Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova accuses officials of home bias after technology failure
At 4-4 in the first set of Pavlyuchenkova's fourth-round match against Britain's Sonay Kartal and with the Russian serving at game point, she was convinced a backhand from her opponent had landed long.
Umpire Nico Helwerth stopped the point to check whether the technology, which has controversially replaced line judges this year, had worked, informing the crowd after a delay that it had not.
Intriguing scenes!
Pavlyuchenkova thinks Kartal has put her forehand long and stops before the Brit slams back a winner.
The umpire checks and confirms the electronic line calling system was unable to track the point, which leads to the point being replayed. #Wimbledon pic.twitter.com/Qkz3Rickj5
— BBC Sport (@BBCSport) July 6, 2025
With no official evidence of whether the ball was in or out, Helwerth ordered the point to be replayed, and Pavlyuchenkova, who would have won the game had the shot been called out, went on to drop serve.
The 34-year-old reacted furiously at the change of ends, saying to Helwerth: 'Because she is local, they can say whatever. You took the game away from me.'
TV replays showed the ball was considerably long, and Wimbledon revealed the problem had been caused by human error.
A spokesman said: 'Due to operator error, the system was deactivated on the point in question. The chair umpire followed the established process.'
Pavlyuchenkova discussed the matter with Helwerth after the match, and she said: 'It was very confusing in the beginning because the ball looked very long to me.
'It was a very crucial moment in the match. I expected a different decision. I just thought also the chair umpire could take the initiative. That's why he's there sitting on the chair. He also saw it out, he told me after the match. I don't know if it's something to do because she's local.
'I think we are losing a little bit of the charm of actually having human beings. Like during Covid, we didn't have ball boys. It just becomes a little bit weird and robot sort of orientated.
'They're very good at giving fines, though, and code violations. This they don't miss because every time any little thing, they are just right there on it. I would prefer they looked at the lines and call the errors better.'
Kartal, who insisted she did not know if the ball was in or out, defended Helwerth's handling of the situation.
'That situation is a rarity,' she said. 'I don't think it's really ever happened. It's tough luck. What can you do? The umpire is trying his best in that situation. I think he handled it fine. I think the fairest way was what he did, to replay the point.'
Pavlyuchenkova regrouped well after the incident, saving a Kartal set point and going on to claim a 7-6 (3) 6-4 victory and a place in the quarter-finals.
Asked how she would have felt had she lost, the 34-year-old joked: 'I would just say that I hate Wimbledon and never come back here.'
The incident is hugely embarrassing for Wimbledon, with organisers having staunchly defended the innovation amid controversy over the removal of line judges.
Britain's leading duo Jack Draper and Emma Raducanu have both complained about the accuracy of the system, which is now widely used on the tour, this week.
After her defeat by Aryna Sabalenka on Friday, Raducanu said: 'It's kind of disappointing, the tournament here, that the calls can be so wrong.'
Pavlyuchenkova also has her doubts, saying: 'Sometimes when we play, I'm thinking, 'Am I crazy, or I just feel like the ball is long?' Then nothing is happening. There is no automatic line calling.
'The chair umpire was so confused. I think the chair umpire needs to maybe have a clear plan if that happens. We probably should have this system like in football to review.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
Wimbledon diary: Sir Ian McKellen takes in the tennis and fans pack Henman Hill
Gandalf witnessed some Centre Court wizardry on day nine of Wimbledon. Actor Sir Ian McKellen, who starred as The Lord of the Rings character, watched Aryna Sabalenka battle back to reach the women's semi-finals before taking in Cameron Norrie's quarter-final defeat to defending men's champion Carlos Alcaraz. The 86-year-old was joined in the Royal Box by fellow thespians Sir Mark Rylance, Sienna Miller, Jodie Foster and Richard E. Grant, singer Katherine Jenkins and coffee magnate Giuseppe Lavazza. Former cricketer David Gower was among those representing the world of sport, while Scotland and Napoli midfielder Scott McTominay and Arsenal duo Bukayo Saka and Jurrien Timber enjoyed the action from less exclusive seats. *** American 13th seed Amanda Anisimova celebrated progression to the semi-finals with a special guest. The 23-year-old was accompanied by nephew Jaxon for her post-match interview on Court One following a 6-1 7-6 (9) win over Russia's Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova. Jaxon, who turns four on Thursday, only arrived in the UK on Tuesday morning. An early birthday present for Amanda's nephew, Jackson #Wimbledon — Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) July 8, 2025 After ensuring his long trip was worthwhile, Anisimova said: 'My sister and her husband are also here and I'm super grateful that they flew in and got to experience this with me – it doesn't happen often.' *** The tension on Centre Court during Sabalenka's match against Laura Siegemund was broken when a mobile phone began to ring. The usual accompanying tuts and moans from other spectators grew louder when it became apparent no one could turn off the annoying ring tone. One unfortunate spectator was rifling through her bag trying to find the offending item. But it turned out to have been left behind by someone else and they were trying to locate it remotely. The phone was eventually found under a seat and handed to a member of security. *** Henman Hill was rammed late on Tuesday afternoon. Fans were glued to the big screen, with the majority cheering on British number three Norrie in his efforts to pull of a major upset against world number two Alcaraz. Barely a spare