EC always a 'puppet' in hands of Modi government: Kapil Sibal
In an interview with PTI, Sibal also alleged that each election commissioner surpasses the previous one in his "alignment to this government".
Hitting out at the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, the former law minister said the Election Commission (EC) doesn't have the jurisdiction to decide issues of citizenship.
The EC has all along maintained that the revision, being held after 22 years, will cleanse the voters' list of ineligible people, duplicate entries and include those eligible as per law to vote.
Asked about the opposition's attack on the EC over SIR, Sibal said, "It has always been a puppet in the hands of the government for a long long time ever since this government came to power."
The conduct of the Election Commission, the less said about it, the better, he said.
"In fact, each election commissioner surpasses the previous one in his alignment to this government," Sibal said.
On the ongoing SIR, he said, "This is according to me a completely unconstitutional process that is being carried on. The Commission doesn't have the jurisdiction to decide issues of citizenship and that also by a block level officer."
"I have been saying that they (BJP) adopt all possible means to somehow win elections. In fact, this whole particular process of a special intensive revision is a process to ensure majoritarian governments for all times to come," the senior advocate said.
"This is the intent because if you delete the names of the poor people, the marginalised, the adivasis, you will ensure that the majoritarian party always wins. So this is yet another way of ensuring that and this is very worrisome," he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Tejashwi seeks to puncture ECI's claims on progress in Bihar SIR
RJD leader Tejashwi Yadav on Sunday (July 13, 2025) cast doubts over the Election Commission's claim that the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar was progressing at a brisk pace and would be completed before the July 25 deadline. Addressing a press conference, the Leader of the Opposition in the State Assembly also took strong exception to the EC's "silence" on the Supreme Court's suggestion that Aadhar card and ration card be included in the list of acceptable documents, to be submitted by voters whose names did not figure in the electoral rolls of 2003 when SIR was last conducted. "In its press note issued on Saturday, the EC claimed that more than 80% of the State's 7.90 crore voters have already been covered under SIR. This is a bewildering claim considering the fact that an estimated four crore people from Bihar live in other states." "We would like to know from the EC how many such migrants have been covered under the exercise. It is well known that during the elections, a large number of people return to their home state to cast their votes. During the COVID-19 pandemic, several special trains had to be run for an estimated 40 lakh returnees. The EC should disclose what arrangements were made this time," the former Deputy Chief Minister said. The EC seems to be playing with figures to give a false impression that it has been undertaking this exercise competently, he alleged. "We have received complaints that booth-level officers (BLOs) are under pressure to achieve targets and they are ending up collecting enumerating forms without getting those duly signed and filled up by the voters concerned," he added. Mr. Yadav also had a few video clips played, in which enumeration forms were shown strewn on the streets, to underscore that the SIR was marred by many irregularities. However, the X handle of the chief electoral officer has been running "fact checks" debunking these videos. Mr. Yadav alleged, "The EC is never coming up with a proper statement or press conference explaining what it intends to do about the SC order earlier this week when it was told to consider including Aadhar card and ration card." There is no clarity on the role that booth-level agents nominated by political parties are supposed to play in the exercise, he said. "In its tearing hurry to meet the July 25 deadline, the EC came up with an advertisement proclaiming that those unable to submit their documents may just deposit their forms, leaving the remaining things for the claims/objections stage. But there was no official notification to this effect and the BLOs are confused," claimed the chairman of the INDIA bloc's coordination committee for the state assembly polls due later this year. Mr. Yadav, who spoke in the presence of a number of alliance partners, also said, "We still hold the view that SIR is an exercise aimed at depriving, wrongfully, many existing voters of their right to franchise in order to benefit the ruling NDA. Leaders like Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Union Minister Amit Shah and Chief Minister Nitish Kumar should be squarely blamed for this undemocratic move." In the 2020 Assembly polls, there were several seats in which candidates of Mahagathbandhan (INDIA bloc's Bihar prototype) lost by margins of 3,000 votes or less. A little manipulation in the voters' list can easily tilt the scales. If indeed the EC believes that the voters' list had been suspect so far, it should declare last year's Lok Sabha elections as null and void, Yadav said. He scoffed at the claim of the BJP that the exercise was essential to weed out "illegal Bangladeshi immigrants and Rohingyas" from the voters' list. "In the 2014 and 2019 Lok Sabha polls, the BJP-led coalition did exceedingly well. Even last year, the NDA bagged 30 out of the state's 40 seats. So the BJP should tell us whether it thinks the alleged infiltrators were voting for Narendra Modi," he added.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
