Government's social housing model not delivering for Wellington residents, Rongotai MP says
Photo:
RNZ / Rachel Helyer-Donaldson
The government is set on shaking up the way social housing is provided in Aotearoa, but the time it is taking to make these changes is leaving dozens of people in dire need of a healthy home, says a Wellington MP.
Thursday marks a year since the Housing Minister announced $140 million of investment into 1500 social homes, and it will be another 18 months until they are all completed.
In January, Charlotte Smith and the five tāmariki under her care were evacuated from their mould-ridden and structurally unsafe home next to Wellington Zoo, and transferred to a four-bedroom apartment.
It was the second home in 16 years living in social housing that she had been evacuated from. Each time her young, healthy baby - first her eldest child and then her youngest - has developed respiratory conditions with countless trips to the hospital emergency department as a result of mould and damp, she said. Two-year-old Wolf was onto his fourth portacot, she said.
"The first one was a metre off the ground, and I found mould underneath, on his mattress. It was happening again, and that's why it was so triggering."
The new apartment did not have mould, but it cost an extra $165 per week, which Smith could not afford. A tenant of a community provider, Smith now hoped to get into a Kāinga Ora house.
She was one of 30 constituents in the Rongotai electorate, which covers Wellington's southern and eastern suburbs, who had asked local MP Julie Anne Genter, of the Greens, for help with their housing situation in the past year.
They included individuals and families, both in emergency housing and on the transfer list, waiting to be put into housing or one that is more suitable.
Rongotai MP Julie Anne Genter.
Photo:
RNZ / Angus Dreaver
Genter said one elderly couple was living in a house that was inaccessible and mould-ridden. It was affecting their health, she added, yet they had been been on the transfer waitlist for nine months with no updates.
Thirty inquiries "may not sound like a lot", said Genter. "But in the context of a community where you have a severe need for healthy housing, this is very material, and it makes a huge difference to people's lives when they can get adequate housing."
Strathmore resident Daisy Taua said she had lost three lounge suites and three mattresses to black mould in the five years she's lived in her Kāinga Ora flat. Bathroom ventilation, installed by the housing agency, had helped, said Taua, who suffered from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, making her particularly susceptible to mould and cold. But she slept on the couch because the downstairs bedroom was "like an icebox in winter".
Kainga Ora regional director for Greater Wellington Vicki McLaren said "extensive work to remediate a mould issue" had been done in Daisy Taua's bathroom in 2023 and she had not raised any concerns to the agency about mould at the property since then. "If there are ongoing issues with mould or cold in the home, we strongly encourage Ms Taua to contact us so we can address them."
McLaren said Kainga Ora was aware of Taua's health conditions and continued work to find another home for her to relocate to "however there are no suitable available properties to offer her at this time".
Healthy, safe and affordable housing in Wellington was extremely difficult to get into, said Genter. "Yet it's really, desperately, needed because we have so many people who are living in inadequate social housing. Whether you're on the streets looking to be placed into a home or if you're on the transfer waitlist it is so challenging and hard our constituents."
At the heart of the problem, said Genter, was the government's policy of putting housing developments on hold or under review.
In the Rongotai electorate alone, six Kainga Ora developments - the equivalent of 215 homes - had been put on hold since December 2023.
Genter said the government had "turned off the pipeline for new healthy state houses".
It was not a numbers game, she said. "Each one of those is a person or a family whose everyday quality of life will be affected by having access to healthy housing, or not."
McLaren said those developments remained under assessment, with decisions on individual projects, including those in Rongotai, to be made over the coming months, "although some sites will potentially need to wait for decisions beyond 2025-2026".
"It's important to understand that we continue to deliver new homes while we are assessing some projects to ensure value for money, and that we are delivering in areas most needed ... This includes 44 homes delivered in Wellington city [this financial year]."
Housing Minister Chris Bishop (L) and Associate Minister for Housing Tama Potaka.
Photo:
Louis Collins
Last month the Minister and Associate Minister for Housing, Chris Bishop and Tama Potaka, surprised many when they announced the bulk of funding to build a thousand social homes, would go to five of the country's 80-plus community housing providers (CHPs).
