Defence accuses ex-detective of bungled investigation into Gareth Ward assault allegations
In March 2022 Mr Ward was charged with three counts of assault with act of indecency – an alternative charge of common assault – involving an 18-year-old man at Meroo Meadow in 2013.
He was also charged with one count of sexual intercourse without consent relating to a 24-year-old man in Potts Point in 2015.
Mr Ward has pleaded not guilty to all charges.
Former detective senior constable Cameron Bignell failed to return to the witness box by the required 10am start time on Thursday.
When the court resumed after 2pm he admitted, under cross-examination, to breaching his subpoena by arriving hours late.
"I had commitments I could not get out of … and I advised I would be a little bit late," Mr Bignell told the court.
Pressed on why he had not sought permission from the judge the previous day, he said he believed an officer would "handle it" after he explained the situation.
Defence barrister David Campbell SC suggested Mr Bignell had shown disregard for his obligations and disrespect towards the court.
"You defied that order, didn't you?" Mr Campbell asked.
"I did, yes," Mr Bignell replied, before adding, "it certainly was not my intention to be disrespectful."
The former detective said he had been unwell and had intended to get a medical certificate, but did not follow through after deciding to return to court.
Mr Campbell accused the former officer of believing he could choose when to attend.
"This is part of you, isn't it — that you do what you want to do, rather than what you should," Mr Campbell said.
"Absolutely not," Mr Bignell replied.
The defence said that same mindset had marked his handling of the case, which Mr Bignell also rejected.
At one point, Bignell acknowledged telling police he was "happy to get arrested" but said he could not avoid his earlier commitments.
He later described that as "an off-the-cuff comment".
Mr Bignell, who led the investigation from May 2021 until his resignation from NSW Police in 2024, was called to give evidence by the Crown on Wednesday.
He told the court he had reviewed and collected statements from both complainants, key witnesses and conducted a walk-through in Sydney's CBD in September 2021 related to the older complainant's account.
But the defence grilled him on missed opportunities and delays in evidence collection.
Mr Campbell questioned why police had never interviewed a third man who shared the Potts Point apartment with Mr Ward at the time of the alleged 2015 assault.
"It would be rather central to determine whether [the flatmate] was in the lounge room," Mr Campbell said.
"I agree," Mr Bignell responded.
"You can't give us one reason why you didn't task anyone to make that enquiry?" Mr Campbell asked.
"I cannot," the former officer said.
The defence also criticised Mr Bignell's delay in seeking taxi records to verify the younger complainant's claim that Mr Ward paid for his ride home to Meroo Meadow.
Police did not request the records until 2024, by which time the company had changed hands and the data was no longer available.
"That was an unfortunate development, yes," Mr Bignell said.
When asked why he had not spoken to Mr Ward's regular driver, Mr Bignell said he had relied on the complainant's version of events.
The court has heard that Mr Ward, who is legally blind, was known to often rely on a driver for transport.
Mr Campbell also challenged the pace of the investigation, including why the September 2021 walk-through – proposed months earlier – had taken so long to organise.
"Why did it take you so long?" Mr Campbell asked.
"I can't recall — scheduling conflicts," Mr Bignell replied.
"It wasn't the only job I was working on."
Mr Bignell pushed back on suggestions the complainant's movements during the walk-through were inconsistent or unclear and rejected claims he zig-zagged around the streets.
"I think you're exaggerating there," Mr Bignell said.
