
Watch: 2006 Mumbai Train Blasts: Why 12 men were acquitted after 18 years
First, let's go back to the day of the terror attack - it was the 11th of July 2006. The time was just past 6:20 in the evening. It was rush hour in Mumbai. The city's lifeline - the suburban trains - was packed. People heading home after a long day, chatting, dozing off, others lost in their thoughts. And then, out of nowhere, a blast ripped through the first-class compartment of a suburban train travelling from Churchgate to Borivali, between Khar and Santa Cruz stations.
Before anyone could even process what had happened, six more blasts followed. One after the other: Bandra–Khar Road. Jogeshwari–Mahim Junction. Mira Road–Bhayander. Matunga–Mahim Junction and Borivali.
Between 6:23 and 6:29 p.m., seven serial blasts ripped through Mumbai's suburban railway network. According to police, the bombs were hidden inside pressure cookers, packed with RDX and ammonium nitrate, and placed in carry bags. 189 lives lost, around 800 injured, for a city that never sleeps, everything came to a standstill.
What followed was swift action. The Anti-Terrorism Squad launched an investigation. Within weeks, they arrested 13 men, accusing them of being part of a larger conspiracy involving Lashkar-e-Taiba. A chargesheet was filed under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act also known as MACOCA.
In 2015, after a long legal process, a special court convicted 12 of the accused. Five were sentenced to death, and seven to life imprisonment. The court found them guilty of planting the bombs, helping terrorists cross the India–Nepal and India–Bangladesh borders, and aiding the conspiracy.
But from the very beginning, there were murmurs of doubt. Multiple agencies later offered contradictory findings. The Mumbai Crime Branch, and even the Delhi Police, claimed that the real culprits were operatives of Students Islamic Movement of India or SIMI and the Indian Mujahideen.
In fact, two IM operatives – Mohammad Sadiq Sheikh and Yasin Bhatkal – reportedly confessed that it was their group that carried out the bombings, allegedly in retaliation for the 2002 Gujarat riots. The Delhi Police even named Abdul Subhan Qureshi, a SIMI ideologue, as a key conspirator.
So how did this group of 12 men come to be convicted?
In court, the prosecution relied mainly on three pillars – eyewitness accounts, recoveries, and confessional statements. But over time, cracks started to show. Eyewitnesses contradicted each other. Confessions were said to have been made under duress. Circumstantial evidence didn't quite connect the dots.
One of the most powerful voices in court was senior advocate S. Muralidhar, former Chief Justice of the Orissa High Court. Representing two of the convicts, he argued earlier this year that there was a bias in the investigation. Innocent people had been sent to jail, and when they were released years later, there was no possibility of reconstructing their lives.
He added that in many such terror-related cases, investigating agencies had failed miserably. First, so many lives were lost, and then innocents were arrested. Years later, when they were acquitted, no one found closure.
Fast forward to July 2025. A Special Division Bench of Justices Anil S. Kilor and Shyam C. Chandak set aside the convictions delivered by a special MCOCA court, which had sentenced five of the accused to death and the remaining seven to life imprisonment.
The Bench observed that the prosecution had 'utterly failed' in establishing the case beyond reasonable doubt. It was hard to believe that the accused committed the crime.
The judgement stated that punishing the actual perpetrator of a crime is a concrete and essential step towards curbing criminal activities, upholding the rule of law, and ensuring the safety and security of citizens. But creating a false appearance of having solved a case by claiming that the accused have been brought to justice gives a misleading sense of resolution. This deceptive closure undermines public trust and falsely reassures society, while in reality, the true threat remains at large.
The verdict was delivered via video conference, with the accused appearing from various prisons across Maharashtra. Visibly emotional, several of them were seen expressing gratitude to their legal counsel after the judgement was announced. They were ordered to be released but were asked to sign a ₹25,000 bond in case further appeals are filed.
The acquittal of the 12 individuals in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case marks a significant moment in India's legal and investigative history. While the High Court's decision brings closure for those imprisoned, it also reopens critical questions about the investigation, prosecution, and accountability in cases of national security.
