Lions still have glaring weakness... and Joe is watching
While Finlay Calder was leading the senior side to a series victory, 'Donal's Doughnuts' were also enshrined in Lions folklore for the tremendous spirit they generated under Lenihan's leadership, while notching up the wins to support the main effort.
You wonder what Lenihan's fellow Munster second row Tadhg Beirne was thinking when his name was read out as captain of the Lions team to take on the Waratahs tomorrow. Tadhg Beirne will captain the Lions against the Waratahs. Pic:With games now coming thick and fast, every player wants to be throwing some Test side shapes and the best way to do that is to be selected alongside Maro Itoje, the tour captain and only guaranteed Test starter.
The fact Beirne is now set to start his third game of the tour means he is extremely unlikely to feature with Itoje against the Brumbies on Wednesday — the game long designated as the one most likely to mirror head coach Andy Farrell's Test selection.
Joe McCarthy could get the nod for that one based on his barnstorming display against the Force, while Ollie Chessum (rested against the Waratahs) is another right in the mix. Joe McCarthy in action for the Lions against Western Force. Pic:James Ryan gets the start he has craved but is playing catch-up and would need the performance of his life to leapfrog McCarthy and Chessum at this stage.
Furthermore, the fact Beirne is selected in the second row for tomorrow suggests the experiment to relocate him to the back row has been shelved, while the identity of who will fill the No6 jersey for the Tests continues to be the biggest selection head scratcher on tour.
Tom Curry has started there twice but, as we said before a ball was kicked in anger, he is clearly better suited to the openside slot where his relative lack of height is less of an issue. James Ryan gets the start he has craved but is playing catch-up. Pic: Steve Christo/Sportsfile
Yet, the Lions continue to persevere with the undersized back-row approach with Henry Pollock playing No6 against the Reds alongside Josh van Flier at openside and Ben Earl at No8.
This immediately puts pressure on the Lions line-out, specifically the two main jumpers Beirne and Ryan and thrower Luke Cowan-Dickie.
For this to be an ongoing problem this far into the tour reflects the initial flawed selection policy — this Lions squad is screaming out for a Courtney Lawes or Ryan Baird type blindside flanker and the closer we get to the Tests, the more Australia head coach Joe Schmidt will be smelling weakness. Australia head coach Joe Schmidt. Pic: INPHO/Laszlo Geczo
Farrell still hasn't tried Chessum in the blindside role and the big Leicester man could well be the solution but the clock is ticking for experimentation.
If he tries Chessum there against the Brumbies on Wednesday and it doesn't work, Farrell has lost the chance to cement a possible Test second row partnership with Itoje.
The coaching ticket would strenuously reject the notion that this team to face the Reds represent the dirt-trackers of this expedition and there are certainly players starting with genuine designs on the Test side.
Hugo Keenan and Blair Kinghorn are getting their first auditions as live Test candidates, Van der Flier has a strong Test claim and the Scotland centres Huw Jones and Sione Tuipulotu are both still well in the mix. Hugo Keenan will get his first audition as a live Test candidates. Pic: INPHO/Billy Stickland
But it is fair to say the half-back pairing of Fin Smith and Alex Mitchell is the designated back-up to Finn Russell and Jamison Gibson-Park, as is the front-row combination of Pierre Schoeman, Luke Cowan-Dickie and Finlay Bealham behind Ellis Genge/Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan and Tadhg Furlong.
So, amid all the furore over Farrell calling up his son, there is a lot still up in the air when it comes to Lions Test selection — not least the situation at No6.
