Zumba in schools draws fire from Muslim groups; government stands firm on anti-drug push
A State-initiated Zumba dance programme, rolled out in schools across Kerala as part of a broader anti-drug campaign, has stirred controversy, drawing criticism from certain Muslim groups who claim the initiative contradicts their moral and cultural values.
The programme, integrated by the General Education department into school schedule this academic year, aims to reduce stress among students and provide them with a healthy outlet to combat the rising threat of drug abuse.
However, the initiative has been met with strong opposition from various Islamic organisations. Abdussamad Pookkottur, State secretary of the Samastha Kerala Sunni Yuvajana Sangham (SYS), the youth wing of the Samastha Kerala Jamiyyathul Ulama, voiced his disapproval in a Facebook post, asserting that 'Zumba dance is against moral values' and urged parents to reconsider the programme's influence.
Study or discussions
The Muslim Students Federation (MSF) also questioned the decision-making process behind the initiative. MSF State president P.K. Navas said, 'When such a programme is introduced in schools, thorough and credible studies must be carried out. Has the department conducted any study or held discussions with students, teachers or parents?,' he asked.
In a Facebook post, Wisdom Islamic Organisation general secretary T.K. Ashraf stated that he had opted out of implementing the programme as a teacher and would not allow his son to participate. He also criticised the programme's alleged promotion of 'a culture where boys and girls, wearing minimal clothing, dance together to the rhythm of music.'
'There may be people who see this as progressive. I am not one of them. I admit I am old-fashioned in this regard,' he wrote, adding that some educators and parents shared his concerns, but feared repercussions for speaking out. He also alleged pressure from the department, including threats of disciplinary action for non-compliance.
Higher Education Minister R. Bindu strongly defended the initiative, and emphasised its role in promoting both mental and physical well-being. She dismissed objections as rooted in outdated ideology.
Inclusive outlook
'We are well into the 21st century; it is 2025. We are not living in the 19th century or the primitive medieval period,' she said, urging critics to adopt a more progressive and inclusive outlook. 'Those who oppose such efforts will only end up isolating themselves.'
She also expressed concern over the rise of 'hardline conservatism' and criticised what she called the resurgence of 'primitive thinking, discrimination and exclusion.'
'Women have gone to space. Unfortunately, some still cling to views from centuries past. What we need is a humane, inclusive outlook. When we say 'man,' it includes all of humanity, including women. Women have equal ownership of this world,' the Minister asserted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Zumba row: Don't bring religious orthodoxy into education field, says CPM's MA Baby
Kozhikode: CPM general secretary M A Baby appealed to the people not to bring religious orthodoxy into the field of education. He was speaking on the controversy over implementing Zumba dance sessions in schools. Zumba dance form is practised in more than 180 countries and many individuals, both young and older generations, follow this dance form for overall physical well-being, said Baby. "There is a saying, 'sound mind in a sound body'. You have to be physically fit when you want to be mentally and intellectually fit. So, this criticism that when Zumba dance is being practised, boys and girls are found scantily dressed is an absolute untruth. I have seen the videos of these performances, and they are fully dressed. So, this initiative should not be subjected to criticism due to these unfounded allegations," Baby told the media. Comments like boys and girls shouldn't participate in events together are not suitable for the modern age, he said. It is time to discuss how to live in the 22nd century and those opposing it should introspect, Baby added.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
What is Zumba and why has it been introduced in schools
Zumba, a fitness programme that blends lively music and dance moves, has been around for years but is now at the heart of a major row that again pits certain Muslim organisations against the State government. The government initiated the zumba programme in schools this academic year to promote students' physical and mental health and in step with its anti-drug campaign 'With children and youth' that sought to channelise students' interests and energy away from drugs into positive alternatives. This followed a meeting convened by Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan of representatives of student and youth organisations, teacher and parent organisations, experts from various fields, and Ministers at the State Assembly on March 30 to prepare an action plan to curb the increase in substance abuse and violence among students and youth. The Chief Minister had then suggested zumba as a way of relieving the many stresses that students faced and directed Minister for General Education V. Sivankutty to look into implementing