Cher wants a better home for Los Angeles' elephants. Not Tulsa.
Advertisement
But instead of the sanctuary that Cher and other advocates wanted, officials said the elephants would be moved to a zoo in Tulsa, Oklahoma, where they could join a larger herd. That has led to protests, a lawsuit, tense city meetings, anger at the zoo director and a legal declaration submitted by the pop icon on the elephants' behalf.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
The battle comes at a time when lawsuits from animal-rights advocates and the shrinking number of available animals have led more zoos to close their elephant enclosures. New York City's Bronx Zoo has faced growing legal pressure to move its last two elephants to a sanctuary, and in 2023, California's Oakland Zoo sent one of its elephants to a sanctuary in Tennessee after it was unable to find it a compatible companion.
Advertisement
Billy and Tina's case was in Los Angeles County Superior Court this week, where a judge denied a temporary restraining order in a lawsuit filed by John Kelly, a longtime Los Angeles resident seeking to stop the relocation to Tulsa. The judge's action allows zoo officials to move forward unless the City Council decides to intervene.
On Friday, the Nonhuman Rights Project filed a separate lawsuit in Los Angeles County Superior Court to stop the move.
Visited by nearly 1.8 million people a year, the zoo is owned by the city of Los Angeles and has been Billy's home since he arrived in California as a 4-year-old from Malaysia. Tina joined him in 2010 from San Diego.
Their herd also included Jewel, who was 61 when she died in 2023, and Shaunzi, who died last year at 53. Zoo officials have said that the elephants were declining for reasons unrelated to their enclosure, and that they were euthanized because of age-related health problems.
To keep their accreditation, zoos must maintain a herd larger than two so that the animals can properly socialize with other elephants. Los Angeles officials said there weren't enough Asian elephants available to acquire more, so they decided to move Billy and Tina to another zoo instead.
Five Asian elephants live on a 17-acre complex at the Tulsa Zoo, and they share a 36,650-square-foot barn -- a space much larger than the one Billy and Tina have now. But animal-rights advocates say they are concerned about Billy and Tina being able to adapt, and the trip there being unhealthy or traumatizing.
'Billy and Tina may not be any better off at the Tulsa Zoo than they are at the LA Zoo,' Chris Draper, an expert in animal behavior and management, said in a declaration filed with the lawsuit by animal-rights advocates last week. Draper is on the accreditation committee for the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries.
Advertisement
The Los Angeles Zoo, which said in a statement this week that its elephants and other animals 'receive the best care possible,' referred questions about the legal battle to the city attorney's office, which declined to comment.
The zoo's director, Denise Verret, has said that the decision to move the elephants was made in consultation with the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, which accredits zoos across the country. She is the current chair of the association's board of directors.
The decision has prompted criticism from some city officials, and concerns about conflict of interest. At a budget hearing last week, City Council member Bob Blumenfield asked Verret if she could promise that the elephants would not be moved until council members had a chance to study the move. She did not agree.
'What I can promise you is that I am always going to make decisions that are for the best interest of the animals at the zoo, including the elephants,' Verret said.
For now, it is unclear when the move to Tulsa will happen. Zoo officials said a date had not been determined.
On Friday morning, Tina appeared to be receiving some sort of treatment inside the zoo's 16,600-square-foot barn. Outside, Billy paced around the 6.56-acre elephant enclosure, at one point stepping in his own feces.
For several minutes, he bobbed his head up and down, which could be interpreted as a sign of a happy elephant. But Cher, co-founder of animal advocacy group Free the Wild, says that when an elephant does that, 'they're having a breakdown.'
Advertisement
Cher acknowledged that she had never visited Billy or his companions at the zoo, but she said in an interview that she had viewed videos of their condition.
'Billy and Tina have served their time in confinement,' she said. 'They deserve the chance to live out their lives in peace and dignity.'
