Israeli opposition appeals against intel chief sacking
Opposition leader Yair Lapid's centre-right Yesh Atid party said it had appealed against Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar's dismissal before the Supreme Court of Israel in the name of several opposition movements.
Yesh Atid denounced what it called "a decision based on flagrant conflict of interest".
The Movement for Quality Government in Israel also appealed against what it said was "an unlawful decision... posing a real risk to the national security of the State of Israel".
The NGO was previously very active in the fight against a controversial move by Netanyahu to curb the judiciary's independence.
The reform was seen by opponents as a danger to Israel's democracy and the rule of law, and sparked one of the largest protest movements in Israel's history.
The separate appeals were launched hours after the government moved to dismiss Bar, with Netanyahu previously citing an "ongoing lack of trust" in him.
Netanyahu's office said later the government would meet on Sunday for a no confidence vote on the country's attorney general, a vocal critic of the prime minister.
"We resolve to express our lack of confidence in the government's legal adviser, Gali Baharav-Miara, due to her inappropriate behaviour and due to significant and prolonged differences between the government and the government's legal adviser," said a cabinet meeting agenda published on the office's website on Friday.
Thousands of Israelis braved cold and rainy weather on Thursday night to protest against the moves against Bar and Baharav-Miara outside Israel's parliament and Netanyahu's home in Jerusalem.
- Opposition appeal -
The opposition's appeal was filed in the name of Yesh Atid as well as the National Union party headed by former defence minister Benny Gantz, the leftist Democrats alliance and nationalist party Yisrael Beiteinu.
Their appeal highlights what critics see as the two main reasons Netanyahu moved against Bar, who had joined the agency in 1993.
The first was his criticism of the government over the security failure that allowed Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack on Israel to become the deadliest day in the country's history.
The second was what media dubbed "Qatargate" -- an investigation into government members paid by Qatar to promote its image.
The decision to sack Bar came "as Israel's Security Agency is currently investigating the prime minister's close associates... on suspicion of receiving money from entities directly linked to and acting on behalf of the State of Qatar", the opposition's appeal read.
The appeal also mentioned the sacking took place after a Shin Bet investigation highlighting, according to the plaintiffs, "that the political leadership bears responsibility for the October 7 disaster".
- Fault lines -
Netanyahu's move revived deep divisions within Israeli society, with many concerned by what they see as the latest iteration of Netanyahu's autocratic slip.
In a video published Thursday, Israeli President Isaac Herzog deplored the government's "controversial moves" that "deepened divisions" in Israel while it is still at war in the Gaza Strip.
A poll by Israel's Channel 12 television network found that 51 percent of Israelis were opposed to Bar's sacking, while 32 percent supported it.
A plurality of 46 percent says they trust Bar more than Netanyahu.
The crisis comes against the backdrop of new Israeli bombings on Gaza since Tuesday and the reintegration into the government of one of Israel's far-right figures, Itamar Ben Gvir.
Ben Gvir had resigned from his position as national security minister to protest the ceasefire with Hamas that came into effect on January 19.
"It's impossible not to be deeply troubled by the harsh reality unfolding before our eyes," Herzog said on Thursday night.
The president said it was "unthinkable to resume fighting while still pursuing the sacred mission of bringing our hostages home" from Gaza.
dms-lba/dv
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Israel rejects Hamas's demand to release living terrorists in exchange for hostage bodies
Hamas has informed mediators that it will not enter negotiations with Israel until the humanitarian situation in Gaza improves, according to two sources who spoke with The Jerusalem Post. Israel has issued a formal response to a position paper sent by Hamas several days ago, where Israeli officials made it clear they reject Hamas's demand to release live terrorists in exchange for the bodies of hostages. Hamas has informed mediators that it will not enter negotiations with Israel until the humanitarian situation in Gaza improves, according to two sources who spoke with The Jerusalem Post. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu discussed partial annexation of the Gaza Strip as a potential course of action if hostage deal talks fail, during a Monday small cabinet meeting – an Israeli source confirmed to The Jerusalem Post on Tuesday. Defense Minister Israel Katz stated on Wednesday, 'Israel is making extraordinary efforts to secure the release of the hostages, while applying heavy pressure on Hamas in Gaza. If Hamas does not soon announce the release of the hostages, it will pay a very heavy price.' Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump's Special Envoy Steve Witkoff is expected to arrive in Israel on Thursday as part of an effort to advance negotiations for a hostage deal and to assess the humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip. Witkoff's visit comes as Israeli officials warn that if there is no progress in the coming days on a deal to release the hostages, Israel may be forced to take further action on the ground. Witkoff concerned over Ben-Gvir, Smotrich's political pressure possibility, reports indicate Witkoff is worried that National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich might sabotage the deal due to political pressures on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, a concern shared by the American administration, according to a Ynet report. During his visit, he may request to meet directly with them in an attempt to convince them to support the move at this critical juncture, the report added. Sources familiar with Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist organizations reported to the London-based Asharq Al-Awsat newspaper earlier this week that the mediators are working to organize a new round of negotiations. 