Farmer guilty of severe animal abuse gets further ban
A negligent Otago dairy farmer has been banned from owning animals for another five years after failing to get rid of her livestock.
Carolyn Sybil Ireland came before the Dunedin District Court in 2022, where a catalogue of severe animal abuse was detailed.
Animal welfare inspectors found dead and emaciated livestock across her 180ha Omimi property, and Ireland was fined $15,000 and ordered to pay veterinary fees of more than $11,000.
She was banned from owning animals for five years, but the Ministry for Primary Industries gave her two months to muster her remaining cattle and transport them off the farm.
The court yesterday heard Ireland tasked a stock agent to sell them but, due to "poor fencing, wild-natured cattle, chronic poor management and various logistical problems", the deadline was not met.
In April 2023, the defendant was given a letter re-emphasising the need to clear her property of the remaining stock.
But the herd continued to grow.
Court documents said there were further failed attempts to muster the cattle and some were reportedly shot by helicopter.
Fifteen were finally "destocked" in September that year, but it was not enough.
Another letter was sent to Ireland encouraging her to contact stock agents or home-kill operators, and warned her of the consequences of non-compliance.
By April 2024 — 18 months after her court appearance — animal welfare inspectors used a drone to locate at least 60 cattle.
Ireland had not been trying to keep the stock, she said, "it's just simply that they have been difficult to get in."
There was limited success in July when 60 cattle were penned by a local farmer and removed from the site but some evaded mustering.
Finally, a couple of months later, Ireland leased her property to another farmer to run his stock on the hill block once all hers was removed.
To make it worse, the ministry said, the defendant had failed to comply with identification and tracing regulations as well as tuberculosis testing during the period.
Counsel Andrew Belcher told the court Ireland was "very, very remorseful to be here, and ashamed".
"Everything's gone now. She realises that's it for any further livestock," he said.
Judge David Robinson convicted Ireland of contravening a disqualification order under the Animal Welfare Act and banned her from animal ownership for another five years. Dairy debacle
Sept 2021: Inspectors find nine dead cattle and many severely emaciated at Ireland's property, following numerous interventions since 2013.
Oct 2022: She is fined $15,000, ordered to pay vet costs of $11,179 and banned from animal ownership for five years.
Apr 2023: Ireland's herd continues to grow despite attempts to destock, some shot by helicopter.
Sept: Fifteen cattle removed from the farm.
Dec: Ireland is warned by the ministry about non-compliance with the ownership ban.
Apr 2024: Inspectors use a drone to locate at least 60 cattle on the loose.
Jul: A local farmer pens 60 but some evade mustering.
Oct: Ireland leases her property to another farmer.
Jun 2025: The court imposes another five-year disqualification on animal ownership.
rob.kidd@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Farmer guilty of severe animal abuse gets further ban
A negligent Otago dairy farmer has been banned from owning animals for another five years after failing to get rid of her livestock. Carolyn Sybil Ireland came before the Dunedin District Court in 2022, where a catalogue of severe animal abuse was detailed. Animal welfare inspectors found dead and emaciated livestock across her 180ha Omimi property, and Ireland was fined $15,000 and ordered to pay veterinary fees of more than $11,000. She was banned from owning animals for five years, but the Ministry for Primary Industries gave her two months to muster her remaining cattle and transport them off the farm. The court yesterday heard Ireland tasked a stock agent to sell them but, due to "poor fencing, wild-natured cattle, chronic poor management and various logistical problems", the deadline was not met. In April 2023, the defendant was given a letter re-emphasising the need to clear her property of the remaining stock. But the herd continued to grow. Court documents said there were further failed attempts to muster the cattle and some were reportedly shot by helicopter. Fifteen were finally "destocked" in September that year, but it was not enough. Another letter was sent to Ireland encouraging her to contact stock agents or home-kill operators, and warned her of the consequences of non-compliance. By April 2024 — 18 months after her court appearance — animal welfare inspectors used a drone to locate at least 60 cattle. Ireland had not been trying to keep the stock, she said, "it's just simply that they have been difficult to get in." There was limited success in July when 60 cattle were penned by a local farmer and removed from the site but some evaded mustering. Finally, a couple of months later, Ireland leased her property to another farmer to run his stock on the hill block once all hers was removed. To make it worse, the ministry said, the defendant had failed to comply with identification and tracing regulations as well as tuberculosis testing during the period. Counsel Andrew Belcher told the court Ireland was "very, very remorseful to be here, and ashamed". "Everything's gone now. She realises that's it for any further livestock," he said. Judge David Robinson convicted Ireland of contravening a disqualification order under the Animal Welfare Act and banned her from animal ownership for another five years. Dairy debacle Sept 2021: Inspectors find nine dead cattle and many severely emaciated at Ireland's property, following numerous interventions since 2013. Oct 2022: She is fined $15,000, ordered to pay vet costs of $11,179 and banned from animal ownership for five years. Apr 2023: Ireland's herd continues to grow despite attempts to destock, some shot by helicopter. Sept: Fifteen cattle removed from the farm. Dec: Ireland is warned by the ministry about non-compliance with the ownership ban. Apr 2024: Inspectors use a drone to locate at least 60 cattle on the loose. Jul: A local farmer pens 60 but some evade mustering. Oct: Ireland leases her property to another farmer. Jun 2025: The court imposes another five-year disqualification on animal ownership.
