Puck Fair's late-night drinking tradition survives garda objections
On July 10 at the District Court of Killorglin, sitting in Caherciveen, 14 publicans applied under Section 10 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act 1962 for the annual special exemption to 3am over the three principal nights of the August Fair, Gathering, Fair and Scattering, on August 10, 11 and 12.
However, gardaí objected on the grounds of straitened resources. District court Judge David Waters set the opening at 2am, in line with the Garda submission, saying the fair was not all about drinking.
On Tuesday in the circuit court in Killarney, Judge Terence O'Sullivan said he saw no grounds to shorten Puck Fair's traditional drinking time to 2am.
Puck Fair dated to 1603, the last year of the reign of King James I of England, Judge O'Sullivan noted. Since the 1970s, the pub closing time at Puck was 3am.
'Bigger than Christmas'
'Prior to that, there was a 24-hour opening of the pubs in Killorglin,' barrister Katie O'Connell, instructed by John O'Dwyer solicitor, had told the court.
All day and family activities took place and afterwards people would go for a drink. Street entertainment ended at midnight and then the fair volunteers would like to go for a drink to relax and enjoy themselves, Ms O'Connell said. Puck Fair was 'bigger than Christmas" for people from region, the barrister said.
'Chipping away' at the status of the festival was taking place. The statue of the Puck Goat sat at the entrance to the town and economically the festival was important to Killorglin, with people put through college and school on the strength of the fair..
Only the gardaí, not the locals, had objected, Ms O'Connell also said.
Garda objections
Garda Supt John Ryan of Killarney was called to give evidence by State solicitor Diane Reidy. The garda objections were twofold, Supt Ryan said.
Pubs were given an exemption to open to 2am the night preceding Puck Fair and the garda felt that four nights to 2am would be sufficient given the street entertainment finished at midnight.
Having pubs open to 3am needed additional police resources. It was reasonable to reduce it by the hour, he felt. Cross-examined by Ms O'Connell, Supt Ryan agreed the fair was "the lifeblood of Killorglin".
Ms O'Connell also told Judge O'Sullivan that the organisers of the festival - who are all volunteers - did not want everyone spilling out from the pubs at 2am and the extra hour would mean there was safer dispersal and organisation of buses and taxis.
'It's always been 3am. Nothing warrants the reduction,' she said.
While she appreciated the extra garda resources was paid for through taxes, the Killorglin community were also tax payers. The festival organisers contributed €3,000 to the resources of the gardaí, she said.
'Judge Waters thought the front line (policing) should trump anything else,' she said.
State solicitor Diane Reidy said the issue was one of resources, not public order and Puck Fair was the only festival in Kerry seeking to open to 3am.
'It's the proper allocation of resources and the additional strain on Garda resources to police it,' Ms Reidy said.
Judge's decision
In his decision, delivered after a recess to look at the legislation, Judge O'Sullivan said the traditional opening had been to 3am, there was no evidence of anyone in the locality objecting on noise or nuisance grounds.
'In reality the objection is about the pressure on police resources without any particular incident,' the judge said.
Judge O'Sullivan said he appreciated the District Court Judge had "more connection" with the locality than himself, but he did not see any grounds to depart from the tradition, he said, granting the exemptions to 3am over three nights.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Report showing many roads gardaí not doing jobs 'shocking'
The chairperson of the Policing and Community Safety Authority has described as "shocking" a report which shows that a substantial number of gardaí assigned to Roads Policing are not doing their jobs and have no interest in doing them. The Garda Commissioner has promised to publish the Crowe Report which also shows that gardaí who were not carrying out their duties did not care that they were being monitored, and that their managers were not dealing with the problem. Drew Harris called their actions "brazen and contemptuous" and the report's conclusions "sobering". The disturbing details in this report emerged on the day that the gardaí launched another of its road safety campaigns. An independent review of roads policing was launched after a garda whistleblower informed garda headquarters that a substantial number of the gardaí tasked with policing the roads were not doing their jobs. The chairperson of the policing and community safety authority also pointed out that garda managers and supervisors in charge of those gardaí, were either unable, unwilling or afraid to do anything about it The chairperson of the Policing and Community Safety Authority described the report as shocking and said there are members within roads policing who seem very much disinterested in their job. The report also showed that not only were these gardaí not conducting speed checks or tests for drink and drug driving, they also did not care that they were being monitored and that their failure to do their job had been identified by the independent investigators. The chairperson Elaine Byrne also said she was not only concerned about the blatant disregard some