BBC Drops ‘Gaza: Doctors Under Attack' Film As Producer Brands Director General A 'PR Person'
The BBC greenlit Doctors Under Attack last year from Basement Films, the production company run by former Channel 4 News editor Ben de Pear.
More from Deadline
International Insider: '28 Years Later' Arrives; Landmark Netflix-TF1 Deal; NHK At 100
BBC Hits AI Startup Perplexity With Legal Threat Over Content Scraping Concerns
BBC's BAFTA-Winning Doc Series 'Once Upon A Time In...' Turns Eye To Middle East
It was meant to spotlight the plight of medics in Gaza, but production was paused in April following the scandal over Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, the HOYO Films doc that was found to have been narrated by the child of a Hamas minister.
A BBC investigation into How to Survive a Warzone remains ongoing. Peter Johnston, the BBC's director of editorial complaints and reviews, is examining the failings that led to the film being broadcast.
Now, the BBC has said it will not screen Doctors Under Attack, or carry any of its contents in news bulletins, after discussions with Basement 'reached the end of the road' on Thursday.
In a lengthy statement, the BBC said: 'We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC.
'Impartiality is a core principle of BBC News. It is one of the reasons that we are the world's most trusted broadcaster. Therefore, we are transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films.'
The corporation continued: 'We want to thank the doctors and contributors and we are sorry we could not tell their stories. The BBC will continue to cover events in Gaza impartially.'
In a statement, Basement Films claimed that the BBC had approved the film for broadcast and it was considered a 'vital piece of public service journalism.'
'They gave us no less than 6 different release dates, and it was subjected to a long and repeated compliance process as well as scrupulous fact checking,' Basement said. 'They then apologised and reversed their position and said that it would be subject to the recommendations of the Johnston report.'
The company added: 'We are relieved that the BBC will finally allow this film to be released.'
It is not clear what brought the talks between the BBC and Basement to a head. De Pear did, however, personally criticize BBC director-general Tim Davie on a public platform at the Sheffield DocFest on Thursday.
He said Davie is 'just a PR person,' who has meddled in editorial decisions and is leading an organization that is 'failing' in its duty to report on the Gaza crisis properly.
'Something needs to happen because they are making decisions from a PR defensive point of view rather than a journalistic one. If you make a decision on a journalistic basis you can defend it, but if you make it on a PR basis, you can't,' de Pear said, per a report in Broadcast.
The BBC said it spent weeks with de Pear attempting to get Gaza doctors' voices heard. 'Our aim was to find a way to air some of the material in our news programmes, in line with our impartiality standards, before the review [into How to Survive a Warzone] was published,' it said.
The BBC added: 'Contrary to some reports, since we paused production of Gaza: Doctors Under Attack in April, it has not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes.'
The BBC's coverage of the Gaza crisis has stoked strong feelings on both sides of the conflict, with How to Survive a Warzone illustrating the fraught nature of the debate.
The UK's Jewish community was appalled that the BBC screened a film narrated by a boy with Hamas connections that were not declared to viewers. Others argued that the BBC's decision to pull How To Survive a Warzone was an act of 'censorship' that played into Israel's agenda.
