Latest news with #JamesOwens
Irish Times
08-07-2025
- Sport
- Irish Times
Time to ‘move on' from semi-final scoreboard controversy, says Tipperary boss Liam Cahill
Liam Cahill says Tipperary were not worried about the possibility of a replay being ordered after last Sunday's All-Ireland semi-final victory against Kilkenny ended in controversy. The scoreboard mistakenly awarded Noel McGrath's 70th-minute effort as a point, even though one of the umpires signalled the Tipp player's shot had drifted wide of the Hill 16 posts. That error gave Tipperary a four-point lead when in fact Kilkenny were three adrift. The score at the final whistle was given as 4-21 to 0-30, a three-point difference. However, just before 8pm on Sunday evening, the GAA amended it, with referee James Owens confirming the result as Tipperary 4-20 Kilkenny 0-30. Speaking at Tipperary's All-Ireland final media evening at Horse and Jockey on Tuesday, manager Cahill says there were no fears within the Tipp camp that the result would not stand. READ MORE 'No, no. What can we say, sure. It's human error, that's the bottom line,' said Cahill. 'A mistake was made but it had no effect on us, on what we wanted to achieve at the end of the day, which was just to get the result. Everybody in the GAA, we do our best to try and do things voluntary and keep things as right as we can. Unfortunately, it was just human error. What can be done, only move on. 'You can go into all the ins and out of it. There were several other passages of play and decisions that work out throughout the 74-plus minutes. The reality is that's what big matches like that are made of and you just roll with the punches and you take the hits. 'We know that Kilkenny from the start of time are a huge hurling county and I said that afterwards on Sunday. Like ourselves, if Kilkenny don't win it on the field, they aren't going to bring it to the boardroom, that's for sure. That's one thing in Tipperary we were fully 100 per cent sure of.' Cahill said he was judging the score during injury-time by the scoreboard but admitted there were some doubts raised by members of his backroom team. 'For me, we were going on the scoreboard. Through Declan [Laffan] and the lads down the earpiece, there might have been a little query all right, but for us we were playing what was in front of us.' Tipperary's Jake Morris celebrates with Darragh Stakelum after last Sunday's All-Ireland SHC semi-final win against Kilkenny at Croke Park. Photograph: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho Cahill's sentiments were echoed by Tipp vice-captain Jake Morris. '[Kilkenny] are a serious, proud hurling county with some serious hurlers, they are a really good team,' said Morris. [ Nicky English: Tipperary proved they're primed to take All-Ireland challenge to Cork Opens in new window ] [ Tactical Analysis: Tipperary's ruthless efficiency and turnovers sank Kilkenny Opens in new window ] 'Derek Lyng seems to be a really good operator, it is credit to them that they didn't make as much of a complaint out of it as they could have. 'As Liam said, it was a human error. It was unfortunate for them but it is just the way it goes sometimes. You get the rub of the green sometimes and it fell our way last Sunday. 'I didn't know what the story was when John Donnelly was hitting that shot at the end. We would have been three up [in my head] but to be honest you don't even think about the score, you are just playing every ball as it comes to you.' Cahill added that Tipperary have no fresh injury concerns. He hopes to have a fully fit squad to select from for the All-Ireland final against Cork on Sunday week. Meanwhile, Liam Gordon from Galway has been announced as referee for the All-Ireland hurling final, his first senior final. Previously he has experience of reffing the All-Ireland under-20 final, the All-Ireland club final and the Munster hurling final.
Irish Independent
07-07-2025
- Sport
- Irish Independent
The five minutes of madness: A blow-by-blow analysis of the closing stages of Tipperary's controversial win over Kilkenny
Tipperary booked their place in this year's All-Ireland SHC final when edging out Kilkenny in Croke Park yesterday but much of the aftermath was centred around a scoring controversy. The official scoreline in the stadium was 4-21 to 0-30 at full-time in Tipp's favour, the same score referee James Owens initially had recorded, before that was later corrected to 4-20 to 0-30. Here is the anatomy of chaos, five minutes of hurling madness.
