logo
Whole Hog Politics: Musk proves elections are awfully hard to buy

Whole Hog Politics: Musk proves elections are awfully hard to buy

The Hill04-04-2025
On the menu: Tariffs taxed in new poll; Senate Dems get their man in New Hampshire; California primary getting crowded; Peter Navarro, 'Drumline' enthusiast; At least he didn't add Jeffrey Goldberg.
People keep telling me that money is the big problem in politics. But if that's true, how come nobody can ever seem to buy a danged election anymore?
In 1980, then-West Virginia Gov. Jay Rockefeller coolly noted to the press that he was willing to devote whatever millions of dollars of his family's fortune were necessary to win a second term in a rematch with Republican Arch Moore, the man who had defeated Rockefeller in 1972.
The boast won a reply in bumper-sticker form from Moore's supporters: 'Make him spend it all, Arch.' And while Moore didn't make him spend it all, Rockefeller did outspend Moore 12 to 1, dumping what would be in today's dollars $45 or $50 million on the race.
Is that why Rockefeller won by 9 points instead of losing by 9 points, as he did eight years earlier? It may have been that in 1972, Richard Nixon was the only Republican to carry the Mountain State between 1956 and 1984 and had coattails; or that in the first race, Moore was the incumbent and Rockefeller was the challenger, and in the rematch the roles were reversed. But spending what today would be more than $115 for every vote he received surely had to be a good bit of the difference for Rockefeller.
Nor was that Rockefeller the only Rockefeller to figure out that carpetbagging was a value proposition. Unlike his uncle Nelson who stayed in New York, where elections are pricey, Jay's uncle Winthrop headed out to Arkansas where grandpa John D. 's compounded profits went a lot farther.
So now it's Teslas instead of Standard Oil, but the impulse remains the same for some of the very rich. Elon Musk, the richest man in America (and therefore the world), tried a similar maneuver in Wisconsin this week, dumping gobs of money and his manic campaign presence into a contest for a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.
Through direct expenditures and his super PACs, it looks like Musk put at least $25 million into an effort to elect Brad Schimel, the state's former attorney general, to fill the swing seat on the state's high court. Musk and the Muskovites ran millions in ads, wrote $1 million checks to two young Wisconsin Republicans as ' spokespeople ' and one of his PACs offered $50 for anyone uploading a photo of a Wisconsin resident outside of a polling place. In West Virginia, when you bought somebody's vote back in the Kennedy era, it was customary to include a pint of whiskey as a courtesy, so the Wisconsin picture payola represents a step backward for electoral compensation but a great advance in convenience.
Musk's loud, early entry into the contest, of course, drew in the aspiring election purchasers from the other side. America's Dairyland overflowed with cash from Democratic billionaires, including Hyatt Hotel heir JB Pritzker, the governor of neighboring Illinois, who has an obvious appetite for even higher office. In all, it looks like the race will have consumed more than $100 million for a single seat on a seven-member court in the 20th biggest state in the union.
Woof.
So what did all that money buy? Wisconsin had an almost identical race with similar stakes in 2023. That time it was a Republican-backed justice who was retiring, so the GOP was trying to maintain control of the court, while this time the roles were reversed. But the result was the same: In both races, the Democratic-backed candidate won by 10 points.
The major difference was that turnout this year was through the roof. An astonishing 520,892 more people voted this time — a 28 percent increase from two years ago.
Musk was explicitly testing the premise of whether he could solve his party's biggest political problem of the Trump era: what to do about midterms and special elections when the Republicans rely on lower-income, lower propensity voters to fuel presidential victories. Musk is broadly unpopular, but is a beloved celebrity in the very online MAGA world. Could his famous name and deep pockets mobilize the younger and more downscale voters who are unlikely to get jazzed up for a judicial election?
