Latest news with #PeopleBeforeProfit-Solidarity
Irish Examiner
09-07-2025
- Politics
- Irish Examiner
Super juniors treated 'identically' to senior ministers, court told
Super junior ministers are treated 'identically' to senior ministers at meetings of Government and have the ability to influence government decision-making, former Cabinet member Shane Ross has said. Mr Ross, who served as minister for transport, tourism, and sport from 2016 to 2020, was yesterday giving evidence at the hearing of People Before Profit-Solidarity TD Paul Murphy's High Court action challenging the attendance of super junior ministers at Cabinet meetings. During his cross-examination of Mr Ross, Attorney General Rossa Fanning claimed Mr Ross illegally breached a constitutional obligation to respect the confidentiality of Cabinet meetings by publishing a book with accounts of discussion at such meetings. Mr Ross denied any illegality. The cabinet confidentiality provision is one of several sections of the Constitution Mr Murphy's case claims is breached by the attendance of super junior ministers at Cabinet. Paul Murphy TD seeking injunction Among the reliefs sought by Mr Murphy is an injunction restraining super junior ministers from going to government meetings. Ministers of state attending Cabinet, or super junior ministers, are appointed by the Government on the nomination of the taoiseach. They participate at government meetings but do not vote. Senior government ministers are appointed by the President of Ireland on the advice of the Taoiseach and with the prior approval of Dáil Éireann. Mr Fanning is leading the defence to the proceedings, brought against the Taoiseach, the Government, and the Attorney General. The hearing into Mr Murphy's action began yesterday, immediately following the conclusion of submissions in a similar case brought by Sinn Féin TD Pa Daly. Super juniors treated 'identically' to senior ministers Led in his evidence by counsel John Rogers, Mr Ross said that super junior ministers were treated 'identically' to senior ministers in the context of cabinet meetings during his tenure in Government. Mr Ross said that they participated fully in discussions at meetings, and agreed that they were never 'curtailed' from participating by virtue of their 'nominally lower status'. Mr Ross agreed that super junior ministers were able to influence government decision-making. On one occasion, Finian McGrath, a super junior minister between 2016 and 2020, 'changed the Government's mind' on a specific cabinet decision after he threatened to resign, Mr Ross said. Put to him by Mr Fanning that there is a difference between having political influence and being a member of Government, and that many people can exercise political influence, Mr Ross said being present at Cabinet is 'not just a matter of political influence'. Super junior ministers' presence at meetings gives them a 'special influence' on legislation, Mr Ross said: I saw it — they have a much greater influence than other ministers of state. Closing his cross-examination, Mr Fanning put to Mr Ross that he breached the constitutional obligation to respect the confidentiality of cabinet meetings in a book he wrote containing accurate descriptions of such meetings. The book — his 2020 title, 'In Bed with the Blueshirts' — was 'an act of calculated and deliberate illegality', Mr Fanning put to him. The book, Mr Fanning claimed, was in contemptuous disregard of the Constitution. Mr Ross denied any illegality, and said that the book pertained to political matters of public interest. 'I thought it was justifiable, there was plenty of precedent for it,' he said. In the witness box, Mr Murphy said super junior ministers are acting as de facto members of Government, not accountable or approved by the Dáil. Earlier, opening Mr Murphy's case, Mr Rogers said the people of Ireland have a constitutional right to choose their 'rulers', and the Constitution only provides for 15 members of Government to act as those 'rulers'. Similar to Mr Daly's case, Mr Murphy's case points to article 28 of the Constitution, which limits the number of government members to 15, including the taoiseach, and provides that they meet and act as a collective authority. Mr Rogers said their case is challenging the arrangement whereby super junior ministers attend meetings of government consistently and participate in Cabinet discussions as though they are members of government. Mr Rogers said: There is no law whatsoever to say that a Minister of State is permitted to be in the government. He said the Taoiseach and the Government had 'usurped a power they don't have' to bring strangers – in a constitutional sense – into the Government room, into the council chamber. Mr Rogers submitted that a 'democratic principle' underpins the process by which deputies are nominated to Government by the Taosieach, and approved by the Dáil, describing it an indirect election or approval on behalf of the people. Counsel submitted that super junior ministers attend at Cabinet and participate in Government deliberations and decisions without any process of approval in the Dáil – unlike the 15 members of Government. 'The Taoiseach nor the Government, cannot hollow out, empty, give away, the expansive powers given to them by the people in article 28,' he said. The case, sitting before a three-judge divisional court, continues, with historian Diarmaid Ferriter and former super junior minister Finian McGrath expected to give evidence.