Of the 500 homes already underway, just 17 were for Wellington, in the Lower Hutt suburb of Wainuiomata.
Dwell Housing Trust chief executive Elizabeth Lester, whose organisation missed out on the funding, said the ministry had told her that Pōneke "was not a priority right now".
For local housing providers that felt like a "kick in the teeth", she added. One of Dwell's projects was Gordon Place, for 26 social homes in the suburb of Newtown, where homelessness was a visible and increasing issue.
"Local housing providers are the best placed organisations to address those specific community needs and yet it looks like nothing going to be happening in our local community here in Wellington [city]."
Housing Minister Chris Bishop said the government was committed to addressing New Zealand's housing crisis and was taking action, including in Wellington.
"We are focusing on the fundamentals of housing supply, which is land supply and infrastructure funding and financing."
In the current financial year Kāinga Ora had already delivered 191 social homes in the Wellington region and had another 58 under construction, he added. "As well as all of this, the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development is working with strategic partner Te Āhuru Mōwai to finalise their delivery schedule for social homes in the Wellington region, and we'll have more to say about this in due course."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
Risks identified with Gumboot Friday's 'fee-for-service' model
Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey says the programme is meeting expectations. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Gumboot Friday's youth counselling initiative has had its $6m annual contract renewed , despite health officials identifying ongoing risks that practitioners could bill for services of poor quality or not delivered. Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey said the programme was meeting expectations, with more than 10,000 young people receiving free counselling in its first year, and the government was "backing Gumboot Friday to deliver more". A partially-redacted briefing to the Minister dated 30 May, released by the Health Ministry on Wednesday - along with [ other documents - noted "ongoing risk through this arrangement that practitioners invoice I Am Hope for services and do not deliver them". Some sections of the document were blanked out, citing the need to preserve "confidentiality of advice tendered by Ministers and officials". The briefing - which recommended the contract be renewed with some changes - noted the risk of non-delivery was no different to other "fee for service" arrangements. It said the charity had "significantly improved and streamlined some of its processes since the contract was developed". These included spot checking, auditing, client surveys and an electronic system to pick up "any unusual invoicing". "To date, I Am Hope [the parent charity of Gumboot Friday] has identified two practitioners that have departed from the agreed procedures and has removed them from the platform." In total there were more than 700 qualified counsellors registered on the platform. In the same section, entitled "Delivery Risks", Health Ministry officials wrote there was also a risk that Gumboot Friday's practitioners could "act unprofessionally" or fail to deliver quality service. A Ministry of Health weekly report said I Am Hope had "enhanced" its vetting process to include mandatory police checks for all practitioners registered before October 2024, and updated its Practitioner (Policies) Handbook in March. The charity now used CV Checker to speed up its verification process, but had limited ability to "scrutinise practice" since client and practitioner sessions had to remain private and confidential. All practitioners were members of professional associations, and the Ministry had not been advised of any complaints to date. Gumboot Friday and I Am Hope were working on evaluations of service delivery and the experiences of young people, while the Ministry was preparing an evaluation framework. In a preface to the documents, the Health Ministry said demographic information from I Am Hope's platform may have produced "potential double counting" of clients, as individuals reappeared across months. "It nevertheless provides additional information about the groups that are engaged in Gumboot Friday." The 30 May briefing said the Gumboot Friday service was "operationally different" to the original design. It recommended some changes to the contract, including increasing the number of sessions and clients, and removing some performance measures "which divert resources and create barriers to maximum performance". The officials advocated for scrapping the monthly limit of $500,000 (to allow for higher demand in some months) and current measures of reporting on wait times, which were not being consistently recorded as some young people contacted counsellors directly rather than going through the website. The original contract required Gumboot Friday to ensure most people could receive services "within 24 to 48 hours of seeking support with 3 to 5 days as a maximum wait time for the first meeting with the person" and provide monthly reporting of wait times. The latest report showed the average wait time for young people across January and February this year was 9.04 days, with 186 young people waiting more than five days. That was up from 5.78 days in November and December. "This increase was in part due to the holiday period in January 2025, however, the longer wait times persisted into February. I Am Hope has highlighted to practitioners the importance of responding promptly to service requests." The briefing also suggested the government could consider funding emergency and crisis referrals, and providing more cash to support evaluation and "verification activities".
RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
Vape rule requiring removeable batteries being lifted
Associate Health Minister Casey Costello said the decision would resolve a current court challenge. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The coalition is revoking the requirement for all vaping devices - including heated tobacco products - to have removable batteries. In a statement published on Thursday, Associate Health Minister Casey Costello said the decision - to take effect from 1 September - would resolve a current court challenge by Mason Corporation, which owns the vape shop Shosha. "Cabinet was advised that taking this step was the best way to resolve the case," Costello said. "This decision means the proceedings, which relate to regulations brought in by the Labour government, can be withdrawn." Costello said the move was not expected to increase smoking or vaping rates. The announcement does not affect the coalition's move to ban disposable or single-use vaping devices. That ban kicked in from 17 June. The former Labour government announced the requirement for removable batteries in June 2023 as part of a suite of changes to vaping rules. At the time, then-Health Minister Ayesha Verrall said the move would make the devices safer. The coalition later delayed the regulations from coming into effect until October 2024 "to ensure sufficient availability of appropriate reusable vaping products to continue to support people to quit smoking". Photo: 123RF RNZ last year revealed that Philip Morris had pulled its IQOS [ heated tobacco product (HTPs) from the shelves] due to the regulations around removable batteries. That proved to be a major roadblock to the government's controversial trial of halving excise tax on HTPs to encourage their use as a smoking cessation tool. Philip Morris has since released a new compliant IQOS product with a removeable battery. Documents showed Costello had tried to delay the battery regulations for two years, but Cabinet agreed only to a six-month delay from the original date of 21 March. The minister's support for HTPs as a less harmful alternative to smoking provoked outrage from the opposition parties and health experts who labelled it a "dangerous and radical experiment". Treasury identified a long list of concerns about the proposal at the time, but Costello said she relied on "independent advice" to the contrary .
RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
Controversial charity Gumboot Friday gets another year's government funding
Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Controversial charity Gumboot Friday will continue to receive government funding through to 2026. Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey said the initiative was helping thousands of young people access mental health support faster. He said New Zealand was "turning the corner with reducing wait times and increasing the workforce". "There are not many organisations that can get our young people off waitlists into counselling often within just a few days," he said. "The government is backing Gumboot Friday to deliver more. Funding for 2025/26 will deliver 40,000 individual counselling sessions, reaching as many as 15,000 young New Zealanders. "Over the next 12 months, the organisation will be looking at how it can scale up and encourage even more young people to access free counselling." The government last year committed $24 million over four years to the Gumboot Friday initiative , which was founded by mental health advocate Mike King. That was despite pressure from Labour at the time, who called on the government to pause its funding of I Am Hope/Gumboot Friday following King's controversial comments on alcohol . "Alcohol is not a problem for people with mental health issues. It's actually the solution to our problem, until you come up with a better solution," King said at the time. The Drug Foundation rejected that, saying alcohol was "really unhelpful during times of mental distress". In November last year Doocey responded, saying while he disagreed King was entitled to have his own opinion on alcohol's association with mental health, and he would not be asking the advocate to rein in his comments. Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone On Thursday, Doocey said in the first 12 months of government funding, Gumboot Friday had been able to deliver more than 30,000 free counselling sessions. "They have supported more than 10,000 young New Zealanders who might not otherwise have access to timely support. The counselling service's procurement process had run into difficulties before. Last October, the auditor-general criticised the government's "unusual and inconsistent" process in giving $24 million to King's initiative. The government had announced the I Am Hope foundation would receive $6m a year for four years to provide counselling services to five- to 25-year-olds, as part of the coalition agreement. But RNZ revealed health officials had struggled to find a way to make the contract compliant with public procurement rules, and ended up invoking a special 'opt-out' clause. Auditor-General John Ryan wrote to the director-general of health then, saying the process was "unusual and inconsistent". Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
