How 'genetics' ads from American Eagle and Dunkin' triggered a cultural firestorm
Fox News Digital breaks down how it happened, what people are saying and whether experts feel if this kind of advertising signals a broader trend to come.
Sweeney paired up with clothing brand American Eagle for its fall clothing campaign, titled "Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans," which sparked a mix of reactions on social media.
In a promo video posted to the brand's Instagram, the 27-year-old walked toward an American Eagle billboard featuring her and the tagline "Sydney Sweeney Has Great Genes." Sweeney crossed out "Genes" and replaced it with "Jeans" before walking away.
Sydney Sweeney's Racy Ad Sparks Outrage But Fans Defend Anti-'woke' Style
Liberal media outlets and progressive commentators fretted over what they deemed coded language from American Eagle about White supremacy and eugenics.
Read On The Fox News App
On ABC's "GMA First Look" Tuesday, the show featured a clip of Kean University professor Robin Landa linking Sweeney's "good jeans" to the eugenics movement.
Liberal outlets like Salon piled in on the backlash, with the outlet's weekend editor CK Smith also linking the tagline of Sweeney's ad to "eugenics movements."
"The advertisement, the choice of Sweeney as the sole face in it and the internet's reaction reflect an unbridled cultural shift toward Whiteness, conservatism and capitalist exploitation. Sweeney is both a symptom and a participant," MSNBC producer Hanna Holland wrote in an MSNBC.com column on Monday.
In response, conservatives gleefully mocked their concerns.
WWE Hall of Famer Sgt. Slaughter appeared to be in Sweeney's corner, posting, "Attention (Sydney Sweeney), YOU GO GIRL," on X on Wednesday.
Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, posted, "Wow. Now the crazy Left has come out against beautiful women. I'm sure that will poll well."
Said OutKick host Clay Travis on his show, "We're repudiating this idea that fat people and woke people advertising works."
A Trump White House official also waded into the controversy, calling left-wing backlash and claims of a "shift toward Whiteness" more "cancel culture run amok."
Not that it was only liberals who took issue with the ad. The satire site Babylon Bee poked fun at conservatives who reveled in Sweeney's ad, saying they were cheering "the death of wokeness as America finally returned to its Christian roots of objectifying women's bodies to sell stuff."
Wwe Legend In Sydney Sweeney's Corner Following American Eagle Ad Furor
In addition to American Eagle, Dunkin' released a short spot for its new summer Refresher drinks on Tuesday featuring "The Summer I Turned Pretty" star, Gavin Casalegno. During the 35-second ad, the actor credited his summer tan to his "genetics."
In the ad, Casalegno sat near a swimming pool holding his Dunkin' Golden Hour Refresher beverage while he referenced his pop culture status as the "king of summer" along with his tan, saying, "Look, I didn't ask to be the king of summer. It just kind of happened," he said. "This tan? Genetics. I just got my color analysis back. Guess what? Golden Summer. Literally."
TikTok users hammered the spot on the platform, taking issue with Casalegno mentioning his genetics, comparing the advertisement to American Eagle. Posts included users decrying Dunkin', along with comments speculating the interest in appearance, "What's up with ads and the word genetics rn," one commenter shared, receiving 40,000 likes.
New Dunkin' Ad Mentioning 'Genetics' Follows Sydney Sweeney Ad In Triggering Social Media
Top Culture/Trending podcast host of The Determined Society, Shawn French, shared his take on what these viral moments mean culturally, and what he believes this signals for the future of advertisements, with Fox News Digital.
"This ad didn't go viral because of its fashion or branding. It became a lightning rod because it hit on deeper cultural anxieties," French told Fox News Digital. "In 2025, we live in a low-trust society where every piece of content is scrutinized for hidden meaning, bias or agenda. The Dunkin' and American Eagle ad wasn't just seen as a marketing play, it was interpreted as a statement, and depending on who you ask, it was either performative pandering or strategic trolling."
"That kind of symbolic over-analysis is now the norm. We've trained audiences to decode everything, and brands are feeling the pressure from both the left and the right," French explained.
French added that the backlash from conservatives, including satire, shows that even "the culture war crowd" is becoming exhausted by what they feel to be inauthentic branding, and that progressives also criticize without any real substance.