Credits: Producer: Athira Madhav | Camera: Thamodharan B
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
100 spots ahead of I-Day: Police conduct checks across Delhi, flag security lapses
New Delhi: Ahead of Independence Day, Delhi Police conducted comprehensive checks at key places in the city, in-cluding hotels, railway stations and bus terminals, and identified security lapses at over 100 spots, sources said on Thursday. The Special Cell, Northeast Delhi, reported lapses at 16 locations, followed by 13 in East, 12 each in Shahdara and North, 11 in Central, 10 in Southeast, nine in South, eight in Metro, seven in Rohini, and six in Dwarka, they said. 'Multiple teams of the Special Cell undertook a five-day security inspection drive across various parts of Delhi in view of the high alert surrounding the upcoming national event,' said a source. During the inspection, non-functional CCTV cameras in hotels, parkings, locations near metro stations, eateries at metro stations, several premises near railway stations, bus stands and many other installa-tions were flagged. 'The teams also inspected non-functional door frame metal detectors (DFMDs), security personnel de-ployment and improper maintenance of visitor records,' a source said. Another officer, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said the Special Cell will write letters to the DCPs of the concerned districts to improve security in their respective areas. The inspection, conducted discreetly by trained teams of the Special Cell, was aimed at assessing the capital's preparedness to tackle any terror threats. It covered public places known to attract large crowds. 'Teams noticed a lack of functional DFMDs at various entry points. Several public places had either switched off their metal detectors, or they did not have power supply, or were not in working condi-tion,' said the officer. At some places, CCTV cameras were poorly positioned. Several public places did not have adequate lighting during night hours.


Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
Motorcyclist, homeless man die in separate road accidents in Delhi
A 22-year-old motorcyclist died after he was hit by a JCB machine in Central Delhi's Ranjit Nagar area early on Friday, the Delhi Police said. The deceased has been identified as Bobby, a resident of Inderpuri, the police said, adding that the accident occurred near Metro pillar no 216 around 6 am while he was proceeding towards the Shadipur Metro station. 'A JCB and a Duke bike were found in an accidental condition, and there was a pool of blood on the road. During the inquiry, it came to the notice that the injured had been taken by a CAT ambulance to Acharya Bhikhsu hospital,' Nidhin Valsan, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Central, said. The hospital authorities said that Bobby was brought dead. The crime team reached the spot and collected blood samples, the police said, adding that the JCB machine has been confiscated. The police have registered a case of rash and negligent driving against the JCB driver, who is absconding, said an officer. In another road accident case, a pavement dweller was mowed down by a speeding cab in the Civil Lines area of North Delhi on Tuesday morning, while another person was injured. The two men, who used to beg at the nearby traffic signal, came under the car and one of them, aged 45, died on the spot, said an officer. According to the First Information Report, the accident happened around 8 am, when the cab coming from the Majnu Ka Tila side lost control and rammed onto the footpath in front of the Monastery Market on Outer Ring Road. The police said the injured homeless man is being treated at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) trauma centre. An FIR has been registered at the Civil Lines police station.


New Indian Express
4 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Delhi Police special cell reports lapses at 16 locations ahead of I-Day
NEW DELHI: In the lead-up to Independence Day, the Delhi Police has intensified security measures across the national capital, uncovering significant lapses at over 100 key locations during a sweeping inspection drive. Conducted by the Special Cell over five days, the checks focused on high-footfall areas such as hotels, railway stations, bus terminals, and metro hubs, aimed at evaluating the capital's preparedness against potential terror threats. Sources revealed that the findings raise serious concerns about the functionality of security infrastructure, personnel deployment, and overall vigilance across several districts. The Special Cell in Northeast Delhi reported lapses at 16 locations, followed by 13 in East, 12 each in Shahdara and North, 11 in Central, 10 in Southeast, nine in South, eight in Metro, seven in Rohini, and six in Dwarka, sources said. 'Multiple teams of the Special Cell undertook a five-day security inspection drive across various parts of Delhi in view of the high alert surrounding the upcoming national event,' said a source. During the inspection, teams flagged non-functional CCTV cameras in hotels, parking areas, locations near metro stations, eateries within metro premises, and several areas near railway stations and bus stands. 'The teams also inspected non-functional door frame metal detectors (DFMDs), gaps in security personnel deployment, and improper maintenance of visitor records,' a source added. Another officer, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the Special Cell will write to the DCPs of the concerned districts to improve security in their respective areas. The inspection, carried out discreetly by trained teams, was aimed at assessing the city's readiness to respond to any terror threats. It specifically targeted public spaces known to attract large crowds. 'Teams noticed a lack of functional DFMDs at various entry points. At several public places, metal detectors were either switched off, lacked power supply, or were simply not in working condition,' the officer said.