This article originally appeared in
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
21 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Demolition planned for century-old cottage in Laguna Beach
Laguna Beach may soon lose one of the oldest structures in town, as a bungalow referred to as the 'Blue Cottage' is set to be demolished. The single-family house, located at 359 Third St., across from the Community and Susi Q Center, was built in 1914. Laguna Presbyterian Church, which owns the property, submitted an application for work that includes the demolition of the structure to put in more parking. The plan would provide for an additional seven spaces, bringing the total to 10 spaces on the lot. The Planning Commission unanimously approved the design review and coastal development permit for the project on May 21, but the item subsequently came before the City Council on July 22 at the request of Mayor Pro Tem Mark Orgill. Council members grappled with several questions, including the historicity of the house and whether records of agreements and entitlements pertaining to master-planned projects for the historic preservation of the church and its administration building required the retention of the cottage in perpetuity. A series of meetings that were held from 2007 to 2009, a period during which the house was also targeted for demolition or relocation, was at the core of the discussion. In the end, the panel upheld the Planning Commission's decision by a 3-2 vote, with Orgill and Councilmember Hallie Jones dissenting. Larry Nokes, representing the church, said that while the heritage committee may have wanted to preserve the blue house, the committee is not a decision-making body. Further, he contended that the future retention of the house was not a condition of approval for entitlements. 'We know the heritage committee was very keen on having the blue cottage remain,' Nokes said. 'But the issue that was considered by the Planning Commission, and by the City Council later, had to do with parking credits, and the incentive for those parking credits was to make the sanctuary and the administrative building an E-rated structure and place it on the [historic] register under a contract by the city and agree to maintain that.' Nokes noted that saving the structure was recommendation made by the heritage committee, but was obviously not binding. 'That recommendation made it into every single public hearing by every single decision-making body, and it was never made a condition of approval by any of those bodies,' Nokes said. 'Now, the needs of the church have changed, and they are requesting removal of that building,' Nokes continued. 'The building is not a historic resource, it was only listed on the [Laguna Beach Historic Resource] Inventory, and the inventory is no longer valid to create a presumption of historicity.' Orgill wondered whether it was made clear in past proceedings that the bungalow was not protected moving forward. 'I'll just say that I think that the conversation around this project in 2008 would have been different,' Orgill said. '... I think that it affected people's opinions and how they processed, proceeded with the whole application at the time.' City resident Ann Christoph spoke in opposition to the structure's demolition on behalf of Village Laguna, a group concerned with preserving the town's cultural heritage. She said the retention of the house was consistently part of the plans during the church's prior dealings with the city. 'Our position is it doesn't matter about whether it was on the register, it doesn't matter what it looks like or what characteristics it has in terms of historicity or its pedigree, the church agreed to keep the house as part of that package of plans,' Christoph said. 'They got everything they asked for from the city. They got their parking variance, the height variances, all the approvals, the [conditional use permits], the [coastal development permits] and all that. Keeping that house was part of the deal, and now they don't want to keep the deal.' Christoph suggested that the property could be used to provide housing or a studio for artists. Mayor Alex Rounaghi said it would be a 'fair compromise' if the the church was willing to give the structure to someone who wanted to move it off site and preserve it. 'But it's really unfair to just force the church to deal with a structure that's uninhabitable. If someone lived in this, the church would get sued under the tenant protection laws.' Councilwoman Sue Kempf said the church has a right to destroy the cottage. 'It's not historic,' Kempf said. 'It's not on the register. Even if it was in some agreement, the heritage committee is a committee. It's not a quasi-judicial body.' While documents showed that the cottage had been remodeled, Councilwoman Hallie Jones and Orgill both indicated they felt there was room to consider the property as a local historic resource. At one point in her comments, Christoph showed a George Brandriff painting from 1928, attempting to appeal to the local history and storytelling involved with preserving a relic of the seaside cottages among which the church was built. Laguna Presbyterian's main sanctuary was built in 1928, and the church bought the blue house in 1967. 'I've lived here since 1974, and there's a lot that was here then that's not here now,' Bob Borthwick said. 'It's kind of a death-by-a-thousand-cuts type of situation. Every time a little structure like this goes away, or a little house goes away, we've lost something of our character and our legacy.'