members have, when they knew they were being reviewed by this but also about the absence of performance management. "They were in the cars with people, and they were openly hostile to doing their job," she said. "And I think once that report is published, you'll see that, but also perhaps another thing that we were shocked about is that there seem to be a deference or a fear of some management, of not actually doing performance management, and just a fear of actually being managers within guards, within Roads Policing." The Garda Commissioner called the actions of the gardaí "brazen" and "contemptuous" and said a working group had been established to implement its recommendations. He also said it was not just a matter of moving people on because the issues identified were "systemic". The findings of this report will be particularly distressing to the families of people who have lost loved ones on the roads because of speed, dangerous, drink or drug driving.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘I beat a shovel off his head': Man sentenced for unlawful killing
A father of four beat a man to death with four blows of a shovel and told gardaí who arrived at the scene: 'I hit him with a shovel and I hope the c**t is dead,' the Central Criminal Court heard today. A sentencing hearing for Joseph Cahill (46), who pleaded guilty to the unlawful killing of 43-year-old Gerard 'Ger' Curtin, heard that Cahill had previously threatened to kill the deceased after Mr Curtin came to his house, threw stones at his windows, threatened to burn the house down and demanded money. Mr Curtin left after Cahill's partner gave him €300. Insp James Ruddle of Roxboro Road Garda station in Limerick told the court that Mr Curtin returned to Cahill's house in the early hours about two weeks later, again demanding money. CCTV footage showed the deceased smashing a window of the Cahill home with a rock. The lock on Cahill's front door was broken so he had propped a shovel against it to keep out intruders. Cahill took the shovel, opened the door and struck the victim on the head, causing him to immediately fall to the ground, the inspector said. Cahill then struck Mr Curtin three more times as he lay 'defenceless and immobile' on the ground. Before delivering the blows, Cahill called emergency services and asked for the police. After delivering the fatal blows, with Mr Curtin lying motionless on the ground, Cahill told the call-taker that a man was trying to get into his house. READ MORE He waited a further eight minutes and 30 seconds before telling the call taker to send an ambulance. When asked why he needed an ambulance, Cahill said: 'I think he's dead ... I had to protect my kids. I don't give a fuck about going to jail. I beat a shovel off his head and I kept beating, to tell you the truth.' The first garda at the scene made a note of Cahill saying: 'I hit him with a shovel, I hope the c**t is dead.' Garret Baker SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions , told Ms Justice Eileen Creedon that Cahill was originally charged with murder. He said the DPP accepted the manslaughter plea on the basis that Cahill honestly believed that he was protecting himself, his property and his children but that the force used in striking Mr Curtin four times with the shovel was excessive. Gerard Curtin died on November 4th, 2023. Photograph: Garda/PA On May 30th this year, Cahill, of Sarsfield Avenue, Garryowen, Limerick pleaded guilty to the unlawful killing of Mr Curtin on November 4th, 2023 outside his home. Mr Baker said the offence warrants a headline sentence of 10-15 years. In an impact statement, Bianca Hickey told the court that the deceased was a brother, father, partner and friend. She said the family has always been 'close-knit' but the killing tore them apart. She said they have watched their parents become 'completely different people'. They never got to say goodbye or kiss him one last time because his injuries were so catastrophic that his coffin had to be closed. Insp Ruddle agreed with Michael O'Higgins SC, for Cahill, that gardaí were aware of allegations over many years that Mr Curtin had smashed windows of houses and threatened the occupants. The court heard that eight days after the killing, Cahill's home was petrol bombed and the family was forced to move out of the area. Cahill's sister's home was also petrol bombed at 5am while all people living there were in bed, the court was told. When Mr O'Higgins began to read a letter of apology from his client, the deceased's family stood up and walked out of court. In the letter Cahill said he wanted to 'express how deeply sorry I am' to the victim's partner and children. He said he carries the 'massive burden' of what he did every day and has turned the lives of his own family upside down. Mr O'Higgins said his client has a long history of mental illness, polysubstance abuse and a gambling addiction. He pointed to a psychiatric report, which states that due to childhood trauma, Cahill is predisposed to act irrationally and to overreact to threats against himself and his family. He has no relevant previous convictions. Counsel asked the court to take into account that Cahill was woken on the night by a volatile man smashing his windows and trying to cross the threshold into his home. While Mr O'Higgins said the court would have to impose a custodial sentence, he asked Ms Justice Creedon to offer the 'maximum leniency' possible. Ms Justice Creedon adjourned sentencing to November 24th.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Youth took money off man, threatened to kill him and then went to his bedroom
