I'm no fan of Elon Musk. But Trump's threat to deport him is sickening
So the news that Donald Trump 'will take a look' at deporting his billionaire former 'first buddy' Musk has many smirking and shrugging: 'Couldn't happen to a nicer guy.'
I like a good comeuppance, but this doesn't please me at all. It sends a chill down the spine. It is the use of law enforcement agencies as a tool to chill debate, to silence disagreement and dissent, and to punish political opposition. Democracy is dimming fast in the United States, but threats to deport US citizens for disagreeing with the governing administration's policies are the domain of authoritarian regimes such as Belarus or Cameroon.
Coming just hours after his officials raised the possibility of stripping Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic mayoral candidate for New York who was naturalised in 2018, of his US citizenship, Trump's threat should have all of America – a country of immigrants – appalled, afraid and up in arms. As the Guardian reported on Tuesday, the White House press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, appeared to pave the way for an investigation into Mamdani's status after Andy Ogles, a rightwing Republican congressman for Tennessee, called for his citizenship to be revoked on the grounds that he might have concealed his support for 'terrorism' during the naturalization process. Trump has branded Mamdani 'a pure communist' and said 'we don't need a communist in this country'.
Mamdani has not broken any laws. His sin? Running for office.
In his threats against Mamdani and Musk, the president comes across like the notorious Republican senator Joseph McCarthy in the 1950s. McCarthy was, according to the Harvard law dean Ervin Griswold, 'judge, jury, prosecutor, castigator, and press agent, all in one'. Trump's threats to Musk and Mamdani are a departure from the administration's modus operandi of targeting foreign students involved in pro-Palestinian organizing on US college campuses. It is now targeting people it disagrees with on any issue. The threats are not based on any generally applicable laws but on the whim of the president or other administration leaders. It is an escalation of the assault on civil liberties using government entities to arbitrarily investigate and potentially punish critics.
Over the past four weeks Musk's sin has been to vehemently oppose Trump's sweeping spending bill, calling it a 'disgusting abomination'. Musk is of course not concerned about the bill's slashing of health insurance, food stamps and other aid for the poor, but that it does not slash enough and that its cuts to green energy tax credits may cost his company, Tesla, about $1.2bn.
But Musk is a US citizen with the right to oppose a piece of legislation without threats from the highest office in the land and the fear of deportation. When Musk poured $288m of his money into Trump and other Republicans' 2024 candidacies, no one raised a hand to question his credentials as an American. Instead, the administration gave him the run of the White House including midnight ice cream binges and a job as a glorified bean counter at DOGE.
The hypocrisy and the corruption embedded within Trump's deportation threats is mind-boggling but unsurprising given his track record. The consequence, like the McCarthyism of the 1950s, is a climate of fear and a chilling of political discourse and action. Proud Americans who arrived here recently, such as Mamdani, are fearful of running for office, of speaking their minds in true American tradition, despite having the same responsibilities and privileges as every other American conferred on them. Trump's threat does to Musk what it does to every immigrant: it shuts them up, it holds over their head the possibility of made-up charges and deportation to El Salvador or some other country.
Musk and his like were chortling when the Columbia University activist Mahmoud Khalil was cruelly detained for months. It is in the nature of those who like to tweet about freedom but do not think about it deeply enough, such as Musk, to not realize that their silence when the rights of a Khalil or a Mamdani are trampled upon will come back to haunt them. The Republican rump is silent today as Musk is threatened with deportation, just as it has been when masked men have come for Khalil and others who dared exercise their first amendment rights.
There will be silence when they come for the Republicans. That's because we will all be gone by then, after no one else said a thing.
