logo
Trump's shift on Ukraine has been dramatic – but will it change the war?

Trump's shift on Ukraine has been dramatic – but will it change the war?

The Guardian6 days ago
Donald Trump presents himself as a peerless president, an unrivaled negotiator, even a 'genius'. So it's a unique moment when he comes close – I emphasize the qualifier –to conceding that another leader has outfoxed him. Trump suggested as much recently when characterizing Vladimir Putin's modus operandi. 'Putin,' he told reporters on 13 July, 'really surprised a lot of people. He talks nice and then bombs everybody in the evening.' Melania Trump may have contributed to this reassessment. As Trump recounted recently, when he told her about a 'wonderful conversation' with the Russian leader, she responded, 'Oh, really? Another city was just hit.'
Trump's new take on Putin is a break with the past. His esteem for Putin–whose decisions he has described as 'savvy' and 'genius' – has contrasted starkly with his derisive comments about the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, whom he memorably disrespected during a White House meeting and even blamed for starting the war.
As recently as February, he declared that Russia's invasion didn't matter to the United States because, unlike Europe, it was separated from Ukraine by 'a big, big beautiful ocean'. He criticized Joe Biden's assistance to Ukraine as a waste of taxpayers' money.
Now, Trump has not only changed his view of Putin, stunning many within his 'America First' MagaA movement; he's decided to start arming Ukraine. Well, sort of.
Trump has gone beyond effectively conceding that Putin has played him. He has decided to sell military equipment to individual European countries so that they can supply Ukraine and restock their arsenals with purchases from the United States. The president formally announced the change during his 14 July meeting with Mark Rutte, Nato's secretary general.
There was more. Trump warned Putin that if he did not accept a ceasefire – which he has steadfastly refused, just as he has ignored Trump's demand to stop bombing Ukraine's cities – within 50 days, Russia would be slammed with tariffs as high as 100%, as would countries that continued to trade with it after the deadline.
Two things are clear. First, Trump's perspective on Putin has changed, unexpectedly and dramatically. Second, a war that Trump once said was none of America's business now apparently matters. The president said European countries would buy 'top of the line' American military equipment worth 'billions of dollars' to arm Ukraine. According to one report citing 'a source familiar with the plan', the total will be $10bn.
This all sounds like a very big deal. But here's where it becomes important to go beyond the headlines and sound bites and delve into the details.
Take the $10bn figure. That's certainly not chump change. Moreover, the main piece of equipment specified so far, the Patriot 'long range, high altitude, all weather' missile defense system, will provide desperately needed relief to Ukrainian city dwellers, who have endured relentless waves of drone attacks – several hundred a night – followed by missiles that slice through overwhelmed defenses. Ukraine has some Patriots but needs more: it's a vast country with a dozen cities whose populations exceed 400,000.
However, a Patriot battery (launchers, missiles, a radar system, a control center, antenna masts, and a power generator) costs $1bn, the missiles alone $4m apiece. Ukraine may not need 10 Patriot batteries, but even a smaller number will consume a large proportion of the $10bn package. The other system that has been mentioned is the Joint Air-to-Surface Standoff Missile (Jassm), which combines stealth technology and GPS guidance with a 230-mile range. Ukraine will be able to use its American-made F-16 jets to fire Jassms into Russia from positions beyond the reach of Russian air defense systems. But a single Jassm costs around $1.5m, so the costs will add up quickly. Additional items have been mentioned but only generically; still, their price must also be figured in, bearing in mind that the war could drag on. So, $10bn could be depleted quickly.
Moreover, beyond a certain point the US cannot sell equipment from its own stocks without regard to its military readiness requirements. Precisely for that reason, the defense department recently declined to send Ukraine some of the equipment promised under Joe Biden.
And Trump has not said that there will be follow-on sales to benefit Ukraine once the $10bn mark is reached. Even if he were to change his mind, individual European countries would be able to buy only so much American weaponry without straining their finances, especially because France and Italy have opted out of the arrangement. Trump has been uninterested in joining the recent move by the UK and the EU to impose a $47.60 per barrel price cap on Russian oil sales, toughening the $60 limit the west enacted in 2022. Finally, Trump isn't going to resume Biden's multi-billion-dollar military assistance packages – 70-plus tranches of equipment, according to the DoD.
Trump's 50-day tariff deadline permits Putin to continue his summer offensive, and may even provide an incentive to accelerate it. Russia has already shrugged off Trump's tariff threat. Its exports to the US in 2024 amounted to $526m, a tiny fraction of its global sales.
By contrast, Trump's secondary tariffs will hurt Russia, which earned $192bn in 2024 from its global exports of oil and related products, much of that sum from India and China. If the president follows through with his threat, Beijing will surely retaliate, and the consequence will be painful: the United States exports to China totaled $144bn last year. Will Trump proceed anyway, and during his ongoing trade wars, which have already started increasing prices in the US? His track record on tariff threats leaves room for doubt.
Ukraine's leaders are understandably elated by Trump's reappraisal of Putin. But it's premature to conclude that it's a turning point that could change the war's trajectory. Washington's new policy may prove far less momentous than Maga critics fear and not quite as transformative as Kyiv and its western supporters hope for.
Rajan Menon is a professor emeritus of international relations at the City College of New York and a senior research scholar at Columbia University's Saltzman Institute of War and Peace Studies
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump's caddy drops golf ball moments before president takes a shot
Donald Trump's caddy drops golf ball moments before president takes a shot

