Irish troop missions 'held hostage' by UN veto, says former army colonel
Former Colonel Colm Doyle – who has also served at UN HQ – told the Oireachtas Defence Committee that claims that the removal of the UN authorisation obligation would threaten Ireland's military neutrality were 'greatly misjudged'.
The committee is continuing hearings on the Defence Bill 2025 which proposes to scrap the requirement for UN approval to send Defence Forces abroad.
The 'Triple Lock' refers to three hurdles – Government, Dáil, and UN – that must be cleared before troops, beyond 12 personnel, can be deployed overseas.
The bill authorises Irish troops to take part in an 'International Force' for the purposes of peacekeeping, conflict prevention, and international security 'consistent with the principles of the United Nations Charter'.
It also plans to increase the number of personnel that can be sent overseas – from 12 to 50 – without the Government needing Dáil approval.
Col Doyle told the committee: 'On the subject of the triple lock and its retention or amendment which has become politically emotive, I find myself very surprised.
That this is in some way being described as a threat to our military neutrality is, in my view greatly misjudged and I do not support those opposing the measure.
He said the UN veto system reflects the 'realities' of global power dynamics, but said it also leads to 'deadlock' where the permanent five members' interests conflict.
'This illustrates one of the main flaws of the UN Security Council - that Ireland's involvement in international peacekeeping can effectively be held hostage by any one of the permanent five members' use of, or threat of the use of a veto,' he said.
"Surely we have the confidence, maturity, and political experience to make our own decisions for Ireland's overseas policy to evolve in response.'
Former Army Ranger Cathal Berry said the original purpose of the Triple Lock was 'to give Dublin a veto' over any Security Council order for overseas deployment, not to give "New York a veto over Dublin".
He said 'no other country, whether neutral or otherwise' require UN authorisation. But he said many parliaments have regard to it. He suggested the Oireachtas Defence Committee and the Attorney General could have a role in examining any proposed deployment.
Major General Kieran Brennan, retired, said the committee members faced a dilemma: 'Do we stand on principle and say no to overseas deployments unless there is an UN Security Resolution because of its supposed impacts on our neutral status or should the saving and enhancements of people's lives trump all else?
'With a dysfunctional UN Security Council are we destined to remain on the sidelines expecting others to intervene on our behalf? Accordingly, I support the proposals.'
Read More
Government proposal on triple Lock gives an Irish solution to an Irish problem
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Sarah Harte: Limiting freedom of speech is a threat to a functioning democracy
The poet and public intellectual Thomas McCarthy told me this week that he thought the Western World was depressed. One depressing and alarming development is the erosion of freedom of speech. Censorship is proliferating in front of our eyes, and it's reached our shores with real-life consequences for our adult children. America, no longer the land of the brave and the free, is where Irish J1 students will have their social media posts checked going back five years. There is something surreal about this. Big Brother is watching you but not even bothering to hide it. Last week, it was reported in the Irish Examiner that visa applicants must 'list all social media usernames or handles of every platform they have used from the last five years on the DS-160 visa application form.' Privacy settings on all social media platforms must be set to public. Talk about having a chilling effect on freedom of speech among a crop of young people who have just come of voting age. We need their young voices. I chatted to a retired senior judge about this last weekend, and he was horrified by the development. As he said, bad things like this happen incrementally, until one day you wake up to a knock on the door and think, 'Jesus, how did we get here?' Workers stand handcuffed after being arrested by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, ICE, at Delta Downs Racetrack, Hotel and Casino in Calcasieu Parish, near Vinton, Louisiana last month. Photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement via AP Both the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste have expressed concern. Simon Harris intends to raise the matter with the new US Ambassador next month. Micheál Martin has stated that he disagrees with the measures. In reality, the American Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) now essentially reject travellers to the United States who are not ideologically in line with the regime. The parameters of what is considered dissent against the regime seem broad and vague. Imagine if we checked the phones of American tourists in Dublin and said, 'No, sorry, you don't get to see the Cliffs of Moher or the Book of Kells because we see from your social media posts that you deny the genocide in Gaza and you seem supportive of Benjamin Netanyahu'. What the hell has happened to America with its modern-day version of McCarthyism restraining people who hold opposing views? Are