BreakingNews.ie
07-07-2025
- Sport
- BreakingNews.ie
Kilkenny considering their options after confusion over final score
Kilkenny were discussing their options on Sunday night after the GAA clarified the final scoreline in Croke Park and RTÉ was incorrect. Croke Park clarified the correct scoreline as Tipperary 4-20 Kilkenny 0-30 in the second of the All-Ireland SHC semi-finals. Advertisement After Oisín O'Donoghue's 69th-minute goal put Tipperary three points ahead, 4-20 to 0-29, a Noel McGrath point effort was waved wide by an umpire. However, it was recorded as a point on the scoreboard. Following Jordan Molloy's point in the second minute of additional time to bring Kilkenny's total to 30, both managers Derek Lyng and Liam Cahill were of the understanding that the margin was three points when it was in fact two. 'I had three, I thought it was three,' said Lyng afterwards. Kilkenny chased a goal in the dying stages when in fact they could have aimed for points to force extra-time — John Donnelly had a goal attempt denied by Robert Doyle on the goal-line. In the immediate aftermath of the game, GAA sources stated afterwards that the scoreline was 4-21 to 0-30 in Tipperary's favour. However, the GAA later corrected it and gave one point fewer to the winning side. Advertisement The Association said they are waiting on referee James Owens' report to ascertain exactly where the confusion arose. A statement on the GAA website read: "The GAA can confirm that the official score at the end of the Tipperary v Kilkenny GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Semi-Final was 4-20 to 0-30. 'The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score. The CCCC (Central Competitions Control Committee) is awaiting the full referee's report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred." This is the second time in two years that a scoreline error has been made in Croke Park. In the 2023 Joe McDonagh Cup final, Carlow beat Offaly after extra-time by a point. Referee Thomas Walsh reported the score as 2-29 to 1-31 as did the stadium scoreboards when in fact it was 2-30 to 1-32. The incorrect score was adopted into the records. Broadcasters RTÉ updated their totals to reflect the right scoreline. Advertisement In 2016, a re-match was ordered for the Christy Ring Cup final between Meath and Antrim in Croke Park after it was miscalculated that Meath had won the game by a point (2-18 to 1-20). It materialised soon after that the actual scoreline was 2-17 to 1-20 yet Meath were awarded the trophy. Antrim requested a second game, which was granted, but Meath won it by a point, 4-21 to 5-17.
The Journal
06-07-2025
- Sport
- The Journal
GAA to investigate after confusion over final score of Tipperary-Kilkenny game
THE GAA ARE set to investigate after confusion emerged over the final score of today's All-Ireland senior hurling semi-final between Tipperary and Kilkenny. Tonight the GAA confirmed the official score was 4-20 to 0-30 in Tipperary's favour and acknowledged the confusion with the GAA set to await the full report from referee James Owens 'in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred'. The confusion centred around a Noel McGrath shot in the 70th minute into the Hill 16 end which was waved wide by an umpire. The scoreboard in Croke Park increased Tipperary's tally from 4-20 to 4-21, but no white flag was raised. It transpired to be Tipperary's final score of the game with a Jordan Molloy Kilkenny point the only additional score. Advertisement Tipperary boss Liam Cahill and his Kilkenny counterpart Derek Lyng both revealed afterwards that they believed Kilkenny were chasing a three-point deficit towards the end of the game. That position contributed to Kilkenny's approach of chasing a goal with both Eoin Cody and John Donnelly taking shots to try to find the net on separate occasions. ***** The full statement reads: 'The GAA can confirm that the official score at the end of the Tipperary v Kilkenny GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Semi-Final was 4-20 to 0-30. The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score. The CCCC is awaiting the full referees report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred.' Written by Fintan O'Toole and originally published on The 42 whose award-winning team produces original content that you won't find anywhere else: on GAA, League of Ireland, women's sport and boxing, as well as our game-changing rugby coverage, all with an Irish eye. Subscribe here . Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The 42
06-07-2025
- Sport
- The 42
GAA to investigate after confusion over final score of Tipperary-Kilkenny game
THE GAA ARE set to investigate after confusion emerged over the ficore of today's All-Ireland senior hurling semi-final between Tipperary and Kilkenny. Tonight the GAA confirmed the official score was 4-20 to 0-30 in Tipperary's favour and acknowledged the confusion with the GAA set to await the full report from referee James Owens 'in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred'. Advertisement The confusion centred around a Noel McGrath shot in the 70th minute into the Hill 16 end which was waved wide by an umpire. The scoreboard in Croke Park increased Tipperary's tally from 4-20 to 4-21, but no white flag was raised. It transpired to be Tipperary's final score of the game with a Jordan Molloy Kilkenny point the only additional score. Tipperary boss Liam Cahill and his Kilkenny counterpart Derek Lyng both revealed afterwards that they believed Kilkenny were chasing a three-point deficit towards the end of the game. That position contribution to Kilkenny's approach of chasing a goal with both Eoin Cody and John Donnelly taking shots to try to find the net on separate occasions. The full statement reads: 'The GAA can confirm that the official score at the end of the Tipperary v Kilkenny GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Semi-Final was 4-20 to 0-30. The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score. The CCCC is awaiting the full referees report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred.'
