Idaho Group Calls Federal Intervention 'Necessary' To Redraw State Border

Newsweek

4 days ago

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
Leaders of a movement to redraw Oregon's state borders so more conservative residents can officially live in Idaho are calling federal intervention "necessary" following years of inaction on behalf of the Democratic-led state Legislature.
Why It Matters
The Greater Idaho Movement has been successful on ballot measures in 13 Oregon counties as of December 2024, with efforts beginning in 2020 to legally redraw state borders to allow current residents in Eastern Oregon to officially become part of Idaho.
Leaders and supporters have been transparent about wanting to promote a "greater Idaho" by adding conservative representation from current Oregon residents. They have also criticized the border line that was established 163 years ago, referring to it as "outdated" and indicative of a current "cultural divide" when juxtaposed with western Oregon.
Demonstrators hold signs in favor of the Greater Idaho Movement in Enterprise, Oregon, on May 12, 2023.
Demonstrators hold signs in favor of the Greater Idaho Movement in Enterprise, Oregon, on May 12, 2023.
ROBYN BECK/AFP via Getty Images
What To Know
State lawmakers from eastern Oregon who sponsored bills this past session to spur a border redrawing "were completely ignored by the Democrat majority in Salem," the Greater Idaho Movement said in a statement on Monday.
"This failure to listen to the people of Eastern Oregon or our elected representatives only reinforces why Eastern Oregon counties need the governance of Idaho, a state far more in line with our values and way of life," the statement says. "After five years of hearing from voters and advocating with legislators to respect voter wishes, it is clear to our organization that Oregon leadership is intent on holding Eastern Oregon counties captive as part of a state we no longer wish to be part of and that federal engagement is necessary to achieve self-determination for the people Eastern Oregon."
Newsweek reached out to the group for comment.
Even with the successful local ballot measures over the years, the longtime Democratic majorities in the Oregon House and Senate have made the group's ultimate intentions to redraw lines and live in Idaho difficult.
Democrats have controlled the Oregon House, Senate and governor's office since 2007. Newsweek reached out to Democratic leadership for comment.
"The failure of the Oregon Legislature to move either of the Greater Idaho bills in this session is an affront to the people of Eastern Oregon, as well as the democratic process in general," the statement adds. "For five years the people of Eastern Oregon have been making their wishes known at the ballot box.
"Those wishes are to have elected leaders investigate letting our counties separate and join Idaho."
In December 2024, following the election of President Donald Trump, Greater Idaho Movement President Mike McCarter, Vice President Sandie Gilson and Executive Director Matt McCaw sent the then-president-elect a letter requesting support from the incoming administration.
In the letter, the group told Trump that "the people here overwhelmingly voted for you," adding: "We humbly ask you for your support in helping Eastern Oregonians achieve what the people have said they want, and that's to join Idaho."
McCaw told Newsweek in 2023 that area voters have been receptive to solving the urban-rural divide, with elections in the eastern portion of Oregon heavily leaning Republican.
"Eastern Oregon is far more similar to Idaho in almost every way than it is to western Oregon," McCaw said at the time. "It doesn't make any sense to be getting the state-level government from the state of Oregon, who feels very differently on almost every issue. It would make far more sense to get that government from Idaho."
Neither the Trump administration nor the president has not commented on the efforts of the Greater Idaho Movement.
What People Are Saying
Senator Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, told Newsweek in 2023 that Greater Idaho's efforts are a "dubious siren song" that is unrealistic and contains "multiple fatal flaws beyond its fundamental implausibility," including questions about Oregon landowners' water rights in addition to some Oregonians paying a sales tax in Idaho for the first time in their lives.
Senator Jeff Merkley, an Oregon Democrat, said during a town hall in 2023 that "there are a whole set of barriers that would make the process very difficult."