NGT asks chief secy to probe ‘security lapse' in cracker blast at Puri yatra
2
Cuttack:
National Green Tribunal
(NGT) has directed the chief secretary "to institute an inquiry" into the "grave security lapse" that led to the
firecracker explosion
killing 17 people and injuring 25 severely during Chandan Yatra in Puri on May 29 last year.In the order uploaded on Thursday, NGT's east zone bench further directed the chief secretary to "take appropriate action against those found guilty of gross negligence and lapse in taking proper security steps to prevent the occurrence of the incident in question".The bench comprising Justice B Amit Sthalekar (judicial member) and Dr Vijay Kulkarni (expert member) said, "For future, it is directed that no explosives of any kind shall be permitted in such religious functions where the swell of the crowd is not just in thousands but in several lakhs and even a small lapse can result in loss of lives of lakhs of people.
One cannot rule out that such an incident can even be triggered by ill-intentioned and anti-social elements using more lethal explosives other than mere firecrackers."NGT was hearing a petition filed by Sanjay Kumar Nayak (46), a resident of Aska in Ganjam district, seeking direction to the authorities to take steps to prohibit bursting of crackers during the rituals of Lord Jagannath in Puri. Advocates Sankar Prasad Pani and Ashutosh Padhy appeared in virtual mode on the petitioner's behalf.While ordering the probe, the bench said it was evident from the Puri collector's affidavit that no one noticed crackers being taken in a trolley and stacked at Dasa Tutha on the north-west corner of the Narendra Pokhari without permission from the competent authority. During Chandan Yatra on May 29, 2024, a cracker after being ignited hit the stack of crackers kept at Dasa Tutha, which led to all the crackers getting lit and causing a huge explosion."This clearly shows that there was gross dereliction of duty on the part of the district administration including the police authorities," the bench observed, adding, "The district administration and the police administration cannot be absolved of their negligence in such a grave security lapse." "In the instant case, it was stacking of firecrackers but one cannot rule out the possibility that it could have been something even more lethal resulting in a massive explosion causing extensive damage to the Lord Jagannath temple itself and loss of human life on a large scale," the bench also observed, while disposing of the petition."That apart, it cannot be ruled out that some offensive material could have been loaded on the trolley rickshaw and carried in the midst of the Chandan Yatra so as to offend the sensibilities of the devotees and thereby create a riotous situation," the bench said. It questioned why the district and police administrations didn't anticipate such an eventuality."The police swinging into action after the occurrence of the incident does not explain the lethargy and total inactivity and the requirement to be vigilant at all times particularly on the occasion of religious functions," the bench observed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
SC to hear plea seeking exemption for BS-VI vehicles from blanket age-based ban in Delhi-NCR
The Supreme Court on Thursday agreed to hear a plea seeking exemption for Bharat Stage VI (BS-VI) compliant vehicles from the blanket age-based ban in Delhi-NCR. The petition challenges the existing rules that restrict petrol vehicles older than 15 years and diesel vehicles older than 10 years, regardless of their emission compliance, ANI reports. A bench comprising Chief Justice of India B R Gavai and Justice K Vinod Chandran took note of the urgent mention and listed the matter for detailed hearing next Monday. The application urges the apex court to allow BS-VI vehicles to remain operational beyond the standard cut-off periods, given their cleaner emission profile. The petitioner argued that the current age limits were mandated by court orders—initially by the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in 2015 and later upheld by the Supreme Court in 2018—to curb air pollution. Therefore, any modification to these timelines must be directed by the court itself, not the government. The legal challenge comes shortly after the Delhi government implemented a ban on fuel refilling for petrol vehicles older than 15 years and diesel vehicles older than 10 years, starting July 1, 2025. The measure, in compliance with directions from the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), was quickly rolled back just two days later following public backlash and logistical concerns. The plea raises the question of whether newer, cleaner BS-VI vehicles should be treated differently under vehicle end-of-life rules. If accepted, it could mark a shift in how emission norms are weighed against age-based restrictions in pollution-control efforts.
Indian Express
5 hours ago
- Indian Express
Should India lower its voting age?