The answer was yes, but, unfortunately for Musk, he also proved to be a powerful motivator for Democrats, too. Turnout went up, but it went up across the board; a very expensive way to get an exact repeat of the election two years ago that cost half as much.
Musk claimed after the loss he expected the Wisconsin effort to fail but that it was worth ' losing a piece for a positional gain,' the premise presumably being that Musk and his team are honing their methods for the future in Wisconsin and elsewhere. It seems obvious that placing such a big bet and walking away with nothing to show for it will tend to increase the willingness of Republicans who have grown resentful of the mercurial methods of the tech billionaire to oppose him. But perhaps even the 'positional gain' idea for methods is flawed.
In 2024, Musk showered Donald Trump with money, spending something like $200 million in the swing states to help the Republican nominee. But nowhere was Musk more active or liberal with his checkbook than in the most important swing state, Pennsylvania. That was where Musk first tried out his idea of paying voters and where he appeared again and again, with and without Trump.
And yet, when the votes were counted, the shift in Pennsylvania was smaller than in the nation as a whole. The Keystone state was 2.9 points more Republican in 2024 than it was in 2020, compared to a 6-point shift in the national popular vote. OK, fine. Democrats weren't spending any time or money in the places where the biggest shifts were happening, mostly metropolitan areas in blue states. So maybe Musk made the difference where it counted.
But the shift in Pennsylvania wasn't even big compared with the six other states where Democrats did spend all their time and money. Pennsylvania's drift to the right was the fourth largest of the seven, smack in the middle. It was half of what it was in Arizona, where Musk spent comparatively little time or money.
Musk's massive cash infusions no doubt helped a Trump campaign that at the end of last summer was in a deep financial hole. But so did the money from other Republican billionaires who were mostly content to let the very effective and well-run Trump campaign proceed as it wished. It wasn't so much that Trump got the bonus of Musk's involvement along with the money, but that he had to accept Musk's meddling as a condition of getting the cash. Whether or not there was any truth in that in 2024, Musk's low, low favorability ratings now certainly suggest that it is the case today.
Polls tell us that the influence of money in politics is a top concern of American voters — 72 percent in a recent Pew Research survey — and it is certainly an easy target for people looking to complain about the rotten way we've been running things in recent years.
But looking at Wisconsin and the astonishing failures of overfunded candidates like Jeb Bush and Hillary Clinton, it suggests that elections are awfully hard to buy. Yes, you don't want to get swamped like Arch Moore did back in 1980, but once you're in contention, more money doesn't equal more votes — especially if the money is coming from one of the most polarizing figures in American life.
There are only two pertinent amounts of money in campaigns: enough and not enough. Everything else is just spoilage.
Holy croakano! We welcome your feedback, so please email us with your tips, corrections, reactions, amplifications, etc. at WHOLEHOGPOLITICS@GMAIL.COM. If you'd like to be considered for publication, please include your real name and hometown. If you don't want your comments to be made public, please specify.
NUTRITIONAL INFORMATION
Trump Job Performance
Average Approval: 45.2%
Average Disapproval: 51.4%
Net Score: -6.2 points
Change from last week: -1.8 points
[Average includes: TIPP: 44% approve – 45% disapprove; Marquette Law: 46% approve – 54% disapprove; AP/NORC: 42% approve – 56% disapprove; Ipsos/Reuters: 45% approve – 51% disapprove; Fox News: 49% approve – 51% disapprove]
Americans overwhelmingly disapprove of Trump's trade tactics
Overall, do you approve or disapprove of the way Donald Trump is handling trade negotiations with other countries?
