'They move from home to home or car to car until they find the one'
Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up.
Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months.
But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door.
"To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around."
While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic.
When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours.
Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards.
"It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said.
He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW.
The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable.
In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts.
Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said.
"We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it."
People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police.
POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked.
Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up.
Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months.
But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door.
"To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around."
While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic.
When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours.
Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards.
"It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said.
He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW.
The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable.
In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts.
Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said.
"We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it."
People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police.
POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked.
Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up.
Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months.
But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door.
"To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around."
While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic.
When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours.
Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards.
"It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said.
He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW.
The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable.
In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts.
Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said.
"We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it."
People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police.
POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked.
Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up.
Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months.
But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door.
"To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around."
While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic.
When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours.
Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards.
"It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said.
He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW.
The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable.
In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts.
Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said.
"The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said.
"We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it."
People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
3 days ago
- The Advertiser
'They move from home to home or car to car until they find the one'
POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked. Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up. Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months. But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door. "To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said. "They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around." While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic. When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said. That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours. Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards. "It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said. He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW. The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable. In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts. Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said. "The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said. "We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it." People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police. POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked. Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up. Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months. But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door. "To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said. "They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around." While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic. When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said. That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours. Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards. "It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said. He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW. The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable. In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts. Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said. "The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said. "We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it." People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police. POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked. Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up. Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months. But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door. "To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said. "They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around." While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic. When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said. That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours. Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards. "It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said. He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW. The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable. In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts. Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said. "The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said. "We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it." People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police. POLICE investigating property offences in Newcastle are often able to piece together a bigger picture that shows how stealthy thieves operating under the cover of night go door-to-door searching for one that's unlocked. Officers are confident they have made a dent in property offending in the region, but have issued a new plea for residents to help protect themselves from the trauma of crime, and protect their belongings, by locking up. Newcastle police acting superintendent Steve Benson said investigations and targeted operations such as Soteria had led to arrests and a reduction in overall property crime in the area compared with recent months. But police who have been called to piece together recent offences such as break-ins and thefts from vehicles had noticed that the vast majority involved access via an unlocked door. "To complement what we are doing in arresting offenders, one of the greatest prevention strategies we have is ensuring it's tough for them to commit these crimes," Acting Superintendent Benson said. "They generally do not want to be heard or seen; they do it in the dead of night when no one is around." While there was the occasional window smashed or forced entry, Acting Superintendent Benson said police knew through their leads and data that most offenders appeared to be "looking for easy access" and were opportunistic. When police were called to an incident, they generally canvassed the street and reviewed CCTV, and were then able to piece together a larger picture, Acting Superintendent Benson said. That often showed how a person or people walked the street and surrounding streets, testing doors and moving on, "looking for the one house or car" that is not secured, even if it took them a few hours. Acting Superintendent Benson said residents could make it tougher for thieves to strike by getting into the habit of locking vehicles, doors to homes, taking valuables out of cars and moving items such as e-bikes out of front yards. "It always has been, and probably always will be, the best deterrent ... a small deterrent goes a long way," he said. He said there was not a particular street or suburb that was more prolific than others locally, and it was an issue police were dealing with across NSW. The latest data from the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research in March showed the two-year and 10-year trends for property offending in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie were stable. In the 12 months to March 2025, there were 1397 break-and-enter dwelling offences in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie, 2795 steal from motor vehicle reports and 1205 motor vehicle thefts. Behind each number was a person coping with the stress that someone had invaded their privacy and questioning what they could have gone through or taken, Acting Superintendent Benson said. "The thought that someone has accessed a private home is confronting ... I certainly know the feeling and that vulnerability," he said. "We know the job is not done, we have really got to keep on it." People who notice suspicious activity in their area should contact the police.