And Joe is watching…
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
Hurls out as the Lions prepare for stellar 'Tahs test
The British and Irish Lions' tour down under rumbles on this Saturday as they go down to Sydney to face the New South Wales Waratahs. Andy Farrell has yet again made numerous changes to his starting team, though there's no spot for his son Owen after he was called into the squad to replace the injured Elliot Daly. Tadhg Beirne is named as captain of the side in place of Maro Itoje to become the second Irish captain of this tour after Dan Sheehan's spell as skipper against the Western Force. Tadhg Beirne during a British & Irish Lions captain's run at North Sydney Oval in Sydney Pic:Steve Christo/Sportsfile Beirne also becomes the seventh Munster man to captain the Lions after Tom Kiernan, Ronan O'Gara, Paul O'Connell, Donncha O'Callaghan, Peter O'Mahony and Conor Murray. There was definitely a Munster feel to the captains' run as Jack Conan popped up with a hurl and was caught hitting a few shots with Englishman Ben Earl. Jack Conan plays hurling after a British & Irish Lions captain's run Pic: Steve Christo/Sportsfile Wicklow man Jack Conan has spoken a few times about his love for GAA recently. In the run up to Leinster's URC final against the Bulls Conan spoke about his memories of Wicklow winning the Tommy Murphy Cup at Croke Park back in 2007. He would subsequently be the man that lifted the URC trophy at GAA HQ after Leinster were resounding winners against their South African rivals. Conan showed Ben Earls, who's starting in place of him this Saturday, a few tricks and got the England and Saracens star to hit a few sliotars across the pitch during the captain's run. Ben Earl during a British & Irish Lions captain's run Pic:Steve Christo/Sportsfile Earl will be joined by Josh van der Flier and Henry Pollock in the back row as Andy Farrell has named another six Irish players in this Saturday's starting team. Van der Flier will be joined by Finlay Bealham, Beirne, James Ryan, Mack Hansen and Hugo Keenan who is looking to finally make his Lions debut after he was a late withdrawal from Wednesday's game against the Reds due to illness. Keenan along with Scots Ben White and Blair Kinghorn are all set to make their Lions debut. Both Scots joined the camp late, White as a replacement for the injured Tomos Williams and Kinghorn made his way down under after playing a starring role as Toulouse won the Top 14 final after an extra-time win over Bordeaux-Begles. Dan Sheehan along with Tadhg Furlong are on the bench as Andy Farrell goes for a 6/2 split with White and Marcus Smith covering the backline on the bench. The Waratahs will offer a stern challenge to the Lions in the form of their star man, the 'Tongan Thor' Taniela Tupou. Tupou is one of the strongest players on the planet and when fit, is impossible to stop. He is joined by Wallaby winger Andrew Kellaway who has been released from the Wallabies squad to play in this match. A former Northampton Saint, Kellaway is a stellar winger who offers huge amount of pace. You can catch the game live on Sky Sports Main Event and Sky Sports Action at 11am on Saturday.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Lions roll on to Sydney where a Waratahs upset seems unlikely
New South Wales Waratahs v British and Irish Lions, Allianz Stadium, Sydney; Saturday, 11am Irish time – Live on Sky Sports The phoney war continues apace. The Lions Tour rumbles on in the established manner; the squad barely setting foot in another new city and another plush new hotel before turning its attention to another match. In time-honoured fashion, too, the Lions pitch up in Sydney to face the New South Wales Waratahs a fortnight out from the first Test against the Wallabies , which in previous Aussie odysseys has been the tourists' toughest examination in many ways. Back in 2001, the tone was set by Waratahs lock Tom Bowen catching Danny Grewcock in the face with a leading forearm literally from the kick-off, leading to his sinbinning after three seconds. Most famously, of course, Ronan O'Gara was pinned to the ground and punched 11 times in the face by Duncan McRae, who became the first player ever to be sent off against the Lions, before a further two players from each side were yellow-carded for a brawl to make it a 13 v 12 game for 10 minutes. Twelve years ago, when Michael Cheika was in charge of the Waratahs, Johnny