Best of Deadline
A Full Timeline Of Blake Lively & Justin Baldoni's 'It Ends With Us' Feud In Court, Online & In The Media
'Poker Face' Season 2 Guest Stars: From Katie Holmes To Simon Hellberg
The 25 Highest-Grossing Animated Films Of All Time At The Global Box Office
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Sonay Kartal: The unlikely heroine flying the flag for Britain
With 14 tattoos, a retro range of baggy Adidas clothes, and a childhood spent around her parents' kebab shop while struggling to afford tennis coaching, the sense that Sonay Kartal's Wimbledon fairy tale could reach far beyond a traditional tennis fanbase is obvious. We also now know that it was almost over before it started, with Kartal revealing ahead of her big Centre Court debut on Sunday how her baby steps in tennis – at the Pavilion & Avenue club in Brighton – became tinged with fear and anxiety. Advertisement 'We used to do this thing called the lines game, it's a little warm-up,' she said. 'They'd shout, 'service line', and all the kids had to run to the service line. That was always the first game and I was too shy for three months to actually come on court. My coach Julie [Hobbs] finally managed to get me to do it. I tried to run to the outside tramline, tripped over, burst into tears. Off I went, and I didn't come back for a couple of months.' It is a story that plenty of parents and children will relate to, with Hobbs, a former British No 1, eventually coaxing her back to the sport. Fast forward 17 years and you did not need long around a packed Court 16 on Saturday to feel the impact that Kartal is having. Fresh from three brilliant singles wins, she was in doubles action alongside her friend Jodie Burrage in front of a distinctly youthful audience. Kartal has attracted a youthful following after a successful first week at Wimbledon - Getty Images/Rob Newell Kartal, who is now 23 and the last remaining British woman in the singles draw, hopes that her story can particularly inspire girls who are shy about sport. Advertisement 'My coach has a daughter and she was super shy, got into tennis and has changed like a completely different person,' she said. 'She's got so much more personality, she's so much more talkative.' And is playing sport becoming cooler for girls? 'I think it's changing,' she says. 'I think now a lot of girls are getting more comfortable with having more muscle on their body. I think that's turning, which is obviously incredible. 'I don't think anyone should feel like girls have to look a certain way. I think that's changing in tennis as well. You look at the tennis players, everyone's all different physiques and sizes and heights. So, it's definitely getting more versatile. If I can inspire kids, whether that's boys or girls, then I'm obviously doing something good.' Kartal played football and cricket at a similar level to her tennis until she was 13 and is a self-confessed sports lover. 'I was a little bit of a tomboy and super sporty,' she said. 'I loved football. My school actually used to have a lot of girls football and I used to go to my local park with my dad. In cricket I was always the batter and just launching [the ball] as far as I could.' Saturday's doubles might not have gone to plan – Kartal and Burrage were beaten in straight sets – but her partner could sense the buzz. Kartal had been informed that she would be first up on Centre Court at 1.30pm on Sunday against the Russian Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova just before stepping on court with Burrage. Advertisement 'Her story shows there's not one way to do what we do – but multiple ways,' said Burrage. 'She has done incredible – and she is going to go a lot higher. For everyone out there, regardless of where you are from, you can do it if you put your mind to it – especially like this chick here. That's the moral of this story.' Kartal's ranking has risen from 864 in 2022 to the world's top 50 – she will overtake Emma Raducanu as the British No 2 once Wimbledon is done and dusted – and Burrage clearly does not think the story will end against Pavlyuchenkova. 'I've got full belief,' she said. Kartal goes into the match against Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova in confident mood - Eddie Mulholland for The Telegraph There certainly seems little chance of the attention going to Kartal's head. She was six when she made that first trip to a tennis club following an invitation from a tennis official who had eaten at one of her father's two Turkish restaurants. And, while she was competitive against players like Emma Raducana through the British junior rankings, has largely progressed in senior tennis away from the limelight. Advertisement Kartal's social media remains largely fixated with animals or food and, perhaps most telling of all, she has resisted inevitable pressure to change a coaching team that, as well as Hobbs, also still includes Ben and Martin Reeves from her original club in Brighton. 