An honour for Kerala too, says Sadanandan
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader C. Sadanandan, 61, a retired teacher from Kannur and a survivor of brutal political attack in the 1990s, has been nominated to the Rajya Sabha under Article 80(3) of the Constitution, which allows the President to nominate individuals with expertise in education, social service, and other key sectors. Mr. Sadanandan told mediapersons in Kannur on Sunday that the proposal was part of the BJP's efforts to implement its slogan of a 'developed Kerala'. 'The party has high hopes for Kerala. This proposal is a step towards fulfilling those hopes,' he said, describing it as not only a personal honour but also a recognition for the State. He said the BJP Central leadership had always bestowed 'special attention' on Kerala regardless of its electoral success in the State. Modi's call Mr. Sadanandan said Prime Minister Narendra Modi had called him two days ago. 'He said the party would delegate me a task. I found out about it only this morning,' he added. He said the BJP's Central approach was not hindered by electoral losses in Kerala. 'That is not seen as a big issue or obstacle. Policies are being formulated for Kerala's development,' he said. Mr. Sadanandan, a native of Perincheri, was a teacher at Sree Durga Vilasam Higher Secondary School in Thrissur. He began his teaching career at Kuzhikkal Lower Primary School and was also as subeditor of Janmabhoomi and an announcer at All India Radio. His social engagements began at the age of 17 through Nehru Yuva Kendra and continued through organisations such as Bharatiya Vichara Kendra and Sri Parvathi Jana Seva Samithi. He also served as the State president of the Desiya Adhyapaka Parishad and Chief Editor of Desiya Adhyapaka Vartha for 15 years. Double amputee At the age of 30, Mr. Sadanandan underwent double amputation below the knees, following an attack allegedly perpetrated by CPI(M) workers in 1994. He continues to remain active in public life using prosthetic limbs. Mr. Sadanandan's elevation to the Raja Sabha is seen within BJP circle as a strategic move to energise the party base in Kerala while honouring a lifetime of ideological commitment and public service.
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Should I Speak In Hindi Or Marathi?: Rajya Sabha Nominee Ujjwal Nikam Recalls Conversation With PM Modi
Ujjwal Nikam, Special Public Prosecutor, was nominated to the Rajya Sabha by President Droupadi Murmu on Saturday. Later, while expressing his gratitude, he shared details of a personal conversation with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who had personally informed him of the nomination over a phone call. Ujjwal Nikam is known for handling high-profile criminal cases, including the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks trial of Ajmal Kasab and the 1993 Bombay blasts case. Speaking to ANI, Ujjwal Nikam shared a light-hearted moment from his conversation with Prime Minister Modi, during which the PM asked if he should speak in Hindi or Marathi. "I thank President Droupadi Murmu for nominating me. When I met PM Narendra Modi during the Lok Sabha election campaign, he expressed his faith in me. Yesterday, PM Modi called to inform me about the nomination. He asked whether he should speak in Hindi or Marathi--both of us laughed. Then he spoke to me in Marathi and told me that the President wanted to assign me a responsibility, and he informed me of her decision," Nikam said. "I immediately said yes. I thank the party leadership and also Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis," said Nikkam who had earlier contested from Mumbai North Central on the BJP ticket in the Lok Sabha polls held last year," the Prosecutor added. #WATCH | Mumbai: On being nominated to the Rajya Sabha, Special Public Prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam says, "Its a proud moment for me. I never thought or expected to be nominated as a member of the Rajya Sabha by the President of India. Yesterday I received a phone call from PM… — ANI (@ANI) July 13, 2025 Rajya Sabha Nominations Ujjwal Nikam, along with former Foreign Secretary Harsh Vardhan Shringla, C Sadanandan Master, a veteran social worker and educationist from Kerala, and Meenakshi Jain, a noted historian, were nominated to the Rajya Sabha by the President. These individuals were nominated under the powers conferred by Article 80(1)(a) of the Constitution, read with clause (3) of the same article. The nominations fill vacancies created by the retirement of previously nominated members. The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) announced the nominations through an official notification. These appointments are seen as a recognition of significant national contributions in the fields of law, diplomacy, social service, and historical scholarship.