Overall: 38% approve – 60% disapprove
Republicans: 72% approve – 27% disapprove
Independents: 28% approve – 68% disapprove
Democrats: 10% approve – 89% disapprove
[ AP/NORC poll of 1,229 U.S. adults, March 2025 ]
ON THE SIDE: SPILLING THE BEANS
Smithsonian Magazine: 'Stenophylla is a coffee plant, not a criminal, and yet it can still lay claim to its very own 'Wanted' poster. In 2018, Aaron Davis, head of coffee research at the Royal Botanic Gardens was desperate to track down the rare species, which hadn't been seen in the wild since 1954. … He had no choice but to start searching Sierra Leone's forests himself. … Yet even knowing what to look for, the two botanists often had to trek for days through rainforests. They got caught in a cyclone; Davis almost died of hookworm. … When they finally found the plant, it ended up being measly, with no fruits or flowers. To an untrained eye, it looked like any other shrub in the forest. But Davis knew right away—he saw that distinctive architecture. … By 2020, Davis' team had finally collected enough stenophylla in the wild to roast nine grams—a tiny amount, but enough for him to finally have his first long-awaited taste. … Stenophylla resembled Rwandan bourbon coffee, a premium arabica of exceptional quality. 'I was just, like, oh, my God, this is amazing.''
PRIME CUTS
Pappas launches New Hampshire Senate bid: The Hill: 'Rep. Chris Pappas (D-N.H.) announced Thursday he's running for a Senate seat in New Hampshire to replace Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.), who's retiring. … Pappas is the first Democrat to throw his hat in the ring for Shaheen's seat, though others in the party, including first-term Rep. Maggie Goodlander (D-N.H.), also could launch bids. Pappas's announcement followed a 10-county listening tour he took as he mulled a potential bid. Should Pappas win the seat, he would make history as the first openly gay man elected to the Senate. … Meanwhile, former New Hampshire Gov. Chris Sununu (R) and former U.S. Ambassador to New Zealand and Samoa Scott Brown are mulling bids on the Republican side.'
Independent Osborn floats second Senate campaign: Nebraska Examiner: 'Former Nebraska U.S. Senate candidate Dan Osborn decided Thursday to explore another run for the Senate, this time against Republican U.S. Sen. Pete Ricketts in the midterms.
… The former Omaha labor leader's announcement of a second possible Senate run comes after his populist bid against U.S. Sen. Deb Fischer, R-Neb., in 2024 made national headlines for turning an expected safe race into a potential upset. … He attracted an extraordinary fundraising haul for a nonpartisan federal candidate in Nebraska of $14 million. … Osborn told the Nebraska Examiner last month that he had expanded his scope for his next political office run last month after initially thinking about running against Republican U.S. Rep. Don Bacon in the Omaha-based 2nd District or running for governor against GOP Gov. Jim Pillen. … The same working-class-focused rhetoric that drove President Donald Trump's victory gives someone like Osborn an opening.'
McMorrow first to join Dem field in Michigan: New York Times: 'State Senator Mallory McMorrow of Michigan, a Democrat from the Detroit suburbs, jumped into her state's U.S. Senate race on Wednesday, becoming the first prominent candidate to enter the contest. … The seat opened after Senator Gary Peters, a Democrat, announced his retirement. … 'We need new leaders,' Ms. McMorrow, 38, said in her announcement video. 'The same people in D.C. who got us into this mess are not going to be the ones to get us out of it.' … Democrats who have signaled that they are eyeing the Senate race include Representative Haley Stevens, a moderate from suburban Detroit; Representative Kristen McDonald Rivet, a Democrat who won a challenging House district in Michigan last year; and Abdul El-Sayed, an outgoing health director in Wayne County.'