'I was hearing people saying, you know, 'Do you think you should get a coach that has already done that?' But I didn't want that. If I can have a coach that can take me from a six-year-old to the WTA Tour, I think that's obviously good enough. We just learned together. It's kind of doing this crazy thing together. Kartal did find herself being recognised during a 'tricky' trip to the shops near Wimbledon on Friday night and her phone has been flooded with suggestions for her next tattoo. They have included one of Centre Court itself, a vintage polo shirt in recognition of her distinctive Adidas playing top and, from Burrage, an image of fire and ice. 'I actually like that,' she said. Among other things, Kartal is known for her tattoos - Eddie Mulholland for The Telegraph Fans are now suggesting what tattoo Kartal gets next - Eddie Mulholland for The Telegraph She has, until now, remained a member of the same no-thrills High Street gym in Brighton, although wonders if she may now have to review that arrangement. 'It was getting a bit tricky prior [to Wimbledon]. But to be honest they were actually pretty respectful there [at the gym]. They would just say hello and then just let me get on with it. So maybe I'll have to test that when I'm back. I go to the gym and just kind of have a bit of 'me time', stick my headphones in and just forget about the world. Advertisement 'People think I don't like [being in the spotlight], because I have gone under the radar my whole life but I don't have an issue with being in the spotlight or not being in the spotlight. I'll take it as a compliment.' Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Mel B is married! Spice Girls star and hairstylist Rory McPhee tie the knot
Mel B is married! The Spice Girls singer and hairstylist Rory McPhee tied the knot on Saturday, July 5, in London. The pair shared the news in a joint Instagram post, which included a look at her wedding dress. McPhee stood at Mel B's side in the photo wearing a kilt. "❤️ 05.07.25," the Instagram caption read. The bride followed up with a second post on Sunday, July 6, which showed "just married" written on the back of her dress. "MARRIED ❤️❤️❤️," she captioned the picture. Attendees at the wedding included Mel B's fellow Spice Girls singer Emma Bunton ("Baby Spice"), while other members of the girl group sent well-wishes on social media. On Instagram, Melanie C ("Sporty Spice") wrote that she was "so so happy for you both" and "beyond gutted" that she couldn't be there for the wedding. "Excited to celebrate with you really soon!" she said. Victoria Beckham ("Posh Spice") also sent "congratulations to you both" on her Instagram story, adding, "We hope you had the most amazing day!!" View this post on Instagram A post shared by 'scary spice Mel B' (@officialmelb) Mel B was previously married to Jimmy Gulzar from 1998 to 2000 and Stephen Belafonte from 2007 to 2017. She shares three children with her former partners Gulzar, Belafonte and Eddie Murphy. Mel B to rejoin 'AGT' for Season 20 as Heidi Klum departs series The "America's Got Talent" judge wrote about her relationship with McPhee in her memoir "Brutally Honest," revealing that he was her cousin's best friend and "knew all my family" before they started dating. "He was kind, he was considerate," she wrote. "A hairdresser who worked between his family's salon in Leeds, high-profile clients in London, and as a mentor and trainer for young hairdressers." View this post on Instagram A post shared by 'scary spice Mel B' (@officialmelb) According to the book, McPhee worked on the singer's hair while she was rehearsing for the Spice Girls' 2019 tour, and when the COVID-19 pandemic began, they started staying together. The pair got engaged in 2022, with McPhee proposing during a romantic weekend and telling her "that he had been to my father's grave to ask his permission to marry me." According to the book, when Mel B's mom heard the engagement news, she said, "Oh well, third time lucky." Mel B's ex-husband sues her for defamation over memoir 'laden with egregious lies' "Okay, yes, I'm not known for the choices I make when it comes to men, but down to my core I knew that I had found a good and decent man with morals," Mel B wrote. "A man I am allowing myself to trust, though I still have a way to go." In the dedication section of "Brutally Honest," the singer thanked McPhee "for showing me there is such a thing as real love." Mel B's wedding day comes just a few weeks after the singer celebrated her 50th birthday. To mark the occasion, McPhee shared a video on Instagram of the couple posing in front of the Eiffel Tower, writing, "50 my love never looked finer. Sooo many exciting things this year but today is all about you! Happy birthday. I love you soooo much." This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Mel B marries hairstylist Rory McPhee, Spice Girls stars celebrate
Washington Post
32 minutes ago
- Washington Post
An actor turns the tables on a brutal critic in ‘Bring the House Down'