'The goal is to reach an agreement on the points still in dispute, as many of the issues were already resolved in the previous round of negotiations,' sources said. They also noted that the next round of talks would focus on Israel's expected response to the proposals Hamas sent to the mediators a few days ago. The Hostage Families Forum called on Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to publicly declare his willingness to sign a comprehensive agreement in response to a video message Netanyahu sent to the hostage families via the Coordinator for the Hostages and the Missing Persons, Brig.-Gen. (Res.) Gal Hirsch, KAN noted. 'We will continue to act responsibly, as we always have, and we will continue to strive for the return of our hostages and the defeat of Hamas,' the Prime Minister's Office said. 'This is the only way to ensure peace for both Israelis and Palestinians.' Yonah Jeremy Bob and Liran Haroni contributed to this report.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
WATCH: US, Israel have new understanding for hostage talks as they reach impasse
Witkoff, who is also likely to visit aid sites across Gaza, traveled to the Middle East as ceasefire and hostage deal talks between Israel and Hamas have stalled. Israel and the United States have formed a new understanding, given Hamas's intransigence, that there is a need to shift the negotiating framework, a senior Israeli official told The Jerusalem Post Staff Thursday, following the meeting between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and US Envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff. There is a need to switch the framework of releasing some of the hostages to a framework that includes the release of all hostages, the disarmament of Hamas, and the demilitarization of Gaza. Concurrently, Israel and the US will work to increase humanitarian aid while continuing military operations in Gaza. Topics discussed during the meeting are believed to have included the Gaza ceasefire talks, returning hostages from Hamas captivity, and Iran. Witkoff's visit comes as Israeli officials warn that if there is no progress in the coming days on a deal to release the hostages, Israel may be forced to take further action on the ground in Gaza. According to two sources who spoke with thePost, Hamas has informed mediators that it will not enter negotiations with Israel until the humanitarian situation in Gaza improves. Witkoff to visit Gaza Strip Witkoff is also likely to visit the Gaza Strip, including the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation centers, according to a Ynet report. Hostage families and activists held protests calling on Witkoff to bring about a ceasefire and the return of their relatives, stating that he "has the power to bring about a deal," according to Israeli public broadcaster KAN News. Walla contributed to this report.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
PIJ claims it lost contact with terrorists holding hostage Rom Braslavski
The Braslavski family said in a statement that Israeli officials were refusing to meet with them and provide updates on Rom's condition. Palestinian Islamic Jihad claimed on Tuesday that the terror group's leadership had lost contact on Monday with the terror cell members holding Israeli hostage Rom Braslavski in the Gaza Strip after Israeli forces besieged an area in Gaza where Braslavski was believed to be held. 'No one knows where Rom is—not the IDF, not PIJ. The only thing we were ever told is that he is being held alone," the Braslavski family said in a statement, adding that they were heartbroken and in pain over the news. The family added that they had demanded a meeting of senior Israeli defense officials to update them on Rom's status, but only one member of the security council responded. "We want to know where our son is. We want those responsible to sit with us and present the full picture—not fragments of information or partial truths." Braslavski family heartbroken after PIJ statement The family added that they completely disagreed with National Missions Minister Orit Strock's statements that the IDF should expand operations in Gaza even at the risk of the hostages' lives. 'There should be no 'do not touch zones' in Gaza. To win this war, we need to take control of these areas as well,' the Religious Zionist Party MK said, adding that the IDF must fight against Hamas and other Gaza terrorist groups in all parts of the enclave and defeat them. "She should try putting herself in our position. If she could feel what I, Tami, feel as a mother, she wouldn't be able to speak the way she did," the statement read. "When people in government imagine themselves in our place, maybe decisions would be different. Let's see if then they'd still prioritize land over hostages." Braslavski was kidnapped from the Nova Music Festival on October 7, 2023; he was a medic who reportedly stayed behind to help others at the festival. He was 19 at the time of his abduction, but is now 21. His family has said that they have received very little information about his whereabouts during his time in captivity. 'For more than a year, we haven't had a single shred of information about what's happening to him,' his cousin, Adam Hajj, told KAN. Hajj added that the family had no idea 'whether he's eating or drinking, or if he's even being warmed.' Yair Golan denounces event as 'nightmare coming true' The Democrats Party leader MK Yair Golan denounced the news on X/Twitter, stating that "As we warned, if we do not bring back the hostages, we risk losing them forever." "For the people of Israel, this is a nightmare coming true; for the Israeli government, it is policy," he added. "I embrace the Breslavsky family and pray that Rom returns home safely and soon. We must reach a deal now, we must bring back the hostages in one phase, now," he concluded.