Sydney Morning Herald
6 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Why police can't prove children like Harry committed serious crimes
A steep decline in convictions has worried the NSW Labor government, which has ordered a review. The Nationals want a major change, arguing doli incapax is failing both victims of crime and the children themselves. But legal bodies, academics and children's advocates fear any rise in convictions, arguing support for a child should not hinge on a finding of guilt. Dramatic fall Across Australia, no child under 10 can be charged with a crime. In NSW, in the 10- to 13-year-old bracket where prosecutors must rebut doli incapax, cases with a proven outcome have fallen off a cliff, collapsing from 76 per cent in 2015-16 to 16 per cent in 2022-23. 'It's a remarkable fall, really,' says Jackie Fitzgerald, executive director of the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research. 'I don't know that the government and possibly even policymakers in this area knew this.' After noticing the trend last year, Fitzgerald commissioned a report into the effect of a 2016 High Court case, RP v R, which clarified the application of doli incapax. The High Court emphasised it was the job of prosecutors to prove beyond reasonable doubt that a child knew what they were doing was seriously wrong, as opposed to merely naughty or mischievous. It was not enough to argue an act was 'obviously wrong'. Since that decision, frontline NSW Police officers have kept on charging roughly the same number of children. But by 2023, one in two cases ended with their police prosecutor colleagues withdrawing all charges. Many more children were pleading not guilty, and when they did, the prosecution was failing to prove them guilty nearly 90 per cent of the time. In May, on the same day BOCSAR released its research into the 'dramatic shift', Attorney-General Michael Daley announced a review of doli incapax. Citing 'concerns' raised by others, Daley said he had asked former Supreme Court judge Geoffrey Bellew and former police deputy commissioner Jeff Loy to advise on new legislation. 'Often, the young person is simply released from custody without support, back into the care of dysfunctional families,' the ministerial media release said. 'Too often, they engage in behaviour that endangers themselves and members of the community.' NSW, Victoria and South Australia have all relied on the common law standard of doli incapax, which has developed over time as individual judges interpret it. All three states have seen falls in guilty findings since the High Court case. (Victoria last year introduced legislation that codifies doli incapax in a similar form.) But in Queensland and Western Australia, which have a lower threshold set down in legislation, conviction rates have remained relatively stable. Prosecutors in those states do not need to prove the child had actual knowledge of serious wrongdoing, only the capacity to know they 'ought not' have acted the way they did. A 2018 review of Queensland's system heard that 'the presumption of doli incapax is rarely a barrier to prosecution'. 'Queensland is the exemplar if you're trying to prosecute children, and you want to convict children,' says Dominique Moritz, a former police officer turned criminal law academic at the University of the Sunshine Coast. 'From a protective perspective, the common law test is much more preferable.' 'In one door and out the other' In the town of Moree, on the NSW Northern Tablelands, robberies, break-ins and car thefts have led to tense discussions about youth crime. 'It's creating a feeling of fear in my community,' Nationals MP Brendan Moylan says. The former solicitor, who has lived in Moree for two decades and won office in a byelection last year, says he has been 'constantly annoying' the attorney-general about reforming doli incapax. 'We can't just let these kids go in one door out the other,' he says. 'Put in place structures to actually help them to stop that reoffending.' Moylan believes only courts can enforce treatment plans for children, whom he acknowledges have often suffered violence or have grown up amid substance abuse. He suggests they could be dealt with in a similar way to adults found not guilty because of mental illness. But others are wary of the review into doli incapax. 'It's a distraction from the real issue,' says Jonathon Hunyor, chief executive of the Justice and Equity Centre, an independent law and policy advisory organisation. 'Why aren't we providing services before children are putting themselves and the community in dangerous situations? Why do children need to act out to get the support they need?' Hunyor said decades of research showed early contact with the criminal justice system 'absolutely guaranteed' a higher likelihood of reoffending down the track. When the review was first announced, the NSW Bar Association also warned against a focus on declining conviction rates. 