James Haskell hits back at Wallabies coach's reaction to controversial flashpoint that secured the Lions a series victory against Australia: 'That is utter c**p'
The Australia coach lashed out at officials and World Rugby over why the Lions match-winning try from Hugo Keenan was allowed to stand after Jac Morgan appeared to clear out Carlo Tizzano, while making contact with the Australian's neck.
'In a world of player welfare… It's what they are there to enforce. A player who dives off his feet and is clearly beaten to the position over the ball, makes neck contact,' Schmidt fumed after the match.
Schmidt used World Rugby's Law 9.20 to justify his point, which states that players cannot enter a ruck and make contact with a player above the shoulder line.
'You just have to read Law 9.20, then listen to the referee's description and watch the vision. A player who dives off his feet, is clearly beaten to the position over the ball, makes neck contact - it's a tough one to take,' the coach, who has previously worked as a technical advisor for World Rugby, fumed.
The incident has divided the rugby community, with Tindall and Haskell both arguing on The Good, The Bad and The Rugby Podcast, that Schmidt wouldn't be making the same claim had the coin flipped in the other direction.
When asked by Alex Payne if Schmidt was right to feel aggrieved, Tindall replied, 'No. The pair then jointly said: 'Absolutely not.'
Haskell then proceeded to deliver an impassioned rant about the comments, with the former Wasps and England star, claiming that the real foul was Tizzano's alleged 'dive' and that if they had penalised Morgan for the clear out, they 'may as well have just disbanded the whole game'.
After Morgan made contact with Tizzano, the flanker appeared to fall backwards and has been blasted for an apperent 'dive' by some members of the English media.
'The only bit of foul play nonsense in that incident was that Australian player [Carlo Tizzano] diving,' Haskell said on the podcast.
'That should have been red carded, because that is utter c**p.'
He then went on to delve into the technicalities of the incident, claiming World Rugby's current laws don't allow players to remove a jackler in any other manner than how Morgan pushed Tizzano away.
'I'm telling you now, there is no physical way to clear out a player who is that low over the ball, without... the only other way that you used to be able to do it is if you put your head underneath him and go head-on-head, because when you're that low over the ball you've got a small window... You've got to get your head underneath him.
'But if you can't get any space to do that, and it would be head-on-head because you just lead with your head, you have to hit where he hit. That was a clear out I did every game, every week for 20 years...'
Summarising his point, Haskell, who toured with the Lions in 2017, said the game would have serious questions to answer had Morgan been penalised over the clear out.
Haskell added: 'That is the only way to do it. Because if you come in at the side at an angle, you'd end up doing a croc roll. It is utter, utter b*******. It is people clutching at straws. When a player is over the ball so low, what we used to be taught to do is I come in and I put my hand on the ground underneath him and lead up with my hands and hit him.
'All of that was just a rugby thing and the only foul was the Australian diving.'
While Haskell praised the Australia coach Joe Schmidt as a 'great bloke' he fumed at how Schmidt had 'the audacity' to question the decision.
Tindall replied: 'Again, if he's on the other side of the coin, it's not even a debate. He's going: 'That's what the game is'.'
Haskell isn't the only person to have slammed Tizzano following the incident. Writing in his column in The Telegraph, Oliver Brown, 'Stop moaning, Australia, your player dived.'
'Tizzano clearly milked the incident, collapsing with a melodrama that could easily have persuaded some officials to chalk off Keenan's try,' he added.
Andy Farrell, meanwhile, praised Morgan for securing the ball so well.
'I thought it was a brilliant clear-out, didn't you?' the Lions coach said, before admitting: 'It depends on what side of the fence you come from.'
However, the refereeing decision has left one ex-Wallabies star livid.
Morgan Turinui, who won 20 caps for Australia, hit out at the officials over the contentious call.
'That decision is 100 per cent completely wrong,' he said. 'The referee got it wrong,' Turinui said after the game.