North Wales Chronicle
17-06-2025
- Politics
- North Wales Chronicle
Irish politician released by Egyptian authorities
Paul Murphy, a TD (MP) for People Before Profit-Solidarity, had first been detained on Friday while attempting to march to the Rafah crossing into Gaza as part of a large demonstration to deliver aid into the blockaded enclave. He was one of a number of Irish people who were expected to take part in the march. Paul has been detained again, with other participants in the Global March to Gaza. On advice of the Irish Embassy, he went to a Cairo police station to retrieve his phone. His passport was taken again & he was prevented from leaving the station. — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 The opposition politician said his phone and passport were confiscated before he and others were put on a bus to Cairo airport, where they believed they would be deported. All Irish people who were detained were then released but some did not have their phones returned. On Monday, Mr Murphy went to a police station in Cairo to retrieve his phone. People Before Profit said this was done on the advice of the Irish embassy. He then sent messages from the station that he was concerned that his passport had been taken again and was told he could not leave. He then attempted to leave, but the party said he and others were prevented from doing so. From Paul: 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo. On the advice of the Irish embassy I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took." — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo,' the party quotes Mr Murphy as saying. 'On the advice of the Irish embassy, I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took. 'They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. 'I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand that other march participants have also been detained.' (cntd) "They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand other march participants have also been detained' — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 Mr Murphy's partner and Dublin councillor Jess Spear asked the Irish Government to intervene. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said it was providing consular assistance. People Before Profit said after 8pm Irish time that Mr Murphy had been released with his passport, and is to 'fly out' on Tuesday morning. The Global March to Gaza is a civilian movement that aims to march from Egypt to Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid and increase pressure so that vital supplies to the besieged region are unblocked. A blockade on Gaza was imposed by Israel when it ended a ceasefire with Hamas earlier this year. This has deepened fears of famine, while a new Israeli-US aid system has been marred by violence. It comes as Israel's 20-month military campaign in Gaza continues, during which an estimated 55,000 Palestinians have been killed. Israel launched a military offensive in Gaza after Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people and abducted 251 hostages on October 7 2023.
South Wales Guardian
16-06-2025
- Politics
- South Wales Guardian
Irish politician released by Egyptian authorities
Paul Murphy, a TD (MP) for People Before Profit-Solidarity, had first been detained on Friday while attempting to march to the Rafah crossing into Gaza as part of a large demonstration to deliver aid into the blockaded enclave. He was one of a number of Irish people who were expected to take part in the march. Paul has been detained again, with other participants in the Global March to Gaza. On advice of the Irish Embassy, he went to a Cairo police station to retrieve his phone. His passport was taken again & he was prevented from leaving the station. — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 The opposition politician said his phone and passport were confiscated before he and others were put on a bus to Cairo airport, where they believed they would be deported. All Irish people who were detained were then released but some did not have their phones returned. On Monday, Mr Murphy went to a police station in Cairo to retrieve his phone. People Before Profit said this was done on the advice of the Irish embassy. He then sent messages from the station that he was concerned that his passport had been taken again and was told he could not leave. He then attempted to leave, but the party said he and others were prevented from doing so. From Paul: 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo. On the advice of the Irish embassy I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took." — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo,' the party quotes Mr Murphy as saying. 'On the advice of the Irish embassy, I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took. 'They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. 'I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand that other march participants have also been detained.' (cntd) "They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand other march participants have also been detained' — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 Mr Murphy's partner and Dublin councillor Jess Spear asked the Irish Government to intervene. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said it was providing consular assistance. People Before Profit said after 8pm Irish time that Mr Murphy had been released with his passport, and is to 'fly out' on Tuesday morning. The Global March to Gaza is a civilian movement that aims to march from Egypt to Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid and increase pressure so that vital supplies to the besieged region are unblocked. A blockade on Gaza was imposed by Israel when it ended a ceasefire with Hamas earlier this year. This has deepened fears of famine, while a new Israeli-US aid system has been marred by violence. It comes as Israel's 20-month military campaign in Gaza continues, during which an estimated 55,000 Palestinians have been killed. Israel launched a military offensive in Gaza after Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people and abducted 251 hostages on October 7 2023.
