Probe called into violent arrest at pro-Palestine rally
The decision on Monday ends days of NSW Police refusals to declare the wounding of Hannah Thomas a critical incident, requiring a full investigation with independent oversight.
The 35-year-old was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets.
Police have faced scrutiny over the arrest after Ms Thomas said the action could result in permanent vision loss in her right eye.
On Monday afternoon, NSW Police said a critical incident investigation had been declared after a review of her medical records, which showed her injury was serious enough to warrant the decision.
"NSW Police had sought medical information from the 35-year-old woman, on multiple occasions, since the incident to determine if her injuries had met the critical incident threshold," a statement said.
A team of officers from another command would investigate the incident, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Earlier, NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden said he had not seen any misconduct on body-worn camera footage of the incident and all officers involved remained on duty.
But lawyer Peter O'Brien, representing Ms Thomas, said he had grave concerns over the force's actions and suggested police felt emboldened to shut down protests after a recent crackdown.
"The recordings demonstrate that there was a fundamental misunderstanding as to the extent of the police officer's powers to give directions leading up to the arrests which ensued," he said.
"Hannah Thomas has sustained a serious and potentially life-altering injury as a result of her interaction with police at the protest."
Posting on social media from her hospital bed, Ms Thomas said "draconian" anti-protest laws had given police a licence "to crack down on peaceful protest in extremely violent, brutal ways".
"I'm five-foot-one, I weigh about 45kg, I was engaged in peaceful protest," she said.
Premier Chris Minns refused to criticise police conduct until further information came to light, underlining a balance of enforcing the law and allowing freedom of political expression.
The protesters accused SEC Plating, in southwest Sydney, of making parts for F-35 jets used by Israel, a claim the firm denies.
Mr Minns denied controversial protest laws passed in February were used by police to move on the demonstrators on Friday morning, as claimed by Greens MPs, or that the laws had emboldened police to act more forcefully.
Police said the protest at SEC Plating was unauthorised and blocked access to the Belmore business.
"A scuffle ensued between police and protesters" during attempts to arrest the protesters for not complying with move-on directions, they said.
A video of the incident showed police dragging one of the protesters as onlookers repeatedly shouted "get off her" and "let go of her".
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged on Sunday with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
She is set to appear at Bankstown Local Court in August.
Footage of Ms Thomas circulating online showed her eye swollen shut and with blood on her face before she was taken to hospital.
All five protesters arrested during the scuffle were granted bail and four will appear in Bankstown Local Court on July 15.
A state police watchdog will oversee a probe into a violent arrest at a pro-Palestine rally that seriously injured a one-time federal Greens candidate.
The decision on Monday ends days of NSW Police refusals to declare the wounding of Hannah Thomas a critical incident, requiring a full investigation with independent oversight.
The 35-year-old was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets.
Police have faced scrutiny over the arrest after Ms Thomas said the action could result in permanent vision loss in her right eye.
On Monday afternoon, NSW Police said a critical incident investigation had been declared after a review of her medical records, which showed her injury was serious enough to warrant the decision.
"NSW Police had sought medical information from the 35-year-old woman, on multiple occasions, since the incident to determine if her injuries had met the critical incident threshold," a statement said.
A team of officers from another command would investigate the incident, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Earlier, NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden said he had not seen any misconduct on body-worn camera footage of the incident and all officers involved remained on duty.
But lawyer Peter O'Brien, representing Ms Thomas, said he had grave concerns over the force's actions and suggested police felt emboldened to shut down protests after a recent crackdown.
"The recordings demonstrate that there was a fundamental misunderstanding as to the extent of the police officer's powers to give directions leading up to the arrests which ensued," he said.
"Hannah Thomas has sustained a serious and potentially life-altering injury as a result of her interaction with police at the protest."
Posting on social media from her hospital bed, Ms Thomas said "draconian" anti-protest laws had given police a licence "to crack down on peaceful protest in extremely violent, brutal ways".
"I'm five-foot-one, I weigh about 45kg, I was engaged in peaceful protest," she said.
Premier Chris Minns refused to criticise police conduct until further information came to light, underlining a balance of enforcing the law and allowing freedom of political expression.
