Man executed for the 2000 killing of a police officer in Indiana's second execution in 15 years
MICHIGAN CITY, Ind. -- An Indiana man convicted in the fatal shooting of a police officer in 2000 was executed Tuesday by lethal injection in the state's second execution in 15 years.
Benjamin Ritchie, 45, had been on Indiana's death row since 2002, when he was convicted of killing Beech Grove Police Officer Bill Toney during a chase on foot.
Ritchie was executed at the Indiana State Prison in Michigan City, according to Indiana Department of Correction officials. IDOC said in a statement that the process started shortly after midnight and Ritchie was pronounced dead at 12:46 a.m.
Ritchie's last meal was from the Olive Garden and he expressed love, support and peace for his friends and family, according to the statement.
Under state law, he was allowed five witnesses at his execution, which included his attorney Steve Schutte, who told reporters he had a limited view of the process.
'I couldn't see his face. He was lying flat by that time,' Schutte said. 'He sat up, twitched, laid back down.'
The process was carried out hours after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to take the case, exhausting all of Ritchie's legal options to fight the death sentence.
Dozens of people, both anti-death penalty advocates and supporters of Toney, stood outside the prison until early Tuesday.
Indiana resumed executions in December after a yearslong hiatus due to a scarcity of lethal injection drugs nationwide. Prison officials provided photos of the execution chamber before Joseph Corcoran's execution, showing a space that looks like an operating room with a gurney, fluorescent lighting and an adjacent viewing room. They've since offered few other details.
Among 27 states with death penalty laws, Indiana is one of two that bars media witnesses. The other, Wyoming, has conducted one execution in the last half-century.
The Associated Press and other media organizations filed a federal lawsuit in Indiana seeking media access, but a federal judge denied a preliminary injunction last week that would have allowed journalists to witness Ritchie's execution and future ones. The judge found that barring the news media doesn't violate the First Amendment nor does it single out the news media for unequal treatment.
The execution in Indiana is among 12 scheduled in eight states this year. Ritchie's execution and two others in Texas and Tennessee will be carried out this week.
The 2000 fatal shooting of a police officer
Ritchie was 20 when he and others stole a van in Beech Grove, near Indianapolis. He then fired at Toney during a foot chase, killing him.
At the time Ritchie was on probation from a 1998 burglary conviction.
Toney, 31, had worked at the Beech Grove Police Department for two years. The married father of two was the first officer of the small department to be killed by gunfire in the line of duty.
Relatives spoke at a clemency hearing last week in support of the execution.
'It's time. We're all tired,' said Dee Dee Horen, who was Toney's wife. 'It is time for this chapter of my story, our story, to be closed. It's time for us to remember Bill, to remember Bill's life, and not his death.'
Appealing a death sentence
Ritchie's attorneys have fought the death sentence, arguing his legal counsel at trial was ineffective because his lawyers failed to fully investigate and present evidence on his fetal alcohol spectrum disorders and childhood lead exposure.
Current defense attorneys say Ritchie suffered 'severe brain damage' because his mother abused alcohol and drugs during pregnancy and he's struggled with decision-making. He was also diagnosed with bipolar disorder in 2005.
Disability rights advocates argued that Ritchie's brain damage should have excluded him from the death penalty.
'This is a foolish, senseless, agonizing waste of time and money,' said Schutte, who added that Ritchie was no longer 'the same person who committed that crime.'
Attorney General Todd Rokita said the execution honored Toney's 'sacrifice to the community.'
Republican Gov. Mike Braun rejected Ritchie's clemency bid last week without explanation.
The Indiana Supreme Court denied a request to stop the execution. Ritchie's attorneys challenged that decision in federal court, which a judge rejected. The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sided with the lower court on Sunday.
As the sun set Monday, the Rev. Richard Holy, a Catholic priest, recited the rosary with about 20 people in the prison parking lot.
'We don't have to keep taking one life to exact justice for taking another,' he said.
Dozens also showed up to honor Toney's memory.
'I support the death penalty in certain cases and this is one of them,' said Mark Hamner, an Indianapolis-area officer.
Expressing regret and awaiting execution
Attorneys said Ritchie changed during his more than two decades behind bars and had shown remorse.
