'Being Jewish in France today means being alone'
The author of these lines is 47 years old. He is French and he is Jewish. For decades, this dual identity did not weigh on him in the slightest. He carried it with a discretion tinged by an awareness of history and a quiet sense of pride.
Everything changed 18 months ago. Admitting this costs me: I have had to overcome a certain fear to publish this op-ed. The fear of isolation; the fear of being reduced to a condition I would have preferred not to have to justify. It is first and foremost this fear that I wish to express. Because the mere fact that it is uncontrollable says a great deal about our country and the direction it is taking.
"It's not easy to be Jewish": What happened to make these words by Charles Péguy, written in 1910 in his essay Notre Jeunesse (Memories of Youth), applicable to France in 2025? Antisemitism has become part of the zeitgeist. It is present every day, almost unconsciously. It no longer emerges only on those rare occasions that a vigilant society once recognized and punished – as in 2014, when shows in which [antisemite comedian] Dieudonné insulted Jews and, mixing vulgarity with abjection, mocked their past suffering and present anxiety, were shut down. Today, thousands of little Dieudonnés thrive, from the Assemblée Nationale to university lecterns. Their calm hatred is becoming a dominant ideology.
Words have lost their meaning
This collapse, like all moral failures, began with a matter of vocabulary. Words have lost their meaning. Two in particular, whose misuse has greatly contributed to offending Jewish sensibilities in France: "genocide" and "Zionist."
"Genocide": It was not as a reference, for example, to the Sudanese war in 2023, with its tens of thousands dead and millions displaced, that this term has become firmly established in public opinion. No, it was carefully turned, with a certain perverse sophistication, against the country created to serve as a refuge for the survivors of the extermination of three-quarters of Europe's Jews. And it has been hammered home until it produced the ultimate offense: equating Israel with the Nazis. Jews, who are, in their hearts and in their very being, orphans of the Holocaust, now find themselves cast as the heirs of their executioners. It is a dagger driven, day after day, into the wounded memory of the Jewish people.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
5 hours ago
- France 24
Israeli attack on Tehran's Evin prison killed 71, Iran judiciary says
An Israeli strike on Tehran's Evin prison during this month's 12-day war killed at least 71 people, Iran 's judiciary said Sunday, days after a ceasefire ended hostilities between the two arch-foes. The strike on Monday destroyed part of the administrative building at Evin, a large, heavily fortified complex in the north of Tehran, which rights groups say holds political prisoners and foreign nationals. "According to official figures, 71 people were killed in the attack on Evin prison," said judiciary spokesman Asghar Jahangir of the attack, part of the bombardment campaign Israel launched on June 13. According to Jahangir, the victims at Evin included administrative staff, guards, prisoners and visiting relatives as well as people living nearby. Images shared by the judiciary showed destroyed walls, collapsed ceilings, scattered debris, and broken surfaces across waiting areas at the facility. The judiciary said that Evin's medical centre and visiting rooms had been targeted. On Tuesday, a day after the strike, the judiciary said that the Iranian prison authority had transferred inmates out of Evin prison, without specifying their number or identifying them. The inmates at Evin have included Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi as well as several French nationals and other foreigners.
Euronews
17 hours ago
- Euronews
Commissioner and MEPs in Budapest to challenge Orban's Pride ban
Around 70 MEPs from the liberal, green and left wing of the European Parliament joined the Belgian equality commissioner in Budapest on Saturday afternoon, as thousands of protestors marched through the Hungarian capital, waving rainbow and EU flags. The MEPs were primarily from the liberal Renew Europe, Socialists & Democrats, the Left and Greens groups, joined by one Irish European People's Party (EPP) MEP, Maria Walsh. Tens of thousands joined the march, with organisers claiming as many as 200,000 were on the streets. 'Long before I got into politics, and long before I leave, I'll be showing up for Pride. For me and for my values, Pride is incredibly important. I only wish more were here, but I joined together with over 70 other MEPs from across political parties,' Walsh told Euronews. 'It's not about one party versus the other party. It's about one human being showing up for another,' she added, when quizzed on the fact that there was no EPP delegation with her. 'I would have preferred that more EPP people would have joined the event. I think it's disappointing because this is an important mobilisation,' the President of Renew Europe, Valérie Hayer, told Euronews. 'We have noted, since the start of this term, that the EPP is wavering between the democratic forces and the extreme right. It's a pity that the EPP doesn't understand who their adversaries are," said French socialist MEP Emma Rafowicz. A notable EPP absence was Hungarian opposition leader and MEP Peter Magyar. His centre-right party Tisza party is currently leading the governing Fidesz party in opinion polls for the 2026 parliamentary election. Magyar was not in Budapest, avoiding taking a stance of the issue of the thorny issue of the Pride march, which a recent survey indicated divides opinion in the country, with 47% of Hungarians opposed to it taking place. However, earlier in the day he called for a peaceful protest. 