The protesters accused SEC Plating, in southwest Sydney, of making parts for F-35 jets used by Israel, a claim the firm denies.
Mr Minns denied controversial protest laws passed in February were used by police to move on the demonstrators on Friday morning, as claimed by Greens MPs, or that the laws had emboldened police to act more forcefully.
Police said the protest at SEC Plating was unauthorised and blocked access to the Belmore business.
"A scuffle ensued between police and protesters" during attempts to arrest the protesters for not complying with move-on directions, they said.
A video of the incident showed police dragging one of the protesters as onlookers repeatedly shouted "get off her" and "let go of her".
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged on Sunday with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
She is set to appear at Bankstown Local Court in August.
Footage of Ms Thomas circulating online showed her eye swollen shut and with blood on her face before she was taken to hospital.
All five protesters arrested during the scuffle were granted bail and four will appear in Bankstown Local Court on July 15.
A state police watchdog will oversee a probe into a violent arrest at a pro-Palestine rally that seriously injured a one-time federal Greens candidate.
The decision on Monday ends days of NSW Police refusals to declare the wounding of Hannah Thomas a critical incident, requiring a full investigation with independent oversight.
The 35-year-old was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets.
Police have faced scrutiny over the arrest after Ms Thomas said the action could result in permanent vision loss in her right eye.
On Monday afternoon, NSW Police said a critical incident investigation had been declared after a review of her medical records, which showed her injury was serious enough to warrant the decision.
"NSW Police had sought medical information from the 35-year-old woman, on multiple occasions, since the incident to determine if her injuries had met the critical incident threshold," a statement said.
A team of officers from another command would investigate the incident, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Earlier, NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden said he had not seen any misconduct on body-worn camera footage of the incident and all officers involved remained on duty.
But lawyer Peter O'Brien, representing Ms Thomas, said he had grave concerns over the force's actions and suggested police felt emboldened to shut down protests after a recent crackdown.
"The recordings demonstrate that there was a fundamental misunderstanding as to the extent of the police officer's powers to give directions leading up to the arrests which ensued," he said.
"Hannah Thomas has sustained a serious and potentially life-altering injury as a result of her interaction with police at the protest."
Posting on social media from her hospital bed, Ms Thomas said "draconian" anti-protest laws had given police a licence "to crack down on peaceful protest in extremely violent, brutal ways".
"I'm five-foot-one, I weigh about 45kg, I was engaged in peaceful protest," she said.
Premier Chris Minns refused to criticise police conduct until further information came to light, underlining a balance of enforcing the law and allowing freedom of political expression.
The protesters accused SEC Plating, in southwest Sydney, of making parts for F-35 jets used by Israel, a claim the firm denies.
Mr Minns denied controversial protest laws passed in February were used by police to move on the demonstrators on Friday morning, as claimed by Greens MPs, or that the laws had emboldened police to act more forcefully.
Police said the protest at SEC Plating was unauthorised and blocked access to the Belmore business.
"A scuffle ensued between police and protesters" during attempts to arrest the protesters for not complying with move-on directions, they said.
A video of the incident showed police dragging one of the protesters as onlookers repeatedly shouted "get off her" and "let go of her".
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged on Sunday with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
She is set to appear at Bankstown Local Court in August.
Footage of Ms Thomas circulating online showed her eye swollen shut and with blood on her face before she was taken to hospital.
All five protesters arrested during the scuffle were granted bail and four will appear in Bankstown Local Court on July 15.
A state police watchdog will oversee a probe into a violent arrest at a pro-Palestine rally that seriously injured a one-time federal Greens candidate.
The decision on Monday ends days of NSW Police refusals to declare the wounding of Hannah Thomas a critical incident, requiring a full investigation with independent oversight.
The 35-year-old was among five people arrested in Sydney on Friday outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for Israeli Defence Force fighter jets.
Police have faced scrutiny over the arrest after Ms Thomas said the action could result in permanent vision loss in her right eye.
On Monday afternoon, NSW Police said a critical incident investigation had been declared after a review of her medical records, which showed her injury was serious enough to warrant the decision.
"NSW Police had sought medical information from the 35-year-old woman, on multiple occasions, since the incident to determine if her injuries had met the critical incident threshold," a statement said.