Sexton and the Lions were rightly agitated by some fairly clear-cut attempts to rough up the Irish outhalf by a Waratahs team then coached by Michael Cheika. READ MORE The quality of the Lions' 41-24 and 47-17 wins were slightly overlooked en route to winning the first Test on both tours, with Cheika's side going on to win their sole Super Rugby title in 2014. Alas, those halcyon days have faded somewhat, and the Waratahs finished eighth of 11 in this year's Super Rugby Pacific campaign, thus missing out on the playoffs, three points above Western Force (who the Lions beat 54-7 a week ago), and a dozen points adrift of the Queensland Reds (who the Lions beat 52-12 last Wednesday). England's Ben Earl takes part in a game of hurling during the warm down after the Lions' captain's run at North Sydney Oval on Friday. Photograph:Following on from the pre-tour loss to Argentina in Dublin, both of those restorative wins adhered to a similar script; fired-up hosts hitting the Lions with all they have for what is a once-in-a-career encounter before ultimately the tourists' greater depth, reinforced by their bench, enabled them to ease clear. Given the Waratahs' unexceptional Super Rugby Pacific season, something similar is expected to unfold in this 21st meeting between New South Wales' finest and the Lions, who have won the last four clashes dating back to a 6-6 draw in 1966. Allowing for the quality of the opposition, much of the focus therefore will home in on individual performances and various combinations, although, as is usually the case, the quality of the collective will help to portray them in a better light. Opportunity finally knocks for Hugo Keenan, who had been due to start against the Reds before falling ill on the morning of the game, and Blair Kinghorn, who featured Toulouse in their epic Top 14 final win last Saturday. They are the last of the original 38-man squad to play on this tour, with Ben White set to become the 40th player to feature for this year's Lions vintage off the bench, pending the arrival of Owen Farrell as the 41st. After Marcus Smith lined out at fullback against Argentina, and the unfortunate departure of Elliot Daly who started the last two games, the 15 jersey looks up for grabs between Keenan and Kinghorn. Their belated Lions debuts will thus be huge occasions for them but also pressurised auditions. Of course that applies across the board to some extent, not least to Tadhg Beirne, who will captain the Lions against the Waratahs, as well as James Ryan, Finlay Bealham, Josh van der Flier and Mack Hansen. The Waratahs won six of their 14 games in Super Rugby Pacific, although five of those were achieved at home. Their only defeats came against eventual champions the Crusaders and the Reds. Australia's Taniela Tupou in action against Georgia at the 2023 World Cup. Photograph: Dave Winter/Inpho Joe Schmidt has released the Wallabies' gargantuan prop Taniela Tupou and winger Andrew Kellaway, both of whom played in Ireland's hard-earned 22-19 win over Australia last November. But five Waratahs players will instead play in Australia's sole warm-up match against Fiji on Sunday (4.30am Irish) – prop Angus Bell, flanker Langi Gleeson, hooker Dave Porecki, winger Max Jorgensen and star centre Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii in his home Test debut. Wallabies scrumhalf Jake Gordon is also nursing a minor injury. Tupou and Kellaway are among seven Australian internationals included in the Waratahs' matchday 23, the others being Lalakai Foketi, Darby Lancaster, Rob Leota, Matt Philip and Tane Edmed. Veteran backrower Hugh Sinclair will captain the side from number eight in the last game of his pro career. Beirne follows his fellow Lansdowne player Dan Sheehan in leading the Lions. What's more, the Waratahs will also be captained by a former Lansdowne man, Sinclair having played for the club in the 2013/14 season to work out whether he would try play professionally when he returned to Australia. For sure then, this once-in-a-career opportunity could again see the Lions have to weather an early storm. 'A bit more continuity, a bit more putting things together,' said Andy Farrell in highlighting what he wanted from his team. 'There's a bit of a stop-start nature with our outcomes which is process-driven, 100 per cent. Just lacking a bit of staying in the moment as much as we possibly can. 