First tranche of final report from Horizon scandal inquiry to be published
Many were wrongly convicted of crimes such as theft and false accounting after faulty Horizon software made it look as though money was missing from their accounts.
Subpostmasters' lives were destroyed – with some bankrupted by legal action and sent to prison.
On Tuesday, the first volume of the Horizon IT inquiry's final report will be published – covering the devastating impact on the lives of the scandal's victims and the compensation process.
The issue of financial redress has frequently been flagged as an issue by subpostmasters – with many still awaiting full compensation.
The various compensation schemes have been criticised by victims as unfair and difficult to navigate – processes which lead campaigner Sir Alan Bates has previously described as 'quasi-kangaroo courts'.
Retired judge Sir Wyn Williams, the chairman of the probe, will make a public statement following the report's publication.
The inquiry was established in 2020, with a number of witnesses giving evidence on the use of Fujitsu's Horizon system, Post Office governance and the legal action taken against subpostmasters.
In a previous statement addressing the compensation schemes, the Department for Business and Trade said: 'This Government has quadrupled the total amount paid to affected postmasters to provide them with full and fair redress, with more than £1 billion having now been paid to over 7,300 claimants.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
27 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
So this is what it's come to: arresting pensioners and priests
That was made abundantly clear when we were treated to the sight of elderly women being bodily carried away by police, arrested under the Terrorism Act, and taken into custody. Their crime was to hold placards reading: 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.' Among the 29 arrested was 83-year-old Reverend Sue Parfitt, taken away by police while wearing her dog collar. Palestine Action is now proscribed as a terror organisation. Members broke into RAF Brize Norton and sprayed two military planes red. For that, it is now on an equal footing with the IRA. The terror label means that even showing support for Palestine Action can lead to 14 years in prison. Our Government has gone through the looking glass when it comes to Gaza. Read more from Neil Mackay To stand in the street and protest what you believe to be genocide, to offer support to an organisation which has been labelled a terror gang itself for protesting what it believes to be genocide, is now enough to get you carted away by the police in Britain in 2025. There's a craziness about this. Rather than discuss what is happening in Gaza, rather than debate how our Government is behaving regarding Gaza, rather than focus on the death, the bombing, the hunger, we're fixated on sideshows about singers causing outrage at Glastonbury, and arresting old ladies. The wilful blindness is absurd. The silencing runs deep. The BBC refused to air one of the most important documentaries of recent years, the film Gaza: Doctors Under Attack. Channel 4 stepped in after the BBC claimed the documentary could create 'a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect'. Channel 4 said the film was 'meticulously reported' and 'deserves to be widely seen'. It was, according to the channel's head of news and current affairs, subject to 'rigorous fact-checking' and presented an 'impartial view'. The channel had a 'duty to tell important journalistic stories – especially those that aren't being told elsewhere'. The film was among the most harrowing and horrifying ever aired on British television. Yet our national broadcaster chose to keep it from public sight. Instead, Channel 4 assumed the mantle of national broadcaster. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy wants BBC staff fired over the decision to air a separate Gaza documentary narrated by the child of a Hamas official. The Mail on Sunday ran a front page headline reading "Now arrest punk band who led 'Death to Israelis' chants at Glastonbury". The band in question is Bob Vylan. It's important to note – in these days of silencing – that the band did not chant "death to Israelis", but "death to the IDF". Accuracy matters, as does the deliberate elision. Perhaps musicians court controversy simply for controversy's sake, perhaps they speak out as they have deeply-held beliefs they wish to tell the world. Either way, the thoughts, words and deeds of minor celebrities should not be given greater importance in our news agenda that the reality of what is happening in Gaza. Reports about Bob Vylan jostled alongside reports of starving Palestinians shot at food distribution centres. There should be no such equivalence. At times, the average citizen must doubt their sanity. Why are we talking about punk bands when Francesca Albanese – who holds the post of United Nations special rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories – is talking about the need for global corporations to be held accountable for 'profiting from genocide' in Gaza? Mirjana Spoljaric, president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, says Gaza is 'hell on Earth', and 'humanity is failing'. She added that 'the fact that we are watching a people entirely stripped of its human dignity, it should really shock our collective conscience.' In Britain, though, it seems we wish either silence or distraction. Our Government and our media have lost all sense of reality when it comes to Gaza. The public simply wants honest reporting, political and moral decency, and an open debate. These are not dangerous nor difficult requests. There is an historic duty on humanity right now. If we cannot find a moral and peaceable solution to what's happening in Gaza then we open the door to a monstrous future for ourselves and our children. If the rules of war can be rewritten in Gaza, they can be rewritten anywhere. If, in the future, some conflict should break out in Europe with Russia, or in the Pacific involving China, then what is happening now in Gaza becomes a template for the rules of engagement in years to come. Our behaviour today shapes tomorrow. Indeed, we are reminded of that truth this week, as we mark the 20th anniversary of the 7-7 London terror attacks. There have been calls for Bob Vylan to be arrested (Image: PA) At the time of the invasion of Iraq in 2003, anyone with a brain was predicting that this illegal war would bring terror to British streets. The 2005 attacks proved those fears valid. As the 20th anniversary rolled round, the former head of counter-terrorism with the Met Police, Neil Basu, said the Iraq war 'made extremists of people who might not have been radicalised'. Foreign policy and Iraq was a 'driver of the 7-7 attacks', he said. The act of silencing is itself radicalising. Anger and fear are bottled up and become channelled in dangerous ways. By telling people not to speak – on an issue as deeply felt as Gaza – the Government risks creating a pressure cooker of rage. It's notable that many now keen on silencing portrayed themselves as champions of free speech for years. They were never interested in the free speech of others, only themselves. Gaza is the greatest test our Government and media face. Trust is on life support in this country. If the Government and media cannot deal honestly with Gaza then trust will die. Once all trust is gone, then we have nothing to hold us together. Neil Mackay is The Herald's Writer-at-Large. He's a multi-award-winning investigative journalist, author of both fiction and non-fiction, and a filmmaker and broadcaster. He specialises in intelligence, security, crime, social affairs, cultural commentary, and foreign and domestic politics.