it in the new academic year. Mr. Sivankutty had then said that some form of exercise would be organised in schools in the afternoons to invigorate students and improve their mental and physical well-being. He later announced a mega Zumba display by 1,000 students in the State capital on April 30 to create awareness against drug abuse and give more importance to physical activity in the school curriculum. The General Education department also provided training to teachers on organising zumba session from class VIII onwards. With the government laying more thrust on health and physical education in the curriculum, more time has been allotted for physical activity in the timetable. State Council of Educational Research and Training Director Jayaprakash R.K. said Zumba was also part of the revised school curriculum. It had been included in the new class VIII art education and physical education textbooks. Following criticism of the Zumba programme, the Kerala School Teachers' Association (KSTA) has questioned the claim that no discussion had gone into it. It pointed out that those flaying the decision should have taken part in the meeting called by the Chief Minister earlier or given their opinions in writing. The Kerala Pradesh School Teachers' Association said organising Zumba sessions was inadequate to keep children from turning to substance abuse. More meaningful and effective strategies had to be implemented, particularly when synthetic drugs were increasingly available. Controversy apart, Zumba remains a popular fitness activity. Its appeal lies in the rhythmic music and the group fitness model that pushes one to do more, says Rashmi Kishore, an instructor. Rashmi says it is an exercise in disguise, something one does without being conscious of it, especially if one does not like working out alone. A chunk of her clientele is middle-aged for whom regular and consistent physical activity is a mantra for good health. It is also a good stress-buster, especially for those working in high-pressure jobs, says Rashmi.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
Thiruvananthapuram medical college scrambles for explanation after Urology head's social media lament
A Facebook post by the Head of Urology at Government Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram, lamenting over his helplessness and inability to provide the best of care to his patients because of systemic issues, has hit headlines in the State, with the college authorities scrambling to give their version of the story and dismissing the social media post as a 'temperamental outburst'. In his post, Harris Chirakkal penned his anguish over having to apologise red-faced to a 23-year-old boy – who was to undergo a scheduled endourology procedure on Friday – for cancelling his surgery at the eleventh hour. Dr. Chirakkal wrote that he was forced to postpone the procedure as the equipment required for the same was unavailable at the hospital, even though his request for purchasing the equipment had been pending with the hospital development society (HDS) for months. He said that he was putting his apology before the public because he was aware of how much the poor depended on this large public sector hospital for affordable care and the hardships they underwent to find money for care (some of the procedures are charged a user fee by the HDS). He wrote that though he was committed to providing the best of care to his patients, the red tape and bureaucratic harassment was getting the better of him. He said that despite heading a speciality department, he did not have any purchasing power to ensure the availability of necessary equipment in his department and was forced to be at the mercy of many administrative powers that be. He penned that he was so dejected that he did not care about the consequences of his open outburst. Authorities say However, with the post making media headlines, the Director of Medical Education (DME), the Principal, and the Superintendent sought to explain on Saturday that Dr. Chirakkal was overreacting and that his post was intended to malign the reputation of the oldest medical college in the State. They explained that equipment was purchased by the HDS as and when HoDs put up purchase requests. However, a single procedure had to be postponed on Friday because of the sudden malfunctioning of an equipment and it was a technical issue which delayed the purchase of the same. The DME said that an explanation would be sought from Dr. Chirakkal about his social media post. The viral post was later removed by Dr. Chirakkal as the issue escalated, but not before it was shared widely on social media. Senior medical college officials confided that these issues were happening because of the outdated rules and procedures which insisted that any purchase above ₹1 lakh in medical colleges has to be cleared by the District Collector. 'In a major tertiary care centre, where complex cases and procedures are taken up round the clock, such outdated procedures for equipment maintenance and purchase are an impediment to the efficient day-to-day functioning of the hospital. The government and the administration should be correcting these anomalies instead of blaming doctors for being 'emotional,' a senior doctor said.