'But having said that, I think it's getting better. There's always things to fix in every single game, but we've been pleased with some of our progression – our breakdown work was great the other night, our transition work, whether it be defence to attack, attack to defence, was pretty good as well. 'We want to keep improving our defence because that's the main thing you'd want to stand for. I know defence has been pretty good, but there's still room for improvement.' WARATAHS: Lawson Creighton; Andrew Kellaway, Lalakai Foketi, Joey Walton, Darby Lancaster; Jack Bowen, Teddy Wilson; Tom Lambert, Ethan Dobbins, Taniela Tupou; Fergus Lee-Warner, Miles Amatosero; Rob Leota, Charlie Gamble, Hugh Sinclair (capt). Replacements: Mahe Vailanu, Jack Barrett, Daniel Botha, Matt Philip, Jamie Adamson, Jack Grant, Tane Edmed, Henry O'Donnell. LIONS: Hugo Keenan (Ireland); Mack Hansen (Ireland), Huw Jones (Scotland), Sione Tuipulotu (Scotland), Blair Kinghorn (Scotland); Fin Smith (England), Alex Mitchell (England); Pierre Schoeman (Scotland), Luke Cowan-Dickie (England), Finlay Bealham (Ireland); Tadhg Beirne (Ireland, capt), James Ryan (Ireland); Henry Pollock (England), Josh van der Flier (Ireland), Ben Earl (England). Replacements: Dan Sheehan (Ireland), Ellis Genge (England), Tadhg Furlong (Ireland), Joe McCarthy (Ireland), Scott Cummings (Scotland), Jac Morgan (Wales), Ben White (Scotland), Marcus Smith (England). Referee: Paul Williams (New Zealand). Forecast: Lions to eventually ease well clear again.
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Craig Casey: Georgia clash a 'huge opportunity' for experimental Ireland
Craig Casey has challenged his side to lay down a marker as he prepares to captain Ireland for the first time in Saturday's Test against Georgia in Tbilisi. Munster scrum-half Casey will lead out an Irish squad showing six uncapped players in the matchday 23 at the Mikheil Meskhi Stadium. With head coach Andy Farrell and some of his assistants away on the British and Irish Lions tour in Australia, Ireland forwards coach Paul O'Connell has taken temporary charge for the two Tests, which also sees a trip to face Portugal in Lisbon next week. Connacht's Darragh Murray and Leinster wing Tommy O'Brien have been handed their first caps in the starting XV against Georgia, while forwards Michael Milne, Jack Aungier, Tom Ahern and scrum-half Ben Murphy are among the replacements hoping to make their debut. With some 16 players on Lions duty – prop Finlay Bealham having been drafted in as a replacement for injured Scotsman Zander Fagerson – the July summer series fixtures were always going to be about having one eye on the future. Casey takes over the Irish captaincy from Caelan Doris, who was a contender to skipper the Lions until being ruled out of the tour by a shoulder injury. "Georgia will bring their game and I imagine their fans are going to make it a special occasion for them, so they will be delighted to have Ireland over and try to knock us off" Despite all of the changes and the sense of occasion for Ireland's newcomers, Casey, 26, maintains the players must be fully focused on the job in hand. "I don't think we have changed anything for them (the debutants)," Casey told a press conference. "It is a special week for them and their families and it is unbelievable for them to make their first caps. "It is a huge opportunity for all of us, but it is a massive privilege for us to put on the Irish jersey at any stage. "It is huge week for them – and it is up to the rest of us to lay down a marker and make it a special one for them." Ireland had been using a heat chamber to help prepare the squad for the expected humidity in Tbilisi, but heavy rain has followed their arrival in Georgia. Whatever the conditions come kick-off on Saturday, Casey insists Ireland must be set to stand up to a stern challenge. "We are expecting them to be probably up the walls with physicality," Casey said. "They have got some really big threats. Their number 15 (Davit) Niniashvili is a high-class player. He has shown it in the Top 14 and he has shown it in Europe. "They have got a back row that are going to contest probably every breakdown. If we are on our breakdown, we will have a good day, but we will have to do a lot of work there. "Georgia will bring their game and I imagine their fans are going to make it a special occasion for them, so they will be delighted to have Ireland over and try to knock us off."