A team of officers from another command would investigate the incident, with internal review by professional standards and external oversight from police watchdog the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Earlier, NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden said he had not seen any misconduct on body-worn camera footage of the incident and all officers involved remained on duty.
But lawyer Peter O'Brien, representing Ms Thomas, said he had grave concerns over the force's actions and suggested police felt emboldened to shut down protests after a recent crackdown.
"The recordings demonstrate that there was a fundamental misunderstanding as to the extent of the police officer's powers to give directions leading up to the arrests which ensued," he said.
"Hannah Thomas has sustained a serious and potentially life-altering injury as a result of her interaction with police at the protest."
Posting on social media from her hospital bed, Ms Thomas said "draconian" anti-protest laws had given police a licence "to crack down on peaceful protest in extremely violent, brutal ways".
"I'm five-foot-one, I weigh about 45kg, I was engaged in peaceful protest," she said.
Premier Chris Minns refused to criticise police conduct until further information came to light, underlining a balance of enforcing the law and allowing freedom of political expression.
The protesters accused SEC Plating, in southwest Sydney, of making parts for F-35 jets used by Israel, a claim the firm denies.
Mr Minns denied controversial protest laws passed in February were used by police to move on the demonstrators on Friday morning, as claimed by Greens MPs, or that the laws had emboldened police to act more forcefully.
Police said the protest at SEC Plating was unauthorised and blocked access to the Belmore business.
"A scuffle ensued between police and protesters" during attempts to arrest the protesters for not complying with move-on directions, they said.
A video of the incident showed police dragging one of the protesters as onlookers repeatedly shouted "get off her" and "let go of her".
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged on Sunday with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
She is set to appear at Bankstown Local Court in August.
Footage of Ms Thomas circulating online showed her eye swollen shut and with blood on her face before she was taken to hospital.
All five protesters arrested during the scuffle were granted bail and four will appear in Bankstown Local Court on July 15.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Appease you': Slain mum's family bombshell
The family of a woman killed by her violent partner in an act of gender-based violence has dropped a bombshell on a special forum hosted by A Current Affair - claiming prosecutors only brought them along to 'appease' them. Lee Little, the father of slain Victorian woman Alicia Little, was one of the headline guests on the special public forum hosted by the Channel 9 program on Wednesday night. The rare and critical gathering allowed victims of gender-based violence to come face-to-face with key figures in policy, law enforcement and the judiciary on a special hour-long edition of the news program. Mr Little was joined by Alicia's son Bronson and daughter-in-law Lauren where the family said nothing was being done about violence in the community. 'It just, it breaks my heart to see this happening every day,' Ms Little said to the forum. Charles McKenzie Ross Evans, Ms Little's former partner, was jailed for four years after violently running her down at a home in Kyneton in December 2017. Lee Little and Bronson Little spoke about their experience of losing Alicia, claiming the DPP only brought them along to one meeting to 'appease' them. A Current Affair/ Nine Credit: Supplied Evans was initially charged with murder over Ms Little's death, which occurred after she attempted to leave the violent relationship. He eventually pleaded guilty to dangerous driving causing death and failing to render assistance after his charges were downgraded. Evans was jailed for four years for Ms Little's death but was released on parole in 2020, moving to NSW. Bronson Little voiced his anger at the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions and how they could not help defend his sister, claiming the family had a shocking encounter with the body. 'They sat my family in a room for 45 minutes and listened to our questions, and at the end of it they said to us, we only brought you here to appease you,' he said. 'To be perfectly honest, the system failed us. 'The system failed my family.' David Heilpern, a former magistrate who sat on the panel, said he has bailed men who have gone on to kill. Mr Heilpern said the system 'needs to change'. 'We actually need a holistic change to ensure that victims of violence take pride of place in the criminal justice system, rather than just being a another case.' Former magistrate David Heilpern said the system needs to change. A Current Affair/ Nine Credit: Supplied At least 36 Australian women have been killed in 2025 so far, according to Australian Femicide Watch. Sue and Lloyd Clarke, the parents of Hannah Clarke - who was murdered by alongside her three children by her estranged husband Rowan Baxter - said that it continue to get harder grieving their family's loss. Sue and Lloyd Clarke, parents of Hannah Clarke, told the forum about their family's experience. A Current Affair/ Nine Credit: Supplied 'I think you miss them more for a while. 'You're in shock and you can explain away that you know they're away or something. 'But it gets harder,' Ms Clarke said. Domestic Violence helplines