Justice Malala is a political commentator and author of The Plot To Save South Africa: The Week Mandela Averted Civil War and Forged a New Nation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
30 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘Accelerated censorship': advocates criticize US supreme court ruling on LGBTQ+ books
Kiernan, a 24-year-old transgender person from Colorado, feels drained from dealing with legislation that consistently limits the spaces and freedoms of people like him. Since he transitioned in 2016, it's been the same – first bathroom bills, then censorship in the education system – routine attacks on LGBTQ+ rights that Kiernan feels have now just become part of living in the US. Now, in the wake of the Mahmoud v Taylor supreme court ruling, the stigmatization of these communities is likely to worsen. The highest court in the US ruled that parents in Maryland's Montgomery county school district can opt their children out of lessons that include books with LGBTQ+ themes and characters if they feel that it violates their religious rights. The move angered LGBTQ+ groups and civil rights advocates who also say that the lengthy and judicial process of these opt-outs could have chaotic implications for the US education system nationwide. 'LGBTQ-relevant books are just the beginning in accelerated censorship,' Sabrina Baêta, a senior member of PEN America, told the Guardian. 'What's to stop schools from backing away from any books that may be offensive? We have already seen other topics like Black history disappear as districts try to avoid anything potentially controversial.' PEN America highlighted in a recent report that teachers may be more likely to overlook topics that require parental consent, thereby brushing over crucial books and subjects in classrooms that promote diverse identities and learning. In administrative terms, the court's ruling also poses problems for teachers and educators. Rather than focusing on lessons at hand, they will have to grapple with what is or isn't appropriate on religious grounds. And while anything with LGBTQ+ themes will constitute a student being able to leave the classroom, it creates a grey zone for topics like science and history, where certain lessons – such as about reproduction – could be seen as now potentially inappropriate. Opt-outs are believed by experts to have a pernicious effect on educational environments, but their implementation is not a new phenomenon. For a short period between the 2022-2023 school year, the Montgomery county board of education allowed them after introducing several 'LGBTQ+ inclusive' texts into the curriculum. Less than a year after the books were introduced, however, the board rescinded this option, saying it 'could not accommodate the growing number of opt-out requests without causing significant disruptions to the classroom environment'. Moreover, a school board official stated that permitting some students to opt out while stories were being told would expose others to 'social stigma and isolation'. 'It's really frustrating and a burden on my psyche,' Kiernan said, speaking on the mounting number of bills and legislation that have recently targeted LGBTQ+ youth. 'These bills aren't doing anything positive for children; it's a political agenda that's trying to veil itself in support for religious people,' he said. 'I wish it would go away. Let people be people and stop using us as a political scapegoat.' Justin Driver, a professor at Yale Law School, submitted a document to the court in the Mahmoud v Taylor hearing in support of the Montgomery county school district, saying: 'the decision succeeds in opening Pandora's box in countless classrooms located in our nation's public schools.' Driver, who specializes in education law, believes it unwise that parents and students be granted the authority to veto individual school lessons and assignments, and added that legal experts have 'long extolled local control of public education'. 'Public schools must now brace themselves for a dizzying array of curricular opt-out demands,' Driver said, adding: 'the American education system will be much poorer for it.' When the conservative-dominated court ruled 6-3 in favour, siding with the Muslim, Christian and Catholic parents who brought the case, Justice Samuel Alito authored the majority opinion, and the three liberal justices – Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson – were in dissent. In the ruling, Alito wrote: 'We have long recognized the rights of parents to direct 'the religious upbringing' of their children. And we have held that those rights are violated by government policies that substantially interfere with the religious development of children.' While parents will be able to uphold these rights under the new ruling, teachers may be overwhelmed at the beginning of the school year. Schools could struggle to determine what constitutes infringement on someone's religious liberty while simultaneously honoring the freedom of speech guaranteed by the first amendment. Assessing the validity of removing books on religious grounds will also be problematic, given the broader ongoing campaign by parents' rights groups and religious organizations to remove LGBTQ+ content from schools across the nation, especially in Republican-led areas. 'The creation of opt-outs is license to censor the very existence of the LBGTQ+ community and their families,' the PEN American writer AJ Connelly concluded in her report. 'It is not difficult to imagine that other groups might soon be added to the list of those who may not be named,' she added.