'His two assistant referees got it wrong.'
He then explained that the referee needed to be brought before World Rugby's Match Official Manager, Joel Jutge.
'Joel Jutge, the head of the referees, is out here on a junket. He needs to haul those referees in and ask for a please explain.
But World Rugby cheif executive Alan Gilpin has claimed that they were standing by Piardi (left) and his team following the incident
'Dan Herbert, the chair of Australian rugby and if I'm Phil Waugh, the CEO, I'm sorry I'm asking for a please explain.
'He did have a good game, but the refereeing group, when it counted, got the match-defining decision completely wrong.
'It's a point of law. It's in black and white. It's not about bias. It's not about colouring. 'There's nothing there. Get away from the fact that it's a wrong call. It's a penalty sanction. It's not a yellow card. It happens.
'The try must be disallowed and we should be going one-all to Sydney.'
But in a fresh turn of events, World Rugby has since made clear their stance on the matter, refuting Schmidt's claims before stating that they were throwing their support behind Piardi and his team of officials.
World Rugby boss Alan Gilpin said: 'It is disappointing when the reaction is, 'this means player welfare isn't taken seriously', because everyone knows we are putting player welfare, in its broadest sense, at the top of the agenda. So, that part is challenging, in terms of the player welfare statements (by Schmidt).'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
13 minutes ago
- The Sun
‘The sport is in good hands' – Adrian Lewis names Luke Littler as one of three stars to take darts forward
ADRIAN LEWIS loves how the fearless Luke Littler behaves on the oche – and has no issue if his records are wiped out. Littler, 18, heads Down Under this week to take part in World Series of Darts events in Australia and New Zealand. 3 3 His last appearance on the oche saw him lift the Betfred World Matchplay – beating James Wade 18-13 in the final in Blackpool to complete the sport's Triple Crown. In the semi-finals, The Nuke hit a stunning nine-darter against Josh Rock and instead of going wild at the feat, he simply shrugged his shoulders. Almost like Lewis, 40, used to do after perfect legs, as if to say: 'Well, what else do you expect from someone as talented as me?' When the tournament was over, Littler had hit 64 180s across five games, eight more maximums than the previous record of 56 set by Jackpot in 2013. Far from feeling angry or jealous, Lewis approves of the audacity of Littler's antics, saying: 'I love it. Anything like that, I think it's great for the game, you need characters. 'I have said it for years, I do believe that, and Luke is certainly one of them. 'First of all, him reaching the world final on his first appearance at Ally Pally was unbelievable. 'To do what he has done since, becoming world champion and still maintaining his form, he's a credit to himself, his family and the sport. 'The sport is in good hands. The two Lukes, and Josh Rock, they are all very professional, they do their jobs. 'That is what darts needs. It is becoming more and more professional as time goes on. Luke Littler takes part in annual fishing competition 'The Matchplay was definitely up there. The standard of it throughout was brilliant. 'Luke Littler hitting a nine-darter always helped. The semis-finals and final made it a great, great tournament.' Later this month, Lewis will mark his return to televised darts – after a near two-and-half year absence. The two-time world champion last threw competitive darts in front of the cameras at the PDC's UK Open in 2023 at Butlin's Minehead. After that tournament, he decided to walk away from the sport for family reasons and having fallen out of love with the game. His wife Sarah has 'an incurable kidney disease' and his son 'has autism and ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder)', which has meant his full-time concentration and care. His comeback will be the MODUS Super Series in Portsmouth at 10pm on Thursday August 28 – and should it all go well, he may attend PDC Q School in January. If he regains his professional Tour Card, he will be reunited with old sparring partner Wade, who turned back the clock to reach the Matchplay final last month against expectation Stoke-born Lewis said: 'I don't think James dropped below a 100 average all the way through the tournament, which takes some doing itself. 'To still do that after he has been playing for 20-odd years, he's a credit to the sport as well. I think he is very underlooked a lot of the time. 'Certainly, to me he has been the best finisher in the world over the last 20 years. 'He deserves more respect, definitely. That might put him in the Premier League next year, which he thoroughly deserves as well. 'He will just go from strength to strength and get more and more confidence. 'Obviously he reached another final and I think he can do big things again.'
