logo
Third-level fees causing tension between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael

Third-level fees causing tension between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael

Irish Timesa day ago
Good morning.
The Taoiseach is swanking around the land of the rising sun. There's
a heatwave in Europe
. And at home there's a bit of a tension convention
between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over third level fees
.
The Fianna Fáil Minister for Higher Education James Lawless is in Fine Gael's bad books after suggesting that third level fees may rise by as much as €1,000 a year as the cost-of-living supports in recent budgets come to an end.
Lawless has actually been talking about this for months –
we reported on it back at the start of April
– but as the budget maneuvering enters a more active phase, he returned to the subject in recent days. Third level fees of €3,000 a year have been reduced by €1000 by cost of living supports in recent years. Get rid of those supports – as the Government is pledged to do – and fees must go up, Lawless reasons.
READ MORE
But Fine Gael, ever attuned to many hardships faced by middle Ireland, is wondering out loud how you can fulfil the Programme for Government pledge to cut the cost of third level education by, er, increasing the cost of third level education.
The situation was sufficiently grave to
warrant a voice note from Tánaiste Simon Harris
to Fine Gael TDs last night. 'The budget will be agreed by Government with key input from the party leaders. But it does need to help families with the cost of putting a young person through college,' Harris told his party. Expect this to be put to him when he takes leaders questions today.
*
Budget matters are also up for discussion when the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac) visits the Budget Oversight Committee today, where Ifac chairman Seamus Coffey will tell the TDs and senators that
the Government is on course for €2 billion of unbudgeted overspends this year
– and that's just in current spending, not to mind ballooning capital projects.
The finding is among a number of criticisms and warnings that Ifac is likely to make. The Government is currently preparing its summer economic statement, a key budgetary document that will indicate the parameters for spending increases in the October budget.
The council will urge the Government not to continue with the pro-cyclical budgetary policies of recent years, which saw billions of euros in giveaways to voters announced on budget day, as well as longer term spending increases.
'Given the economy is in a strong position, it does not require support from budgetary policy. Standard economics suggests the government should support the economy when it is weak, but show restraint when the economy is strong,' Coffey is expected to tell the committee.
Budgetary restraint, of course, in a time of plenty for the Exchequer, is a hard political sell.
*
The Cabinet meets this morning, sans Taoiseach, and the agenda features a number of housing related memos. As Harry McGee reports, the Government
intends to establish a league table of how local authorities are performing
when it comes to building social housing, which will be useful for blaming someone else.
*
Dublin
has a new Lord Mayor
. He is Ray McAdam, a Fine Gael councillor – the third FGer in a row to hold the position – and chum of the Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe.
Best reads
One of the largest estate agents in Ireland has launched an internal investigation after one of its staff allegedly offered to split the sale of a new build home in Newtownmountkennedy in order for it to qualify for the Help to Buy scheme.
Niamh Towey has the story
, and it's our lead this morning.
A telecoms company with suspected ties to a key arm of the Iranian regime asked Irish diplomats
for help setting up business deals in the Republic with Eir, Vodafone and Three
, Jack Power reports.
Fintan O'Toole finds that
he has more wives than Henry VIII
– thanks to AI.
Playbook
As mentioned above, Taoiseach Micheál Martin is in Japan for an official visit, with the agenda mostly dominated by trade and investment. China Correspondent Denis Staunton is covering the trip
and has a preview here
.
Back at home, the Cabinet meets at Government Buildings this morning under the chairmanship of Simon Harris.
Dáil business starts at 2pm with Leaders' Questions – Harris in the hot seat again – followed by the usual weekly row over the order of business. There's housing questions later, and a private members motion from Sinn Féin on the GPO and Moore St – which the party wants to see developed as a 1916 quarter. How long has this been going on now?
Two Government Bills are due to conclude in the Seanad – the Supports for Survivors of Residential Institutional Abuse Bill and the Finance (Local Property Tax and Other Provisions) bill.
At the committees, there's a few things to watch. The foreign affairs committee
will begin pre-legislative scrutiny of the Occupied Territories Bill
when senior officials from the Department of Foreign Affairs come in.
The Committee on Defence and National Security is also doing pre-legislative scrutiny on the bill to abolish the triple lock, while the Budget Oversight Committee – as mentioned above – have the Fiscal Council in. Senior wallahs from the Department of Arts and Media are in to talk about the Arts Council and the controversy over its abandoned IT project. Full list of committee and details of the Dail and Seanad sittings
are here
.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tanaiste 'not convinced' that pension and dole Budget increases should equal
Tanaiste 'not convinced' that pension and dole Budget increases should equal

Irish Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Tanaiste 'not convinced' that pension and dole Budget increases should equal