The Sun
30 minutes ago
- The Sun
Dramatic footage reveals moment Julio Cesar Chavez Jr is arrested by ICE just days after losing Jake Paul fight
DRAMATIC footage has captured the moment boxer Julio Cesar Chavez Jr was arrested by ICE for his alleged involvement in organized crime. It came just days after the former middleweight world champion was beaten by YouTuber-turned-boxer Jake Paul in California. 5 5 5 Chavez Jr - son of the legendary Julio Cesar Sr - was arrested in Los Angeles and faces deportation back to Mexico. Police cam footage has emerged of the 39-year-old being arrested by ICE agents - put in cuffs and chained up. US officials say he is affiliated with the notorious Mexican Sinaloa drug cartel - helping with "trafficking firearms, ammunition, and explosives". Homeland Security posted his mugshot and wrote: "On July 2, ICE arrested Mexican boxer and criminal illegal alien Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. "He is now being processed for expedited removal from the United States. "This Sinaloa Cartel affiliate has an active arrest warrant in Mexico for his involvement in organized crime and trafficking firearms, ammunitions and explosives. "Under President Trump, NO ONE is above the law—including world-famous athletes. "Our message to any cartel affiliates in the U.S. is clear: We will find you and you will face consequences. "The days of unchecked cartel violence are over." President Donald Trump designated the Sinaloa Cartel as a terrorist organization on his first day back in office in January. Chavez Jr's wife Frida Munoz was previously married to the son of former Sinaloa cartel leader Joaquin "El Chapo" Guzman. El Chapo is serving a life sentence in a U.S. prison and his son Edgar was assassinated in 2008. Describing Chavez Jr's alleged connection, the statement says he applied for US permanent residency last year due to his marriage to a US citizen "who is connected to the Sinaloa Cartel through a prior relationship with the now-deceased son of the infamous cartel leader Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzman". In January 2024, Chavez Jr was arrested in LA and later convicted for illegal possession of an assault weapon. A year earlier, a local judge issued an arrest warrant against him for allegedly trafficking weapons for a criminal organisation. He also allegedly made multiple fraudulent statements to US immigration authorities in attempts to gain permanent residency and over-stayed a tourist visa that expired last February. A lawyer for Chavez Jr called his arrest "nothing more than another headline to terrorise the Latin community". Lawyer Michael Goldstein told NBC,: "This is the first we've ever heard of these outrageous allegations." Chavez Jr won the WBC title in 2011 and made three defenses of the belt but his later career has been plagued with scandals and a lack of discipline. His record is now 54-7-1 after losing over ten rounds to Paul in Anaheim. 5 5
NBC News
31 minutes ago
- NBC News
Trump to sign 'big beautiful bill' and #MeToo setback in Sean Combs' trial: Morning Rundown
Donald Trump's influence over Congress is proven with the passage of his megabill. A military analysis contradicts Pete Hegseth's stated reason for halting a weapons shipment to Ukraine. And why some feel like the verdict in Sean Combs' trial is a setback for the #MeToo movement. Here's what to know today. Trump takes victory lap after Congress advances his agenda President Donald Trump is expected today to sign the megabill containing many of his agenda priorities after the Republican-led House passed the legislation in a 218-214 vote, capping a tense 24 hours of negotiations and arm-twisting. The Fourth of July signing ceremony at the White House will include fireworks, sources said, and the possibility of a military plane flyover. Trump applauded Republicans after the bill passed, writing on social media that the effort signaled a unified Republican Party. He continued celebrating yesterday evening at a rally in Iowa organized to mark Independence Day, telling his audience there was 'no better birthday present for America' than this bill. This is Morning Rundown, a weekday newsletter to start your day. Sign up here to get it in your inbox. The 887-page package, dubbed the 'one big, beautiful bill,' includes a tax-cut and spending package that is projected to increase the national debt by $3.3 trillion over a decade. The bill also adds $5 trillion to the debt ceiling. The House vote yesterday was mostly along party lines, with just two Republicans — Reps. Thomas Massie of Kentucky and Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania — joining all Democrats in voting against the bill. Before the House passed the bill, Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries gave the longest House floor speech ever and stalled a vote for over eight hours. The bill's passage through Congress, regardless of the hurdles along the way, displays Trump's influence over the Republican Party that many of his predecessors would have envied. In a procedural vote Wednesday night that stretched into Thursday morning, Republican critics folded one by one and accepted demands they insisted they wouldn't, thanks to efforts by Trump and House Speaker Mike Johnson. The president's demands didn't always match reality. For example, the bill includes Medicaid cuts despite Trump's insistence that he wouldn't touch the program. And since Trump's takeover of the Republican Party, its core tenet of fiscal conservatism has been set aside. So will the bill unleash the economic growth that Trump predicts? Or will the steep cuts in the social safety net alienate some of the same blue-collar voters that Trump wrested from the Democratic coalition? Next year's midterm elections will serve as a huge test. Federal lands and waters will be opened up for oil and gas drilling, as well as coal mining, under the new law, while key support for solar and wind power will end. More politics news: Trump said he 'didn't make any progress' toward a potential ceasefire in the Russia-Ukraine war when he spoke to Russian President Vladimir Putin yesterday by phone. Florida's 'Alligator Alcatraz' immigration detention center has so far received no federal