all lessons from the past being lost? Barack Obama, who has frustrated many Democrats with his relative silence on a range of subjects in the USA, issued a warning a week ago that America is dangerously close to losing its democracy. Except it's not just in America that this censorship is taking place. Kneecap fans at Glastonbury at the weekend. Following the festival, British police are considering whether to launch criminal investigations into the hip hop group and punk duo Bob Vylan. Freedom of speech has been under relentless attack in the UK. Their Public Order Act 1986 is capable of broad interpretation. In tandem with two further acts of 2002 and 2022, it effectively allows policing to be politicised with jokes, social media posts, and even private conversations arguably coming within their dragnet. Following the Glastonbury Festival last weekend, British police are considering whether to launch criminal investigations into two acts: the Irish hip-hop group Kneecap and the punk duo Bob Vylan. One of the members of Bob Vylan chanted 'Death, death, to the IDF'. The police announced the possibility of an investigation on Saturday on X. You might not like what someone says, but you may want to ensure that people still have the right to say it. The question is, where does cultural resistance and performance (including satire) end and terrorism or incitement to hatred begin? This is not an easy question to answer, but it is a vitally important one. While 'Glasto' was going on, John Brennan, former Director of the CIA, addressed a summer school for the Law Society's Centre for Justice and Law Reform in Dublin. It was on the theme 'Defending Democracy: Legal Responses to Emerging Threats'. He remarked on the 'delicate balance' faced by governments in permitting free speech while prohibiting hate speech and incitement to violence. We've had a back-and-forth on this ourselves, with hate speech laws being dropped last year by former minister for justice Helen McEntee due to a lack of consensus on the thorny issue. I have found myself flip-flopping on the subject, but I have come to believe that we should probably be wary of hate speech laws for fear of stifling public discourse. Kneecap It is precisely because clamping down on freedom of expression is taken so seriously by human rights lawyers that Kneecap's frontman, Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh, who performs under the name Mo Chara, has attracted an extraordinarily heavyweight legal team defending him in his alleged terrorism offence. He was charged last month for allegedly displaying a flag in support of Iran-backed militant group Hezbollah at a concert in November 2024. He has firmly denied the charge but is currently on bail. Ó hAnnaidh's legal team (Kneecap call them An Scoithfhoireann or the Dream Team) is a roll call of who's who in human rights law, including Gareth Peirce, who formerly represented the Guildford Four and the Birmingham Six. Peirce has devoted decades to defending underdogs. Critics see her as destabilising the establishment and undermining national security, which is the catch-all rationale that the Americans are using now to reject visa applications or even detain people. Peirce has spoken in the past about the dangers of stigmatising people as a threat to national security when they're not, and 'how justice dies when the law is co-opted for political purposes'. Gareth Peirce avoids the media like the plague, but in an old interview, she said: 'We take it on trust that if the government suspects people of terrorism and locks them up, or puts them on control orders without charge, they must be terrorists.' When a political context is as febrile as it is now, it is more likely that governments will dismantle fundamental freedoms, and we won't question what is really going on. Could this crackdown be a reaction or an attempted distraction from the allegation that the British state has failed to uphold international law and arguably been complicit in genocide through its supply of arms to Israel? Either way, the trial promises to be an important test of the principle of freedom of expression. At Glastonbury, Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh accused Israel of genocide and led the crowd in a chant of "free, free Palestine' as well as anti-Starmer chants. The anti-Starmer chants were explained by British Prime Minister Keir Starmer's remarks last week when he said that it was 'not appropriate' for Kneecap to appear at Glastonbury. Michael Eavis and his daughter Emily, who run the famous festival, were said to have been pressurised not to let them play. At Glastonbury, Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh accused Israel of genocide and led the crowd in a chant of 'free, free Palestine' as well as anti-Starmer chants. Photo: Yui Mok/PA Meanwhile, in Germany, you can't hold a pro-Palestine demonstration without risking arrest and being accused of anti-Semitism. The Irish writer, Naoise Dolan, has spoken about being detained twice in Berlin for attending pro-Palestinian demonstrations. We're fortunate enough to live in a country where freedom of speech is protected in our Constitution. We received a positive school report from the Democracy Index last year, indicating that we have a fully functioning democracy and are expected to perform well in the 2025 Index. Let's keep it that way because we need dissenting voices now more than ever.
