Latest news with #WolseleySchool
Winnipeg Free Press
02-07-2025
- Politics
- Winnipeg Free Press
Street names and recognizing public figures
Opinion 'A rose by any other name would smell as sweet,' William Shakespeare famously wrote in his play, Romeo and Juliet. The problem is, sometimes the bloom falls off the rose, and other times, the smell becomes something that isn't sweet at all. A year ago, Bishop Grandin Boulevard was renamed Abinojii Mikanah, a name that translates to 'children's way' in Anishinaabemowin. Bishop Grandin Trail became Awasisak Meskanôw — 'the children's road' in Ininimowin, or Cree, and Grandin Street, which runs from Taché Avenue to St. Joseph Street in St. Boniface became Taapweewin, which means 'truth' in Michif. Russell Wangersky / Free Press A street sign for Wolseley Avenue The name changes all came because of the recognition of the extent of Bishop Vital Grandin's troubling role in establishing residential schools. With that change in mind, it may well be a reckoning is coming for Wolseley the school, Wolseley the avenue, and maybe even Wolseley the neighbourhood — to cite just one other troubling name from the past. Wolseley School's parent council has looked at the possibility of changing the school's name, and the Winnipeg School Division has collected feedback on the idea, because the school is named after Col. Garnet Wolseley, who led a campaign of repression against Manitoba Métis. (Interestingly, the Manitoba Métis Federation has argued the name should stay, arguing that renaming landmarks and removing statues is a way of erasing a history of wrongdoing.) But one thing has arisen out of the renaming process that should also be considered by the city going forward. The WSD set renaming criteria for the Wolseley school that said prospective names 'should represent the neighbourhood and community; should connect to learning for the students' and 'must avoid the names of people.' The last one is an idea whose time may have come — avoiding the names of people. Because, more than anything else, people are complicated. Right now, the City of Winnipeg website devotes more than 300 words to explaining how it chooses to name a street after a person, saying that it wants 'to honour and commemorate noteworthy people associated with the city of Winnipeg.' That includes 'a person who demonstrates excellence, courage or exceptional dedication to service in ways that bring special credit to the city of Winnipeg; a person who volunteers and gives extraordinary help or care to individuals, families or groups, or supports community services or humanitarian causes; a person who fosters equality and reduces discrimination' and even 'an early pioneer or group or settlers who have contributed to the development of the city.' The city is so keen on naming streets after worthy Winnipeggers that the $200 fee for adding a name to the suggested street name reserve list is waived 'for applications recognizing individuals.' But maybe streets shouldn't be named after people at all, because history is a long road, and our viewpoints — and our knowledge about the character and behaviour of people who may seem like great examples today — can change with the years and with new knowledge. We've certainly seen that here. It's been recognized in other places as well. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. St. John's, the capital of the province of Newfoundland and Labrador, has taken the approach of changing its street naming policy this month to exclude naming streets after individuals. Simply put, it can be fraught with difficulties. 'Naming streets after people carries a number of risks,' St. John's Coun. Ron Ellsworth said during a June 17 council meeting, including ' problematic legacies, political polarization, disparity in representation and cultural marginalization.' The council vote in St. John's was unanimous, following the advice of the city's legal staff and the advice of the city's senior management. Maybe it's not an approach that will garner much support from Winnipeg's council. But maybe it's an idea whose time has come.
CBC
04-04-2025
- Politics
- CBC
MMF opposes changing Wolseley School's name despite namesake's violent suppression of Métis
A move by the Winnipeg School Division to rename Wolseley School is being met by opposition from the descendants of those victimized by the controversial colonial figure. As terrible as it was, it's a history that shouldn't be glossed over or erased, said Will Goodon, Manitoba Métis Federation minister of housing and Métis identity. "The fear, I think, is that if these names are taken off and we just say, let's not talk about it — don't ask, don't tell — that it just sort of subtly slides from history and the issues, the things that our country did under people like John A. Macdonald and Wolseley, become forgotten," Goodon said. "In a country like ours, [touting] reconciliation, we need to talk about the issues. It's not just land acknowledgments, it's about getting to the heart of the matter of why some peoples were targeted as being lesser than others." Col. Garnet J. Wolseley was a British general who commanded the 1870 Red River Expedition, which marched west from Ontario to suppress Louis Riel and the Métis resistance in what was to become Manitoba. Although Riel's provisional government had been dissolved and most of its members had fled before the troops arrived, soldiers abused and attacked Métis people living in the settlement. Wolseley soon returned to Ontario, leaving militia members behind to garrison the province. Abuse by the soldiers chased many Métis out of the province, while others who stayed tried to hide their Métis backgrounds out of shame and fear. Métis elders, over generations, described that period as a "reign of terror" against the Métis. "The reign of terror was in his name, and he's the one who instituted it, where, you know, people were murdered and raped and their houses were stolen and burned down," said Goodon, who admits it seems counterintuitive for a community to defend the name of someone so despised by its people. "It's complicated, but education of what Wolseley did is also vitally important," he said. "We can't learn the lessons of the past if we don't have conversations." The Winnipeg School Division launched a public survey last week, outlining the guidelines and criteria for renaming Wolseley School, and has invited the public to submit ideas. The cut-off date is April 7. The aim is to have the new name