Written by Anandini Dar A young activist, Ridhima Pandey, at age 11 in September 2019, led a strike in Dehradun, drawing attention to government inaction on the extreme weather and deforestation plaguing northern India. After experiencing the 2013 Uttarakhand floods, Pandey became a champion for climate change. She also led strikes aligning with the Global Fridays for Futures Movement. When she was 9 years old, she filed a case via the National Green Tribunal against the Indian government for its inaction regarding the future of children, calling for a carbon budget and a national climate recovery plan. On the other hand, working-class children and other marginalised young people are fighting for basic rights to living conditions, healthcare, dignity, and justice. Mexican anthropologist Valentina Glockner discusses how non-state actors engage with migrant Adivasi and Dalit children who work in Bangalore, an urban city in southern India, to educate them and support them in accessing their rights. She argues that in the interactions between the children and the NGO staff, it was apparent that working children are highly vocal and aware of the injustices they face, yet operate within the context of the 'weight that the existing social and symbolic order places upon them.' Children today are engaging in rights-based movements for their futures and are invested in civic and political issues at as early as 11 years old. Their investment in the future can contribute to the growth of the nation, and hence, including their voices is essential. B R Ambedkar, the Chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Indian Constitution, among other things, advocated for democracy as a tool for ensuring social and economic equality. As children continue to hold low social, economic, and educational standing, a criterion for being a minority according to Ambedkar, I argue that they are minorities who are marginalised and ought to be enfranchised. Historically, marginalised communities were disenfranchised owing to their low social status and consequently, low literacy rates. Today, many of the arguments against granting children the right to vote, or lowering the age of voting below 18 years, a general standard across most countries, are akin to those made at the time of India's Independence, wherein there was a resistance to include 'poor' and landless persons as enfranchised. For instance, many members of the Indian Constitutional Assembly in 1947 were against a universal adult franchise. I wrote elsewhere, 'Some members argued that it was an 'impractical endeavour' as there was limited education in India, and the vote would be a 'dangerous weapon' in the hands of the uneducated or the illiterate. Such expressions are nothing less than how the British displayed colonial and racist ideologies of domination and exclusion, as they sought to limit the franchise to the privileged alone.' (Dar, 2022, p. 122). Recently, the UK government announced their plans to include 16-17-year-old children as registered voters. This move is being discussed as bringing about a parity in the voting age across the island, including Scotland and Wales, which have already reduced the voting age for their citizens to 16 years. In 1988, in a watershed moment, India's 61st constitutional amendment lowered the voting age from 21 to 18 years. This change was brought about to increase the participation of the youth in the electoral process of the country. Low voter turnout, especially among young voters, has been a major cause of concern for the Election Commission of India (ECI). In the UK, young people are responding excitedly to the prospect of a lowered voting age. They are asking for the education system to include materials on political and civic education at earlier stages in schools. While engaging in such studies, young people will also be interested in participating in and testing out their right to vote. These educational programmes may also encourage greater voter turnout at earlier ages. Globally, several other countries, including Germany, Austria, Malta, Estonia, Argentina, Nicaragua, and some others, have lowered their voting age from 18 to 16 years. Since many children are employed at 16 years in India, and are taxpayers, they also ought to have the right to vote for the representatives who may best serve their interests. Given greater global connectivity and meanings of shared global childhoods and youth across class backgrounds, there is a need to include children in the democratic processes through the franchise, enabling a more just present and future. At the very least, enfranchisement offers a universal parity to all citizens for political representation, and creates avenues for greater accountability directly towards the young. India should not be far behind in considering what is becoming a global move vis-à-vis suffrage rights for children. Many young people in this country are politically motivated and have been at the forefront of several political and ecological issues that concern our collective futures. Thus, to strengthen their collective voices and aspirations for a just and shared future, it is crucial that they have a political voice. The right to vote would ensure greater accountability from our political leaders, who tend to, at best, dismiss young people as petulant or, worse, as easy targets of state repression. Lowering the voting age would also broaden the election manifestos with a greater focus on child rights, quality education, and gender justice. The writer is associate professor, BML Munjal University