Times
13 minutes ago
- Times
Series win and a commercial success but have Lions lost their soul?
The morning after the night before. A group of British & Irish Lions players were sipping whiskey sours in the lobby of their hotel. Some had not slept. All of them were determined to enjoy the final moments of this eight-week adventure; sad it was over, proud to have won the Test series and now in desperate need of a holiday and a chance to decompress at the end of a 12-month season. All the experts insist that workload is unsustainable and yet every two years — for a World Cup and a Lions tour — it is explained away as being an aberration. No wonder players are looking admiringly towards the R360 model and a global franchise season promising fat paychecks for no more than 18 games in a season. Ben Calveley, the Lions chief executive, said on Sunday that he had neither been contacted by anyone from R360 nor sought out talks with representatives from the new venture. But he insisted: 'Our players remain committed to the Lions. We are very confident that our position in the future is secure.' What does that future look like? Much of it will be shaped by the outcome of a review into this tour to Australia. The Lions say they will engage with all stakeholders. Andy Farrell, the head coach who is in pole position to lead the team in New Zealand in four years' time, will contribute once he is home and the dust has settled. The Lions are already planning for a more international feel to the 2029 tour to New Zealand, with fixtures against other nations being proposed in the build-up to the Test series. This is an important move. The Lions were dissatisfied with the quality of the tour-game opposition they faced in Australia. They gain very little from walkovers and the games hold no interest for fans. The next Australia tour, scheduled to be 12 years from now, certainly has to be designed differently. The best tour game the Lions played was the last non-Test match, against a combined First Nations & Pasifika (FNP) team in Melbourne, when finally they ran full force into a scratch side unified by their culture and history. The quality may not have been that high but it was physical and competitive; it was a test. The Lions want more of that. New Zealand's provincial scene is stronger than Australia's, plus the Maori All Blacks will provide determined opposition. Maybe bring back the FNP XV, too. Games against Fiji or Japan are also on the agenda as part of a ten-match schedule, for both performance and commercial reasons. 'Would we be interested in bringing in, for example, a Fiji or a Japan? And you can think of other countries as well. Yes we would. That is a conversation we will have with New Zealand Rugby to see if that is possible. We would be interested in something like that,' Calveley said. 'We've had a wonderful tour here in Australia and it is a hundred per cent our ambition to return. We would want the next one to be bigger and better than this one. 'If we're looking at bringing in new components into the tour, it's because we're interested in building relationships with those markets. There's an opportunity to grow even further. That's what that will be.' The thorny issue of midweek games before Test matches must be addressed. For the FNP XV game, the Lions drafted in additional players in order to protect the Test squad, which suggests it is an inconvenience. Those temporary call-ups can lead to consternation in the squad and accusations of the jersey, and the whole Lions concept, being devalued. So scrap that game? Well, four players — Owen Farrell, Blair Kinghorn, Jac Morgan and James Ryan — played themselves into the squad for the second Test. So it is a tricky balance. 'We need to have a look at that,' Calveley said. The Lions' on-field performance will be judged a success in the review. And rightly so. They won the series 2-1, which is not an achievement to be sniffed at. The Wallabies are not world-beaters by any means but the Lions did not exist as a team eight weeks ago. Andy Farrell's men fell short of their stated aims: to win 3-0 and return home as one of the greatest Lions teams in history. Had they achieved it, then statistically it would have been true. The Lions do not win many Test series — only two in the professional era — and it is almost a century since they managed a clean sweep. But it would have jarred to bracket them with the 1974 team, who went undefeated in 22 games in South Africa, winning 21. Where would this Lions team rank against the others in the professional era? Even with a 3-0, they would not have been rated above the teams of 1997 (series winners), 2001 (series losers), 2009 (series losers), 2017 (drawn series) or 2013 (series winners). So, a 2-1 result against the sixth-best team in the world is a more accurate reflection of their status. The Lions took the series with a positive points difference of plus one; the tightest series, and one that became compelling and brilliantly competitive