Residential plots in Karachi: Notification legalising commercial activities withdrawn by SBCA
Sindh High Court (SHC) heard a petition filed by Jamaat-e-Islami Karachi challenging the Sindh government's move to legalize the commercial use of residential plots.
During the proceedings, Director-General of SBCA, Ishaq Khoro, submitted a response in court stating that the notification issued on March 13 has been withdrawn.
Following this, the SHC issued a brief order and disposed-off the petition.
The petition was filed by opposition leader of the City Council, Saifuddin Advocate, along with nine town chairmen.
Saifuddin Advocate hailed the development as a victory for the public of Karachi, describing the move to allow commercial use of residential plots as part of a conspiracy to damage the city.
He noted that Jamaat-e-Islami's constitutional struggle had been successful, emphasizing that the city's layout should not be distorted.
He also pledged to continue the fight against illegal commercial activities, demanding accountability for those responsible for the plot to alter the city's master plan.
He added that the decision to legalize commercial use of residential areas was driven by the personal interests of a few, to the detriment of the city's future.
Earlier, the SHC had clubbed petitions of Jamaat Islami and Pasban challenging amendments to the Karachi Building and Town Planning Regulations 2002 with a previous petition under hearing of the court.
Jamaat Islami's lawyer argued before the court that a residential plot could not be used for commercial activities. 'There is a procedure to convert the residential plot into commercial,' JI lawyer argued.
'It required an NOC from the Master Plan, KDA and other concerned departments as well as meeting necessary preconditions,' the lawyer said.
'After the amendment in regulations, only the SBCA's NOC required to convert the residential plot into commercial,' JI lawyer said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
‘Ethics should be taught to everyone, not just to minority students,' says Sindh MPA
KARACHI: Concerns over minority education rights, illegal construction in Karachi, and transport reforms dominated the latest session of the Sindh Assembly on Friday, highlighting a growing demand for inclusive policymaking and transparent governance across multiple sectors. Minority legislator from MQM, Mahesh Kumar Hasija drew the House's attention to the controversial allocation of the Ethics subject exclusively for non-Muslim students in the official curriculum. 'Ethics should be taught to everyone, not just to minority students,' said Hasija, urging the government to replace it with an alternative subject for non-Muslims, noting that minority students have never objected to the presence of Islamic Studies in the curriculum. He also demanded a separate board to cater to the educational needs of the Christian community. Responding to the notice, Sindh Education Minister Sardar Shah acknowledged the flaws in the current curriculum, which was introduced during the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf government under a single national framework. 'We reviewed the curriculum in 2022 and recognize that further improvements are necessary,' he said, adding that curriculum development is an ongoing process that must evolve with global standards. He noted that most non-Muslim students in Sindh belong to the Hindu community, underscoring the historical roots of Hinduism in the region. Multiple attention notices were also raised during the session on pressing civic issues. MQM MPA Fauzia Hameed expressed concern over the unchecked proliferation of illegal constructions in Karachi, blaming the Sindh Building Control Authority (SBCA) for systemic corruption and negligence. 'There are over 15,000 illegal structures, especially in areas like Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Orangi, Liaquatabad, and Korangi. If SBCA didn't grant approvals, how did these buildings emerge?' she questioned. Parliamentary Secretary Qasim Siraj Soomro responded that action has been taken against responsible individuals and that the government is committed to curbing unauthorized developments. In response to a separate notice by MQM's Najam Mirza concerning the Centralized Admission Policy (CAP), Sardar Shah clarified that the policy has now been extended province-wide, and the admission process is entirely computerized to eliminate human interference. He emphasized that admissions are merit-based, prioritizing students with A1 and A grades. Shah pointed out that some institutions like PECHS College receive disproportionately high application volumes, and it is not feasible to accommodate everyone's preferences. He also highlighted faculty shortages in key areas such as computer science despite rising student interest. Law Minister Ziaul Hasan Lanjar tabled various audit reports in the house, which were subsequently referred to the Public Accounts Committee. He also introduced an amendment to the Sindh Civil Servants Act, which was unanimously passed. Under the new law, government employees can now retire after 25 years of service or at the age of 55, whichever comes first. Additionally, a provincial motor vehicles amendment bill was introduced and sent to the relevant standing committee for review. Meanwhile, Sindh's Senior Minister for Information and Transport, Sharjeel Inam Memon, shared updates on ongoing transport projects. He said the government remains committed to improving mobility for all citizens, noting that the People's Bus Service is currently serving 110,000 passengers daily. New electric buses and scooters are expected by the end of August, with electric scooters to be distributed free of charge to women. Memon emphasized that the province was the first in Pakistan to introduce EV buses and that work is underway to link all BRT corridors for greater efficiency. Karachi will also see the development of two new bus terminals, with funds allocated in the current budget. He added that route permits, once manually issued, are now digitized and that the entire transport department will be digitalized by 2026, marking a significant administrative overhaul. The session, presided over by Speaker Awais Qadir Shah, also reflected a festive mood as female members wore green outfits and white dupattas in celebration of the upcoming Independence Day. The Assembly will reconvene on Monday at 1:30 p.m. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