Adams ditches Dems, will run as independent: The Hill: 'New York City Mayor Eric Adams (D) announced he is running for reelection as an independent in the mayoral race, as he has faced long odds of being able to win as a Democrat. … The mayor said in a video posted on the social platform X that the 'bogus' criminal case against him dragged on too long, causing a primary campaign to be impossible to mount. 'But I'm not a quitter, I'm a New Yorker,' he said. 'And that is why today, though I am still a Democrat, I am announcing that I will forego the Democratic primary for mayor and appeal directly to all New Yorkers as an independent in the general election.' … The news comes a day after a federal judge formally dismissed the corruption case against Adams. … Despite emphasizing his innocence, his already poor approval rating plummeted since he was indicted in September, and a majority of New Yorkers have consistently said in polling that they believe he should resign.'
Dem overperformances in Florida remind GOP of 2018: UVA Center for Politics: 'A theme of the first two years of Donald Trump's first administration was Democratic overperformance in special elections. In the oft-memed words of the Giant in Twin Peaks, 'It is happening again.' … In 2017-2018, Democrats ran on average 10.6 points ahead of Clinton's showing in 2016. That was a smaller 4.8 points in 2020, and then Democrats ran 3.7 points on average behind Joe Biden in the 2022 cycle. … This isn't a perfectly predictive indicator—indeed, it suggested a better showing for Democrats than they got in 2024, for sure. … But it is notable that the biggest overperformances in the Trump era came in advance of 2018, also the Democrats' best electoral showing in this era. The 2025 Downballot average so far, including the two races [on Tuesday], is that Democrats are running 11.4 points ahead of Kamala Harris's 2024 margin, very similar to the 2017-2018 number. This is why we think it feels a lot like 2017 right now.'
SHORT ORDER
Handful of Republican senators join Dems to try to undo Canada tariffs— Wall Street Journal
GOP leaders dismiss Trump's talk of third term— NBC News
Xavier Becerra launches California gubernatorial bid— Los Angeles Times
Former aide launches primary challenge to longtime Dem Rep. Brad Sherman — The Hill
TABLE TALK
'The beginning is always today.'
'As the movie 'Drumline' goes, 'one band, one sound.'' — White House senior trade adviser Peter Navarro in a statement likening the administration's tariff approach to the 2002 coming-of-age comedy-drama.
MAHA or MWHAHAHA?
'I said to Governor Morrisey the first time I saw him, I said, 'You look like you ate Governor Morrisey.' … Raise your hand if you want Gov. Morrisey to do a public weigh-in once a month. Then when he's lost 30 pounds, I'm going to come back to the state and do a celebration and a public weigh-in with him.' — Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. at an event in West Virginia for health initiatives, with some notes for Gov. Patrick Morrisey (R).
You should email us! Write to WHOLEHOGPOLITICS@GMAIL.COM with your tips, kudos, criticisms, insights, rediscovered words, wonderful names, recipes, and, always, good jokes. Please include your real name—at least first and last—and hometown. Make sure to let us know in the email if you want to keep your submission private. My colleague, the upwardly mobile Nate Moore, and I will look for your emails and then share the most interesting ones and my responses here. Clickety clack!
FOR DESSERT
Next Time, Try Signal
AP: 'The mayor of one of North Dakota's largest cities resigned after an investigation into him mistakenly sending a lewd video to the city attorney. Minot Mayor Tom Ross resigned Tuesday, the same day an investigative report was made public that found Ross sent a video of himself masturbating to City Attorney Stefanie Stalheim in January. He sent the video minutes after the two had a telephone call discussing a [police matter]. Ross asked Stalheim to delete the video, not to watch it and to keep the incident between them, the report said. Ross told an interviewer he had recorded the video at home during a lunch break and meant to send it to his romantic partner, not to Stalheim. He had said it was 'a sexy video for his girlfriend.''
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'Relieved': Educators await Trump administration to release $6 billion in frozen funding
'Relieved': Educators await Trump administration to release $6 billion in frozen funding