"This isn't about jeans or coffee. It's about what side of the cultural fence people think you're on and if you're trying too hard to sell 'belonging' instead of building it," French said.
When it comes to the future of advertising, French said that this moment reveals consumers have lost trust in storytelling by corporations, and that brands are being picked apart for "allegiance."
"That kind of symbolic paranoia is a direct reflection of where we are as a culture: fractured, hyper-interpretive and desperate to know what and who we're really supporting," French said.
'The Five': Will Woke Outrage Over Sydney Sweeney Ad Help Dems With Their 'Glaring' Man Problem?
While some have dubbed the American Eagle and Dunkin' campaigns "tone-deaf" due to the alleged racial undertones, others have praised the actress for killing "woke" advertising.
Advertisements of the past have a history of marketing based on looks and attractiveness — including fellow clothing producer Abercrombie & Fitch, which some believe promotes exclusivity.
CEO Mike Jeffries once said about his brand, "We go after the cool kids… a lot of people don't belong."
Other well-known advertisements featuring marketing tactics tied directly to appearance include makeup company Maybelline Cosmetics' tagline, "Maybe she's born with it," which some argue is a reference to genetic inheritance.
Despite the controversy, The Times reports that American Eagle has garnered more than $65 million in free advertising since the Sweeney advertisement launched on July 23 — with over four billion impressions. Comparatively, the clothing brand was operating at a $68 million loss in May of 2025. And $200 million was added to American Eagle's market capitalization by Monday.
The War On Hot Women: Why The Woke Mob Hates Sydney Sweeney
Public Relations and branding expert Eric Schiffer told Business Insider that, in reference to Sweeney, "She's going to be even bigger because of this."
At the time of this article, no official numbers had been released for Dunkin' following the advertisement launch on July 29.
When it comes to the future of business for brands, French noted that brands are judged by perceptions of their audiences by what the meaning of their advertisement is, not just what's being said.
"Brands need to understand this isn't business as usual anymore. Every campaign is a Rorschach test, and people are no longer buying just for the product they're buying (or boycotting) what it represents," French said.
Representatives for Dunkin', American Eagle, Sydney Sweeney and Gavin Casalegno have not responded to requests for comment.Original article source: How 'genetics' ads from American Eagle and Dunkin' triggered a cultural firestorm
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
American Eagle Defends Sydney Sweeney Ad Campaign Amid Controversy: ‘Her Jeans. Her Story… Great Jeans Look Good on Everyone'
American Eagle is standing by its controversial ad campaign featuring Sydney Sweeney, which includes various commercials with the tagline: 'Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans.' The campaign creates a pun around 'great genes,' which ignited outrage online over American Eagle glorifying the Emmy nominee's white heritage and thin physique. Some users on social media even compared the ads to 'Nazi propaganda.' 'Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans' is and always was about the jeans. Her jeans. Her story,' the company said in a statement posted on social media. 'We'll continue to celebrate how everyone wears their AE jeans with confidence, their way. Great jeans look good on everyone. More from Variety JD Vance Urges Democrats Angry Over Sydney Sweeney Jeans Ads to Keep It Up: 'Continue to Tell Everybody' Who Thinks She Is Attractive That They're 'a Nazi' White House Says Liberal Outrage Over Sydney Sweeney's American Eagle Jeans Commercial Is 'Moronic' and a 'Big Reason Americans' Voted for Trump Katy O'Brian Says Sydney Sweeney 'Didn't Care' About Getting Hurt During Fight Scenes in Christy Martin Biopic: 'She Was Like, "If You Break My Nose, That's Fine"' Sweeney's American Eagle campaign caused so much chatter online that even Trump's White House weighed in on the backlash, with communications manager Steven Cheung calling the backlash a prime example of 'cancel culture run amok.' 'This warped, moronic and dense liberal thinking is a big reason why Americans voted the way they did in 2024,' Cheung added. 