Latest news with #DeniseJansevanRensburg
The Citizen
10-07-2025
- Business
- The Citizen
Ekurhuleni metro and Nersa lock horns over electricity tariff discrepancy
'Resulted in thousands of residents being overcharged for electricity on 1 July.' Resellers don't know which of two sets of tariffs to apply – and if they fall into arrears entire residential complexes could have their power disconnected. Image: Supplied A discrepancy between the electricity tariffs approved by the Ekurhuleni metro council on 29 May 2025 and those approved by energy regulator Nersa thereafter has left residents angry and confused. Electricity resellers, who must base the tariffs they charge end-users on the municipal tariffs, are at a loss. 'You don't know what to implement, because who do you believe – the metro or Nersa?' asks Johan Hopley, chair of the Electricity Resellers Association of South Africa (Erasa). Electricity resellers play a critical role – especially in sectional title complexes where the municipality supplies electricity only to one bulk meter. The developer provides the internal distribution network, and a reseller thereafter manages the metering and billing of each unit. They buy electricity from the municipality at a bulk tariff and resell it to the user in each unit at a margin. ALSO READ: Nersa approves 12.7% electricity tariff hike for Eskom Resellers must be familiar with tariffs Resellers are, however, by law prohibited from charging each end user more for electricity than it would cost them had they bought directly from the municipality. It is therefore critical that resellers know exactly what the municipal tariffs are. The council implemented the following tariffs for residential customers on 1 July: 0-50kWh – R2.82 50-600kWh – R2.82 600-700kWh – R4.41 More than 700kWh – R11.44 Basic charge (Tariff A2): R142.50 This corresponds with the tariffs published in Schedule 2 on its own website and approved by Nersa. Source: Nersa website It does not, however, correspond with what was approved by the council: 0-50kWh – R2.59 50-600kWh – R2.59 600-700kWh – R4.03 More than 700kWh – R10.43 Basic charge (Tariff A2): R109.78 These discrepancies are not limited to this customer category. Apparently relying on the council approved tariffs, the metro 'admitted' its 'mistake', which was 'due to a technical error' and gave an undertaking that those residents who bought prepaid electricity on 1 July will be credited accordingly. The tariffs were adjusted the next day. ALSO READ: Nersa slashes Eskom's tariff hike – but consumers could pay the price in taxes In reaction, the Freedom Front Plus (FF+) says the error 'resulted in thousands of residents being overcharged for electricity on 1 July'. 'The most contentious issue is the incorrect basic charge of R142.50, which was deducted upfront for electricity purchases, meaning residents received fewer units than they were entitled to,' says FF+ councillor Denise Janse van Rensburg, Deon Conradie, pricing expert and former senior manager for tariffs at Eskom, says municipalities are, in terms of the Electricity Regulation Act (ERA), only allowed to charge tariffs that have been approved by Nersa. Such tariffs are supposed to be based on the cost of supply plus a reasonable margin. Should the municipality charge lower rates, as will be the case in Ekurhuleni after the 'correction', it may indicate some form of subsidisation. Conradie says any deviation from the tariffs Nersa approved must also be approved by the regulator. Subsidies must be transparent and strongly motivated. ALSO READ: Eskom proposes further tariff restructuring to ensure 'transparency and fairness' Corrections will fall foul of ERA It therefore stands to reason that the 'corrections' the metro has promised will fall foul of the ERA. On the other hand, tariffs must also be approved by the council in terms of municipal legislation. That assumes that there is only one set of tariffs, both approved by the council and Nersa, which is seemingly not the case in Ekurhuleni. Hopley says this is extremely problematic for resellers, who had very limited time from the date Nersa approved the metro's tariffs to the implementation date on 1 July to calculate the tariffs they must charge end users to remain viable. Initially he battled to get the approved tariffs from Nersa. They were only published on the regulator's website on 7 July. Now there are two different sets of tariffs and resellers are not certain which one to base their tariffs on. ALSO READ: At least electricity tariff increase is not 36%, but still 3 times inflation rate Hopley says Ekurhuleni changed the structure of its bulk resellers' tariff, which has resulted in a complete mismatch between wholesale and retail tariffs. In the new structure resellers, who before were only charged a basic fee plus the cost per unit consumed, must now pay a demand charge, network charge, basic charge – and the unit cost is based on time-of-use. In practice, the bulk electricity cost of a residential building with 145 units that each use 400kWh per month on average has increased by 20.84%, while the municipal retail tariffs that resellers are not allowed to exceed have increased by 11.32%, calculated over a year. Hopley says there is no way resellers can make ends meet as their margins have been less than 10%. If resellers fall in arrears, it may result in the disconnection of entire residential complexes. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
The Citizen
09-05-2025
- Politics
- The Citizen
MILLIONS in power assets lie idle amid continuing energy crisis
While residents of Ekurhuleni endure near-daily power outages, more than R500 million worth of critical electricity infrastructure has been sitting unused in municipal warehouses for nearly a decade. An inventory report from the Department of Energy revealed that prepaid electricity meters, transformers, breakers, switches, and high-voltage cables, valued at approximately R512 million, have gathered dust since 2015. This equipment could be deployed immediately to address urgent repairs and upgrades across the Metro. Also read: Kempton Park resident in trouble after tenant tampers with electricity meter Despite these findings, the Department continues to cite equipment and labour shortages as the reason for delayed repairs, an explanation that is now under intense scrutiny. Freedom Front Plus (VF Plus) councillor Denise Janse van Rensburg has raised the alarm, saying the situation reflects severe mismanagement within the Metro's energy services. 'Residents are suffering while life-saving infrastructure rots in warehouses,' said Janse van Rensburg. 'The excuses have run dry. There needs to be full transparency and urgent intervention.' The VF Plus has repeatedly challenged the Mayoral Committee Member for Energy, Mzayifani Ngwenya, over the backlog in service delivery and the apparent contradiction in the Department's justifications. Also read: Terenure resident faces electricity woes Ngwenya has maintained that the inventory is being managed according to service delivery needs and denied any overspending in its procurement. However, concerns are mounting that much of the unused equipment may already be obsolete or damaged, representing a looming financial loss for the City. In response, the VF Plus has called for a full, independent investigation into the management of power inventory since 2015 and a comprehensive audit of all electricity-related equipment procured and stored. The party has also requested a detailed action plan to ensure proper supply, circulation, and installation. Also read: Water and electricity supply in Kempton Park gets worse 'The Department of Energy underpins the economic and social well-being of Ekurhuleni,' Janse van Rensburg added. 'This level of mismanagement is unacceptable. The community deserves transparency and decisive action.' The Kempton Express requested comment from the City of Ekurhuleni by close of business on May 8. At the time of publication on May 9, no comment had been received from the City of Ekurhuleni. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
