logo
Watch: 2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Why 12 men were acquitted after 18 years

Watch: 2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Why 12 men were acquitted after 18 years

The Hindu5 days ago
In a landmark judgement, the Bombay High Court acquitted all 12 individuals convicted in one of India's deadliest terror attacks – the 2006 Mumbai train blasts. But why did these men spend 18 years in prison, and then get acquitted on 21st June 2025?
First, let's go back to the day of the terror attack - it was the 11th of July 2006. The time was just past 6:20 in the evening. It was rush hour in Mumbai. The city's lifeline - the suburban trains - was packed. People heading home after a long day, chatting, dozing off, others lost in their thoughts. And then, out of nowhere, a blast ripped through the first-class compartment of a suburban train travelling from Churchgate to Borivali, between Khar and Santa Cruz stations.
Before anyone could even process what had happened, six more blasts followed. One after the other: Bandra–Khar Road. Jogeshwari–Mahim Junction. Mira Road–Bhayander. Matunga–Mahim Junction and Borivali.
Between 6:23 and 6:29 p.m., seven serial blasts ripped through Mumbai's suburban railway network. According to police, the bombs were hidden inside pressure cookers, packed with RDX and ammonium nitrate, and placed in carry bags. 189 lives lost, around 800 injured, for a city that never sleeps, everything came to a standstill.
What followed was swift action. The Anti-Terrorism Squad launched an investigation. Within weeks, they arrested 13 men, accusing them of being part of a larger conspiracy involving Lashkar-e-Taiba. A chargesheet was filed under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act also known as MACOCA.
In 2015, after a long legal process, a special court convicted 12 of the accused. Five were sentenced to death, and seven to life imprisonment. The court found them guilty of planting the bombs, helping terrorists cross the India–Nepal and India–Bangladesh borders, and aiding the conspiracy.
But from the very beginning, there were murmurs of doubt. Multiple agencies later offered contradictory findings. The Mumbai Crime Branch, and even the Delhi Police, claimed that the real culprits were operatives of Students Islamic Movement of India or SIMI and the Indian Mujahideen.
In fact, two IM operatives – Mohammad Sadiq Sheikh and Yasin Bhatkal – reportedly confessed that it was their group that carried out the bombings, allegedly in retaliation for the 2002 Gujarat riots. The Delhi Police even named Abdul Subhan Qureshi, a SIMI ideologue, as a key conspirator.
So how did this group of 12 men come to be convicted?
In court, the prosecution relied mainly on three pillars – eyewitness accounts, recoveries, and confessional statements. But over time, cracks started to show. Eyewitnesses contradicted each other. Confessions were said to have been made under duress. Circumstantial evidence didn't quite connect the dots.
One of the most powerful voices in court was senior advocate S. Muralidhar, former Chief Justice of the Orissa High Court. Representing two of the convicts, he argued earlier this year that there was a bias in the investigation. Innocent people had been sent to jail, and when they were released years later, there was no possibility of reconstructing their lives.
He added that in many such terror-related cases, investigating agencies had failed miserably. First, so many lives were lost, and then innocents were arrested. Years later, when they were acquitted, no one found closure.
Fast forward to July 2025. A Special Division Bench of Justices Anil S. Kilor and Shyam C. Chandak set aside the convictions delivered by a special MCOCA court, which had sentenced five of the accused to death and the remaining seven to life imprisonment.
The Bench observed that the prosecution had 'utterly failed' in establishing the case beyond reasonable doubt. It was hard to believe that the accused committed the crime.
The judgement stated that punishing the actual perpetrator of a crime is a concrete and essential step towards curbing criminal activities, upholding the rule of law, and ensuring the safety and security of citizens. But creating a false appearance of having solved a case by claiming that the accused have been brought to justice gives a misleading sense of resolution. This deceptive closure undermines public trust and falsely reassures society, while in reality, the true threat remains at large.
The verdict was delivered via video conference, with the accused appearing from various prisons across Maharashtra. Visibly emotional, several of them were seen expressing gratitude to their legal counsel after the judgement was announced. They were ordered to be released but were asked to sign a ₹25,000 bond in case further appeals are filed.
The acquittal of the 12 individuals in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case marks a significant moment in India's legal and investigative history. While the High Court's decision brings closure for those imprisoned, it also reopens critical questions about the investigation, prosecution, and accountability in cases of national security.
Credits: Producer: Athira Madhav | Camera: Thamodharan B
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Woman migrant worker, minor son ‘beaten up' by Delhi police
Woman migrant worker, minor son ‘beaten up' by Delhi police

The Hindu

time28 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Woman migrant worker, minor son ‘beaten up' by Delhi police

A migrant worker from West Bengal's Malda district alleged that she and her minor son were detained and beaten up by Delhi Police on suspicion of being Bangladeshi nationals living illegally in India. Sajnur Bibi said her son was playing at a parking lot in Pandav Nagar in East Delhi when Delhi Police picked her along with her son on Saturday. The sanitation worker alleged that she was beaten on her back, hands, legs by a baton. Her family also alleged that they had to 'pay' ₹25,000 to Delhi Police officials to release the mother-son duo. The police have not yet commented on the allegations.