In court as a young man, Ritchie smiled at Horen and laughed as the verdict was read.
He told a parole board he deeply regretted his actions, especially how he acted with Toney's widow.
'I wish I could go back to the day in court, because that man's wife deserved to say everything she needed to say to me, and that punk kid should have just kept his mouth shut and let her say whatever she needed to say,' Ritchie said.
Ritchie, who was also a father, spent his last days getting visits from friends and family.
'I've ruined my life and other people's lives, and I'm so sorry for that night,' he told the parole board earlier this month. 'You can't take back what you did.'
------
By Sophia Tareen And Ed White
Tareen reported from Chicago. Associated Press writer John O'Connor contributed from Springfield, Illinois.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
2 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Ex-CFL player Paul Markle used his marketing skills to help the Blue Jays soar
At the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum in October of 1992, the police created a barrier around Paul (Sparkle) Markle and a group of Toronto Blue Jays front office workers and players' children and wives. It was Game 4 of the American League Championship Series and after Roberto Alomar slapped a ninth-inning, game-tying homer off A's closer Dennis Eckersley, the fans, already rowdy, began sniffing for Canadian blood. The Jays eventually won in the 11th inning. 'The police said, 'Stay in your seat until the crowd leaves,' because we didn't want to get rained on with popcorn and warm beer,' says Glen Wilkie, known as Hoop, Mr. Markle's best friend of 67 years. As Mr. Wilkie relates, the Jays' contingent did as the police advised, but the evening wasn't over. After exiting the stadium, Hoop and Sparkle, sporting powder blue Jays' caps and shirts, hit an East Oakland bar. 'Of course, we decided we needed one more beer, so we enter this place and all of the people are wearing black leather and chains – it was a biker bar,' Mr. Wilkie says, adding that the situation's danger subsided when Sparkle showed how he earned his nickname for exploits well beyond the playing field. 'Paul just went over to one guy and started a conversation – engaging him – and that guy brought over his friends,' Mr. Wilkie says, disbelief still apparent in his gravelly voice. 'Next thing you know, we're part of the biker gang, and that was Paul: a raconteur, but he listened and was always interested in other people.' Mr. Markle died on July 2 from early onset dementia complications at the age of 78, with Lisa Moore, his wife of 28 years, and his son, Blake, at his side. He was born on Oct. 23, 1946, in London, Ont., to Beatrice, a homemaker, and Gower Markle, a labour negotiator with the gift of gab, who would body-build and demonstrate his physique in miniature gym trunks, his body painted in gold. 'It was a popular thing in the fifties, posturing like Adonis, and I think dad grew up like grampy, admiring the beauty of the human form,' Blake recalls, adding that his father was a standout high-school football player at Richview Collegiate in Etobicoke and then Waterloo Lutheran University (now Wilfrid Laurier University). After university, he married Cheryl Johnson, a flight attendant with Canadian Pacific Air Lines whom he first met at a Toronto bar. He was drafted by the Toronto Argonauts in 1968, and later played for the Blue Bombers. In Winnipeg, he thrived as a hard-to-bring-down tight-end and a neighbourhood fixture when being a CFL star was still a lunch pail job. 'When those Canadian kids made the roster, especially making it as a starter, it was special,' says Ken Derrett, a sports marketing professional who grew up in Winnipeg and remembered Sparkle giving him an autograph as a childhood fan. 'Paul had time for young kids and wanted to have a conversation. Even then, he was genuine, caring and calm.' Mr. Markle's six-year CFL career included stints in Toronto, Winnipeg and Edmonton. He capitalized on the unique light professional sports shone on homegrown stars. He believed in the power of storytelling and competition, which made him a natural in sports marketing. 'He was a small-market jock in Manitoba and, as an enthusiastic side hustle, hosted radio shows and the interview program CFL Today,' Blake recalls. 'I think he enjoyed breaking down the nuts and the bolts of the sport and articulating the nuances of the game and its players – his buddies – to a wider audience.' He also worked at a used-car dealership. When his CFL games played on the radio, the announcer would urge listeners head over later to buy a car from Sparkle Markle. After his CFL career ended, Mr. Markle moved his family back to Toronto and took a job in marketing with Labatt's, which then owned the Toronto Blue Jays, a brand new expansion baseball team. Like a hand in a glove, the opportunity was a perfect fit for the former pro athlete, who had enough chutzpah and entrepreneurial zeal to become the team's first director of marketing. 