'I ask everyone not to fall for any provocation. If anyone gets hurt today in Budapest, if anyone comes to harm, Viktor Orbán alone will be responsible,' Magyar posted to his social platforms. European Commissioner for equality Hadja Lahbib held meetings with local civil society organisations on Friday. However, she did not show up at the march, telling Euronews that she instead would be attending meetings in the city. Risking fines and jail time In March, the Hungarian parliament approved a bill that in effect banned the gay pride march. As the legislation states, this event could violate Hungary's so-called child protection law, adopted earlier in the country, prohibiting any portrayal of same sex relationships for minors. The European Commission views this as a violation of its community law and has referred the case to the European Court of Justice. Conservative and far-right MEPs in the European Parliament defended Orbán's move to ban Pride events, saying the EU should not interfere in Hungary's internal affairs. However, the mayor of Budapest, Gergely Karácsony from the Green party, allowed the parade to go ahead by re-labeling it as a 'Day of Freedom' celebration, officially organized by the city council. This legal loophole allowed the thousands of people to march through the streets of Budapest in sweltering heat, protesting not just the ban Pride ban, but Viktor Orban's government generally. Alongside pride flags and the loud music, there were banners displaying the prime minister. 'I am not a big fan of Pride events, but this extends beyond Pride. This is about freedom too, because Hungary, a European Union country, banning Pride, is simply not on," one attendee told Euronews of his motivations for attending. Security was tight, with security cameras installed on lamp posts in the city centre and hundreds of police officers deployed at key spots of the parade, keeping watch over protesters and ensuring there were no clashes. Attendees were warned by the Hungarian Ministry of Justice that parade organisers risked up to a year in prison, and that those marching could be fined €500. The police have been encouraged by the government to use facial recognition technology to identify the attendees, although Karácsony insists that nobody will face punishment for their participation in the march. Anti-LGBT protesters also assembled in Budapest The nationalist 64 Counties Youth Movement held a legally sanctioned event on the same square in Budapest where Pride participants later gathered. Meanwhile, the Our Homeland Movement, a small far-right parliamentary party, organised a police-approved counter-march along the same route as the municipal Pride event. However, during the day the far-right protest was blocked by a strong police presence to avoid conflict. No major incidents were reported by the evening, although Euronews witnessed a confrontation between a small group of the 64 Counties Youth Movement – holding a banner comparing LGBT people to paedophiles and the Pride March. 'We are here because we want to warn the people of Hungary about the LGBT paedophilia, it is a really danger for our children,' one anti-LGBT protester told Euronews. Another anti-Pride protester tried to stop the march by standing in front of the truck leading the parade. He was jeered by the crowd and removed by the police.
LeMonde
21 hours ago
- LeMonde
'Being Jewish in France today means being alone'
The author of these lines is 47 years old. He is French and he is Jewish. For decades, this dual identity did not weigh on him in the slightest. He carried it with a discretion tinged by an awareness of history and a quiet sense of pride. Everything changed 18 months ago. Admitting this costs me: I have had to overcome a certain fear to publish this op-ed. The fear of isolation; the fear of being reduced to a condition I would have preferred not to have to justify. It is first and foremost this fear that I wish to express. Because the mere fact that it is uncontrollable says a great deal about our country and the direction it is taking. "It's not easy to be Jewish": What happened to make these words by Charles Péguy, written in 1910 in his essay Notre Jeunesse (Memories of Youth), applicable to France in 2025? Antisemitism has become part of the zeitgeist. It is present every day, almost unconsciously. It no longer emerges only on those rare occasions that a vigilant society once recognized and punished – as in 2014, when shows in which [antisemite comedian] Dieudonné insulted Jews and, mixing vulgarity with abjection, mocked their past suffering and present anxiety, were shut down. Today, thousands of little Dieudonnés thrive, from the Assemblée Nationale to university lecterns. Their calm hatred is becoming a dominant ideology. Words have lost their meaning This collapse, like all moral failures, began with a matter of vocabulary. Words have lost their meaning. Two in particular, whose misuse has greatly contributed to offending Jewish sensibilities in France: "genocide" and "Zionist." "Genocide": It was not as a reference, for example, to the Sudanese war in 2023, with its tens of thousands dead and millions displaced, that this term has become firmly established in public opinion. No, it was carefully turned, with a certain perverse sophistication, against the country created to serve as a refuge for the survivors of the extermination of three-quarters of Europe's Jews. And it has been hammered home until it produced the ultimate offense: equating Israel with the Nazis. Jews, who are, in their hearts and in their very being, orphans of the Holocaust, now find themselves cast as the heirs of their executioners. It is a dagger driven, day after day, into the wounded memory of the Jewish people.