A teenager has been given two years detention for the false imprisonment of another young man. Dublin Circuit Criminal Court heard that the 17-year-old, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded guilty to false imprisonment with other counts to be taken into consideration at a location in Dublin on June 15, 2023. He was aged 15 at the time of the offending and had ten previous convictions from the Children's Court, including seven convictions for theft, one for attempted robbery, one for assault causing harm and one for production of a knife. He was also on bail at the time of this offending. Detective Garda John Hayes from Blanchardstown Garda Station told Stephen Montgomery BL, prosecuting, that a young man then aged 19 was travelling on a bus in the Clonsilla area of Dublin in May 2023. Neither the accused or the victim were known to the other. The detective told the court that the accused was larger in stature than the injured party. When the victim got off the bus, he was followed by the teenager, who started a conversation with him and broke his glasses. The accused then ordered the injured party to walk to a nearby shop and instructed him to withdraw €50 from an ATM. The teenager then threatened the victim to keep this a 'secret'. The court heard that a week later, the victim was on the bus again, and the teenager sat behind him and put his hands around his neck and told him to be quiet. They got off the bus together, and the teenager took the victim's iPhone 13, worth € 1,300. The teenager then added the victim as a friend on Snapchat. Det Gda Hayes told the court that the victim received a message on June 15, 2023, from the teenager, who told him to meet him with his bank card, which he did. The teenager brought the victim to an apartment where he produced two knives and told the victim he was going to kill him and slice him. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week He also instructed the victim to remove his clothing, as he would have to burn it. The injured party did not take his clothes off, but his backpack was searched, and his driver's licence with his address on it was taken. The court heard that the victim was then brought to his own home by the teenager, who disposed of one of the knives en route. While in the injured party's house, the teenager threatened to harm the family dog if he didn't 'put it out of the way'. The teenager searched the victim's bedroom and took a Nike tracksuit, an Under Armour top, Nike runners, a PlayStation, and a camel jacket, all with a total value of € 1,751. The teenager then made the victim transfer €500 from his Revolut account to one of the injured party's friends' accounts, as he did not have a Revolut bank card. He told his friend to meet him in a local shopping centre, and the defendant, the victim and the victim's friend went to multiple ATM's while withdrawing €460 in total. The teenager then left with the cash and the items taken earlier from the victim's house. Later that evening, the victim told his mother and showed her the knife left behind by the teenager. They went to the gardai, and the victim showed them the apartment he had been taken to. CCTV footage from the shopping centre and footage from the Ring doorbell of the victim's home were obtained, and the defendant was identified. He was interviewed on two occasions. None of the money or belongings were recovered. A victim impact statement was submitted to the court and read by the prosecuting counsel. It outlined how the victim quit his job in case the teenager came back. He was also afraid that the defendant would come back to his home and described that he was in 'fear for his parents'. He said he was always 'looking over his shoulder' and said he 'can never relax on public transport'. He still has trouble sleeping. Padraig Dwyer SC, defending, said his client was forthright with the Probation Services and is apologetic, showing empathy towards the victim in his case. He stated that his client has taken responsibility for his actions and told the probation officer that he deserves a prison sentence. Counsel said his client was 15 at the time of the offending. He said that his client's parents do not condone this behaviour and are very pro-social people. He said his client 'self-reports that he has used cannabis but is now self-reporting that he is clear at present. He said his client is expressing regret for his actions. On Thursday, Judge Martina Baxter noted the defendant had two knives with him and the 'brazenness' of going to the victim's home. 'It wasn't as if it was a once-off situation, the judge said. It was clear that the 'fear and threat' was 'pervasive and real,' said the judge. Judge Baxter said she had to have regard for his previous convictions. She said the victim was bullied and traumatised 'while going about his business'. She said a significant factor was that the accused was 15 at the time but noted he was 'back in adverse company'. 'Clearly there has to be an intervention,' said Judge Baxter. She said the aggravating factors were the effects on the victim who is 'constantly in fear', the threats and the menace. In mitigation she took account of his age and that the Children's Act states detention is 'the last resort'. Judge Baxter imposed two years detention on him. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
