3 days ago
Over 100 Journalists Sign Letter Accusing BBC of Acting as ‘PR for Israel'
Rabat – Over 100 BBC journalists have formally expressed deep concern about the Corporation's coverage of the Israeli genocidal war on Gaza. The 111 journalists signed anonymously out of fear of consequences to their job.
In a letter dated July 2, addressed to Director-General Tim Davie, they accuse the BBC of acting as 'PR for the Israeli government,' and suppressing critical reporting, including the decision not to publicly broadcast the BBC 'Gaza: Medics Under Fire.'
The signatories say that this and other editorial choices were 'agenda‑driven' and 'crippled by fear of being perceived as critical of the Israeli government.'
The letter, which was endorsed by hundreds more journalists from other outlets and celebrities such as Juliet Stevenson, Zawe Ashton, and Miriam Margolyes, says it does not necessarily demand a pro‑Palestinian stance. Instead, it simply urges impartial, transparent news reporting, citing significant omissions like BBC's failure to investigate UK arms sales to Israel. Conflicts of interest
At the heart of the criticism is Sir Robbie Gibb, BBC board member and chair of the Editorial Standards Committee, whose ties to the Jewish Chronicle and long-standing Conservative Party affiliations raise significant concerns of partiality.
The letter calls his role 'untenable,' arguing that his ideological influence has led to 'double standards' in how internal newsroom objections and external editorial choices are handled.
The BBC has recently pulled two films on Gaza.
'Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone,' narrated by 14‑year‑old Abdullah Al‑Yazouri ( reportedly son of a Hamas official), sparked accusations of insufficient disclosure and prompted a tribunal from the UK government.
'Gaza: Doctors Under Attack' was also withdrawn over 'impartiality concerns', which critics argue was due to political pressure rather than editorial flaw.
Media commentators argue these decisions reflect a broader reluctance to shed light on Palestinian suffering, and an double-standard sensitivity to accusations of bias when covering Israel. Accusations of anti‑Palestinian racism
The internal letter asserts that the BBC's coverage is defined by 'anti‑Palestinian racism,' citing disproportionate use of emotional language and humanizing imagery for Israeli victims versus minimal empathy or acknowledgement for Palestinians. Signatories argue this echoes past data-driven studies showing stark disparities in coverage.
The wave of internal dissent follows high‑profile exits in the global media giant, such as BBC North Africa correspondent Bassam Bounenni, who resigned in October 2023 over, stating he could no longer reconcile his conscience with the BBC's framing of the war on Gaza.
The BBC's critics also point to incidents such as presenter Lucy Hockings minimizing Palestinian civilian deaths, which generated widespread public backlash. She interrupted a Palestinian as he was speaking about Israeli Occupation Forces' aggression against civilians before she sarcastically said, while smiling: 'And civilians have been dying.'
The BBC is not alone. In October 2023, several Tunisian journalists resigned from French media outlets in protest at how coverage of Gaza downplayed civilian suffering. These include Achouad Hannachi and Amani Oueslati from Canal+ who resigned over the French outlet's biased coverage of Israel's genocidal war on Gaza.
'Since October 7, my Tunisian colleague and friend, Amani Oueslati, and I have decided to resign from Canal+. We have not set foot in it since then! Our professionalism, our upbringing, and our unwavering support for the Palestinian cause do not allow for compromise! #FreePalestine,' Hannachi said.
In a vague response to the letter, the BBC said it remains committed to impartiality and is reviewing its coverage guidelines. The media giant added that its management insists all pulled content adhered to editorial policy and will resubmit one documentary (the Gaza medics film) through internal oversight.
'We have ongoing discussions about coverage and listen to feedback from staff and we think these conversations are best had internally,' a BBC spokesperson said.
Although many activists, journalists, and everyday media consumers who are fighting for the Palestininan cause have been long-aware of stark biases within mainstream media on Gaza genocide coverage, this scandal marks a notable turn. As Israel's relentless genocide rages on in the enclave, more global media conglomarete's are realizing that they cannot get away with turning a blind eye to the livestreamed carnage, not matter the internal ties to Israel. Tags: BBCGazagenocideIsraelLetterwar