Leader Live
16-06-2025
- Politics
- Leader Live
Irish politician released by Egyptian authorities
Paul Murphy, a TD (MP) for People Before Profit-Solidarity, had first been detained on Friday while attempting to march to the Rafah crossing into Gaza as part of a large demonstration to deliver aid into the blockaded enclave. He was one of a number of Irish people who were expected to take part in the march. Paul has been detained again, with other participants in the Global March to Gaza. On advice of the Irish Embassy, he went to a Cairo police station to retrieve his phone. His passport was taken again & he was prevented from leaving the station. — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 The opposition politician said his phone and passport were confiscated before he and others were put on a bus to Cairo airport, where they believed they would be deported. All Irish people who were detained were then released but some did not have their phones returned. On Monday, Mr Murphy went to a police station in Cairo to retrieve his phone. People Before Profit said this was done on the advice of the Irish embassy. He then sent messages from the station that he was concerned that his passport had been taken again and was told he could not leave. He then attempted to leave, but the party said he and others were prevented from doing so. From Paul: 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo. On the advice of the Irish embassy I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took." — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo,' the party quotes Mr Murphy as saying. 'On the advice of the Irish embassy, I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took. 'They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. 'I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand that other march participants have also been detained.' (cntd) "They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand other march participants have also been detained' — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 Mr Murphy's partner and Dublin councillor Jess Spear asked the Irish Government to intervene. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said it was providing consular assistance. People Before Profit said after 8pm Irish time that Mr Murphy had been released with his passport, and is to 'fly out' on Tuesday morning. The Global March to Gaza is a civilian movement that aims to march from Egypt to Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid and increase pressure so that vital supplies to the besieged region are unblocked. A blockade on Gaza was imposed by Israel when it ended a ceasefire with Hamas earlier this year. This has deepened fears of famine, while a new Israeli-US aid system has been marred by violence. It comes as Israel's 20-month military campaign in Gaza continues, during which an estimated 55,000 Palestinians have been killed. Israel launched a military offensive in Gaza after Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people and abducted 251 hostages on October 7 2023.
Rhyl Journal
16-06-2025
- Politics
- Rhyl Journal
Irish politician released by Egyptian authorities
Paul Murphy, a TD (MP) for People Before Profit-Solidarity, had first been detained on Friday while attempting to march to the Rafah crossing into Gaza as part of a large demonstration to deliver aid into the blockaded enclave. He was one of a number of Irish people who were expected to take part in the march. Paul has been detained again, with other participants in the Global March to Gaza. On advice of the Irish Embassy, he went to a Cairo police station to retrieve his phone. His passport was taken again & he was prevented from leaving the station. — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 The opposition politician said his phone and passport were confiscated before he and others were put on a bus to Cairo airport, where they believed they would be deported. All Irish people who were detained were then released but some did not have their phones returned. On Monday, Mr Murphy went to a police station in Cairo to retrieve his phone. People Before Profit said this was done on the advice of the Irish embassy. He then sent messages from the station that he was concerned that his passport had been taken again and was told he could not leave. He then attempted to leave, but the party said he and others were prevented from doing so. From Paul: 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo. On the advice of the Irish embassy I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took." — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 'I have been detained in the Abdeen police station in Cairo,' the party quotes Mr Murphy as saying. 'On the advice of the Irish embassy, I went to the station at 12.30pm Egyptian time to enquire about my phone that they took. 'They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. 'I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand that other march participants have also been detained.' (cntd) "They took my passport again, had me talk to the secret police and left me in a room with an interpreter. They claim they are looking for my phone. I just attempted to leave but they said that I cannot leave. I understand other march participants have also been detained' — Paul Murphy 🇵🇸 (@paulmurphy_TD) June 16, 2025 Mr Murphy's partner and Dublin councillor Jess Spear asked the Irish Government to intervene. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said it was providing consular assistance. People Before Profit said after 8pm Irish time that Mr Murphy had been released with his passport, and is to 'fly out' on Tuesday morning. The Global March to Gaza is a civilian movement that aims to march from Egypt to Gaza to deliver humanitarian aid and increase pressure so that vital supplies to the besieged region are unblocked. A blockade on Gaza was imposed by Israel when it ended a ceasefire with Hamas earlier this year. This has deepened fears of famine, while a new Israeli-US aid system has been marred by violence. It comes as Israel's 20-month military campaign in Gaza continues, during which an estimated 55,000 Palestinians have been killed. Israel launched a military offensive in Gaza after Hamas-led militants killed around 1,200 people and abducted 251 hostages on October 7 2023.