'Paul was able to expand our fan base not only across the city, but across the province and, ultimately, across the country,' says Paul Beeston, the Toronto Blue Jays president from 1989 to 1997 and again from 2008 to 2015. (Mr. Beeston, from Welland, Ont., was president of Major League Baseball from 1997 to 2002). It was under Mr. Beeston's watch that the Jays moved from Exhibition Stadium to the SkyDome in 1989 and Mr. Beeston says that Sparkle Markle was able to bring athletes, executives and sponsors on board to his line of community building and growth. Generally, over a beer. 'Paul was the one who kept everyone together and he may not have been the face of the Blue Jays, but he was the heart and soul of it,' Mr. Beeston says. Under the leadership of Mr. Beeston and Mr. Markle, the Blue Jays became the best and most popular team in baseball. In the 1991 season, they became the first team in Major League Baseball history to surpass four million fans in attendance. The team – backed by John Olerud, Roberto Alomar and walk-off home-run-hitting Joe Carter – won back-to-back World Series titles in 1992 and 1993. When Blake Markle was growing up, he recalls, the Blue Jays were like Marvel superheroes, and like Marvel executives, his sky's-the-limit father knew how to extend the intellectual property. 'There wasn't a single non-branded Blue Jays item in our house,' Blake says, adding that his father, through his network, knew how capitalize on his beloved team's popularity. 'He was like, 'Blakester, I know a guy with Polo Ralph Lauren who has a warehouse downtown,' and we went into that factory and took whatever we wanted because Dad had gotten him season tickets. Everybody wanted a piece of the Jays – Dad knew how to pull those levers.' His career with the Blue Jays would last 14 years and when it was over, Mr. Markle took his love of sports and drama to public speaking, giving inspirational talks across Canada and, once, in New Zealand. He became a sports marketing instructor at Toronto's George Brown College and maintained his lifelong loves of marathon running, people and taverns. In 1997, after his first marriage ended in divorce, he married Ms. Moore, a television commercial producer. Together, they enjoyed golf, crossword puzzles, music and catching the game – any game – with Mr. Markle's wide circle of friends. Obituary: Maine-born football star John Huard fumbled as coach of Toronto's Argos Mr. Wilkie says that until the end, his buddy enjoyed telling stories, engaging with strangers and letting other people shine in his light. 'He was one year and one day older than I was – my birthday is Oct. 22 and his is Oct. 23 – so every year we'd have a tray full of draft beer and reminisce about the old days at the downstairs bar at the Old Victoria Hotel,' Mr. Wilkie recalls. 'Various loved ones would come and join us, but Paul would also engage with people he didn't know.' The evenings would sometimes get a bit rowdy. Even after 67 years of friendship, Wilkie says, certain things didn't change. 'Right up until the very end,' Mr. Wilkie says, 'he still called me Hoop.' Mr. Markle leaves his wife, Ms. Moore; son, Blake; daughter-in-law, Julie Bogdanowicz; granddaughters, Mia and Flora; as well as his former wife, Cheryl Markle; his brother Ross; and extended family. He was predeceased by his brother Glen. You can find more obituaries from The Globe and Mail here. To submit a memory about someone we have recently profiled on the Obituaries page, e-mail us at obit@
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
Colorado deputies disciplined for helping federal immigration agents
This image from police body camera footage provided by the Mesa County Sheriff's Office shows sheriff's Deputy Alexander Zwinck conducting a traffic stop on June 5, 2025, near Fruta, Colorado. DENVER — Two Colorado deputies have been disciplined for violating state law by helping federal agents make immigration arrests, and their sheriff says officers from other agencies have done the same. One of the deputies, Alexander Zwinck, was sued by Colorado's attorney general last week, after his cooperation with federal immigration agents on a drug task force was revealed following the June arrest of a college student from Brazil with an expired visa. Following an internal investigation, a second Mesa County Sheriff's Office deputy and task force member, Erik Olson, was also found to have shared information. The two deputies used a Signal chat to relay information to federal agents, according to documents released Wednesday by the sheriff's office. Zwinck was placed on three weeks of unpaid leave, and Olson was given two weeks of unpaid leave, Mesa County Sheriff Todd Rowell said in a statement. Both were removed from the task force. Two supervisors also were disciplined. One was