Boston Globe

time2 minutes ago

  • Boston Globe

'Relieved': Educators await Trump administration to release $6 billion in frozen funding

Advertisement The Trump administration announced the funding freeze on June 30, a day before the money was supposed to be sent to school districts in both New England and across the nation. It was another move toward the White House's goal to dismantle the Education Department, as President Trump argues that classrooms are teaching left-wing ideology. In Massachusetts, the freeze translated into $108 million withheld, leaving many districts scrambling to ensure they could still provide services during the summer months and the upcoming fall semester, with some cancelling summer programs entirely. In addition to training educators Advertisement Ray Hart, executive director of the Council of the Great City Schools, a nationwide association of urban districts that includes Boston, said in a statement they're 'relieved' about the administration releasing the funds 'for the benefit of schoolchildren throughout our nation.' In Rhode Island, education commissioner Angélica Infante-Green said, 'On behalf of Rhode Island's students, families, and teachers,' it is 'relieved to hear that the congressionally approved education funding is set to be released.' The Education Department 'will begin dispersing funds to states next week,' said Madi Biedermann, a spokesperson for the department, in a statement Friday. Biedermann said the Office of Management and Budget completed its review of the grants and directed the Education Department to release the funding. The move comes after the District of Columbia and 24 states, including Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Maine, 'It is impossible for states to effectively budget for an upcoming school year ... when the president takes the football away from us, like Lucy in a Charlie Brown cartoon,' said Peter Neronha, Rhode Island Attorney General, at a press conference announcing the lawsuit earlier this month. Related : A coalition of school districts and teachers' unions, including the Rhode Island Federation of Teachers and Health Professionals, Susan Collins, a Republican senator from Maine, and Ed Markey, a Democratic senator from Massachusetts, were among the politicians who criticized the freeze and demanded the administration release the money. Advertisement 'Every day that goes by without this education funding hurts our students, educators, and communities,' said Pedro Martinez, Commissioner of the Massachusetts Department for Elementary and Secondary Education, in a statement Thursday. 'We are still recovering from pandemic learning loss, and these federal funds are directly related to improving student academic achievement.' In early July, Governor Maura Healey said in a statement that districts would be forced to lay off staff, delay or cancel programs, and disrupt learning. 'Our schools were promised this funding, and the Trump Administration needs to deliver it,' Healey said. In a survey by the School Superintendents Association, about three-quarters said they would cut academic programs, and half said they would lay off teachers if funding was not restored. In a statement, the executive director of the association, David Schuler, said he was 'pleased' with the news of the funding being released. Some programs saw an immediate, negative impact following the freeze, including the The program, which has operated in Massachusetts since 1966, aims to address the toll on children's education caused by the frequent moves, as students transfer between different school districts or miss school altogether to work alongside their parents. In Springfield, 9-year-old Ery Perez Gutierrez last summer focused on sharpening his academic skills at Advertisement Ery is among hundreds of children in Massachusetts spending the summer at home because of the funding freeze. President Trump had proposed cutting the Migrant Education Program altogether in the next Last year, the grant served 438 students for summer programs statewide, said Emily Hoffman, director of the program in Massachusetts. The loss of the program at Boland Elementary is 'heartbreaking' and a 'huge step backwards,' as students are going without much-needed services, said Lisa Bakowski, the school's principal, who oversaw the program for the past three summers. Bakowski said the children enrolled in the program are among the most vulnerable in the community. Their parents work in the fields all day and often don't speak English. 'It sickens me that it's become a political issue when it really should never have been,' Bakowski said. 'It's about the betterment of humanity and being able to work to assist and provide for pockets of our community that need it.' Related : Other programs targeted in the freeze weren't immediately impacted. The largest grant frozen, known as Advertisement In previous years, Boston Public Schools used the funding to provide additional support for the district's recruitment efforts and educator preparation, including through an intensive 12-month program that prepares aspiring teachers to enter the classroom at no cost to them. Following the freeze announcement, BPS 'identified temporary one-time funding to maintain these efforts, which will continue in Fiscal Year 2026 despite the funding freeze with the hopes that the funding will eventually be available,' a spokesperson said in a statement Thursday. Massachusetts districts received $27 million in fiscal year 2025 for teacher training, with BPS receiving about Marcela Rodrigues can be reached at

NY Republicans tie Dem opponents to Zohran Mamdani: 'They're Mamdani Democrats!'
NY Republicans tie Dem opponents to Zohran Mamdani: 'They're Mamdani Democrats!'

New York Post

time32 minutes ago

  • New York Post

NY Republicans tie Dem opponents to Zohran Mamdani: 'They're Mamdani Democrats!'

