
Fair taxation is about more than bashing the rich
Wealth does need to be taxed more fairly, and equalising capital gains tax with income tax would be a good start – easy to administer and yielding significant revenues. Making council tax fairer would result in a massive redistribution of wealth. And middle-income earners – the biggest segment of taxpayers – will need to pay higher taxes.
Only the first of these is politically straightforward – the other two would need a much greater consensus around solidarity and fair contribution than exists in Britain today, and politicians need to start laying the groundwork for that now if the tax system is to be made fairer.Duncan CraigLondon
It is inarguable that Britain's economy has, as you say, become 'a machine for the upward redistribution of wealth' – a dynamic surely fuelling the fear-driven rightward drift of our politics. Yet contemporary surface trends alone cannot explain this volcano of discontent. A surprising amount of inequality remains rooted deep in mercenary medieval violence, bequeathing us a land ownership pattern that never seems to change.
So, of course, as long as our public realm is threadbare, target the newly income-wealthy, but do not forget to tax the hoarders of these unearned historical assets (eg through land value tax). And never permit the affluent and privileged to criticise our struggling public services while arguing for tax cuts for their ilk.Dr Brendan HillEdinburgh
What is the purpose of a majority of British people being in favour of a wealth tax when too many non-productive UK billionaires dictate and control our trickle-up economy to their advantage? Is it ignorance, fear and cowardice that diverts the minds of too many parliamentary leaders and economists away from fairness and decency?
Tax Justice UK is correct. A relatively modest wealth tax would enable practical moves towards equality, not least for students and staff in further and higher education. The government needs to give moral leadership, and here are policies for meaningful ways forward.Barry JonesEmeritus professor, Brunel University of London
Your editorial ignores three factors: wealth is reinvested (alienate it and there is less to sustain our economy); inheritance and wealth taxes amount to double taxation (they are major disincentives to the wealth creation on which high-spending economies depend); in terms of the first tranche of taxation, that on income and in terms of 'who pays the bills', the top 1% pay 30% of income tax, the top 10%, 60% and the top 50%, 90%.
Better public services depend on the encouragement of wealth creation, not its disincentivisation.David BiesterfieldEglingham, Northumberland
The reason we have so many billionaires (and such an egregiously skewed distribution of wealth) is simply that our political parties depend on, and are beholden to, their billionaire funders.Jon MarksTring, Hertfordshire
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Times
7 minutes ago
- Times
Can I sell my dad's house while waiting for probate?
Q. We have been waiting for probate on my father's estate for three months and are becoming really anxious to sell his property in case the market turns. Is there anything we can do to hurry the process along, and can we get on with starting to sell the house in the meantime? Name supplied Since 2019 delays at the probate registry have been common and have posed a real challenge for many dealing with the administration of an estate, adding to the stress and uncertainty of what is already an extremely difficult time. While waiting times have shown some signs of improvement over the past year, the process unfortunately remains quite unpredictable. In our experience, some grants are being issued within as little as two weeks of the application, while others are taking up to 12 weeks. That said, 12 weeks is generally considered the upper limit in most cases, so I am hopeful that you will get the grant shortly.