Metro

time13 minutes ago

  • Metro

Donald Trump's caddy drops golf ball moments before president takes a shot

Donald Trump may be failing to secure a ceasefire in Ukraine, or stop the speculation about the unreleased Jeffrey Epstein files, or reduce prices of food in the US – this list could go on – but his ability to bend reality is in top form. His Air Force One touched down at Prestwick Airport in Scotland on Friday and the US president wasted no time hitting the golf course – or having his caddy hit it for him, actually. Footage circulating online shows the Republican allegedly cheating at golf with some help from staff. Two caddies – people who assists golfers by carrying their bags and with some strategic advice – are seen walking next to Trump who is driving in a cart. Both walk ahead and one is spotted discreetly dropping the golf ball to the ground. Trump then gets out of the vehicle and approaches it, appearing to pretend that it is the shot he made. 'Trump working hard to bring down grocery prices,' the caption of the video reads, referencing his campaign promises to tackle inflation and costs in the US. Of course, a long line of accusations that the president cheats follow in the comments on X. Political commentator, Richard Angwin, wrote under: 'His shameless golf cheating, having his caddie drop a ball for a better lie outside the bunker, exposes the same fraudulent tactics he employs in politics, proving once again he's a con artist through and through.' Another comment read: ' Caddy did that so smoothly. I can only imagine how many times he has done it.' Soon enough, the phrase 'commander in cheat' was trending on X amid the allegations. The president has boasted of winning dozens of golf championships – all on courses he owns – including five this year alone. Rick Reilly, a former Sports Illustrated journalist who has played with him and has interviewed dozens of people familiar with his game, claimed this is a lie 'that is so over-the-top Crazytown it loses all credibility among golfers the second it is out of his mouth.' More Trending In his book 'Commander in Cheat: How Golf Explains Trump', he said that Trump has likely won none of the club championships he claims to have. Trump's four-day trip to the UK is not an official visit. He is due to return for a meeting with state heads in September. The main purpose appears to be to play golf at his two courses – Trump International at Menie in Aberdeenshire and Trump Turnberry in South Ayrshire. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Man shouting 'death to Trump' tackled by passengers on EasyJet flight to Glasgow MORE: Prince Andrew among 100 people who could be dragged into Epstein scandal MORE: New arrest in cold case of mum killed 30 years ago walking home from shops

Business news live: FTSE 100 to open near record high and latest bitcoin price after fall
Business news live: FTSE 100 to open near record high and latest bitcoin price after fall

The Independent

time13 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Business news live: FTSE 100 to open near record high and latest bitcoin price after fall

The FTSE 100 rose to new highs once again last week, tipping the scales well above 9,100 points after a particularly strong day on Thursday which saw the likes of BT Group rise ten per cent. The British companies index is up more than 11 per cent this year, outpacing the key US benchmarks. Meanwhile, key upcoming UK economy data this week includes mortgage approvals and the Nationwide House Price Index. Additionally, there is likely to be more news emerging on how the government may tackle pension reform, amid debate over what age the state pension should be and whether the tax relief rate on pension contributions may be altered. In other markets, bitcoin fell towards the end of last week, from the highs above $123,000 down to around $115,000, with gold also retreating as investors took a risk-on approach once more.

Nato jets scrambled after Putin launches massive overnight drone and missile attack on Ukraine
Nato jets scrambled after Putin launches massive overnight drone and missile attack on Ukraine

Scottish Sun

time13 minutes ago

  • Scottish Sun

Nato jets scrambled after Putin launches massive overnight drone and missile attack on Ukraine

Five people have been injured after an apartment building was bombed in Kyiv NATO member Poland has scrambled fighter jets after Russia's latest blitz on Ukraine. The jets took to the skies as Vladimir Putin sent the latest wave of kamikaze drones and rockets at Kyiv. 1 Poland scrambled jets after Putin launched his latest onslaught Credit: Getty Eight people, including a two-year-old girl, were injured in the strikes with shrapnel wounds after one bomb hit an apartment building. Kyiv's Mayor Vitali Klitschko said that all of the people were residents of a multi-storey apartment building in the city's Darnytskyi district on the left bank of the Dnipro River. The Polish Ministry of Defence said the jets took off as a precautionary measure during the strikes. They said: "Polish and allied aircraft on standby were scrambled and ground-based air defence and radar reconnaissance systems were placed on the highest level of combat readiness." Four of those injured in the attack, which took place soon after midnight on Monday, have been hospitalised, with one person in serious condition, the head of Kyiv's military administration, Tymur Tkachenko. More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos. Like us on Facebook at TheSunUS and follow us on X at @TheUSSun

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store