in place within the year and possibly before summer, Matt Henderson, WSD superintendent and CEO, told CBC News on Wednesday. At that time, there were already more than 155 submissions for a new name for the 104-year-old school on Clifton Street in the Wolseley neighbourhood, he said. A renaming committee will cut down the list to three names, which will be presented at a community consultation for feedback. Those three will be narrowed to two and given to the WSD board of trustees for a final decision. Henderson said it has already been a long process to get to this point, with consultations held in the community. Teachers and students have also examined the school's name, the significance of Wolseley and other key figures at that time and conducted a Métis learning series on the history of the area, Henderson said. The guidelines around a new name prohibit another person being honoured. That's part of a recent fundamental shift in WSD policy "for obvious reasons," Henderson said. Despite the WSD's work leading up to the renaming survey, Goodon is disappointed the MMF was never consulted. "The school division in Winnipeg is likely just trying to do what they think is right, but there's a need for those decision-makers to understand that it is the Red River Métis who are the most affected by the horrific actions of Gen. Wolseley," he said. "It would have been much better for I think everyone if we'd had a fulsome discussion, conversation, about the different positions." Henderson said the WSD sent an invitation to the MMF on Feb. 14 to be part of the discussions. It was addressed to Goodon and two other ministers. Goodon responded March 3, deferring to the other two ministers. The WSD hasn't heard back from anyone since. The process is being guided by Teresa Byrne, the Métis Way of Life teacher within the WSD, Henderson wrote in an email to CBC News. Byrne is also the MMF's own Métis history and culture co-ordinator As well, Marsha Missyabit, a divisional kookum (grandmother), is also involved, along with three Métis board members who participated in community consultations, Henderson said in the email. "It is important to understand that this is a community-led and driven process. The board [of trustees] sets out the policy for name change, but does not direct it," he said. "The board only makes a final decision once names have been submitted." The division will reach out again to the MMF once names have been presented to the board, "so that trustees and MMF ministers can engage in a fulsome conversation and decision-making process," Henderson said.
CBC
02-04-2025
- General
- CBC
Winnipeg's Wolseley School to be renamed within the year, ending connection to colonial general
Five years after a petition circulated calling for the renaming of Wolseley School in Winnipeg, the province's largest school division is taking new name suggestions from the public. The aim is to have the new name in place within the year, possibly before summer, says Matt Henderson, chief superintendent and CEO of the Winnipeg School Division (WSD). "I have four board meetings left [before the school year is over] and so hopefully we'll be able to get that done, but we don't want to rush the process," he told CBC Manitoba Information Radio host Marcy Markusa. "My initial thought is sort of spring, but if the stars don't align we can push that to fall. If we have to kick it into next year, we can do that, too." Built on Clifton Street in 1921, the school — and the entire neighbourhood in which is exists — was named after Col. Garnet J. Wolseley, a British general who led colonial campaigns in the 19th century, including commanding the 1870 Red River Expedition to suppress Louis Riel and the Métis resistance in what was to become Manitoba. The WSD launched a public survey last week, outlining the guidelines and criteria for the renaming process, and invited the public to submit their ideas. The cut-off date is April 7. "We've had over 155 submissions so far, which is exciting," Henderson said. The renaming committee will cut down the list to three names, which will be presented at a community consultation for feedback. Those three will be narrowed to two and given to the WSD board of trustees for a final decision. "These decisions aren't made on the fly by the board or by anyone. There is a bit of a process within board policy," Henderson said, noting the process began a while back. The division has held community consultations, while teachers and students examined the school's name, the significance of Wolseley and other key figures at that time, and conducted a Métis learning series on the history of the area. Students were then asked to make reasoned ethical judgments, Henderson says: "We want people to think deeply about names and not take them for granted." A recent fundamental shift in WSD policy means schools can no longer be named after a person "for obvious reasons," Henderson said. "I know some schools in North America that are called Justice or that they're called Hope. Certainly, we see that there's a move to schools that are named in Anishinaabemowin." The WSD in 2022 renamed Cecil Rhodes School in the city's Weston area to Keewatin Prairie Community School. Keewatin means "the land of the northwest wind" in Cree and Ojibway. That was also prompted by a public petition. Rhodes, founder of the Rhodes Scholarships at Oxford, was a British businessman, imperialist and politician. He advocated vigorous settler colonialism and touted views that white Europeans were "the first race in the world." His policies paved the way for apartheid in South Africa. The petition came out during a global wave of anti-racism rallies, the same week the Wolseley petition began. The latter also called for the renaming of Wolseley Avenue in that neighbourhood and Lord Wolseley School on Henderson Highway in the city's East Kildonan area. The wave eventually subsided and the focus on Wolseley slipped off the public radar until a couple of years ago when the parent advisory council at Wolseley School revived it, putting forward a request to the WSD to start a formal review process. "That's really where it needs to come — from [the] community, to be able to say, 'hey, we're not really comfortable [with] the name of a particular school for these reasons. Let's engage in a conversation,'" Henderson said. "So that's what happened. There was lots of consultation over the last few years, and now we're kind of at a critical point where we're asking for suggestions."
