logo
Demons make appeal call after May ban

Demons make appeal call after May ban

Perth Now4 days ago
AFL players have already begun to 'hesitate slightly', knowing the 'margins' between a fair contest and a lengthy ban are slim as the impact of a three-match suspension handed to Melbourne defender Steven May reverberates through the game.
The Demons on Thursday confirmed they would appeal the ban, adamant May's 'sole intention was to win the ball'.
FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1.
Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge weighed in, saying he didn't agree with the suspension, but was adamant talk of it changing the fabric of the game was misplaced.
May was suspended despite the AFL tribunal conceding his collision with Carlton's Francis Evans last Saturday night was not a bump.
In the final minutes of his defence, May's legal counsel Adrian Anderson declared 'there was not much more he could do', but after more than 90 minutes of deliberation, the three-man tribunal panel determined he should have slowed down or changed his path to avoid Evans. Steven May's bump has divided the footy world. Photo: Fox Sports Credit: FOX SPORTS
Debate has raged since the incident, with some pundits adamant the game could no longer allow players to charge headlong towards opponents, whether the ball was in play or not.
That's the grounds on which Melbourne will appeal with a hearing next week.
'We felt we presented a really strong case and Steven's sole intention was to win the ball, and we believe he provided a contest in a reasonable way given the circumstances.' Melbourne football boss, Alan Richardson said.
'After reviewing the outcome and seeking further expert legal advice this morning, we have decided to appeal the Tribunal's decision.'
Evans, who lost a tooth and was left bloodied and bruised, conceded to the tribunal that he didn't think he was going to get to the ball before May, adding to the confusion over the ban.
Essendon vice-captain Andy McGrath conceded the incident was a 'tricky' one for the tribunal but said over the course of his career his on-field attitude had changed, and he now asked himself questions despite the 'split second' nature of making calls.
'They are split-second decisions, there are so many in game, and the longer I play – this is my ninth season – those split-second contests have changed a lot,' he said.
'If you are second to the ball, you have a big responsibility to not make contact with your opponent's head.
'It definitely comes through your mind, whether that causes us to hesitate slightly, I am questioning that more and more in the game to protect the opposition player's head.'
Beveridge said talk of the May ban setting any sort of 'precedent' was unfounded and it purely determined that the outcome of this collision was a suspension.
The Demons star failed to beat a three-match ban at the Tribunal for this shot on Carlton's Francis Evans.
'One of the things that has never happened in our tribunal system is there's never really been any precedent established, so I don't think anyone should be talking about precedents and how it affects the game into the future,' he said.
'Each one on their own terms is assessed.
'Do I agree with it? Probably not. When there is eyes for the ball and for all intents and purposes the players are trying to win the ball … that's where the debate rages.'
Carlton captain and Brownlow medallist Patrick Cripps said he wasn't sure what May could have done and McGrath agreed.
'It didn't look great but it's really hard to pull out of that contest at the last second,' he told SEN.
'As players, it's pretty tricky to know what penalty lies based on the act and we know that's margins between a fair play and a pretty significant sanction.'
Prior to their announcement, Demons great Garry Lyon believed the club would appeal.
Lyon did not agree with the AFL tribunal's argument that May 'had sufficient time with an unimpeded view of what was before him to determine what he could and should do in the likely event that he did not reach the ball either first or at the same time'.
'That's nonsense, which is why I've lost a bit of faith in this and why I think they'll appeal,' Lyon told SEN Breakfast.
'No-one could reasonably think that they weren't going to get to that football. (Evans) thought Steven May was going to get there first.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Why 'boring footy' will be the key for Melbourne Storm without Jahrome Hughes
Why 'boring footy' will be the key for Melbourne Storm without Jahrome Hughes

ABC News

time23 minutes ago

  • ABC News

Why 'boring footy' will be the key for Melbourne Storm without Jahrome Hughes

Melbourne's first efforts without Jahrome Hughes helped propel them to one of their best wins of the season, but if the Storm are to continue their premiership charge they'll need plenty of the same for as long as the reigning Dally M medallist is sidelined. The Storm are hopeful Hughes can return from a dislocated shoulder for the finals and rallied against the Roosters for a win that showed their toughness and character. It was a seminal showing but only a taste of what's to come. In the meantime, they'll face a six-week fury road that may define or destroy what's possible once the New Zealand playmaker is fit again. The Victorians have a tough run home, starting with a rejuvenated Parramatta side on Thursday before they take on Brisbane, Penrith (away) and Canterbury before facing the Roosters and Broncos (away) again. Right now, the Storm are comfortably in the top four, but nothing is certain given the quality of their opponents on the way home. Melbourne are expected to welcome back Cameron Munster and Ryan Papenhuyzen for Thursday's clash with the Eels while Tyran Wishart is tipped to take over at halfback. The utility is a quality replacement — he made himself a star filling in for Munster in the halves last season — but it will require an adjustment of style for Craig Bellamy's side. "One of the strengths of our team is depth, it's getting tested at the moment with a few injuries and other circumstances but our depth will come into play now," Wishart said. "[We have to] narrow the focus and playing to individuals' strengths and the team's strengths. Playing to our strengths is the main thing. "Boring footy is good footy. You could see that against the Roosters, it was boring — we just kicked to corners, but luckily it worked for us. "Off the back of that you can get combinations going." Hughes has not hit the heights of his superb 2024 season this time around but was coming into that kind of form at just the right time — he's the equal leader for try assists in the NRL and over the last 18 months has re-emerged as Melbourne's best and most consistent player. Without him, Melbourne will look to play more direct and through the middle of the field. They'll rely more on their forward pack to create ruck speed and on their spine to take advantage of it. The Roosters game can be something of a blueprint, with that style bringing them plenty of joy with hooker Harry Grant playing his finest game of the year. Working off Grant and Munster, who missed last week to attend his father's funeral, will be crucial if the Storm are to lock up a top-four spot in Hughes's absence. Once Munster returns he is expected to take control as the side's main organiser — a task that is newer for him, but one he performed beautifully for Queensland in this year's Origin series. "I think we're both naturally runners, but Munster's really good at organising as well. I didn't mind doing that [against the Roosters] when I had to," Wishart said. "The more you train with someone, the more games you get together, you work out a combination. "One of the strengths of our team is depth, it's getting tested at the moment with a few injuries and other circumstances but our depth will come into play now." Wishart and Munster have already played one game together this year, a forgettable 14-8 loss to the Dragons in round four where the Storm attack struggled to fire a shot. Now they'll have more time on their side but losing Hughes for this crucial stretch, plus the high re-occurrence rate of shoulder problems meaning he's no guarantee to last once he does return, has put their premiership charge in the balance. But it's far from impossible. Penrith have won the last two premierships despite Nathan Cleary carrying a similar shoulder problem into each finals series and with the Storm's talent behind them they're not giving the doubters a moments thought. "We wouldn't pay too much attention to that. We know what we can do, our team isn't based on individuals and that's our main strength," Wishart said. "People can say what they want, as long as we believe in ourselves we can do it."