SHC suspends ombudsman's order against KE CEO
The Sindh High Court (SHC) on Tuesday suspended the provincial ombudsman's order to remove K-Electric Chief Executive Officer Moonis Alvi and impose a Rs2.5 million fine in a workplace harassment case filed by a former company executive. A two-judge bench comprising Justice Faisal Kamal Alam and Justice Hassan Akbar gave the order while hearing a petition filed by Moonis Alvi, who challenged the ombudsman's ruling on grounds of jurisdiction and procedural flaws. The petitioner appeared in court with his counsel, Barrister Abid Zuberi, who argued that the provincial ombudsman had no legal authority to decide the case as K-Electric is an inter-provincial organisation, supplying electricity beyond Sindh to areas including Lasbela, Hub, and Winder. Barrister Zuberi further argued that such cases fall under the jurisdiction of the federal ombudsman, not the provincial one. He also questioned the legal soundness of the ombudsman's findings, citing previous precedents where jurisdictional conflicts arose in similar cases involving the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC) and labour courts. Barrister Zuberi pointed out that the complaint relied heavily on WhatsApp messages and that the proceedings lacked due process. Justice Alam inquired about the legal grounds of the provincial ombudsman's decision, to which the petitioner's counsel responded that both the removal order and the monetary penalty were unlawful. He prayed the court annul the decision and grant interim relief. The bench suspended the implementation of the ombudsman's decision and directed the petitioner to deposit the Rs2.5 million in fine with the SHC registrar. The court did not grant the petitioner's plea for a reduction in the amount. It also issued notices to the provincial ombudsman and the complainant, Mehreen Zehra - former chief marketing officer at KE - for August 8. Later in the day, the SHC issued a written order, noting that the provincial ombudsman lacks jurisdiction over complaints involving inter-provincial institutions and that such matters fall within the federal ombudsman's purview. The written order directed the deputy attorney general, the advocate general Sindh, and other relevant parties to submit their replies before the next hearing. The court also warned that failure to deposit the Rs2.5 million by the petitioner would result in the revocation of the interim relief. On Thursday, the provincial ombudsman found Moonis Alvi guilty of harassment and ordered his removal from office, along with the imposition of the penalty. The court will take up the case again on August 8.
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Over 110,000 use PBS daily: Sharjeel
People's Bus Service is operating successfully across Sindh, currently serving over 110,000 passengers daily, said Sindh Senior Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon on Friday. Sindh government is committed to providing quality transportation facilities to the public across the province, he said during the question-hour session in the Sindh Assembly regarding the Transport and Mass Transit Department. He added that the government is planning to expand the fleet to address the longstanding transport crisis in Karachi and other parts of the province. The assembly session was chaired by Speaker Awais Qadir Shah. In a symbolic celebration of Independence Day, women lawmakers attended the session dressed in green outfits and white dupattas, reflecting a festive patriotic atmosphere in the House. In response to a written and supplementary question from MQM MPA Dr. Fauzia Hameed, Minister Memon confirmed the government's provision of subsidies for the bus service and outlined further plans, including the launch of Pakistan's first electric vehicles (EV) for public transport. "EV buses and scooters will be introduced by the end of August. The scooters will be distributed free of cost to women," he announced. Minister Memon further highlighted digital reforms in the transport department: "Previously, vehicle route permits were handled manually. Now we are digitizing the entire process. By 2026, the entire transport department will be fully digitized. Route permits have already been digitized." Illegal constructions Raising a call-attention notice, MQM MPA Dr. Fauzia Hameed criticized the Sindh Building Control Authority (SBCA) for widespread illegal constructions in Karachi. She claimed that more than 15,000 unauthorized structures have emerged, particularly in Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Orangi Town, Liaquatabad, and Korangi. "If SBCA didn't grant approval, how did these constructions happen? Clearly, corruption is involved," she alleged. In response, Parliamentary Secretary Qasim Siraj Soomro said action had been taken against several individuals and the government was "seriously committed" to curbing illegal construction activities.