Tánaiste Simon Harris has suggested that the rate for those receiving Jobseeker's Benefit should not increase as much as the pension rate in the budget. It comes as Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe warned that choices will have to be made in Budget 2026 as he remained non-committal on the prospect of tax cuts for workers. In the last budget, Fine Gael and then social protection minister Heather Humphreys had sought to increase the Jobseekers' payment and the pension by different amounts. At one point, it was suggested that the dole could rise by €10 a week and the pension could go up by €15. However, there was pushback by the Green Party, who said that they were 'uncomfortable' at the idea of making a distinction. There was a smaller level of resistance from Fianna Fáil. Senior Government sources told the Irish Mirror that it is too early to make any decisions on any budget matter, noting that the Summer Economic Statement has yet to be published to set out the parameters of Budget 2026. Speaking to reporters after a meeting of the Government Trade Form, the Tánaiste opened the door to a distinction being made between pension increases and Jobseeker increases in Budget 2026. Mr Harris told reporters that he did not want to 'open another budget line' at the press conference. He continued: 'Other than to say I do always think there's merit in not looking at social welfare payments with uniformity across the board. 'We've been talking a lot about college fees in the last couple of days, unexpectedly, perhaps. 'But, roughly speaking, the equivalent of €1.20, €1.25 on every social welfare payment is roughly the equivalent of reducing college fees by €1,000. 'Budgets are all about choice and they're all about balance and there's only so much money in the pot. 'So I'd keep an open mind on that. I'm not convinced that you need to see as significant a rise in the dole as you do on the pension, for example, at the time when our country's in full employment and there's lots of supports out there for people getting into work. 'There's other supports out there for people who can't work for very many good reasons. 'That's my view. We'll thrash all this out in the budget. We've quite a way to go.' At the same press conference, Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe warned that the impact of tariffs will have an impact on the growth of the Irish economy. He suggested that while there will still be budget surpluses, the surplus amount will be revised. He also repeated that while new jobs will still be created, they are likely to be created at a lower level because of the potential impact of tariffs. Minister Donohoe also warned that choices will have to be made as part of Budget 2026 and would not commit to changes to tax rates and bands for workers. He stated that the Programme for Government stated that these things will be reviewed in case of an economic shock and that people's take home pay should increase as a result of actual wages going up. He said: 'In relation to Budget 2026 it is a budget that is going to prioritise the creation and the retention of jobs and keeping our public finances safe while investing in our future. 'We will make decisions closer to the time regarding what is the way in which we will do that. 'Clearly, if the government does decide to make investments and decisions in particular areas, we will then decide there are other things that we cannot do. 'That's the right thing to do and we'll make the case for that on Budget Day. 'But this will be a budget that will contain important measures with regard to investment in our country's future and in terms of people's appetite.' The row over college fees and whether or not they will return to €3,000 following Budget 2026 continued to dominate Dáil proceedings on Wednesdays. In response to Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Higher Education Minister James Lawless noted that it is July and the budget will be announced in October.

EU blocks Britain's attempts to join pan-European trading bloc
EU blocks Britain's attempts to join pan-European trading bloc

Irish Times

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Times

EU blocks Britain's attempts to join pan-European trading bloc

British government hopes of joining a pan-European trade area to reduce post-Brexit supply chain challenges for UK goods exporters are being blocked by Brussels, according to officials on both sides. The UK announced it was considering whether to join the Pan-Euro-Mediterranean (PEM) convention as part of its new trade strategy published last week, arguing it could help boost the UK's flagging goods exports. However, the European Commission has made clear to the UK that it would not currently support such a move, according to four people familiar with discussions, in a move the officials acknowledged had 'frustrated' London. The blockage is the first sign of friction between the UK and European Union (EU) since the two sides announced a 'reset' of their relationship at a summit on May 18th, promising to improve energy trading arrangements and sign a so-called veterinary agreement to remove checks on agri-food exports. READ MORE The PEM convention is an agreement between the EU and 20 other countries in Africa and the Middle East that allows inputs for manufacturing supply chains to be sourced across multiple countries in order to qualify for low-tariff access to markets under free trade agreements. Joining PEM is a move supported by UK trade groups, including the British Chambers of Commerce. According to the UK's trade strategy published last week it could reduce 'complex paperwork' and 'increase flexibility for UK exporters where they source their inputs'. [ Brexit was 'single stupidest thing a country's ever done' Opens in new window ] EU officials familiar with the discussion said the commission had decided that the UK joining PEM was not currently in the EU's interests, because it would increase the risk of products unfairly qualifying for low-tariff access to the bloc. UK prime minister Keir Starmer has ruled out rejoining the EU single market or re-entering into a customs union with the EU, but industry has pushed the government to consider joining the PEM convention as an interim step to help goods exporters. Trade experts said the UK would need EU co-operation to join the convention because it would require rewriting the terms of the existing post-Brexit EU-UK trade deal – even though the PEM is not exclusively an EU arrangement. IATA Director General Willie Walsh on airline profits, air fares and why the Dublin Airport passenger cap makes Ireland a laughing stock Listen | 35:56 'For it to be meaningful for the UK, the EU would need to agree to incorporate the PEM rules of origin into the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement. This gives the EU de facto blocking powers,' said Sam Lowe, trade lead at consultancy Flint Global. Brussels indicated previously that it was open to the UK joining PEM, but has since gone cold on the idea, arguing that it wants to stick closely to the agreements proposed in the 'common understanding' set out between the two sides at the May 18th summit. In 2023, PEM was mooted as a solution to a stand-off over post-Brexit tariffs on electric vehicles, while as recently as January this year EU trade commissioner Maroš Šefčovič said it was something the EU 'could consider'. [ Supply risk identified for some UK animal medicines shipped to North Opens in new window ] David Henig, a former UK trade negotiator now at the ECIPE think-tank, said the EU commission's reluctance demonstrated the ongoing political challenge of repairing relations with the bloc. 'The EU isn't united on the importance of the UK reset and issues like PEM can easily be caught up in this even though technically straightforward,' he said. 'The UK government is going to have to work hard in London and Brussels to build momentum.' Separately, in another point of tension, the EU is still demanding full implementation of the Windsor framework deal on Northern Ireland ahead of any veterinary agreement that would remove the need for most checks on goods crossing the Irish Sea. The final phase of the Windsor framework deal came into force on July 1st. M & S boss Stuart Machin last week described the implementation as 'bureaucratic madness', saying it requires 1,000 products to have 'not for EU' labels, and 400 more will have to undergo full customs checks. [ The UK's trade performance remains dire Opens in new window ] Machin added the promised EU-UK veterinary agreement 'can't come soon enough,' but EU officials said the commission was being 'very firm' on the point that the deal must be fully implemented ahead of any EU-UK veterinary agreement. Industry insiders said that European relations minister Nick Thomas-Symonds had called supermarkets to a meeting in Whitehall last Thursday to urge them to comply with the deal or risk jeopardising talks over the veterinary agreement. The EU has repeatedly raised concerns that many big UK supermarkets are not fully complying with the rules. The commission did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The UK government said it was committed to full implementation of the Windsor framework and would review the merits of joining PEM through engagement with the trading group's members, including the EU. 'We aren't going to provide a running commentary on our ongoing discussions with the EU,' the Cabinet Office added. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025 .