Mr Bignell is expected to continue being cross-examined tomorrow as the trial, now in its seventh week, continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
3 hours ago
- SBS Australia
Evening News Bulletin 12 July 2025
Listen to Australian and world news, and follow trending topics with SBS News Podcasts . TRANSCRIPT: A nine year old boy shot on a hunting trip in New South Wales; Traditional owners celebrate the listing of Murujuga on the World Heritage List; An Australian trio named as the referees for Sunday's FIFA Club World Cup final. A child is in a stable condition after being shot in the leg near Bourke in far northwestern New South Wales. Police say the nine-year-old boy was apparently injured during a hunting trip with four boys and five men on a property 40 kilometres from the town. A pedestrian is still fighting for his life in hospital while police wait to speak to an elderly driver at the centre of an accident in Melbourne. Victoria Police say the 91 year old motorist is yet to be interviewed after her Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath in Wantirna and hit the man, a two year old child and a woman - before smashing through a fence on Friday afternoon. The accident has prompted the Victorian government to announce rule changes for elderly drivers are being considered. Victorian acting Premier Ben Carroll says the tragedy has brought into focus previous calls for older people to prove they're fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. West Australian traditional owners say they remain concerned about the fate of rock art at Murujuga, despite the site winning a sought after UNESCO heritage listing. The Burrup peninsula in northwest WA near Karratha is home to two gas plants, a fertiliser plant and iron ore and salt export facilities, which Mardathoonera woman and Murujuga traditional custodian Raelene Cooper says could still harm the art. Still, the Murujuga Aboriginal Corporation says they are thrilled the site has won world heritage status. Deputy Chair of the Board Belinda Churnside was there for the announcement. "We have all come here together and from far away from the Murujuga lands. This has been a long awaited journey and a fight for our elders - our old people and we are thankful to receive this recognition from a global scale." A German backpacker found after nearly two weeks lost in the remote West Australian outback is now in a stable condition in hospital. 26 year old Carolina Wilga is being treated for exhaustion, dehydration and minor injuries following 11 nights in the elements, surviving with minimal food supplies, and water from rain and puddles. Detective Acting Inspector Jessica Securo says it's sheer luck she was found after flagging down a passing motorist for help - 24 kilometres from where her van had become stuck. "The area out there - there's mixed terrain. It can be quite dangerous if you don't know what you are doing or where you are going. It's very easy to get lost in that area." A preliminary investigation into the Air India crash has found fuel control switches to its engines were moved moments before impact. The 15-page report, issued by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau, did not offer any conclusions or apportion blame for the disaster on the 12th of June - but it has revealed that both pilots were confused over the change to the switch setting that caused a loss of engine thrust shortly after takeoff. The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner was headed to London when it crashed 30 seconds after takeoff, killing all but one of the 242 people on board, as well as 19 people on the ground. US President Donald Trump has toured the scene of deadly floods in Texas that have killed at least 120 people and left more than 170 missing. But Mr Trump has stirred controversy in his response to a reporter who asked about whether the warning alert system for the devastating floods worked as well as it could have. "Only a bad person would ask a question like that. I don't know who you are, but only a very evil person would ask you a question that." Public officials have faced intensifying questions about who was in charge of monitoring the weather and warning that floodwaters were barrelling toward camps and homes. But Texas Republican Representative Chip Roy says those questions are in poor taste. "The governor said it best when he said that pointing fingers is for losers. This state is about looking forward and we'll figure out how to make our systems the best they can be. But importantly, when you see 26 feet of water rising a foot per minute, don't go around pointing fingers." Australian Alireza Faghani has been appointed as a referee for Sunday's FIFA Club World Cup final between Chelsea and Paris St Germain in New Jersey. The two-time Asian Football Confederation's Referee of the Year winner will have fellow Australians Ashley Beecham and Anton Shchetinin as his assistants. Chairman of the FIFA Referees Committee, Pierluigi Collina, says it was a hard decision because of a competitive line-up. "They really put us in a very, very difficult position, because there were many referees who would have deserved to be in the final. We chose Alireza Faghani and the rest of the team, because we think, we are convinced, that this is the best team for the final."