The National
10 minutes ago
- The National
Business confidence in Scotland at highest level in 8 months
The private sector also saw its strongest rise in activity since November, the bank's growth tracker found. BUSINESS confidence has risen to its highest level in eight months, according to a Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) survey. Overall, the combined output of Scotland's manufacturing and service sectors rose from a score of 50.5 in May to 50.9 in June. It marks the second consecutive monthly rise in business activity. READ MORE: 'What do they stand for?': What we learned about Labour from new poll of 7000 voters RBS said that while the uptick was modest overall, it was the strongest since November 2024. The growth was driven entirely by the services sector with new project funding and a rise in demand underscoring the uptick. Manufacturing continued to fall sharply, the tracker found. Overall, business confidence improved to its highest level of optimism in eight months. Judith Cruickshank, chair of the One Bank Scotland Board, said: 'Scotland's private sector recorded a sustained uptick in activity at the end of the second quarter, with growth predominantly driven by service providers. 'In contrast, the manufacturing sector faced a challenging demand environment, leading to overall declines in new business and production. 'Despite these sectoral differences, firms exhibited increased optimism about the future, with manufacturers reporting positive growth forecasts for the first time in three months. 'In June, private sector firms encountered sharply rising operating costs, but selling price inflation slowed notably. This suggests a willingness among businesses to absorb some costs to bolster sales. 'The employment landscape remained broadly stable compared to the previous month, with sector data continuing to highlight diverging trends between manufacturers and service providers.' The UK as a whole saw output growth rise to a nine-month high, the tracker found, driven by expansions in business activity across eight of the 12 nations and regions monitored by the survey. Companies in Scotland recorded a ninth successive monthly fall in incoming new orders during June. The reduction in new work was centred on the manufacturing sector as services firms reported another expansion. UK-wide, new business rose for the first time in seven months. In Scotland, private sector companies remained optimistic about the year-ahead for activity in June. The degree of positive sentiment rose for a third straight month to the highest since October but was weaker than that recorded for the UK as a whole. Confidence across Scotland was supported by plans to introduce new product lines, improved operational performance, and strategic marketing efforts, the survey found. And after a slight rise in employment in May, Scotland's workforce numbers were broadly unchanged in June. Services firms reported increases in staffing levels amid upturns in new business and activity. However, this was offset by another month of job shedding at manufacturers. A near universal fall in headcounts was also recorded across the 12 monitored UK regions and nations, with Northern Ireland being the sole exception. Among the remaining areas, Scotland experienced the least pronounced drop in employment and one that was only 'fractional', RBS said. Since mid-2024, Scottish firms have continued to record a drop in backlogs of work, although June's rate of depletion was the weakest in eight months. RBS said that the fall is driven by a lack of orders in manufacturing which has allowed firms to complete outstanding orders. According to the survey, Scottish firms signalled another marked increase in average input costs during June. It found the rate of inflation quickened from May and was 'historically elevated'. Survey respondents often reported higher costs for materials, labour and energy, as well as rising supplier prices. READ MORE: Ancient neolithic festival site unearthed ahead of planned football pitches However, the rise was less pronounced in Scotland compared to the UK as a whole. Firms north of the order also raised their output prices at a reduced rate in June. RBS described the latest increase in charges as 'solid' but still amounted to the slowest rate in 11 months and was similar to the UK-wide average. Where higher charges were recorded, they were primarily attributed to the pass-through of increased operating expenses to customers.


The Independent
15 minutes ago
- The Independent
The Amazon Fire TV stick HD is cheaper than ever for Prime Day
Amazon has launched its annual Prime Day sale, a four-day shopping event bringing big savings to everything from air fryers to laptops and televisions. I've spotted one pretty impressive deal in the sale. Right now, the Amazon Fire TV Stick HD has 40 per cent off, bringing the price of the no-fuss streaming dongle down to just £23.99. You'll find plenty of deals on many of Amazon's most popular own-brand products in the rest of the sale, like the Ring battery video doorbell (was £99.99, now £49.99, The Echo Show 8 (was £149.99, now £89.99, and Kindle Paperwhite (was £159.99, now £124.99, have been discounted, too. The Amazon Prime Day sale runs from now until 11 July and features thousands of deals on products across most categories. Be sure to check out our full Prime Day shopping guide for the latest deals as they drop. Whether your TV doesn't have smarts or the interface is a little slow and clunky, you can add or upgrade its capabilities cheaply with the Amazon Fire TV stick HD. The dongle and remote control let you access entertainment from all of the most popular streaming services – including Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video and Apple TV+ – as well as watch live TV, listen to music and control your smart home with voice commands. More affordable than Roku's excellent streaming stick 4K (was £49.99, now £39.99, this version of the Amazon Fire TV stick only outputs at 1080p rather than full 4K, which is perfect if your TV is a little older or if your streaming subscription is only providing full HD video. Amazon Prime Day is a four-day sale event for Prime members. It's usually held twice a year – once in the summer and again in October to kick-start Christmas shopping. The event features deals across top brands, from Apple to Dyson, as well as offers on its bestselling own tech, including Kindle and Echo dot smart speakers.