Babbar Khalsa International Operative, 22, Arrested For Punjab Grenade Attack
Babbar Khalsa International Operative, 22, Arrested For Punjab Grenade Attack

NDTV

time2 hours ago

  • NDTV

Babbar Khalsa International Operative, 22, Arrested For Punjab Grenade Attack

New Delhi: The Special Cell of the Delhi Police has arrested a 22-year-old man linked to the banned terror group Babbar Khalsa International (BKI) and wanted in connection with a grenade attack in Punjab. The accused was identified as Karanbir alias Karan, said Amit Kaushik, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Special Cell/New Delhi Range. Karanbir was arrested in connection with the grenade attack at Police Station Quila Lal Singh, in Punjab's Gurdaspur district in April, the police said in a statement on Sunday. The accused was arrested in Gurdaspur, Punjab, under the Arms Act on Saturday. Confessing to his involvement in the grenade attack, Karanbir said that he was in contact with a person from Punjab, but based abroad and handling operations for BKI. The accused also shared that he facilitated the stay of two persons at his home before the attack, who had executed the task of launching the grenade at Police Station Qila Lal Singh. The accused revealed that his handler used to instruct him through social media applications to commit criminal and terror activities. Karanbir revealed that he also visited a West Asian country in 2024. Karanbir told the police that he received money from his handler for executing the said grenade attack. Karanbir's brother, Gursewak, who was also involved in the attack, has already been arrested in the case. Karanbir was arrested based on the leads provided by Akashdeep alias Bazz of Amritsar, an accused in a case registered under the Arms Act. Akashdeep, who was arrested in Indore on Tuesday, was also found involved in the grenade attack case at the Police Station Quila Lal Singh. Notably, soon after the attack, a social media post by Happy Passia, Mannu Agwan and Gopi Nawanshahria, affiliated with BKI, claimed responsibility for the attack and also extended a threat to Delhi. The National Investigation Agency is probing the case. Further investigation is underway.

Delhi Police's Fingerprint Bureau Gets ISO Certification
Delhi Police's Fingerprint Bureau Gets ISO Certification

Time of India

time3 hours ago

  • Time of India

Delhi Police's Fingerprint Bureau Gets ISO Certification

New Delhi: The Fingerprint Bureau of achieved a notable milestone by receiving the ISO 9001:2015 certificate. This quality management system standard acknowledges its rigorous methods and procedures in fingerprint analysis and crime investigation, as certified by a quality control certification body. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now This is significant as the certification has made the investigations validated by the bureau more credible, according to police. The bureau helped crack a significant number of cases in the last three years, the data shows. According to special commissioner of police Devesh Srivastava, the bureau helped solve 171 cases in 2022, while 275 cases were solved in 2023, and the figure rose to 314 in 2024. By July 25, the bureau already helped crack 101 cases. Given the performance of the last few years, police brass decided to obtain the standardisation of its work. The processes and technicalities of its working were formalised and documented. After a thorough audit of the procedure and documentation, the Quality Control Certification granted the ISO 9001:2015 certificate to the Fingerprint Bureau Unit. Established in 1983, the bureau is a specialised wing that plays a crucial role in identifying suspects and linking them to crime scenes through scientific analysis of fingerprints. "Initially, fingerprint-related work for Delhi Police was managed by the Fingerprint Bureau in Phillaur, Punjab. While this arrangement served its purpose, the process of obtaining fingerprint results was often time-consuming and challenging for Investigating Officers," Srivastava recalled. Recognising the need for a more efficient and streamlined system, the establishment of an independent Fingerprint Bureau for the Union Territory of Delhi was proposed. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now In response, a full-fledged Fingerprint Bureau was set up in 1983 at RK Puram. The first batch of fingerprint cadre personnel joined in 1985, marking the beginning of expert, in-house fingerprint analysis in Delhi. "With a vast database pool of over 5 lakh criminals, the bureau, which is a part of the crime branch, utilises advanced forensic techniques and software to deliver accurate and timely results," Srivastava said. The Fingerprint Bureau databases include the Automated Fingerprint Identification System (AFPIS), the National Automated Fingerprint Identification System (NAFIS), and the Crime Record Information System (CRIS). The use of modern technology and traditional expertise has made it an indispensable part of Delhi Police's crime-solving mechanism, members of the team said. "The bureau's activities include capturing finger/palm prints of arrested and convicted persons, editing and analysing received finger/palm slips, and operating modern applications. The unit also imparts training and refresher courses for Delhi Police personnel and other law enforcement agencies," explained a senior officer. The ISO standard provides a framework for consistently delivering services that meet court and regulatory requirements, ultimately contributing to a higher rate of conviction. The bureau's director, Sanjay Jha, works in close coordination with DCP Harsh Indora to analyse possible suspects in crimes. This certification is expected to further improve the quality and legal value of evidence. "This recognition highlights the unit's commitment to maintaining high standards in crime investigation. It is also a testament to the police striving for quality management and public satisfaction," Srivastava added.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store