The Herald Scotland
40 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Ireland can teach us valuable lessons on tax and prosperity
Besides, the evidence of 'over-reliance' on inward investment in Ireland is sparse. On the contrary, Ireland's success in attracting inward investment has had a transformative effect on the country's economy, by building the productivity of its workforce, its entrepreneurial flair and its supply chains. The Ireland of the time when both our countries joined the EU depended on the UK for 60% of its foreign trade; now it's well under 10%. The Ireland of today has produced two to three times as many companies worth over $1 billion than Scotland. It enjoys higher average earnings, lower overall and youth unemployment and lower poverty and child poverty levels than Scotland. And here's where the connection to independence, which as Ewen pointed out to Jackie Kemp (Letters, July 4), he didn't mention, comes in. Ireland was able to generate these fruits from inward investment to a greater degree than Scotland quite simply because Ireland attracted much more inward investment than Scotland. And it was able to do so because, as an independent country, it was able to maintain for many years a corporation tax regime designed to make it attractive to the inward investment it decided it needed to transform its economy. That's a luxury we chose to deny ourselves in Scotland. Martin Togneri, Linlithgow. Read more letters It's all about the economy Many of us write in on all sorts of topics: unionism, nationalism, the NHS, various conflicts, immigration and so on. In terms of priorities every government over the past 20 years or more has failed on the most vital task of all: the economy. It's a strong, healthy economy that creates the wealth needed to fund housing, health, education, transport, pensions, defence et al. We have squandered billions with abandon on crazy bottle deposit schemes, ferries that are half-built, cycle lanes that are empty, over-management in the Civil Service and on and on. A healthy economy depends on reasonable tax, high employment, lower red tape and entrepreneurship coupled with a social conscience. The sooner our headlines are highlighting the economic performance of the Government the sooner we will be able to address these issues and clean up our filthy road signs, the illegible road signs, the ferries in dry dock et al. It's the economy, first, last and always, stupid. John Gilligan, Ayr. Important visitors Further to Dr Ibiyemi Omeihe's article ("Do you want thriving universities in Scotland? Then we need immigration", The Herald, July 5) she is right to emphasise what international students bring, but I think it's even more important to remember what they take home with them. The cost of a British university degree to these students is so high, most of them will already be funded as future leaders at home – teachers, doctors, scientists, lawyers, politicians. Who knows how important the countries they are running in 25 years' time may be to us – politically, economically, scientifically? The opinions of this country's attitudes and values which they form now could influence all our futures. Carol Primrose, Bishopbriggs. Net zero claim is wrong Gillian Martin, the Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Energy, recently stated that "we are over halfway on our journey to net zero". This claim is is wrong. Net zero is achieved by a combination of reducing emissions and then balancing the remaining emissions by the removal of an equivalent amount of greenhouse gases from the atmosphere by using "carbon sinks", like forests for example. Net zero is accounted for on an annual basis. At the end of a year you calculate your emissions and removals and if your removals are the same or more than your emissions then you have achieved net zero for that year. In following years you may not achieve net zero because of an increase in emissions or a reduction in removals, obviously. By how much you have reduced your emissions from 1990 is not included in the formula to calculate net zero. The year was proposed by the UN so countries could compare how well they were doing in reducing emissions. Scotland's greenhouse gas emissions in 2023 were gross 54.4 million tonnes, though this figure is not stated in the published statistics as far as I could see. The figure used is net 39.6 million tonnes which is after deducting the removals of 14.8 million tonnes of emissions estimated to have been sequestered by Scottish forests. So in 2023 Scotland removed 14.8 million tonnes of the 54.4 million tonnes of greenhouse gases it produced, which is 27.2%. To claim "halfway to net zero" we would have to have removed 50%, ie 27.2 million tonnes. So based on the latest figures we have – for 2023 – Scotland has net 39.6 million tonnes of emissions to remove by 2045 by a combination of reductions and removals to "carbon sinks". Because of the length of time it takes to compile the emissions statistics we do not know even what has happened in the past two and a half years, let alone trying to predict emissions for the next 20 years which many people are forecasting will increase. Also trying to increase the amount of carbon sinks will be extremely