5 days ago
Floating bus stops under review amid safety concerns
The roll-out of floating bus stops has been halted amid fears that pedestrians risk being hit by cyclists.
Campaigners have welcomed the Government's decision to order an immediate suspension of bus stops where pedestrians board and disembark directly from or to a cycle lane.
The schemes, known as 'shared use bus stop boarders', have been widely criticised for forcing pedestrians to 'run the gauntlet' of cyclists on bike lanes.
Now, new design guidance will be drawn up which must fully consider how disabled people can use buses without risking injury from cyclists.
Last year, The Telegraph revealed how academics found guide dogs avoided floating bus stops because they encountered cyclists travelling at speed on bike lanes. A University College London (UCL) professor even described such stops as 'conflict zones' between pedestrians and cyclists.
El Briggs, head of policy, public affairs and campaigns at Guide Dogs, which commissioned the UCL study, said: 'Our research has shown the significant fear, anxiety and distress caused by bus stop boarders for disabled people.
'We are glad the Government has listened to our concerns. Our research shows bus stop boarders are confusing, difficult to detect, and can create frightening near-misses with cyclists. No one should have to risk stepping into harm's way just to board or leave a bus.'
Simon Lightwood, the local transport minister, announced the 'pause' on the 'particularly problematic' bus stops in a statement to MPs last week.
He said bus stops should be 'accessible to all', adding that he was also aware of MPs' concerns 'about the behaviour of some cyclists' at zebra crossings where many fail to stop.
However, disability campaigners believe the other more common type of floating bus stop – so-called 'bus stop bypasses' where passengers use a zebra crossing over a cycle lane to reach a bus stop island – should also be halted.
Sarah Gayton, of the National Federation of the Blind UK, said: 'All types of floating bus stops are not safe or accessible for blind people, as well as all bus passengers.
'Guidance will not resolve this design flaw. The only solution is for the bus to pull up to the pavement curb where passengers can board and alight without crossing any cycle lane.
'We want cyclists to be safe, but not at the expense of the most vulnerable people; pedestrians, but particularly blind and disabled pedestrians.'
Last year, Transport for London (TfL) was forced to apologise after an official safety report into 164 of these bus stops failed to disclose the extent of pedestrians injured at such locations.
TfL's report concluded the risk to pedestrians was 'very low' and wrongly claimed only four people were injured – two seriously – between 2020 and 2022 at floating bus stops with the island.
However, The Telegraph revealed there were in fact six collisions – three serious – during that period, prompting TfL to apologise.
Analysis also showed that on average only one in 10 cyclists stop for pedestrians at zebra crossings, despite those on foot being classified as the most vulnerable road users in the Highway Code.
Referring to the suspension of bus stop boarders, a Department for Transport spokesman said: 'The safety and accessibility of our roads and pavements is an absolute priority.
'That's why the Government will ask all local authorities in England to halt the implementation of floating bus stops until new statutory guidance is created.'