once the Wallabies finally turned up. Will Skelton changed the dynamic when he came in for the second Test; throwing his weight around, picking fights, driving the Wallabies forward and pushing the Lions off their game. Suddenly Australia had discovered some fight and character. What if they had played like that in Brisbane in the first Test? The Lions had to stage a record fightback in front of a record crowd of 90,000 to win the second Test in Melbourne from 23-5 down and take the series with a last-gasp try from Hugo Keenan. It was one of the great Lions occasions. Australia then played the biblical conditions in Sydney much more smartly than the Lions. They dominated the scrum, destroyed the Lions lineout and bossed the breakdown to control the game. The touring side lost key players but they were poor. When they were at their best — for the first half in Brisbane and the comeback in Melbourne — Tadhg Beirne, Tom Curry and Ellis Genge were the driving forces. Even on Saturday, those three dug deep to try to turn the game. They all had great tours. Beirne was the rightful player of the series. The unsung hero would have to be Pierre Schoeman, who took on the valuable role of the midweek player who just bought into everything the Lions was about, committing fully to the squad in support of the Test side. The Lions stand for more than just winning. The review will judge the Australia tour against four criteria: rugby/high-performance, commercial/profit, Lions fan engagement and community outreach, which covers their ambassadorial responsibilities. All four elements supposedly hold equal billing, although the experience on this tour would suggest otherwise. The hearts and minds element, which used to be so important for the Lions, has been denuded. Calveley disagreed, stating the Lions had got the balance right. In doing so he rather prejudged the review. He should wait and listen to feedback from sponsors, broadcast partners and the many people the Lions engaged with across Australia. It will paint a different picture. Perhaps the best metaphor was the sight of David Nucifora, the head of high-performance, covering a changing room camera with a towel on Saturday. It portrayed a complete lack of feel for the situation and how the team is perceived. Please enable cookies and other technologies to view this content. You can update your cookies preferences any time using privacy manager. The terms and conditions of the tour agreement did not cover what might happen in a lightning break and so up went the towel. That same attitude has been prevalent across the tour. Ask the student who was blocked from asking a question of Beirne when the Lions were at his school. Ts&Cs have been cited as a reason to restrict independent media access (but not inhouse cameras) and to block the FNP team from selecting Pete Samu. He was rejoining a Super Rugby side but had not played for one last season, so could not be picked for the representative side on a technicality. Again, a lack of feel. The Lions need to work out what they stand for. The players and coaches have been generous with their time and are interesting, engaging people. But they are let down by an inelegant infrastructure that has failed to win over hearts and minds in Australia. In our podcast series The Red Lions, before the tour, Willie John McBride, Matt Dawson and Martyn Williams all expressed concerns that the Lions were becoming too commercial and losing their soul. The Lions trade on that romantic reputation of being rugby's great adventurers but they do not always live up to those same values. They sell an 1888 whiskey and yet no players attended a ceremony at the grave of Robert Seddon, captain of the first Lions team from 1888 who died in a boating accident midway through the inaugural tour. Calveley and Ieuan Evans, the Lions chairman,were there. It will all be justified in the review by record levels of social media engagement. This tour, arranged as a joint venture with Rugby Australia, will be the most profitable ever undertaken by the Lions. Howden, the shirt sponsors, paid £6million for the rights. The players are on a profit-share arrangement and expected to receive about £100,000 each. The Test venues operated at 98 per cent capacity, with 40,000 Lions fans making the journey. The sold-out pre-tour game in Dublin against Argentina was another commercial triumph, although playing games at home is another erosion of the mystique of the Lions. The home game is now baked into the planning unless the Lions receive a better offer to play abroad. That is possible, and should be preferable. Play the Pumas in Barcelona or Buenos Aires; meet France in Paris or New Orleans. 'We are really keen on doing more in the pre-tour element. You might bring different countries into that space,' Calveley said. 'Could you see us being interested in doing something with the French or in North America, for example? The answer is yes. We will look to capitalise on that in the future.'
