Latest news with #QuentinDuff
RNZ News
03-07-2025
- RNZ News
Khandallah murder trial: Blood 'wiped' onto walls to stage scene
Julia DeLuney is on trial for the murder of her mother Helen Gregory. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii A forensic scientist has told the jury in the Khandallah murder trial that, in her opinion, the blood on the hallway walls was staged. Julia DeLuney is accused of murdering her 79-year-old mother, Helen Gregory, who was killed at her Wellington home in January last year. The jury has already seen photos of blood smeared on the walls in the hallway, in and around the utility cupboard which houses the entrance to the attic. DeLuney's defence is that her mother was injured falling from the attic, and she put her in the bedroom on the floor while she drove to get help. In that time, the defence said, someone else caused those fatal injuries. But Knight gave evidence that the blood smears on the hallway walls looked like it had been applied to the wall with fabric. Defence lawyer Quentin Duff asked whether it could have been applied by someone staggering around the house - to which she replied that she doubted it. "I've never seen it in my experience." Knight said in her opinion, the most likely scenario was that blood was wiped onto the walls. She explained that the horizontal bloodstains along the wall curved upward and downward, making it unlikely they were made by the leaning shoulder of either an injured person - or an attacker covered in blood. She told the court an orange fake nail, broken off beside Gregory's body, was found sitting on a pool of blood, and was also covered in tiny blood spatters. Knight said it was possible it had been kicked onto the area of pooled blood, but in her opinion, it had been present and lying face up on the carpet while blood was flying around. DNA testing had shown there was "extremely strong scientific support" for at least some of the DNA on the nail coming from DeLuney. But the defence has argued throughout that the investigation suffered from tunnel vision from the very beginning. Duff pointed to an online exchange between Knight and her peer reviewer. He challenged her on her likely scenario, asking her to present an alternative explanation, and instead Knight doubled down, offering information she gained from police about what they think happened that night by way of explanation. She pointed out a number of things she understood DeLuney had done that night, which she said she was told by the police, to lend weight to her likely scenario. For example, she told her reviewer that DeLuney supposedly changed her clothes, took a shower, and chased a rubbish truck down the street to dispose of some clothing. It is not yet clear from the proceedings of the trial so far whether all of those things did happen. The defence said it caused the reviewer to change his own conclusion - but Knight said she thought of it more as a lightbulb coming on for him during the course of the conversation, and by the end of it, he came around to her way of thinking. Friday would mark the final day of the trial's second week, and it was set down for at least a further two weeks after that. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
25-06-2025
- RNZ News
Helen Gregory murder trial: How the investigation shifted away from accidental death
Julia DeLuney in the High Court. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Details of how the police investigation into the death of Helen Gregory began to shift from accidental death to murder have been revealed to a jury. Julia DeLuney is accused of murdering her 79-year-old mother Helen Gregory at her Khandallah home in January 2024. She has pleaded not guilty to the charge. One detective told the High Court at Wellington on Wednesday that he locked down the scene when he saw the amount of blood around the house. Under cross examination by defence lawyer Quentin Duff, detective Luke Hensley said when he was called in, the death was not being treated as suspicious. But he said the blood around the house struck him as strange - as did the fact DeLuney had left her mother on the bedroom floor after her fall from the attic, to drive back to Kāpiti to pick up her husband, rather than calling an ambulance. In DeLuney's initial statement to police as a witness, she explained her mother did not like hospitals. When she and Antonio DeLuney returned, there was far more blood than before. The Crown's case is that DeLuney attacked her mother, and then staged it to look like a fall, but the defence's case is that while she was gone, a third person caused those fatal injuries. The DeLuney's gave their statements in the early hours of the morning, at the Johnsonville Police Station. But Julia DeLuney's status as a witness would change in the coming days. On Wednesday afternoon, Detective Sergeant Guilia Boffa told the court about her notes from the time, regarding the results of the post-mortem - something experts are expected go into in more detail in the coming days. "There were seven to nine lacerations on the scalp, and that there were defensive wounds, three skull fractures, two separate impacts, and that there was a brain bleed to the front and back, bruising, blunt force trauma, that was not consistent with a fall." Meanwhile, other information was coming to light. DeLuney had changed her clothing multiple times over the course of the evening, observed in different outfits by ambulance officers and on CCTV. Police also discovered there were previous protection orders against DeLuney and record of a gambling problem dating back to 2015. In the following days, police sought a search warrant under the offence of manslaughter. But during cross examination, Duff for the defence asked Boffa whether she recalled a neighbour approaching a scene guard in the days following the death, to say someone had knocked on their door that same night, between 9.30 and 10pm. On reviewing her notebook, Boffa confirmed she was aware of that happening. Earlier in the week Duff accused the police investigation of tunnel vision when it came to pursuing the case against DeLuney, and failing to properly investigate whether a third person could have done it. The trial continues today. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