Otago Daily Times
5 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Texts and emails help sink illegal Southland fishing ring
Text and emails helped uncover an illegal seafood black market in Southland which has resulted in fines of almost $37,000. Commercial fishers Michael Noel Hawke (61), Stuart Teiwi Ryan (48) and Peter George Fletcher (32) were sentenced in the Invercargill District Court after pleading guilty to multiple charges under the Fisheries Act. Another man, Duncan William Davis (39) was sentenced on two charges for illegally selling a large amount of kina, some pāua and blue cod, following a successful prosecution by the Ministry for Primary Industries. Mr Hawke was fined $6000, Mr Ryan $13,000, Mr Fletcher $3900, and Mr Davis $14,000. The prosecution was part of a larger 2023 investigation into illegal sales of kina, pāua, crayfish, blue cod and oysters. Fishery Officers gathered evidence of the illegal sales by studying seafood landing records and electronic communications between the fishers, black-market suppliers and potential buyers, MPI said in a statement. The electronic communications included text messages, emails, and messages on other platforms. 'Our investigation found Mr Hawke sold about 1000 dredge oysters during the 2023 season that were not part of his allowable commercial take. They were his allowable recreational take and should have been in his landing report," Fisheries New Zealand district manager Greg Forbes said. 'Based on 2023 prices of $37 a dozen, the oysters were valued at more than $3,000. Bluff is the only wild oyster fishery in the world and selling fish illegally has a serious effect on sustainability.' The investigation found a deckhand aboard the fishing vessel was also selling his allowable recreational catch. 'Mr Ryan was found to have sold 114 crayfish and about 40 blue cod. Crayfish retails at about $140 a kg and blue cod $75 a kg. Mr Ryan made around $2,250 in illegal earnings. 'Most commercial fishers follow the rules because they want their fishery to remain sustainable into the future – black-market sales of recreational catch is a slap in the face to the majority of commercial fishers who do the right thing.' Electronic evidence found Mr Davis, who is not a commercial fisher, sold seafood including up to 400 punnets of kina roe, some pāua and blue cod on the black market he had either caught, or bought from Mr Ryan to resell. 'This was up to $5000 of kina that was sold illegally and finfish valued at about $2000. This was deliberate and the motivation was simply to make money.' Fishery Officers found the third commercial fisher, Mr Fletcher, sold about 200 dredge oysters illegally on about six occasions. - APL
Scoop
5 days ago
- Scoop
Southland Commercial Fishers And Seller Fined $36,900 For Black-Market Seafood Sales
Thousands of dollars of black-market seafood sales have cost three Southland commercial fishers and another man fines of $36,900. Commercial fishers Michael Noel Hawke (61), Stuart Teiwi Ryan (48) and Peter George Fletcher (32) were sentenced in the Invercargill District Court having pleaded guilty to multiple charges under the Fisheries Act. Another man, Duncan William Davis (39) was sentenced on two charges under the Fisheries Act for illegally selling a large amount of kina, some pāua and blue cod, following a successful prosecution by the Ministry for Primary Industries. Mr Hawke was fined $6,000, Mr Ryan $13,000, Mr Fletcher $3,900, and Mr Davis $14,000. The prosecution was part of a larger 2023 investigation into illegal sales of kina, pāua, crayfish, blue cod and oysters. Fishery Officers gathered evidence of the illegal sales by studying seafood landing records and electronic communications between the fishers, black-market suppliers and potential buyers. 'Our investigation found Mr Hawke sold about 1000 dredge oysters during the 2023 season that were not part of his allowable commercial take. They were his allowable recreational take and should have been in his landing report. 'Based on 2023 prices of $37 a dozen, the oysters were valued at more than $3,000. Bluff is the only wild oyster fishery in the world and selling fish illegally has a serious effect on sustainability,' says Greg Forbes, Fisheries New Zealand District Manager. The investigation found a deckhand aboard the fishing vessel was also selling his allowable recreational catch. 'Mr Ryan was found to have sold 114 crayfish and about 40 blue cod. Crayfish retails at about $140 a kg and blue cod $75 a kg. Mr Ryan made around $2,250 in illegal earnings. 'Most commercial fishers follow the rules because they want their fishery to remain sustainable into the future – black-market sales of recreational catch is a slap in the face to the majority of commercial fishers who do the right thing.' Electronic evidence found Mr Davis, who is not a commercial fisher, sold seafood including up to 400 punnets of kina roe, some pāua and blue cod on the black market he had either caught, or bought from Mr Ryan to resell. 'This was up to $5000 of kina that was sold illegally and finfish valued at about $2000. This was deliberate and the motivation was simply to make money.' Meanwhile, Fishery Officers found the third commercial fisher, Mr Fletcher, sold about 200 dredge oysters illegally on about six occasions. 'None of these fishers held permits allowing them to sell fish, nor were they Licensed Fish Receivers or fish farmers. When we find evidence of deliberate illegal sales of seafood – we will take action. 'Poachers steal from everyone because the shared resources belong to all New Zealanders. Their behaviour also undermines the Quota Management System and our reputation for sustainable kaimoana,' Mr Forbes says.