suspended without pay for two days, and another received a letter of reprimand. A third supervisor received counseling. State laws push back against Trump crackdown The lawsuit and disciplinary actions come as lawmakers in Colorado and other Democratic-led states have crafted legislation intended to push back against President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown. Since Trump took office, pro-immigrant bills have advanced through legislatures in Illinois, Vermont, California, Connecticut and other states. The measures include stronger protections for immigrants in housing, employment and police encounters. Trump has enlisted hundreds of state and local law enforcement agencies to help identify immigrants in the U.S. illegally and detain them for potential deportation. The Republican also relaxed longtime rules restricting immigration enforcement near schools, churches and hospitals. Zwinck was sued under a new state law signed by Gov. Jared Polis about two weeks before the arrest of the student from Brazil. It bars local government employees including law enforcement from sharing identifying information about people with federal immigration officials. Previously, only state agencies were barred from doing that. It's one of a series of laws limiting the state's involvement in immigration enforcement passed over the years that has drawn criticism and a lawsuit from the federal government. The U.S. Department of Justice has also sued Illinois and New York, as well as several cities in those states and New Jersey, alleging their policies violate the U.S. Constitution or federal immigration laws. Officers say they were following established procedures Zwinck and Olson told officials they thought they were operating according to long-standing procedures. However, the internal investigation found they had both received and read two emails prior to the passage of the new law about previous limits on cooperation with immigration officials. The most recent was sent on Jan. 30, 2025, after an official for Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), part of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), had asked state and local law enforcement officers at a law enforcement meeting to contact HSI or ICE if they arrested a person for a violent crime who was believed not to be a citizen, the investigation documents said. The email said not to contact HSI or ICE. Zwinck said he didn't know about the new law and was not interested in immigration enforcement. 'When I was out there, I wanted to find drugs, guns and bad guys,' Zwinck said at a July 23 disciplinary hearing. 'And sending that information to HSI they provided the ability to give me real time background information on the person I was in contact with,' he said. Olson, who said he had been with the sheriff's office 18 years, testified at his disciplinary hearing that it was 'standard practice' to send information up to federal agents during traffic stops. 'It was routine for ICE to show up on the back end of a traffic stop to do their thing,' Olson said. 'I truly thought what we were doing was condoned by our supervision and lawful.' A lawyer at a law firm listed as representing both deputies, Michael Lowe, did not immediately return a telephone call or email seeking comment. Rowell said drug task force members from other law enforcement agencies, including the Colorado State Patrol, also shared information with immigration agents on the Signal chat. The state patrol denied the claim. The sheriff faulted Attorney General Phil Weiser for filing the lawsuit against Zwinck before a local internal investigation was complete. He called on the Democrat, who is running for governor, to drop it. 'As it stands, the lawsuit filed by the Attorney General's Office sends a demoralizing message to law enforcement officers across Colorado — that the law may be wielded selectively and publicly for maximum political effect rather than applied fairly and consistently,' he said. Weiser said last week that he was investigating whether other officers in the chat violated the law. Spokesperson Lawrence Pacheco said Weiser was presented with evidence of a 'blatant violation of state law' and had to act. 'The attorney general has a duty to enforce state laws and protect Coloradans and he'll continue to do so,' Pacheco said. ___ Brown reported from Billings, Montana. Colleen Slevin And Matthew Brown, The Associated Press
CTV News
4 hours ago
- CTV News
A U.S. judge says arrested Haitian businessman and former presidential hopeful will remain in custody
Barbed and razor wires are installed on the fence at The Port Isabel Detention Center, as seen during a media tour of the Port Isabel Detention Center (PIDC), hosted by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Harlingen Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) in Los Fresnos, Texas, June 10, 2024. (Veronica Gabriela Cardenas/Pool Photo via AP)