ABC News
2 days ago
- ABC News
Sexual assault survivors call for pre-recorded testimony laws to be expanded
Amira* describes her court experience as akin to a "second rape". "The original act of violence was essentially replicated, just in a courtroom in front of the prosecution, defence, judge and a jury of 12 people," she says. "I felt like I was the one on trial." Warning: some people may find details in this story distressing. In 2022, Amira's sexual assault case finally went to court three years after she reported the alleged crime, and six years after it had occurred. The now 26-year-old describes a "looming sense of doom" as the trial approached. "During that time my life was effectively on pause … it affected every part of my existence; my relationship, my work … there was no focus on healing. Just a lot of waiting." When her day in court came, it was worse than she anticipated. She came face to face with her accused perpetrator on multiple occasions, including any time there was a break from proceedings. During cross-examination, defence lawyers grilled her about aspects of her life that were deeply personal, including telling the court she had been taking antidepressants at the time of her alleged rape — details they had subpoenaed from her health records. "It was brutal," Amira says. During the trial, Amira barely slept, and describes being so nauseous that she struggled to keep water down, let alone food. "It was tortuous," she says. "No-one deserves to be put through what I went through." Amira, alongside other victim survivors and gender equity campaigning organisation Fair Agenda, is calling for the criminal justice system to be reformed so that complainants in sexual assault cases have the right to pre-record testimony for trials. This option is offered in Queensland and the Northern Territory and some changes are underway in Western Australia, but other states and territories are yet to follow. Extending the right to pre-recorded testimony was one of a number of recommendations made by the Australian Law Reform Commission's (ALRC) review into sexual assault cases earlier this year. "If I had the opportunity to pre-record testimony, it would have given me some control over what happened, because I felt like prey sitting in the witness box," Amira says. Criminal justice researcher Julia Quilter from the University of Wollongong has spent more than 25 years researching sexual violence, and spent a decade practising as both a solicitor and barrister in criminal law. She argues the proposed reform would be transformational for the health and wellbeing of sexual assault victims. "I think this would be a game changer. It needs to happen, because what's happening at the moment is not working." Professor Quilter reviewed 75 sexual offence trials from 2014 – 2020 in New South Wales and found disturbing patterns. Lines of inquiry that tried to undermine a complainant's character were common, including questions about their history of drug and alcohol use, mental illness or the removal of children from their care. "Those sorts of character assassinations are obviously very traumatic for complainants to have to deal with, and that's before we even get to giving evidence about the circumstances of the sexual offence," Professor Quilter says. The impact of that trauma can be profound, according to Tara Hunter, director of clinical and client services at Full Stop Australia, an organisation that provides 24-hour support to victims of sexual violence. Ms Hunter has worked as a social worker for more than 30 years and supported many clients through the court process. "What we most commonly hear is [victim survivors] feel they themselves are on trial, because of the nature of questioning and the sense of victim-blaming they feel," she says. "One of the more common responses that people experience to sexual violence is shame, so [these lines of questioning] embed the impacts of that shame response." Ms Hunter explains that for many sexual assault victims, there are psychological impacts from testifying in court, including sleeplessness, depression, anxiety, hypervigilance, and a loss of sense of safety. All of this can have wide-reaching impacts on a person's life. "It can really impact their relationships in terms of their ability to connect with people, including people who are supportive," Ms Hunter says. "I've seen people change schools, drop out, not finish their uni courses. I've witnessed so many young women's life trajectories change." Both Professor Quilter and Ms Hunter believe pre-recorded testimony has the capacity to mitigate the health impacts on complainants, in part because it reduces the potential trauma of having to be in court with the accused and their supporters. As Professor Quilter explains, complainants currently have the option to give testimony via video link, but this will often be in the court building itself. Pre-recorded testimony can also be provided much closer to the alleged incident, so that complainants are not at the whim of an "unpredictable" court system characterised by long lead times and last-minute adjournments. "All the evidence indicates that having to wait around with this thing hanging over your head for potentially some years is one of the reasons complainants can't move on with their lives," Professor Quilter says. The other advantage of pre-recorded testimony is that it can improve witnesses' recall of key details of the alleged incident. "There are potential improvements in memory because of course the longer we leave something, the harder it's going to be for anybody to recall the details," Professor Quilter says. She adds that pre-recording means questions asked during cross-examination can be "edited" at the request of the prosecution before reaching (and potentially prejudicing) the jury. This is currently permitted in Queensland and the Northern Territory and is something Fair Agenda has been pushing for in its campaign for a uniform model of pre-recorded testimony. "One key benefit of pre-recorded testimony is that the judge can remove any inadmissible or inappropriate content before it's shown to the jury," campaign manager Jacinta Masters says. "So, if the defence lawyers are relying on rape myths — such as asking about the victim's clothing or sexual history — this can be edited out." She adds that the necessary technology already exists in courtrooms across Australia, with children given the right to pre-record evidence in all states and territories. "The infrastructure is already there, so we're not starting from scratch," Ms Masters says. "What's missing is the legislation to give all survivors the right to testify on their own terms." On this point, Ms Hunter says it is important to remember that not every complainant will choose to give pre-recorded testimony. But it is important that they have the choice, she argues. While pre-recorded evidence "won't fix every problem with the justice system", Ms Masters says, it will give victim survivors more agency and control over the court process. "[This] is a crucial step towards a system that puts their wellbeing at the centre." In a statement to the ABC, a spokesperson for the NSW Attorney-General said the ALRC recommendation for pre-recorded testimony would be considered at an upcoming meeting of the standing council of Attorneys-General. A spokesperson for the Victorian Government said "we understand the trauma" and have a number of strategies. People with cognitive impairment would be able to give pre-recorded evidence in committal hearings by 28 December this year, but the spokesperson did not indicate whether pre-recorded video would be more widely implemented in the future. An ACT Government spokesperson said it was aware of the recommendation but "there are risks that [pre-recorded evidence hearings] and it could create further delay and inefficiencies in the trial process if not implemented correctly". Meanwhile, Western Australia has a bill before parliament, which will allow complainants to pre-record testimony, but only in cases where a judge agrees. The ABC also contacted the Attorney General of Tasmania but they did not respond to questions before deadline.
