'No clean toilets, yet want Olympics?' Delhi HC slams civic bodies for filthy public loos
Delhi High Court
on Wednesday pulled up the city's municipal bodies for their failure to maintain
public toilets
, calling the situation 'hurting and unfortunate' and accusing civic agencies of 'complete apathy and insensitivity', TOI has reported.
A division bench of Chief Justice DK Upadhyaya and Justice Tushar Rao Gedela made the observations while hearing a PIL filed by
Jan Sewa Welfare Society
. The NGO sought directions for the provision of clean, functional public toilets equipped with basic amenities like water and electricity across Delhi.
'We are staking claim to host the Olympics, and we don't even have
clean public toilets
in the city,' the bench said, expressing deep concern over the poor state of sanitation infrastructure.
The court noted that municipal agencies, including the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (
MCD
), New Delhi Municipal Council (
NDMC
), and Delhi Development Authority (DDA), had displayed a 'complete apathy, insensitivity and even dereliction of duty' in maintaining public conveniences.
'These agencies need not be reminded repeatedly that under law it is their primary responsibility to provide adequate public conveniences,' the bench said.
Live Events
Following earlier court directions, the civic bodies had submitted status reports outlining their steps on the issue. However, the petitioner's counsel presented recent images and reports indicating that the situation remained largely unchanged.
'After all, the municipal bodies and development agencies are created by the legislature for the benefit of the general populace and they function on public money. It is hurting and unfortunate to note the conditions of toilets,' the bench said.
The judges questioned whether officials responsible for sanitation ever used the facilities themselves. 'If they were forced to use them, these conveniences would be 'spanking clean' in no time,' they remarked.
Highlighting the disproportionate impact on women, the bench added, 'Given such a state of public utilities available in the city, the problems being faced by women get compounded for obvious reasons.'
The court, as per TOI report, has now directed the MCD, NDMC and DDA to escalate the matter to the 'highest level' and come up with comprehensive, expert-based plans for public toilet maintenance in their respective areas.
These plans must include actionable recommendations and ensure that the public utilities remain functional at all times.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
‘Hosting Olympics? First Fix Toilets': Delhi HC Slams Civic Bodies For Dirty Public Amenities
Last Updated: The Delhi High Court criticized civic bodies for failing to maintain public toilets, calling the situation "hurting and unfortunate". The Delhi High Court pulled the city's municipal bodies for failing to maintain public toilets and said the situation was 'hurting and unfortunate", according to a report by the Times of India. The report said that the High Court accused the civic agencies of 'complete apathy and insensitivity". The comments came when a division bench of Chief Justice DK Upadhyaya and Justice Tushar Rao Gedela heard a PIL filed by Jan Sewa Welfare Society. The NGO sought directions for clean and functional public toilets equipped with basic amenities like water and electricity across the city. 'We are staking claim to host the Olympics, and we don't even have clean public toilets in the city," the bench observed, voicing deep concern over the condition of Delhi's sanitation infrastructure. The court criticised the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC), and Delhi Development Authority (DDA) for their 'complete apathy, insensitivity and even dereliction of duty" in maintaining public conveniences. 'These agencies need not be reminded repeatedly that under law it is their primary responsibility to provide adequate public conveniences," it said. While the civic bodies had submitted status reports detailing their actions as per earlier court directions, the petitioner's counsel presented fresh photos and media reports showing that the situation remained largely unchanged. 'After all, the municipal bodies and development agencies are created by the legislature for the benefit of the general populace and they function on public money. It is hurting and unfortunate to note the conditions of toilets," the bench said, questioning whether officials in charge of sanitation had ever used the facilities themselves. 'If they were forced to use them, these conveniences would be 'spanking clean' in no time," the court remarked. Noting that the burden is greater on women, the bench said, 'Given such a state of public utilities available in the city, the problems being faced by women get compounded for obvious reasons." The court has now directed MCD, NDMC and DDA to escalate the issue to the 'highest level" and come up with expert-driven, comprehensive plans for maintaining public toilets. These plans must be actionable and ensure that public conveniences are functional at all times. About the Author Shankhyaneel Sarkar First Published: July 03, 2025, 20:40 IST