blade of grass was available as other spectators queued to join them. Quote of the day 'I'm more for line umpires, to be honest. Sometimes it's scary to let machines do what they want, you know (smiling)?' – Russian 17th seed Karen Khachanov joined the growing list of players to question Wimbledon's electronic line calling system following a malfunction during his quarter-final loss to Taylor Fritz. Picture of the day Wednesday's match of the day Teenage Russian Mirra Andreeva has been one of the standout performers in the women's draw. The 18-year-old, who is coached by 1994 Wimbledon champion Conchita Martinez, is bidding to reach a second grand slam semi-final and has been given another Centre Court slot after shining in front of Roger Federer on Monday during her fourth-round defeat of Emma Navarro. Standing in her way is 2021 Olympic champion Belinda Bencic. The 28-year-old Swiss player is also enjoying her best run at SW19, having missed last year's tournament after giving birth to daughter Bella in April 2024. Wednesday weather watch
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Cameron Norrie's meek exit leaves Centre Court pining for the days of Murray
When this quarter-final was definitively wrapped up after only one hour and 39 minutes, the noise on Centre Court was a subdued mixture of applause and the odd whoop. The applause was polite, acknowledging a sporting contest had taken place, even if it had not been competitive. The whoops were a little performative. Britain's last remaining singles hope at these Championships, Cameron Norrie, had been outclassed by a purring Carlos Alcaraz 6-2, 6-3, 6-3. Alcaraz, the reigning men's champion, had whipped through the match, whipped forehand winner after forehand winner, and whipped his opponent into meek submission. It had been so tough for Norrie that he had felt the need to fist pump simply for holding points on his serve. This is where the whoops came in; the crowd's own attempt to find encouragement where it could. Quarter-finals with a British interest are far from a given at Wimbledon. The decade between 2008 and 2017, when Andy Murray never went home before the final eight, is a glaring anomaly in the men's game. Equally exceptional were the successes of Virginia Wade in the 1970s. This was only the fifth quarter-final to feature a home competitor in the past decade and the unspectacular Norrie, born in South Africa and raised in New Zealand, is not someone who can easily be described as a fan favourite. So it was a big match, but not as big as it could have been and this perhaps was reflected around the showpiece court. Half empty as the match got under way, albeit with British theatrical titans Sir Ian McKellen, Mark Rylance and Richard E Grant in their seats throughout, the ground filled up but the atmosphere never took off. Were the crowd cheering for an underdog victory or applauding the effort of an emerging titan of the modern game? In the end it was a bit of both and neither. A raucous home crowd would probably have had no effect on the outcome of the match, unless it was to inspire Alcaraz to higher levels than those he deemed necessary to win. Even in the first game of the match, in which Norrie valiantly held serve, the No 2 seed pummelled the Briton with power and placement. One of Norrie's key strengths are on the defensive, with a tigerish ability to chase down angles and take the speed out of dangerous play. But it was clear from the off that these tools, effective in the tournament to this point and in his run to the semi-finals in 2022, were not going to work here. Alcaraz was typically considerate in his post-match remarks on court, declaring Norrie a 'really difficult' opponent. 'I am really happy,' the 22-year-old said. 'To be able to play another semi-final here at Wimbledon is really special. I want to go as far as I can and I am really happy with the level I played today against a really difficult player like Cam. He is an amazing guy. No one works harder than him and it is nice to see him fighting for great things.' Alcaraz was right, there was no doubting Norrie's work ethic, at least in the first two sets when the writing was only being daubed on the wall. But the limits of his ability against the top players was clear. This was more like a British Wimbledon encounter in the years pre-Murray, such was the imbalance on court, but this is 2025 and expectations have long been revised upwards. Jack Draper, the British No 1 and another player to have exited meekly from the tournament this year, wondered out loud 'How did Andy Murray do it?' after his second-round loss. This question will surely come into sharper focus by the time next year's Championship comes around. Sign up to The Recap The best of our sports journalism from the past seven days and a heads-up on the weekend's action after newsletter promotion On the other hand, at least everyone got to see Alcaraz. The Spaniard does not yet have his supporter army, like the omnipresent and slightly unsettling Nole-fam that stand foursquare behind the 24-time major winner Novak Djokovic. But the 22-year-old does have the game to win the hearts of neutrals. Yes he has the 135mph aces, and the bludgeoning strokes from the back of the court that are the pre-requisites for success in the hard court age. But his love of the drop shot is something that is shared by Wimbledon aficionados too, and he also found time for some exquisite lobs in the few moments Norrie could be tempted into the net. His roar of celebration upon victory seemed pretty genuine too, and this crowd loves a fighter. Norrie will now try to take the momentum he has generated and turn it into a run at the US Open later this summer. For Alcaraz, it's the American Taylor Fritz in the semis and the ongoing shot at a threepeat. That match is scheduled for Friday, and in between Alcaraz plans to take in some sights. 'I will make the most of the time with my team and family in London,' he said, further endearing himself to the crowd. 'I might try to go to the city centre if I have time. What I have been doing so far has worked so we will try to switch off together.'