Hindustan Times
9 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
NGT reviews interim measures for Pavana river pollution; PCMC, PMRDA's efforts under lens
Amid rising concerns over degradation of Pavana river, the National Green Tribunal's Western Zone Bench reviewed interim pollution control measures submitted by Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal Corporation (PCMC) and other authorities at a hearing held on July 17 . The tribunal urged them to transform words into water-saving actions. Acting on the directives, PCMC, one of the key stakeholders in the case, submitted a list of ongoing and proposed measures aimed at curbing solid and sewage pollution in the river. (HT) The watchdog registered a suo motu case regarding the river pollution after taking cognizance of news report published in Hindustan Times in February 2024. In the last hearing held on June 24, 2025, the river rejuvenation committee in their response stated that the Pune Metropolitan Region Development Authority (PMRDA) has submitted a detailed project report on 15 proposed sewage treatment plants along the river. The authority will submit the ₹215-crore project to the National River Conservation Directorate and the state government for approval. Objecting the timeline of the project which is December 2029, the NGT directed PCMC to submit interim measures to control the river pollution. Acting on the directives, PCMC, one of the key stakeholders in the case, submitted a list of ongoing and proposed measures aimed at curbing solid and sewage pollution in the river. According to PCMC's affidavit, mechanical and manual screening units have been installed at 16 major nullahs to prevent solid waste from flowing into the river. To reduce sewage pollution, the civic body has laid 32 km of interceptor lines along the river's banks, tapping and diverting multiple outfalls to pumping stations and sewage treatment plants (STPs). Several new sewage pumping stations have been constructed at Dapodi, Pimple Gurav, Kalewadi, and Chinchwad Bhatnagar. The existing STP at Bhatnagar has been augmented from 30MLD (million litres per day) to 45MLD and is expected to be fully operational within 15 days, currently undergoing trial runs. The civic body has also taken up the continuous removal of invasive water hyacinth under a three-year contract. To ensure uninterrupted functioning of its sewage infrastructure, express feeder connections have been provided to 26 SPSs and 16 STPs. Furthermore, under the 'Jal Hi AMRUT Scheme', the municipal corporation is preparing to upgrade nine aging STPs—some over 20 years old—to meet updated discharge norms mandated by the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board and NGT. The civic body is also planning a ₹1,980-crore holistic master plan and detailed project report for an integrated sewerage system. The plan envisions re-routing sewers away from riverbeds and nullahs to more accessible areas along roads. PCMC has submitted the proposal to state and central governments for financial support and has allocated budgetary funds for phased execution. 'It is heartening to note the measures proposed by PCMC. However, effective implementation and timely execution are crucial, or else the efforts will merely remain on paper,' observed the bench comprising Justice Dinesh Kumar Singh, judicial member and Vijay Kulkarni, expert member. The NGT also scrutinised the role of the PMRDA, which has tasked an expert agency, Tandon Urban Solutions Pvt. Ltd., with reviewing objections and preparing revised measures to address sewage inflows and nalla miscounting—an error highlighted by the applicant. The tribunal directed that the discrepancy in drains entering the river (15 reported versus 20 observed) must be corrected in the final plan. The river rejuvenation committee (RRC), through the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board, has proposed its own set of interim measures to be completed by June 2026. These include deploying 15 mobile STPs, installing floating solar creators, hyacinth removal, laser-cutting waste barriers, and continuous public education. The NGT has scheduled the matter for final hearing on August 20, 2025. NGT penalty on Pune Zilla Parishad The tribunal during its hearing on Wednesday took note that none of the zilla parishad representative were present for the hearing despite issuing two reminder letters. Taking serious note of the neglect, the bench imposed a penalty of ₹10,000 on the Pune Zilla Parishad for causing delay in proceedings by failing to appear before the tribunal. It granted a final opportunity of two weeks to the zilla parishad to file its reply affidavit—subject to payment of penalty. The amount is to be deposited in the account of NGT Bar Association (Western Zone), Pune, within one week.