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
India-US trade deal: What's the deadlock about? Top issues blocking agreement as Donald Trump's 26% tariff deadline looms
India is taking a firm stance against US pressure in the proposed trade agreement. (AI image) India and the US are racing to seal a trade deal ahead of American President Donald Trump 's July 9 deadline, when 26% reciprocal tariffs on Indian goods will kick in. Despite India's chief negotiator Rajesh Agarwal and his team extending their stay in Washington for discussions, talks are stuck on certain issues on either side. Trump has suggested that extending the reciprocal tariff suspension period to beyond July 9 is unlikely. He has, however, also expressed hope of a trade deal with India in the coming days. Earlier this week, Trump emphasised that the United States and India are nearing completion of a trade agreement that would significantly reduce current tariffs, allowing fair competition between both nations. "I think we are going to have a deal with India … and if they do that, we are going to have a deal for much less tariffs," Trump said. Also Read | Donald Trump's tariff wars: US announces trade deal with Vietnam; is India next? Why China should be worried Without an interim trade deal agreement, Indian industries must prepare for a 26% tariff. It's important to note that the US is also eager to close a deal since Trump needs to demonstrate success through trade agreements with nations like the UK, China and India to encourage other countries to negotiate. Biggest Thorn: Access For US Agriculture Products India is taking a firm stance against US pressure in the proposed trade agreement, particularly regarding reduced tariffs on American agricultural imports such as maize and soybean, according to a TOI report. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Your IQ Is 140 If You Can Answer 10 Of These Questions Correctly IQ International Undo by Taboola by Taboola The US seeks reduced tariffs on maize, soybean, dairy products, apples, and various fruits and nuts. It is seeking market access for numerous products, including dairy, poultry, corn, soybeans, rice, wheat, ethanol, citrus fruits, almonds, pecans, apples, grapes, canned peaches, chocolates, cookies, and frozen French fries. However, this presents a significant challenge for the Modi government, considering the substantial number of small-scale farmers dependent on these commodities and potential political implications. The primary concerns revolve around protecting domestic farmers and addressing health-related issues associated with genetically modified products. While India is open to increasing access for US dry fruits and apples, it remains resistant regarding corn, soybeans, wheat, and dairy products. Also Read | Big remittance cheer for NRIs! US Senate draft of Donald Trump's 'One Big Beautiful Bill' reduces remittance tax to 1% from 3.5%; details here The dairy sector is particularly sensitive in India due to cultural and dietary preferences. Indian consumers express concerns about US cattle feeding practices involving animal by-products, which conflict with Indian dietary customs. India has consistently declined to open its agriculture and dairy sectors in free trade agreements with Australia and the UK, and has expressed similar reservations to the EU. The US maintains that a trade agreement without reduced agricultural duties is unacceptable, even with limited quantity provisions. India is also maintaining its prohibition on genetically modified food crops, whereas US corn and soybean production predominantly involves GM varieties. Also Read | India-US trade deal: India eyes middle ground, mulls GM-free 'self-certification' for US food imports as Donald Trump's tariff deadline nears An ET report suggests that to solve this deadlock, India is mulling the introduction of a 'self-certification' mechanism for US exporters to fulfil India's stipulations on GM-free/non-GMO status of imported goods whilst making the procedure more efficient. Under this framework, the United States would be required to maintain a current list of food crops where 'no GM event' has received approval. Furthermore, the US would need to establish an online database listing food crops with approved GM events, enabling Indian officials to make well-informed decisions regarding imports. Zero Tariff Demand During initial talks, India sought duty-free market access for various products including textiles, leather goods, pharmaceuticals, engineering goods and auto parts. The US has essentially dismissed the possibility of immediate zero tariffs. The US negotiators, whilst eager to conclude the agreement, have conveyed to Indian officials that the Trump administration cannot immediately eliminate tariffs. India has also requested protection from subsequent tariff impositions after finalising the agreement. Indian government officials consider the Trump administration's proposed 10% baseline tariff for all nations not