ABC News
2 days ago
- ABC News
Defence accuses ex-detective of bungled investigation into Gareth Ward assault allegations
The former detective who led a sexual assault investigation into New South Wales MP Gareth Ward has come under fire from Mr Ward's counsel for breaching a court order after arriving hours late to give evidence despite being under subpoena. In March 2022 Mr Ward was charged with three counts of assault with act of indecency – an alternative charge of common assault – involving an 18-year-old man at Meroo Meadow in 2013. He was also charged with one count of sexual intercourse without consent relating to a 24-year-old man in Potts Point in 2015. Mr Ward has pleaded not guilty to all charges. Former detective senior constable Cameron Bignell failed to return to the witness box by the required 10am start time on Thursday. When the court resumed after 2pm he admitted, under cross-examination, to breaching his subpoena by arriving hours late. "I had commitments I could not get out of … and I advised I would be a little bit late," Mr Bignell told the court. Pressed on why he had not sought permission from the judge the previous day, he said he believed an officer would "handle it" after he explained the situation. Defence barrister David Campbell SC suggested Mr Bignell had shown disregard for his obligations and disrespect towards the court. "You defied that order, didn't you?" Mr Campbell asked. "I did, yes," Mr Bignell replied, before adding, "it certainly was not my intention to be disrespectful." The former detective said he had been unwell and had intended to get a medical certificate, but did not follow through after deciding to return to court. Mr Campbell accused the former officer of believing he could choose when to attend. "This is part of you, isn't it — that you do what you want to do, rather than what you should," Mr Campbell said. "Absolutely not," Mr Bignell replied. The defence said that same mindset had marked his handling of the case, which Mr Bignell also rejected. At one point, Bignell acknowledged telling police he was "happy to get arrested" but said he could not avoid his earlier commitments. He later described that as "an off-the-cuff comment". Mr Bignell, who led the investigation from May 2021 until his resignation from NSW Police in 2024, was called to give evidence by the Crown on Wednesday. He told the court he had reviewed and collected statements from both complainants, key witnesses and conducted a walk-through in Sydney's CBD in September 2021 related to the older complainant's account. But the defence grilled him on missed opportunities and delays in evidence collection. Mr Campbell questioned why police had never interviewed a third man who shared the Potts Point apartment with Mr Ward at the time of the alleged 2015 assault. "It would be rather central to determine whether [the flatmate] was in the lounge room," Mr Campbell said. "I agree," Mr Bignell responded. "You can't give us one reason why you didn't task anyone to make that enquiry?" Mr Campbell asked. "I cannot," the former officer said. The defence also criticised Mr Bignell's delay in seeking taxi records to verify the younger complainant's claim that Mr Ward paid for his ride home to Meroo Meadow. Police did not request the records until 2024, by which time the company had changed hands and the data was no longer available. "That was an unfortunate development, yes," Mr Bignell said. When asked why he had not spoken to Mr Ward's regular driver, Mr Bignell said he had relied on the complainant's version of events. The court has heard that Mr Ward, who is legally blind, was known to often rely on a driver for transport. Mr Campbell also challenged the pace of the investigation, including why the September 2021 walk-through – proposed months earlier – had taken so long to organise. "Why did it take you so long?" Mr Campbell asked. "I can't recall — scheduling conflicts," Mr Bignell replied. "It wasn't the only job I was working on." Mr Bignell pushed back on suggestions the complainant's movements during the walk-through were inconsistent or unclear and rejected claims he zig-zagged around the streets. "I think you're exaggerating there," Mr Bignell said. Mr Bignell is expected to continue being cross-examined tomorrow as the trial, now in its seventh week, continues.