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
Kanye West visa cancelled by Australian government
Kanye West's Australian visa has been cancelled over his "offensive comments". The 48-year-old rapper - whose wife Bianca Censori has family Down Under - had a "lower-level" visa which has now been revoked after he release antisemitic song Heil Hitler in May. The country's Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told ABC: "He's been coming to Australia for a long time. "He's got family here and he's made a lot of offensive comments that my officials looked at again. "Once he released the Heil Hitler song, he no longer has a valid visa in Australia. "It wasn't a visa for the purpose of concerts. It was a lower-level and the officials still looked at the law and said, you're going to have a song and promote that sort of Nazism, we don't need that in Australia." Earlier this year, the Stronger rapper came under fire over his controversial behaviour, including praising Adolf Hitler and selling t-shirts emblazoned with a Swastika, a notorious Nazi hate symbol. However, in May he asked for forgiveness and called for peace. He wrote in a series of posts on X: "I am done with antisemitism. I love all people. "God forgive me for the pain I've caused. "I forgive those who have caused me pain. Thank you God. "The earth itself is in Gods Kingdom. "GOD CALLS FOR PEACE. "Share peace. "Share love." Kanye claimed his outlook changed after he enjoyed a video call with his and ex-wife Kim Kardashian's four children, North, 11, Saint, nine, Chicago, seven, and six-year-old Psalm. He wrote: "I simply got a FaceTime from my kids and I wanna save the world again." This isn't the first time Kanye has seemingly had a change of heart as in February, he declared he was "not a Nazi" following "further reflection. Taking to X, he wrote: "After further reflection I've come to the realization that I'm not a Nazi." Kanye had previously declared his anti-Semitic comments to be "90 percent Jew proof", as he went on to explain he meant no one had been able to "stop" him. He wrote: "I will write this more poetically in a bit cause right now I'm finishing my verse for Game's album. "The idea of being Jew proof is "I said all these politically incorrect things and nobody was able to stop me extort me threaten me to change anything "And I made 40 million the next day between my different business "There's a lot of Jewish people I know and love and still work with "The point I made and showed is that I am not under Jewish control anymore (sic)"
The Advertiser
6 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Kanye West's Australian visa axed over Heil Hitler song
US rapper Kayne West has had his Australian visa cancelled over a controversial song referencing Adolf Hitler in which the singer claims to be a Nazi. Immigration officials made the decision to deny the controversial musician access to the country after listening to his track "Heil Hitler", which was released earlier in the year. West is married to Melbourne woman Bianca Censori. "He's been coming to Australia for a long time ... he's got family here and he's made a lot of offensive comments," Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told ABC TV on Wednesday. "My officials looked at it again once he released the 'Heil Hitler' song and he no longer has a valid visa in Australia." West's axed visa had not entitled him to perform in the country but was at a "lower level", Mr Burke added. "The officials still looked at the law and said, 'if you're going to have a song and promote that sort of Nazism, we don't need that in Australia'," he said. The song included the phrase: "So I became a Nazi ... I'm the villain". The chorus "Ni**a, heil Hitler" is chanted by a group of men standing in formation. West, who prefers to be referred to as Ye, frequently raps about being misunderstood and his custody battles with ex-wife Kim Kardashian. The winner of 24 Grammys was dropped by his talent agency earlier in the year after he posted a stream of anti-Semitic comments on social media and put T-shirts bearing swastika up for sale in his online shop. Shopify, the company that provided the online platform for West's fashion brand Yeezy, previously took the store offline. West also made a controversial appearance with Ms Censori at the Grammy Awards earlier in the year, when she appeared virtually naked in a sheer mini-dress after removing her fur coat. US rapper Kayne West has had his Australian visa cancelled over a controversial song referencing Adolf Hitler in which the singer claims to be a Nazi. Immigration