good enough for India. But, they have also informed exporters that a 10% base tariff under Trump's administration would still advantage Indian businesses compared to competitors facing reciprocal tariffs. Several industry representatives have held private discussions with the commerce department officials, advocating acceptance of the US administration's terms. However, the government remains committed to securing a balanced agreement. Also Read | US plans 'economic bunker buster' bill: Will Donald Trump impose 500% tariff on countries importing oil from Russia? How it may impact India Industry Concerns US negotiators are seeking concessions on cars and whiskey imports, but Indian officials express concern over inadequate reciprocal benefits for their key export sectors. These sectors include textiles, garments, leather products, footwear, engineering products and automotive components. Additionally, there are concerns that specific automotive parts, along with iron and aluminium products, might remain subject to sectoral tariffs. These items currently face supplementary sectoral duties ranging from 25% to 50%, based on the product category. Ethanol Imports India's Ethanol Blended Petrol (EBP) programme aims primarily to reduce reliance on imported energy through the combination of locally-produced ethanol with petrol. Due to substantial investments from Indian companies, India stands close to reaching its target of 20% ethanol blending. Any ethanol imports from the US could potentially harm these domestic enterprises, says a Reuters report. The EBP initiative additionally serves to handle excess production of rice, sugarcane and corn by channeling these crops towards ethanol manufacturing. The introduction of American ethanol imports would significantly impact India's growing distillery industry in an adverse manner. Will A Trade Deal Happen? Key is 'Interim' A recent report in Financial Times indicates that India and the US may seal an interim trade deal as early as the end of this week. Although there are differing stances, India and US seem to be progressing towards an interim trade deal ahead of the first phase of the bilateral trade pact by Fall (Sept-Oct), the timeframe established during PM Narendra Modi and Trump's earlier meeting this year. At a discussion with exporters on Monday, commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal remained open to the prospect of an agreement in the coming days, indicating that sectors excluded from the first phase should remain optimistic as additional items would be incorporated in subsequent rounds. Also Read | What is Donald Trump's net worth? Billionaire US President has a big portfolio of cryptocurrencies, stocks & more - top details Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Debate over renaming Dakshina Kannada district resurfaces
- MANGALURU: The Karnataka Cabinet renamed Bengaluru Rural to Bengaluru North, sparking renewed debate over the nomenclature of Dakshina Kannada district. People's representatives, political party leaders, and various organisations are advocating for the coastal district to be renamed 'Mangaluru'. While the demand for a change of the district's name is widely discussed on social media, an online meeting was also held recently involving leaders from political, religious, and social organisations. Dakshina Kannada MP Capt Brijesh Chowta told TOI that normally all districts are named after the name of their district headquarters. 'Mangaluru has its own significance when it comes to its historical background. The city is known as Mangaluru because of Goddess Mangalambike. People across the world identify residents of the coastal district as Mangalureans. Hence, calling our district 'Mangaluru' is better,' the MP said. KPCC General Secretary Padmaraj R Poojary said that the coastal city has several names, including Kudla, Kodiala, Maikala, Mangalapuram, and Mangalore. 'Naming Dakshina Kannada as 'Mangaluru' is an ideal suggestion. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Pensia Pilon 3 NN Pensia Facultativă NN Vezi oferta Undo Since Tulu is widely spoken in the district and the coastal city is also known as Kudla, the district headquarters may be called 'Kudla'. Many who participated in the Google Meet also expressed similar views, and according to me, 'Mangaluru' is an ideal name for the district as globally we are identified as 'Mangalureans',' he said. The seer of Gurupura Vajradehi Mutt, Sri Rajashekarananda Swamiji, said a new name for Dakshina Kannada should reflect the identity of the region since the district has its own cultural history. Mangaluru City South MLA D Vedavyas Kamath said that renaming Dakshina Kannada as 'Mangaluru' is a necessity. Extending his support to the demand, he also mooted the idea of the region being known as 'Tulunadu' instead of 'Karavali'. Mangaluru City North MLA Dr Y Bharath Shetty, former Chairman of the Karnataka Tulu Sahitya Academy Dayanand Kattalsar, Tulunada Rakshana Vedike founder President Yogish Shetty Jeppu, and others also support the demand for a change in the name of the coastal district.
