage became legal in Canada, couples who fought for that right and other advocates are celebrating the milestone while also acknowledging that there's a long way to go before reaching full equality.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Off-duty border patrol agent shot in a Manhattan park in apparent botched robbery, police say
The lower Manhattan skyline is seen from Little Island park, Friday, Nov. 22, 2024, in New York. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson) NEW YORK — An off-duty U.S. Customs and Border Protection officer was shot in a Manhattan park on Saturday following an apparent robbery gone wrong, New York City police and federal officials say. The 42-year-old officer was in stable condition Sunday and expected to survive. A spokesperson for the NYPD said there was no indication that the shooting was politically motivated. The agent, who was not in uniform, was sitting in a park beneath the George Washington Bridge when he was approached by a man riding on the back of a moped, who then shot him in the face and arm, police said. The off-duty officer returned fire as the moped driver and alleged shooter rode off. No arrests had been made as of Sunday afternoon, according to a police spokesperson. The Department of Homeland Security shared video online of the two men on a moped, alleging the shooter was caught entering the country illegally in 2023, but released. The NYPD spokesperson said they had no information about the source of that claim. In a social media post Sunday afternoon, U.S. President Donald Trump seized on the shooting as evidence of Democrats' failures to secure the border. 'The CBP Officer bravely fought off his attacker, despite his wounds, demonstrating enormous Skill and Courage,' Trump added. The shooting comes as federal officials warn of a surge of attacks on agents carrying out President Donald Trump's mass deportation agenda. As enforcement efforts have ramped up in recent months, many officers have chosen to cover their faces with the goal of avoiding harassment in public and online. On Sunday, the acting director of U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, Todd Lyons, said he would allow agents to continue covering their faces as a safety measure. 'If that's a tool that the men and women of ICE that keeps themselves and their families safe, then I will allow it,' Lyons said. The Associated Press