officials made the decision to deny the controversial musician access to the country after listening to his track "Heil Hitler", which was released earlier in the year. West is married to Melbourne woman Bianca Censori. "He's been coming to Australia for a long time ... he's got family here and he's made a lot of offensive comments," Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told ABC TV on Wednesday. "My officials looked at it again once he released the 'Heil Hitler' song and he no longer has a valid visa in Australia." West's axed visa had not entitled him to perform in the country but was at a "lower level", Mr Burke added. "The officials still looked at the law and said, 'if you're going to have a song and promote that sort of Nazism, we don't need that in Australia'," he said. The song included the phrase: "So I became a Nazi ... I'm the villain". The chorus "Ni**a, heil Hitler" is chanted by a group of men standing in formation. West, who prefers to be referred to as Ye, frequently raps about being misunderstood and his custody battles with ex-wife Kim Kardashian. The winner of 24 Grammys was dropped by his talent agency earlier in the year after he posted a stream of anti-Semitic comments on social media and put T-shirts bearing swastika up for sale in his online shop. Shopify, the company that provided the online platform for West's fashion brand Yeezy, previously took the store offline. West also made a controversial appearance with Ms Censori at the Grammy Awards earlier in the year, when she appeared virtually naked in a sheer mini-dress after removing her fur coat. US rapper Kayne West has had his Australian visa cancelled over a controversial song referencing Adolf Hitler in which the singer claims to be a Nazi. Immigration officials made the decision to deny the controversial musician access to the country after listening to his track "Heil Hitler", which was released earlier in the year. West is married to Melbourne woman Bianca Censori. "He's been coming to Australia for a long time ... he's got family here and he's made a lot of offensive comments," Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told ABC TV on Wednesday. "My officials looked at it again once he released the 'Heil Hitler' song and he no longer has a valid visa in Australia." West's axed visa had not entitled him to perform in the country but was at a "lower level", Mr Burke added. "The officials still looked at the law and said, 'if you're going to have a song and promote that sort of Nazism, we don't need that in Australia'," he said. The song included the phrase: "So I became a Nazi ... I'm the villain". The chorus "Ni**a, heil Hitler" is chanted by a group of men standing in formation. West, who prefers to be referred to as Ye, frequently raps about being misunderstood and his custody battles with ex-wife Kim Kardashian. The winner of 24 Grammys was dropped by his talent agency earlier in the year after he posted a stream of anti-Semitic comments on social media and put T-shirts bearing swastika up for sale in his online shop. Shopify, the company that provided the online platform for West's fashion brand Yeezy, previously took the store offline. West also made a controversial appearance with Ms Censori at the Grammy Awards earlier in the year, when she appeared virtually naked in a sheer mini-dress after removing her fur coat. US rapper Kayne West has had his Australian visa cancelled over a controversial song referencing Adolf Hitler in which the singer claims to be a Nazi. Immigration officials made the decision to deny the controversial musician access to the country after listening to his track "Heil Hitler", which was released earlier in the year. West is married to Melbourne woman Bianca Censori. "He's been coming to Australia for a long time ... he's got family here and he's made a lot of offensive comments," Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told ABC TV on Wednesday. "My officials looked at it again once he released the 'Heil Hitler' song and he no longer has a valid visa in Australia." West's axed visa had not entitled him to perform in the country but was at a "lower level", Mr Burke added. "The officials still looked at the law and said, 'if you're going to have a song and promote that sort of Nazism, we don't need that in Australia'," he said. The song included the phrase: "So I became a Nazi ... I'm the villain". The chorus "Ni**a, heil Hitler" is chanted by a group of men standing in formation. West, who prefers to be referred to as Ye, frequently raps about being misunderstood and his custody battles with ex-wife Kim Kardashian. The winner of 24 Grammys was dropped by his talent agency earlier in the year after he posted a stream of anti-Semitic comments on social media and put T-shirts bearing swastika up for sale in his online shop. Shopify, the company that provided the online platform for West's fashion brand Yeezy, previously took the store offline. West also made a controversial appearance with Ms Censori at the Grammy Awards earlier in the year, when she appeared virtually naked in a sheer mini-dress after removing her fur coat.