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Alcaraz dominates Norrie to end British hopes at Wimbledon
The statistics told the story of a one-sided quarter-final contest: a 6-2, 6-3, 6-3 masterclass from a player who is attempting to join Bjorn Borg, Pete Sampras, Roger Federer and Novak Djokovic in winning three consecutive Wimbledon titles in the Open era. Norrie had beaten Alcaraz twice before, but on these lawns — where the Spaniard is unbeaten in 19 consecutive matches — he is far more at home than the home hope. So popular is Alcaraz that cries of "Come on, Carlos" were nearly as loud as those backing the British No 3. The Centre Court crowd quickly sensed the inevitability of the result, and the defending champion wrapped up his victory in just 99 minutes — his swiftest of the Championships thus far. Even Oliver Tarvet, the world No 733, had made him work harder for over two hours last week. Alcaraz won 89 per cent of his first-serve points and fired down 13 aces. He accumulated 94 points with 39 winners, and even when Norrie occasionally threatened his serve, the Spaniard remained unflustered. "Yes we Cam," shouted one optimistic voice in the crowd, although the sentiment owed more to summer sunshine and too many glasses of Pimm's than on-court reality. There was sympathy for Norrie who, despite his exceptional fitness, may have been feeling the effects of a five-set thriller against Nicolás Jarry just 48 hours earlier. Arthur Ashe, who won his historic title here 50 years ago, once remarked that the gap between the world No 1 and No 10 was as great as that between ten and 100. You did not need expert eyes to see that Norrie's current ranking — No 61, though this run will lift it — was cruelly exposed. "I was the underdog and he just took care of things really well," said Norrie. "It was a good experience to play the best player in the world, on his favourite surface. I didn't take my chances and that showed in the score. "When he's enjoying his tennis like this and he's serving that well, he's the favourite to win again for sure and the level he is playing is unreal. He's got so many options - he's got power and then he plays a drop shot. His physicality and movement makes it very tough for you. "It was one of the biggest matches of my career but for him that was probably just another match. He just played much better than me in the big moments and it all seemed to happen very quickly. I fought to the last point and I'm proud of my championships and I can take lots of confidence from it." Cam Norrie's great @Wimbledon run comes to an end as defending champion Carlos Alcaraz wins their quarter-final on Centre Court #BackTheBrits 🇬🇧 | #Wimbledon — LTA (@the_LTA) July 8, 2025 Alcaraz paid tribute to Norrie's work ethic and expressed confidence in his ability to return to the upper echelons of the sport after his best Grand Slam showing since reaching the semi-finals here in 2022. His own focus now turns to Taylor Fritz, his semi-final opponent, whom he has beaten twice without dropping a set. "This was my best match of the tournament," he said. "I'm feeling great and while every match is different, my confidence is really high. "The more matches I've played, the more I've started to get a good rhythm with my serve. I'm feeling really calm and my thinking is very clear. "I struggled a bit in the first rounds of the championship but it's started to click now and feel really good. "Taylor is having a really successful season and he's playing some great tennis on grass, his aggressive game really suits this surface. "I need to find an even higher level than I did against Cameron, it doesn't get any easier. The key will be not to let him dominate the game. "This is my 23rd match in my winning streak but I don't want to stop, the players have a target on me and I know that." Fritz produced two outstanding sets to take control of his quarter-final against Karen Khachanov before inexplicably losing the third. He regained his composure, however, to complete a 6-3, 6-4, 1-6, 7-6 win. It is further evidence of the American's steely mindset, cultivated in recent years as he has become a consistent presence in the second week of majors. This will be only his second Grand Slam semi-final, after his run to last year's US Open final, where he was well beaten by Jannik Sinner. That experience, though, instilled fresh belief in his ability to navigate the latter stages of major tournaments. His current Wimbledon campaign has underscored that resilience. Fritz came through two five-set matches in the opening rounds — including a first-round tie against Giovanni Mpetshi Perricard that spanned two days — and has improved as the grass at the baseline has thinned. His game has long been suited to grass, and after recent ATP Tour titles in Stuttgart and Eastbourne, he is as confident as ever as he attempts to dethrone the reigning champion. "[The US Open final] has given me a lot of confidence in those moments and situation — just having been there — that I can do it again," he said. "I feel like in other years, when I reached the quarter-finals here, it felt like a really big deal. This time I went into the match much more calm and relaxed. "I've just been really proud of how I've been mentally all week. I was about as close to being out of the tournament in the first round as you can be. "I think grass can be an equaliser. I trust how I'm playing. I truly believe that, playing the way I did in the first two sets today, there is not much any opponent can do." For the latest action on the British summer grass court season, check out the LTA website.