difficult: we cannot double Scotland's forests. When net zero was first proposed it was envisioned that countries would employ direct air capture, which is using very large fans to suck in air from which CO2, the main greenhouse gas, could be extracted and this would count towards their removals to help achieve net zero. CO2 is very dilute in the atmosphere, only 429 parts per million which is a ratio of 2,331 to 1. So if you want to find one tonne of CO2 you need to suck in 2,331 tonnes of air, which uses a lot of electricity, the production of which would, they say, create more than a tonne of CO2, so that is not going to work. Hugh McAdams, Bearsden. Should Donald Trump press for more sanctions on Russia? (Image: PA) Trump should get priorities right In a review of its military support, the White House says it must 'put America's interests first', and still seems ambiguous in its attitude to Vladimir Putin's war. But in a meeting last week with Kaja Kallas, Vice-President of the European Commission, China's foreign minister Wang Yi said Beijing does not want Russia to lose the war, as the USA would then be able to focus more directly on China. That plausible (albeit surprising or even unintended) admission surely makes President Trump's priorities straightforward. He should immediately support the pro-Ukraine Republicans in Congress, enforce with the European and other allies the maximum economic and financial sanctions against Russia, impose stronger penalties on those countries that finance Vladimir Putin by their purchase of Russia's oil, gas and minerals, and supply Ukraine with the intelligence data and hardware needed for swift military success – which many experts have thought feasible since late 2022, with the right support. That would then allow the USA to pass the Ukraine baton safely and effectively to Europe, and to concentrate on confronting China globally – politically, diplomatically, economically and militarily – which President Trump has for years asserted is their greatest competitor and enemy. John Birkett, St Andrews. • On Donald Trump's visit to Scotland, nothing could deflate his huge ego more than for no-one to turn up. Let him see empty pavements. Let's ignore him and his cavalcade. Eileen Stables, Paisley.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Post Office compensation handouts slump despite ‘catastrophic' backlog
Compensation payouts for victims of the Post Office scandal have slumped to their lowest monthly total this year despite a backlog of thousands of claimants. More than 900 sub-postmasters were wrongfully prosecuted between 1999 and 2015 after faulty Fujitsu Horizon software incorrectly recorded shortfalls on their branch accounts. Several schemes have been set up to financially redress the victims of the scandal – some of whom were jailed for thefts and false accounting offences they did not commit. However, the schemes – of which all but one are now administered by the Government – have been criticised by former sub-postmasters, including campaigner Sir Alan Bates. The figures come ahead of the publication of the first part of a report by the chairman of a public inquiry investigating the Horizon scandal. Sir Wyn Williams is expected to focus on how effective the compensation schemes have been, as well as the human impact of the scandal. He will then give findings on other issues, such as governance at both Fujitsu and the Post Office, in the coming months. However, Telegraph analysis has found that just 514 payouts were awarded to applicants between June 2 and June 30. This was significantly lower than the previous month – a 16 per cent drop from 612 – and the lowest total recorded so far this year, during which an average of 685 claimants have received compensation each month. The Government statistics also show there are currently 2,590 eligible claimants awaiting financial redress. Process 'catastrophically poor' Chris Head, one of many sub-postmasters who has rejected offers owing to the size of the sums put forward, said the latest figures show the schemes had been 'catastrophically poor'. Speaking to The Telegraph on Monday evening, Mr Head, 37, added: 'It's completely unacceptable that people have had to wait so long for redress.' Mr Head, who was falsely accused of stealing more than £80,000 in 2006 before his criminal case was dropped, says he has so far been offered just 36 per cent of what he believes he is entitled to. 'I've always said there are two things that need to be tackled – accountability and redress – and the former will take longer because the wheels of justice take some time,' he added. 'This is something that just needs to be addressed at a faster rate.' Those unhappy with their offers can have their cases reviewed by an independent panel of experts. At least 350 Horizon victims have reportedly already died before receiving their final compensation payouts. A government spokesman said: 'We are grateful for the inquiry's work, which has revealed the immeasurable suffering that victims of the scandal have endured. 'This Government has quadrupled the total amount paid to affected postmasters to provide them with full and fair redress, with more than £1 billion having now been paid to over 7,900 claimants.'