funds despite assurances otherwise from Donald Trump and Gov. Ron DeSantis, court documents reveal. The judge presiding over Kilmar Abrego Garcia's criminal case directed both the government and Abrego's lawyers to stop making public statements about the case. The Supreme Court allowed the Trump administration to move forward with plans to send eight convicted criminals to South Sudan despite them having no ties to the war-torn country. Beach closures in several states over fecal bacterial concerns As millions set out to celebrate Fourth of July weekend, at least five states have issued advisories for certain beaches and lakes that have tested positive for above-safe levels of fecal bacteria. Almost two dozen beaches in Massachusetts are closed, as well as four beaches in New York and three beaches in Michigan. Meanwhile, Illinois has issued at least eight advisories in the past few weeks, and Los Angeles County has released eight ocean water quality advisories. And in North Carolina, officials urged people to keep children and pets away from water that appears bright green, blue or scummy over concerns about cyanobacteria algae blooms. The bacteria being monitored include which is more likely to be found in freshwater, and Enterococcus, which can form in both marine and freshwater. Here's what else to know. Hegseth's reason for halting weapons to Ukraine contrasts military analysis The Defense Department halted a shipment of U.S. weapons to Ukraine this week over what officials said were concerns about low stockpiles. But an analysis by senior military officers found that the aid package would not jeopardize the American military's own ammunition supplies, according to three U.S. officials. Suspending the shipment of military aid to Ukraine was a unilateral step by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, three congressional aides and a former U.S. official familiar with the matter said. This week's move blindsided the State Department, members of Congress, officials in Kyiv and European allies, multiple sources said. In fact, some of the weapons had already been loaded onto trucks in Poland and other European countries, only for those handling the shipment to receive word that the delivery had been called off. While the White House has defended the decision, bipartisan lawmakers have expressed disapproval. Read the full story here. Dozens of news crews, hundreds of curious bystanders and law enforcement were set up outside the Manhattan courthouse this week when the verdict in Sean 'Diddy' Combs' sex-trafficking trial was read. Among them were also influencers, content creators and provocateurs who hoped to boost their online followings. And then there were Combs' supporters — some dressed in costumes, others wielding baby oil — who cheered 'Free Puff!' when he was acquitted of racketeering and sex trafficking. The celebratory mood among Combs' supporters stood in contrast to the reactions from some sexual assault survivors and advocates who feel the trial's outcome was a devastating 'step back' for the #MeToo movement, which gained prominence in 2017 after producer Harvey Weinstein was accused of assault. In the years since the movement took hold, it has 'suddenly started to shift to 'Don't believe all women,' or 'Women are liars,'' said Kaja Sokola, who was one of three women who testified in Weinstein's May retrial. Nicole Bedera, a sociologist who studies sexual violence, said she 'we're in a new era where instead of people trying to convince us not to believe survivors, they tell us the survivors deserved it.' Read the full story here. Meanwhile, Combs' team described the verdict as a 'great victory.' But Combs did not come out of the trial scot-free, with the jury convicting him on two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution. His future in the music industry will depend heavily on how he owns up to the 'freak offs' and other transgressions that his legal team didn't dispute. Read All About It Men in the U.S. are spending a record-high amount of time on household activities, a new analysis found. These charts show which tasks they're tackling most. ICE agents arrested renowned Mexican boxer Julio César Chávez Jr. outside his Los Angeles home on allegations that he is involved in organized crime and trafficking and is an affiliate of the Sinaloa Cartel. Indie rock band Velvet Sundown is gaining traction on Spotify, but some critics are convinced the band and its music are 100% AI-generated. The 2025 Tour de France kicks off this weekend, promising another showdown between two frontrunners and a more challenging finish to the race. Staff Pick: I CE shut down this Latino market — without even showing up Latinos across the Las Vegas Valley have flocked to the thriving Broadacres Market, a massive swap meet where items like semilla pipianera, micheladas and banana leaves are part of the standard fare. With little warning, the marketplace, which has been in operation for nearly 50 years, announced that it was closing indefinitely. The reason? To avoid an ICE raid, which recently happened at another swap meet in Southern California that the Broadacres owners also manage. The act of caution has further affected small business owners who run the stalls and the shoppers who rely on them for food and community. 'As a family, we're facing questions like: What are we going to do about the mortgage payment, with groceries? How are we going to recover from this?' Rico Ocampo — whose family has run their business selling nuts, seeds, cheeses, and other goods at Broadacres for 20 years — told reporter Denise Chow, who spoke to Ocampo and other community members reeling from the market's sudden closure. Ocampo's family's stock is slowly running out, and with it, the safety of their steady business, as they call on lawmakers and Broadacres management to do something to protect those whose lives might be disrupted by an ICE raid. — Michelle Garcia NBC Select: Online Shopping, Simplified July Fourth is here, and so are the sales. Here are 50 deals worth checking out, with discounts on brands like Apple, Yeti, Dyson and more. And get up to 80% off during Amazon's Fourth of July sale, which has deals on TVs, mattresses, outdoor gear and more.