In his 1878 travel book 'Edinburgh: Picturesque Notes,' Robert Louis Stevenson declared that his native city wouldn't appeal to everyone. 'For all who love shelter and the blessings of the sun, who hate dark weather and perpetual tilting against squalls, there could scarcely be found a more unhomely and harassing place of residence,' he wrote. In Charlotte Runcie's Edinburgh-set debut, the weather is the least of her characters' problems. For the man at the heart of the book — and at the center of a potentially reputation-destroying and career-ending furor — the Scottish capital proves to be 'unhomely and harassing' as a result of his reckless actions and ruthless words. 'Bring the House Down' plays out during the Edinburgh Fringe, the annual arts festival that comprises a dizzying range of actors, musicians, comedians and artists. Runcie, who is British, spent years as a journalist reviewing shows at the Fringe, and she channels her experience of the event in general and cutthroat criticism in particular in her accomplished novel. Alex Lyons, chief theater critic at a London newspaper, is a man of extremes who awards shows either five stars or, as is more often the case, one star. 'Anything in between was air.' At the Fringe, he writes a lacerating review of American performance artist Hayley Sinclair's first-ever one-woman show, 'Climate Emergence-She.' Later on, Alex meets Hayley at a bar and takes her back to his place for a one-night stand — while conveniently neglecting to mention his hatchet job, which has gone to press. When Hayley reads the review the next morning and discovers the man she slept with is its author, she fights back. Retitling her show 'The Alex Lyons Experience,' and repurposing it into an excoriating character assassination of the unscrupulous critic, Hayley immediately has a hit on her hands. As her story goes viral, her show expands to spotlight the widespread harm Alex has caused as both a critic and a philanderer, and to examine new ways of calling out and stamping out misogyny in the arts. Alex's colleague — and Runcie's narrator — Sophie Rigden looks on in awe as Hayley captivates her audience. 'It was like watching Botticelli's Venus come to life as a hipster enchantress,' she observes. 'She was essential, elemental, primordial with commanding rage.' While Hayley enjoys, and harnesses, her newfound fame, Alex crashes and burns. At one pivotal moment, it looks like it might be more than his career that goes up in smoke. Sophie tries to offer him support, but soon she is buckling under the weight of her own problems. Her workload multiplies when she takes over Alex's duties. Her emotional strain intensifies: She is mourning her mother, desperately missing her young son at home in London, wrestling with conflicting feelings for her previously unfaithful partner and weighing up the consequences of a drunken encounter. Can she regain control and come out on top like Hayley, or is she destined for disaster like Alex? This is a smart, sharp and compulsively readable first novel that provides food for thought on a variety of complex topics. A less skilled writer would have adopted a strident tone and resorted to speechifying during the passages that engage with themes such as male power and privilege, or publicity, notoriety and cancel culture. However, Runcie strikes a perfect balance, and instead of tub-thumping or finger-pointing, explores each issue with nuance and evenhandedness. She is especially insightful on both the criticism of art and the art of criticism. 'Personal recommendation has been replaced with consensus,' Sophie muses. 'We rely on there being hundreds of people rating everything, a critical mass of approval.' A novel isn't carried by its big ideas alone. It needs strong characters to convey them and react to them. Fortunately, Runcie's creations are forceful presences, all the more so because they are intriguingly multifaceted and resist cut-and-dried classification. Hayley is hell-bent on getting justice, yet there is more to her than a woman scorned or an avenging angel. Similarly, Alex has harsh judgments and selfish motives, and is given to 'tricking women into thinking he could give them what they wanted, only to maim them emotionally the moment they opened themselves up,' but he is no mere one-dimensional hate figure. Sandwiched between the two is Sophie, at once a 'sarcastic, sceptical, media-savvy hack girl with a flip answer to everything' and a sensitive young woman with divided loyalties who refuses to cast aspersions on either party. All of which sounds serious and thought-provoking. This is only partly true, for the novel is also fun and frequently witty. The dialogue sparkles. Alex's mother, acclaimed actress and 'national treasure' Dame Judith Lyons, steals scenes. Throughout, Runcie showcases the giddy whirl of the Fringe with its lively crowds, wild parties and madcap acts ('Hamlet' performed on a bouncy castle, confessions to the 'Chill Pope' conducted in portable toilets). Alex justifies his brutal takedowns by arguing that 'people like reading bad reviews.' They also like reading good books. 'Bring the House Down' is one such book: not a one-star flop but a five-star triumph. Malcolm Forbes is a freelance writer whose work has appeared in the Economist, Financial Times, Wall Street Journal and New Republic. By Charlotte Runcie Doubleday. 304 pp. $28