Japan expresses concern over security of subsea cables off the Irish coast
Japan expresses concern over security of subsea cables off the Irish coast

Irish Times

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Japan expresses concern over security of subsea cables off the Irish coast

Japan has expressed concern about the security of subsea cables off the Irish coast, seeking reassurance from the Taoiseach that the Government was taking adequate steps to protect them. During a meeting in Tokyo on Wednesday, prime minister Shigeru Ishiba also raised the issue of cybersecurity . 'I explained to him that two years ago we had a national forum on modern-day security challenges, and how we saw our priority as protecting subsea cables, developing stronger resilience there, and also in terms of cybersecurity,' Micheál Martin said after the meeting. 'We both agreed that we would continue that conversation because in the world of cybersecurity, collaboration is essential, as he said himself, and we agree with that. I think our officials will engage further in terms of expertise and knowledge around that cybersecurity space.' Japanese companies have doubled their footprint in Ireland over the past decade with significant investments in technology, life sciences, financial services and engineering. Mr Ishiba referred specifically to the activity of Russian fishing vessels close to the interconnector between Britain and Ireland and to subsea cables used for data transmission. READ MORE 'He said that Ireland was a very important technology centre with significant traffic conducted through those subsea cables,' the Taoiseach said. 'I indicated to him that we have taken quite a number of measures. We have a national cybersecurity centre. We have an individually tailored plan agreed with Nato , for example, in respect of cybersecurity co-operation and in terms of subsea cables. And also we're part of the Pesco projects within the European Union in terms of cybersecurity and again, subsea cables, building up expertise and knowledge.' The Taoiseach opened the meeting by reaffirming Ireland's commitment to nuclear disarmament and the belief that war and conflict should be avoided 'at all costs'. He told Mr Ishiba that his visit to Hiroshima on Friday would reflect this outlook. 'We are two peace-loving nations who believe in avoiding war and conflict at all costs. And I want to remember those who suffered and the survivors, and going there in all solemnity to reflect our commitment to nuclear disarmament and nuclear non-proliferation,' Mr Martin said. The Taoiseach was welcomed to the Kantei, the prime minister's glass-walled headquarters, by a colour guard from the 302nd military police company of the Japan ground self-defence force. Wearing white dress uniforms, a military band played Amhrán na bhFiann and the Japanese national anthem while the colour guard presented arms with bayonets fixed. Mr Ishiba served the Taoiseach green tea during the meeting, remarking that he had heard about Mr Martin's fondness for it. After the formal meeting they had lunch including Wagyu beef with colcannon, served with Guinness, while the music of Enya played in the background. Mr Ishiba is under intense political pressure in advance of elections to Japan's upper house on July 20th, with polls suggesting that support for his Liberal Democratic Party has fallen by 20 points since the last such election in 2022. Donald Trump this week threatened to impose a tariff of up to 35 per cent on Japanese goods if Tokyo does not agree to import cars and rice from the United States. Later on Wednesday, with Japan's Princess Takamado among those present, the Taoiseach opened Ireland House in Tokyo, a landmark building housing the Irish Embassy and State agencies the IDA, Enterprise Ireland and Bord Bia. At a cost of more than €20 million, it is the biggest single capital project the State has ever undertaken. 'The relationship between Ireland and Japan is a very special one. Ireland House Tokyo stands as a testament to that relationship and a symbol of the economic, cultural, and social values that we share,' the Taoiseach said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store