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
South Florida pilot dies in plane crash while trying to fly around the world
Ahn-Thu Nguyen had already made history. After becoming the 10th woman to fly solo around the world, the South Florida woman took off again this month to embark on a similar journey. The 44-year-old Nguyen, who was known as a groundbreaking aviator, educator and fierce advocate for women in aerospace, died on Wednesday in a plane crash near Greenwood, Indiana, during the early leg of her second global solo flight. The crash occurred shortly after takeoff from Indy South Greenwood Airport around 10:45 a.m, according to the National Transportation Safety Board, which is investigating the crash. The agency identified the plane as a Lancair IVP. The NTSB investigation is ongoing and will examine the aircraft, pilot qualifications, maintenance records, weather conditions, and additional data, including air traffic control communications and surveillance footage. Nguyen, a Pembroke Pines pilot who chronicled her flight journeys on her social media page, made her last post the day her plane crashed. In a video posted to her Instagram, with over 166,000 followers, Nguyen is seen sitting in a small aircraft and excitedly tells the camera that she has just completed the first leg of her solo flight around the world. In the video, she says that she is getting ready to fly from Indiana to Pennsylvania. A resident of South Florida Nguyen was founder of Asian Women in Aerospace and Aviation, a nonprofit based in Miami and Pembroke Pines that empowers Asian women and girls through scholarships, mentorship and flight training. She also operated Dragon Flight Training Academy at North Perry Airport in Pembroke Pines, where she mentored the next generation of pilots. Her 2025 solo journey was the continuation of a mission that had already made history. In 2024, Nguyen became only the 10th woman in history — and the first Vietnamese woman — to complete a solo flight around the globe. 'This isn't just a flight — it's a movement,' a GoFundMe page to help Nguyen in her journey reads. Her proposed route covered 26,800 nautical miles across 25 countries, promoting aerospace education for girls worldwide, according to the fundraiser. 'Anh-Thu was an inspiring pilot, instructor, and advocate for girls and women in aerospace, engineering, and aviation,' AWAA said in a statement. 'She lived with boldness, curiosity, and drive.' Born in a remote village in Tuy-Hoa, Vietnam, she attended a UNICEF-built school and grew up without electricity or running water, according to her bio. She arrived in the U.S. at 12 as a refugee, not speaking English, and her family relied on welfare and food stamps. Nguyen went on to graduate as valedictorian of her high school, earn an engineering degree from Purdue University, and went on to pursue a Ph.D. in aerospace engineering at Georgia Tech. As a student, she worked for $6 an hour as a math tutor, took out student loans, and often lived out of her car while completing flight training, her bio reads. She eventually became a Boeing 767 pilot for a major airline and earned recognition as an AOPA Distinguished Flight Instructor. Even with her achievements, Nguyen often faced skepticism. In her bio she recounted repeated instances of being stopped at airport gates and having to prove she was, in fact, a pilot. In 2018, she founded AWAA with a mission to break barriers and provide opportunities for underrepresented girls in STEM. Through the organization, she helped create scholarships and provided discounted flight training for aspiring female pilots. Her nonprofit, headquartered at 7201 S Airport Rd. in Pembroke Pines, says it will continue her legacy. Donations can be made in her honor to Asian Women in Aerospace and Aviation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, to fund scholarships and mentorship programs. 'We will use the funds to continue her dream of helping young girls pursue their dreams,' the nonprofit said. In her last post to the internet Nguyen told her audience 'Let's keep flying forward together.'
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
Woman who died in Indiana plane crash was trying to fly solo around the world
Anh-Thu Nguyen, 44, wanted to be the first Vietnamese woman to complete a solo flight around the world. Her journey ended prematurely after her airplane crashed in Greenwood, Indiana, on July 30. The Johnson County coroner has identified Nguyen, a flight instructor and a Purdue University graduate, as the pilot killed in the small-plane crash. Nguyen was on the second leg of her journey. She left the Indy South Greenwood Airport at 10:45 a.m. and was en route to an airport in Pennsylvania, according to flight records from Flightaware. A few minutes after taking off from the Greenwood airport, Nguyen's 2005 Lancair IV-P was seen spiraling out of the air. The plane ultimately landed on a hill behind a Circle K gas station. Frank Williams, a witness to the crash, said the airplane was quiet as it fell from the sky. "There was no explosion, and there was no fire. I pulled right up, and I could smell fuel. As I got close to the plane, I could tell there wasn't a survivor," Williams said. It's unclear what led to the crash. The Federal Aviation Administration and the National Transportation Safety Board are investigating. Who was Anh-Thu Nguyen? Nguyen, a 2015 Purdue graduate, wanted to inspire other Asian women to get in the cockpit. She started Asian Women in Aerospace and Aviation Inc., a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization in 2018 and became the chief flight instructor at Dragon Flight Training Academy in Georgia. Nguyen was born in Vietnam, moving to the United States when she was 12 years old. She received a bachelor' of science's in math and a master's in aeronautics and astronautics engineering from Purdue University. She received a doctoral degree in aeronautics and astronautics engineering from Georgia Institue of Technology. "As an Asian woman, I faced many obstacles and challenges to get to where I am today, especially adapting to a new culture, language, and life in the United States. I wanted to give back and inspire the next generation," she told Purdue University. Nguyen originally conceived the idea of becoming the first Vietnamese woman to complete a solo flight around the world in 2019, but due to a number of issues, her plans were pushed back. On July 27, 2025, Nguyen officially started the journey when she flew out of Oshkosh, Wisconsin, toward Indiana. On July 30, before Nguyen left the Greenwood airport, she posted an update about her journey on social media. "I just completed the first leg of my solo flight around the world," she said. "This is more than just a flight. It's a mission to inspire the next generation of Asian female pilots and aerospace engineers and STEM professionals." Her death has come as a shock to many who were following the start of her journey on Facebook, Instagram and Threads. The comment sections of her videos were filled with "rest in peace" messages. Noe Padilla is a Public Safety reporter for IndyStar. Contact him at npadilla@ follow him on X @1NoerPadilla or on Bluesky @