25-06-2025
- RNZ News
Detective tells court of 'unusual' actions by murder-accused Julia DeLuney
Julia DeLuney at Wellington High Court. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii A detective who was among first responders to 79-year-old Helen Gregory's death has told the court he thought it was strange that her daughter, Julia DeLuney, chose to drive back to Kāpiti and get her husband instead of calling an ambulance. The trial before a judge and jury at the High Court in Wellington is set down for four to five weeks, and on Wednesday entered its third day. The Crown's case is that DeLuney violently attacked her mother on the evening of 24 January last year, possibly using a vase that was missing off one of the bedside tables, and staged it as a fall from the attic. DeLuney dealt in crypto currency and appeared to be in some financial trouble. However, the defence has asked the jury not to discount the possibility that there was a third person involved, with a neighbour reporting a mysterious knock on their door that same evening. The detective, Luke Hensley, under cross examination by defence lawyer Quentin Duff, said when he was called in the death wasn't being treated as suspicious. But he said the blood around the house struck him as strange - as did the claim from DeLuney that, when she had left her mother on the floor of a bedroom to drive back to Kāpiti to pick up her husband to help, there had been no significant blood. Hensley had eight years' experience at the time, but called a more senior officer to get advice, and they walked through the house on Facetime. In his statement on the night, he wrote they agreed it was "likely some sort of accident, but where the blood was located around the house was strange". They locked the scene down for an examination the next day. Hensley also noted at the time he thought it was "unusual" that DeLuney had driven to Kāpiti to fetch her husband, instead of calling an ambulance. The defence's case is that while she was gone, a third person caused those fatal injuries to her mother. Duff asked Hensley on the witness stand: "Did it ever occur to you that perhaps someone else might have broken into the house and caused those injuries and spread that blood?" Hensley replied: "At the time I believed that getting the statement from Ms DeLuney would cover off a lot of that" and "fill in those blanks". On the night of the death, DeLuney was not yet being treated as a suspect. She and her husband followed police officers in their own car to the Johnsonville police station in the early hours of the morning to give statements. The court heard DeLuney's account for the first time on Wednesday, in the form of her statement given in the early hours of that night in January 2024. Detective Elizabeth Lee, who worked in the Wellington Crime Squad based in Johnsonville, read out the written statement to the court. She was one of the officers who was on the scene, but then took witness statements from the DeLuneys at the police station just after 2am. The statement begins by detailing some recent falls her mother had had in the past two years, both times ending up in hospital. One fall resulted in a concussion and a skull fracture. She said her mother often lost her balance, or felt that she might lose her balance around home. That evening, Julia DeLuney's husband, Antonio DeLuney, had brought the car home from work, and she had driven it to her mother's house on Baroda Street around 6pm. It was her mother's birthday in May, and she and her daughters had thought tickets to the ballet would be a nice present. They sat down at computer and picked out seats. "She was in a good mood," she said in her statement. But her mother was "kind of obsessed" with a shirt she had misplaced and asked for help finding it, going into cupboards and wardrobes. At one point, DeLuney went up into the attic to store some watches. The rungs of the ladder to the attic were built into the wall. "Even I struggle to get up there," DeLuney said. About 8.30pm, Gregory went into a cupboard to search for the shirt again, and knocked over some toilet paper, which she said she wanted to put into the attic. DeLuney said at this point, she was in the kitchen. "All of a sudden, I heard a big crash, and I went over to find that she had fallen." Her mother was "sore everywhere" and holding the top of her head, "crumpled and tangled" against some objects at the base of the attic entrance. She moved her to one of the bedrooms, with her mum saying things like, "I'll be alright". She had a little bit of blood on her hand from holding her head. DeLuney said she couldn't see any open wounds, but it looked like the blood - "not a lot" - was coming from the top of her head. She told her mother she was going to get her husband Antonio to help. "At this stage I didn't think there was anything major going on, and I knew she hated hospitals," she said. She left Gregory lying on the floor, with her feet facing the window. She was "agitated" and trying to get up, but she told her to stay put. Then, she drove 40 minutes home, and found Antonio in bed. She told him her mother had fallen and she needed him to come with her to check on her. It took another 40 minutes to get back to the house, and when they entered, they ran into the bedroom and "freaked out" because "it looked like a warzone" with blood in lots of different places. She said none of that blood was there when she left, "so I got a hell of a shock". The trial continues, and is set down for four to five weeks.