Demons star to learn rough conduct fate in AFL appeal
Demons star to learn rough conduct fate in AFL appeal

Perth Now

timean hour ago

  • Perth Now

Demons star to learn rough conduct fate in AFL appeal

Melbourne will reiterate their belief that Steven May had a legitimate play at the ball in his high-speed clash with Carlton's Francis Evans when the star defender fronts the AFL Appeals Board. The case, which Demons coach Simon Goodwin predicts will shape the way players approach contests in future, will be heard on Monday evening. May was initially handed a three-match ban by the Tribunal for rough conduct over the collision that left Blues forward Evans with concussion, a broken nose and a missing tooth. But the All Australian defender maintained the ball was always his focus. "We think he had a play on the ball and it was a football incident," Goodwin said after the Demons confirmed they would appeal the Tribunal's decision. "From my perspective, that's ultimately the argument that we'll go with. "Clearly there's some legal stuff that they'll go through in terms of the case as part of the appeal. "But you can see it's divided a lot of the public and I think it's one of those cases where everyone wants it to go through the appeals (process) and see what the outcome is going to be." Goodwin said May was "devastated and shattered" by the Tribunal's decision. "Right from the outset when he first came to the bench, he was a little bit confused and thought he'd done the right thing and gone at the footy," Goodwin said. "He was shattered, he was disappointed with the outcome and clearly frustrated. "This is part of the process, go through the appeals, get the clarity required and we'll all move forward post that." Goodwin predicted players would adapt with the more information they get from the AFL about how they are required to act in certain scenarios. The 2021 premiership coach referenced the aerial contest between Fremantle captain Alex Pearce and Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones, which caused similar controversy to the May-Evans collision. Pearce was handed a three-match ban before overturning it on appeal. "This is part of the game," Goodwin said. "We're learning more and more about the game and what's required in the game, and what the players need to do in the game, especially around concussion. "But if you look at the Alex Pearce case, these cases go all the way through to the appeals and you get more information." May is recovering from his own concussion, having missed Sunday's horror fade-out against St Kilda after an accidental knee to the head from Carlton's Tom De Koning.

Young the ‘point of difference' to Freo's flag tilt
Young the ‘point of difference' to Freo's flag tilt

Perth Now

timean hour ago

  • Perth Now

Young the ‘point of difference' to Freo's flag tilt

Hayden Young has been labelled Fremantle's 'point of difference' in the Dockers' flag tilt following a blistering return from injury over the past fortnight. Young secured his first Glendinning-Allan Medal despite being subbed off early in the fourth quarter against West Coast after a commanding display with 23 touches, seven clearances and three goals in a derby domination. Channel Seven commentator Kate McCarthy said it was imperative the Dockers keep the left-footer fit, if they are to go deep into September and their hopes of winning a maiden premiership. 'Purely for what they have through the midfield, they have Andrew Brayshaw and (Caleb) Serong with Luke Jackson running through, but he (Young) is a genuine point of difference for them,' she said on 'He had a really important fourth quarter last week as the sub with 11 disposals and just continued on with that momentum, he's been their most important player. 'Keeping him on the park is an absolute must if you're Fremantle because he is key to your team going deep into September and maybe onto their first flag.' Young has managed just six games this year after undergoing surgery on a hamstring injury he picked up in their round eight loss to St Kilda, having missed the start of the year with a similar injury. Hayden Young & Justin Longmuir pose for a photo after the match. Credit: Janelle St Pierre/AFL Photos / Getty Images Given his history, the Dockers have been managing his return to the AFL level, including acting as the sub against Collingwood, with coach Justin Longmuir warning there is still more to come as he works his way back to full fitness. 'It was a good build from last week and should set him up well for next week. I thought he was clean, I thought he found space, and I thought he finished well. He was sharp,' Longmuir said post-game. 'We've missed his ball use at times this year. He's a welcome addition. He gives us another big body around there as well, which helps Andy and Caleb and the other mids. We've missed that as well. 'I thought our stoppage work went to a level it hasn't seen for a while today. I'm sure Youngy had an impact on that. Of course, that excites me.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store