Glasgow Times
18 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Hopefully I will be back – Lewis Hamilton dejected after Hungaroring nightmare
A day after Hamilton described himself as 'absolutely useless', and called on his own Ferrari team to replace him, the seven-time world champion started 12th and finished in the same position at the Hungaroring, a lap behind winner Lando Norris. Charles Leclerc was fourth in the other Ferrari. Fronting up to TV cameras after the conclusion of the 14th race of his Ferrari career which has so far failed to live up to its pre-season hype, Hamilton was asked to reflect on his post-qualifying comments. Lewis Hamilton started 12th and finished 12th at Sunday's Hungarian Grand Prix (Bradley Collyer/PA) 'When you have a feeling, you have a feeling,' he told Sky Sports. 'There is a lot going on in the background that is not great.' Asked if he had fallen out of love with racing, Hamilton replied: 'No, I still love the team.' Hamilton then headed for his session with the print media. Quizzed on how he felt a day on from being eliminated in Q2 – a performance made all the more harrowing after Leclerc took pole position, he replied: 'Same.' Put to him that his remarks suggesting that Ferrari 'need a new driver' would worry his fans, the British driver again replied: 'Same.' Asked if he had anything else to say other than 'the same', Hamilton said: 'I have got nothing else to say.' Lewis Hamilton doubles down on 'change the driver' Ferrari comment 😔 — Sky Sports F1 (@SkySportsF1) August 3, 2025 The sport now breaks for three weeks for its mid-season shutdown. The next race takes place in the Netherlands on August 31. 'Very much so,' said Hamilton, who was then asked if he was looking forward to the summer break. Quizzed as to whether he will definitely be driving at the next round in Zandvoort, Hamilton replied: 'I look forward to coming back… Hopefully I will be back, yeah.' Hamilton has won a record eight times at the Hungaroring but this has been an alarming weekend for the 40-year-old. Hamilton stood largely on his own for the drivers' parade, which takes place before every race, and was later accompanied by Italian rookie Kimi Antonelli. By the end of the first lap, he dropped behind Carlos Sainz and Antonelli and was 14th. At the end of the eighth lap, he was 20 seconds behind Leclerc, then leading, in the other Ferrari, and at the end of lap 14 he trailed his team-mate by half a minute. When he left the pits on lap 43 for his sole change of tyres, Hamilton was a lap down on the leaders. Hamilton fought back past Alpine's Pierre Gasly and then Sainz to cross the line in 12th. However, he is 42 points behind Leclerc, has been out-qualified by his team-mate at 10 of the 14 rounds, beaten him in only two races, at Imola and Silverstone, and is still awaiting his first podium in Ferrari colours. Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff threw his support behind Lewis Hamilton (Bradley Collyer/PA) But Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff, who oversaw six of Hamilton's record-equalling seven titles, said: 'Lewis is wearing his heart on his sleeve. 'It was very raw what he said. He was hard on himself. We have seen it before when he felt he had not met his own expectations. He's been that emotionally transparent since he was a young adult. 'But he is the GOAT. He will always be the GOAT. And nobody is going to take it away for any single weekends or a race season that hasn't gone to plan. That is something he always needs to remember – that he is the greatest of all time.' Hamilton's Ferrari boss Fred Vasseur added: 'I don't need to motivate him (Hamilton). He is frustrated but not demotivated, that is a different story. I can perfectly understand the situation.'