RTÉ News
5 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Harris to tell forum that 10% US tariffs are 'new normal'
Tánaiste Simon Harris will tell a trade forum today that US tariffs of 10% on exports from Ireland will be the "new normal" but that efforts are continuing to agree zero for zero taxes in some key areas. The meeting takes place a week before the scheduled lifting of a pause on higher tariffs by the US president Donald Trump. The Government's forum is comprised of State agencies, business groups, unions and senior ministers. At present most Irish exports to the US now have tariffs of 10%. But there are significant exceptions including Ireland's pharmaceuticals sector and computer chip manufacturers. Those arrangements were in place temporarily pending a trade deal between the US and EU but they could now become permanent. The EU is reportedly negotiating to keep some sectors free of tariffs and accepting 10% duties on other goods. Today's meeting will also hear an update on the new strategy for the computer chip industry. The forum will also receive an economic assessment of impact of tariffs from Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe. There will also be discussion about how Irish companies can diversify into new markets. Ahead of the meeting, the Tánaiste said Ireland needed an agreement "that has zero-for-zero or as near as possible in as many areas as possible". "We cannot ignore the fact that every single day the trading relationship between the EU and the US is worth more than €4 billion," Mr Harris said.
RTÉ News
9 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Israeli attacks on Gaza ramp up before Netanyahu US visit
Residents in Gaza have reported fierce Israeli gunfire and shelling as Israel's military said that it had expanded its operations, days before a planned trip to Washington by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The intensified attacks came after days of mounting calls for a ceasefire, with US President Donald Trump - whom the Israeli prime minister is scheduled to meet next week - among those urging Israel to strike a new deal to halt the war and bring home the hostages still held in Gaza. Israeli forces killed at least 20 people today, Gaza's civil defence agency reported. Raafat Halles, 39, from the Shujaiya district of Gaza City, said "air strikes and shelling have intensified over the past week", and tanks have been advancing. "I believe that every time negotiations or a potential ceasefire are mentioned, the army escalates crimes and massacres on the ground," he said. "I don't know why." Amer Daloul, a 44-year-old resident of Gaza City, also reported fiercer clashes between Israeli forces and militants in recent days, saying that he and his family were forced to flee the tent they were living in at dawn today "due to heavy and random gunfire and shelling". Photographers saw Israeli tanks deploying at the Gaza border in southern Israel and children picking through the rubble of a destroyed home in Gaza City. Others photographed Palestinians mourning over the bodies of relatives in the city's Al-Shifa hospital and the Al-Aqsa hospital in Deir el-Balah, central Gaza. Aid seekers killed Civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal said that eight people were killed near aid distribution sites in central and southern Gaza, in the latest in a spate of deadly attacks on those seeking food. He said one person was killed and 50 wounded when tanks and drones opened fire as crowds were waiting to collect aid near the Wadi Gaza Bridge in the middle of the territory. The civil defence agency said another six people were killed nearby while trying to reach the same aid centre. At least one more person was killed near another aid centre in Rafah, it added. Commenting on those incidents, the Israeli military said its forces "fired warning shots to distance suspects who approached the troops", adding it was not aware of any injuries but would review the incidents. In the Rafah incident, it said the shots were fired "hundreds of metres away from the aid distribution site", which was "not operating". Mr Bassal said later that an air strike killed three people in front of a school housing displaced people in the Al-Daraj neighbourhood of Gaza City, raising the overall toll to 20. Calls for return of UN-led aid mechanism A group of 169 aid organisations called yesterday for an end to Gaza's "deadly" new US- and Israeli-backed aid distribution scheme, which they said was leading to civilian deaths. They said the system forced starving civilians to "trek for hours through dangerous terrain and active conflict zones, only to face a violent, chaotic race" for food. They urged a return to the UN-led aid mechanism that existed until March, when Israel imposed a full blockade on humanitarian assistance entering Gaza during an impasse in truce talks with Hamas. The new scheme's administrator, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), has distanced itself from reports of aid seekers being killed near its centres. Netanyahu to visit White House Mr Netanyahu announced he would visit Mr Trump and senior US security officials next week, amid mounting pressure to end more than 20 months of devastating fighting in Gaza. Mr Trump vowed to be "very firm" in his stance on ending the war when he meets the Israeli premier on 7 July. "But he (Netanyahu) wants it too.... He wants to end it too," the US president added. Hamas official Taher al-Nunu said the group is "ready to agree to any proposal if it will lead to an end to the war and a permanent ceasefire and a complete withdrawal of occupation forces". "So far, there has been no breakthrough."