'The NSW government does not need to reform doli incapax in order to provide the vital services and support needed by vulnerable children and their communities,' then-president Ruth Higgins, SC, said. Doli incapax is a live issue because the state government has resisted a push to change the minimum age of criminal responsibility. Loading Bodies that want to 'raise the age' to 14 or higher include the Bar Association, the Law Council of Australia, the Aboriginal Legal Service and the Australian Medical Association. The NSW Children's Court has previously called for it to be raised to 12. A 2020 draft report by the Australian Council of Attorneys-General, which recommended the age be raised to 14, found 'placing a child in detention can disrupt normal brain development and compound pre-existing trauma'. Since then, the ACT has permanently shifted the minimum age to 14. Victoria raised it to 12, but has walked away from plans to raise it to 14 by 2027. The NSW government says it should stay at 10. As a research agency, BOCSAR has no position on raising the age or changes to doli incapax. But its executive director says a comparison of crime statistics around the country shows NSW does not have a youth crime 'crisis'. 'There's considerable community harm posed by allowing those young people to continue to offend, of course,' Fitzgerald says. 'But a heavy-handed justice response is not the way to turn the tables on that trajectory.' In a statement, NSW Police said it was working with the government as part of the review. In response to questions, the attorney-general did not elaborate on the concerns raised with him about doli incapax nor answer whether the government intended to increase the conviction rate for 10- to 13-year-olds. 'It is appropriate that doli incapax is reviewed by two eminent experts to ensure that it continues to operate in the best interests of the community and the children it applies to,' a spokesperson for Daley said. 'We acknowledge that vulnerable children in NSW need more support, which is why we are investing a landmark $1.2 billion in the child protection system. The government invested more than $100 million in additional youth justice funding in last year's budget, with further additional funding in [last month's] budget.' In the case of Harry, who turned 14 in detention, magistrate Hayes noted 'the accusatorial system is not focused on the referral to expert services or the reasons why you have been in conflict with the law'. Avoiding legalese, Hayes spoke in simple sentences, telling Harry that sometimes detention changes people. In the short term, it protects the community, he said, and sometimes, in the long term, it makes things worse. 'Harry, you will now be released back into the community,' Hayes concluded. 'I wish you well.'
The Age
6 days ago
- The Age
Why police can't prove children like Harry committed serious crimes
A steep decline in convictions has worried the NSW Labor government, which has ordered a review. The Nationals want a major change, arguing doli incapax is failing both victims of crime and the children themselves. But legal bodies, academics and children's advocates fear any rise in convictions, arguing support for a child should not hinge on a finding of guilt. Dramatic fall Across Australia, no child under 10 can be charged with a crime. In NSW, in the 10- to 13-year-old bracket where prosecutors must rebut doli incapax, cases with a proven outcome have fallen off a cliff, collapsing from 76 per cent in 2015-16 to 16 per cent in 2022-23. 'It's a remarkable fall, really,' says Jackie Fitzgerald, executive director of the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research. 'I don't know that the government and possibly even policymakers in this area knew this.' After noticing the trend last year, Fitzgerald commissioned a report into the effect of a 2016 High Court case, RP v R, which clarified the application of doli incapax. The High Court emphasised it was the job of prosecutors to prove beyond reasonable doubt that a child knew what they were doing was seriously wrong, as opposed to merely naughty or mischievous. It was not enough to argue an act was 'obviously wrong'. Since that decision, frontline NSW Police officers have kept on charging roughly the same number of children. But by 2023, one in two cases ended with their police prosecutor colleagues withdrawing all charges. Many more children were pleading not guilty, and when they did, the prosecution was failing to prove them guilty nearly 90 per cent of the time. In May, on the same day BOCSAR released its research into the 'dramatic shift', Attorney-General Michael Daley announced a review of doli incapax. Citing 'concerns' raised by others, Daley said he had asked former Supreme Court judge Geoffrey Bellew and former police deputy commissioner Jeff Loy to advise on new legislation. 'Often, the young person is simply released from custody without support, back into the care of dysfunctional families,' the ministerial media release said. 