3 days ago
Air India crash prelim report sparks criticism, debate: ‘Bias toward pilot error, shrouded in secrecy'
According to the report, fuel to both engines was cut off, even though the pilots could be heard saying they did not do it. They also seemed to have tried to restart fuel supply to the engines, but could not manage to keep the aircraft up. On 12 June, the London-bound 787-8 Dreamliner crashed within 1 minute of departure, right after take off. At least 275 people died in the crash, 241 of the 242 on board.
While many pointed out that the report raised many questions and provided few answers, some already began a blame game.
New Delhi: Soon after the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) of India came out with its 15-page report on the AI-171 crash, reactions started pouring in, despite Minister of State for Civil Aviation warning that this was just a preliminary report and people should not jump to conclusions.
Minister of State for Civil Aviation Murlidhar Mohol's warned after the report was made public: 'The AAIB has brought out a preliminary report. This is not the final report. Until
the final report comes out, we should not arrive at any conclusion. AAIB is an
autonomous authority, and the ministry does not interfere in their work.'
But despite this, the detailed findings in the report have already sparked public debate and raised serious concerns.
'The Preliminary Report on the accident of B787 of Airlines raises more
questions than answers,' said Aviation expert and former Head of Operations at
Indian Airlines, Shakti Lumba, reacting to the findings in a post on X.
'What I find interesting is this observation: Any such action is the purview of
@DGCAIndia, and giving a clean chit to @BoeingAirplanes, @airindia, and
@GeneralElectric sours the whole investigation—especially given the fact that
the Service Bulletin (SB) on the fuel switches was ignored. A safe airline would
have carried it out no matter what,' Lumba added.
The report also mentions that the aircraft accelerated normally during takeoff. But
seconds later both engines of the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner shut down one
second apart. This caused the aircraft to lose altitude rapidly and crash near the boundary of Ahmedabad's Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport.
'Does the takeoff roll and critical gates (V1, Vr) versus time indicate a normal
acceleration till liftoff? There's nothing in the CVR or prelim report that says it
doesn't. Why would any trained crew operate a fuel switch at that critical juncture?' asks K.P. Sanjeev Kumar, widely known as Kaypius, is a former Indian Navy test pilot.
'Lack of transparency'
In response to the AAIB's preliminary report, the ALPA-India (The Association of Licensed Pilots of India) has issued an official statement expressing serious concerns over the investigation process and the manner in which the report was presented to the public.
'Investigations continue to be shrouded in secrecy, undermining credibility and
public trust. Qualified, experienced personnel—especially line pilots—are still not
being included in the investigation team,' said ALPA-India.
ALPA-I also raised concerns over a recent Wall Street Journal article that
mentioned the inadvertent movement of fuel control switches, questioning how
such sensitive details were leaked to international media while the investigation
was still ongoing.
ALPA-India also rejected any presumption of pilot guilt. 'The investigation suggests a bias toward pilot error, we reject this presumption and insist on a fair, fact-based inquiry,' the statement further said.
Preliminary rep sparks debate
Reactions—not only from the general public and families of victims, but also from aviation officials and industry experts—are mixed.
Former Union Civil Aviation Minister and BJP leader Syed Shahnawaz Hussain said, 'This report is an eye-opener about how the aircraft engine was not getting fuel.'
Families of those who lost their lives in the tragic Air India Flight AI-171 crash
have also expressed concerns following the release of the AAIB's report.
Speaking to ANI, Yashpal Singh Vansdiya, who lost both his parents in the crash, raised questions about the findings. 'I have certain questions to ask the government and the investigation agencies. Based on the report, which mentions one pilot asking the other if he
has turned off the switch, it means there were some technical issues. Were all
preventive checks of the aircraft done? I hope I get answers to all these
questions,' he said.
As the report was released a month after the incident, there are questions also on the timing of its release. 'Like everything the Modi government does, the report was released late in the night—at 2 am—under the cover and silence of darkness,' said Rajya Sabha MP
and All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) national spokesperson Saket Gokhale.
(Edited by Viny Mishra)
Also read: Fuel switches transitioned to 'cut-off' 1 second apart for both engines—Air India crash preliminary report