Gleeful Republicans will make socialist Democratic mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani a key campaign issue as they pound 'Mamdani Democrats' running for election across the state, party insiders said. GOP officials will tie Mamdani to Democrat candidates from Long Island to upstate, with the idea the party will answer for the nomination in more moderate areas such as Staten Island, Nassau and Suffolk — and even places like Binghamton, The Post has learned. 'If there was ever any doubt that our city is headed in the wrong direction, this past Democratic mayoral primary election gave people their answer,' Staten Island Republican chairman Michael Tannousis said, noting Mamdani will be a campaign point even in judge races. 3 Republican candidates across New York state will attempt to tie their opponents to New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani, party insiders told The Post. Getty Images 'Zohran Mamdani is the official nominee of the Staten Island Democratic Party,' he added. 'In November, Staten Island voters will have a choice: whether they will vote for Zohran Mamdani's socialist Democratic Party or the Republican candidates they trust.' Republican nominee Remy Smith, a Housing Court judge, was set to kick off her campaign Sunday against Democrat attorney Matthew Santamauro for a civil court seat on the island. Tannousis said that the Democrat is running on 'the Mamdani ticket.' Mamdani's name will 'absolutely' be used as a weapon against Democrats in Suffolk County, where Republican District Attorney Ray Tierney is up for re-election and 18 county legislative seats are up for grabs, the GOP chairman said. 'The Democratic Party has anointed a communist as the face of the party,' party chairman Jesse Garcia said. 'hey've embraced his policy of defunding the police, antisemitism and higher taxes. Not one Democrat in Suffolk County has denounced Mamdani. 'Our policies are more in tune with Suffolk voters,' Garcia claimed. 'We are going to compare our Republican candidates' records of making Suffolk safer and affordable compared to the Mamdani Democrats' that advocate communism, loss of property rights, antisemitic views, higher taxes and defund the police.' 3 New York Republicans hope that Mamdani will hurt Democrats in more moderate areas like Long Island or upstate. Paul Martinka Mamdani identifies himself as a democratic socialist but he has come under fire for declaring in a resurfaced clip that one of his goals is 'seizing the means of production' — which critics note reeks of the approach of communist regimes. Meanwhile, Republicans in Nassau County will claim that Democrats there share the 'dangerous and reckless Mamdani agenda,' said Nassau GOP chairman Joe Cairo. There are dozens of county, town and village seats up for election in November. The headliner countywide races include Republicans seeking re-election — County Executive Bruce Blakeman Bruce Blakeman, DA Anne Donnelly and Comptroller Elaine Phillips. Cairo called Mamdani and extreme socialist who will destroy the city's economy and make 'Gotham a lawless haven for criminals.' 'Sadly, Zohran Mamdani shares more than a political party line with his Long Island Democrats – he shares a corrosive and dangerous agenda that embraces defunding the police, cashless bail, closing jails, and soaring taxes,' Cairo said. 'Every Nassau County Republican candidate on the ballot — from county legislators to town supervisors – stand firmly against the out-of-touch priorities of Zohran Mamdani and the Democrat candidates in Nassau County who clearly share the dangerous and reckless Mamdani Agenda.' Mamdani's earth-shattering election win in last month's crowded Democratic primary has made him the immediate frontrunner to become New York's next mayor — but the win has not gone unnoticed by upstate Republicans, either. 'We will be ready to strike once voters are educated about Zohran Mamdani. Mamdani is out of touch with the voters here,' said Broome County Republican Party Benji Federman, which includes the city of Binghamton. Binghamton Republican Mayor Jared Kraham is running for re-election in the Democratic-leaning city against Miles Burnett. Start and end your day informed with our newsletters Morning Report and Evening Update: Your source for today's top stories Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters The upstate city is part of the economically struggling Southern Tier that borders Pennsylvania and higher taxes that Mamdani is proposing for the Big Apple are out of sync with the region, the GOP leader said. Federman said he even has liberal friends in Williamsburg, Brooklyn who are terrified of a Mamdani mayoralty. 'Proposals to raise corporate taxes and taxes on the rich are not popular in Williamsburg and not popular in the Southern Tier,' he said. 3 The Post's coverage of Mamdani's meeting with city business leaders. State Democratic Party chairman Jay Jacobs said the GOP scare tactics of trying to make Mamdani the bogeyman won't work, especially when they have to defend President Trump's hardline policies. 'Typical Republican distraction. Should we tie every Nassau Republican to that nut, Marjorie Taylor Green [Georgia congresswoman] or the assorted antisemites that Trump regularly socializes with?' said Jacobs, also the Nassau County Democratic leader. 'We will do fine just tying them to that Big Ugly Bill that will cause health insurance rates to go through the roof,' added Jacobs, referring to the tax and spending bill approved by Trump and the Republican-led Congress. Jacobs has not endorsed Mamdani. Neither have Senate Democratic Minority leader Chuck Schumer and House Democratic Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, both Brooklynites. Mamdani, who is vacationing in his native Uganda, will face Republican Curtis Sliwa and three independents in the November election. Current Mayor Eric Adams, ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo and attorney Jim Walden will each appear on city election ballots on minor party lines. The Mamdani campaign had no immediate comment.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store