'Too often, they engage in behaviour that endangers themselves and members of the community.' NSW, Victoria and South Australia have all relied on the common law standard of doli incapax, which has developed over time as individual judges interpret it. All three states have seen falls in guilty findings since the High Court case. (Victoria last year introduced legislation that codifies doli incapax in a similar form.) But in Queensland and Western Australia, which have a lower threshold set down in legislation, conviction rates have remained relatively stable. Prosecutors in those states do not need to prove the child had actual knowledge of serious wrongdoing, only the capacity to know they 'ought not' have acted the way they did. A 2018 review of Queensland's system heard that 'the presumption of doli incapax is rarely a barrier to prosecution'. 'Queensland is the exemplar if you're trying to prosecute children, and you want to convict children,' says Dominique Moritz, a former police officer turned criminal law academic at the University of the Sunshine Coast. 'From a protective perspective, the common law test is much more preferable.' 'In one door and out the other' In the town of Moree, on the NSW Northern Tablelands, robberies, break-ins and car thefts have led to tense discussions about youth crime. 'It's creating a feeling of fear in my community,' Nationals MP Brendan Moylan says. The former solicitor, who has lived in Moree for two decades and won office in a byelection last year, says he has been 'constantly annoying' the attorney-general about reforming doli incapax. 'We can't just let these kids go in one door out the other,' he says. 'Put in place structures to actually help them to stop that reoffending.' Moylan believes only courts can enforce treatment plans for children, whom he acknowledges have often suffered violence or have grown up amid substance abuse. He suggests they could be dealt with in a similar way to adults found not guilty because of mental illness. But others are wary of the review into doli incapax. 'It's a distraction from the real issue,' says Jonathon Hunyor, chief executive of the Justice and Equity Centre, an independent law and policy advisory organisation. 'Why aren't we providing services before children are putting themselves and the community in dangerous situations? Why do children need to act out to get the support they need?' Hunyor said decades of research showed early contact with the criminal justice system 'absolutely guaranteed' a higher likelihood of reoffending down the track. When the review was first announced, the NSW Bar Association also warned against a focus on declining conviction rates. 'The NSW government does not need to reform doli incapax in order to provide the vital services and support needed by vulnerable children and their communities,' then-president Ruth Higgins, SC, said. Doli incapax is a live issue because the state government has resisted a push to change the minimum age of criminal responsibility. Loading Bodies that want to 'raise the age' to 14 or higher include the Bar Association, the Law Council of Australia, the Aboriginal Legal Service and the Australian Medical Association. The NSW Children's Court has previously called for it to be raised to 12. A 2020 draft report by the Australian Council of Attorneys-General, which recommended the age be raised to 14, found 'placing a child in detention can disrupt normal brain development and compound pre-existing trauma'. Since then, the ACT has permanently shifted the minimum age to 14. Victoria raised it to 12, but has walked away from plans to raise it to 14 by 2027. The NSW government says it should stay at 10. As a research agency, BOCSAR has no position on raising the age or changes to doli incapax. But its executive director says a comparison of crime statistics around the country shows NSW does not have a youth crime 'crisis'. 'There's considerable community harm posed by allowing those young people to continue to offend, of course,' Fitzgerald says. 'But a heavy-handed justice response is not the way to turn the tables on that trajectory.' In a statement, NSW Police said it was working with the government as part of the review. In response to questions, the attorney-general did not elaborate on the concerns raised with him about doli incapax nor answer whether the government intended to increase the conviction rate for 10- to 13-year-olds. 'It is appropriate that doli incapax is reviewed by two eminent experts to ensure that it continues to operate in the best interests of the community and the children it applies to,' a spokesperson for Daley said. 'We acknowledge that vulnerable children in NSW need more support, which is why we are investing a landmark $1.2 billion in the child protection system. The government invested more than $100 million in additional youth justice funding in last year's budget, with further additional funding in [last month's] budget.' In the case of Harry, who turned 14 in detention, magistrate Hayes noted 'the accusatorial system is not focused on the referral to expert services or the reasons why you have been in conflict with the law'. Avoiding legalese, Hayes spoke in simple sentences, telling Harry that sometimes detention changes people. In the short term, it protects the community, he said, and sometimes, in the long term, it makes things worse. 'Harry, you will now be released back into the community,' Hayes concluded. 'I wish you well.'