'They're tired of this bullshit.' Vice president JD Vance also mocked liberals for creating a hysteria around the American Eagle campaign, saying on an episode of the 'Ruthless' podcast: 'My political advice to the Democrats is continue to tell everybody who thinks Sydney Sweeney is attractive is a Nazi. That appears to be their actual strategy.' Vance continued, 'I mean, it actually reveals something pretty interesting about the Dems, though, which is that you have, like, a normal all-American beautiful girl doing like a normal jeans ad, right? They're trying to sell, you know, sell jeans to kids in America and they have managed to so unhinge themselves over this thing. And it's like, you guys, did you learn nothing from the November 2024 election? I actually thought that one of the lessons [Democrats] might take is we're going to be less crazy. And the lesson they have apparently taken is we're going to attack people as Nazis for thinking Sydney Sweeney is beautiful.' Even Stephen Colbert, who frequently speaks out against Trump and the White House, called the backlash against Sweeney and American Eagle overblown 'Now, some people look at [the ads] and they're seeing something sinister, saying that the genes-jeans denim wordplay in an ad featuring a white blond woman means American Eagle could be promoting eugenics, white supremacy and Nazi propaganda,' Colbert said this week on 'The Late Show.' 'That might be a bit of an overreaction.' Sweeney has yet to publicly comment on the outcry over the advertisements. Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week What's Coming to Disney+ in August 2025 What's Coming to Netflix in August 2025
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
American Eagle Responds to Backlash Over Sydney Sweeney Campaign: 'It Was Always About the Jeans'
American Eagle has responded after its latest denim campaign with actress Sydney Sweeney was greeted with an online backlash. The brand issued a statement on August 1 following backlash that the campaign slogan 'Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans' was a tone-deaf and offensive pun, one which some said was advocating for eugenics. The ad, which debuted on July 23, features the Euphoria and Anyone But You star modeling American Eagle denim as she is accompanied by her German shepherd, Sully Bear. In one of the campaign clips that has been widely shared, Sweeney says, 'Eyes up here,' as the camera pans across her body, with viewers questioning the intent of the commercial's sexual tone and marketing strategy. But it was not just the racy photos that created a buzz. Offense was taken at the headline 'Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans,' which was seen as an objectionable allusion to Sweeney's physical characteristics, such as her blonde hair, blue eyes, and white race, because of the homophone of 'jeans' and 'genes.' Critics took it a step further when some on social media linked the campaign to a legacy of beauty standards long predicated on exclusionary ideas. One since-removed version of the ad even called out Sweeney's blue eyes, fueling further speculation that the campaign was using retro, racially charged aesthetics. Some went as far as to say it was reminiscent of Nazi propaganda, with some accusing the brand of aping eugenics language for the sake of catchy wordplay. In an statement published on Instagram, American Eagle denied those claims: ''Sydney Sweeney has great jeans' is and always was about the jeans. Her jeans. Her story. We'll continue to celebrate how everyone wears their AE jeans with confidence, their way. Great jeans look good on everyone.' The company emphasized that the campaign's focus was denim and individuality, not genetics or appearances. However, there is still controversy over the tone and audience of the advertisement. Critics argued that the campaign was for the male gaze, despite being designed to sell women's clothing. An Instagram commenter wrote under AE's post, 'This was not the move AE, we needed and wanted something DIFFERENT as women.' The scandal has even touched the political arena. On July 29, Steven Cheung, Director of Communications at the White House, had this to say on X (formerly Twitter), 'Cancel culture run amok,' suggesting that the outrage over the advert might be overboard. As for Sydney Sweeney herself, the 27-year-old actress has remained largely removed from the drama. Aside from posting one image from the campaign on her Instagram grid, Sweeney has continued to post casual content featuring her dogs and snippets from her daily life, seemingly bypassing the media storm. While not the inaugural fashion brand to be rebuked for sexy denim ads, this does bring to mind past controversies, such as the 1980 Calvin Klein campaign starring a then-15-year-old Brooke Shields. The campaign included the line, 'You want to know what comes between me and my Calvins? Nothing.' Shields later told Vogue she was 'naive' to the ad's implications, although she did acknowledge its lasting cultural relevance. 'The controversy backfired,' Shields said in the 2021 interview. 'The campaign was really successful, and then the underwear overtook the jeans.' It remains to be seen if American Eagle's latest marketing mishap will have the same destiny or enjoy the same lifespan. In the meantime, the brand insists that it's standing by its campaign and standing by Sweeney. The post American Eagle Responds to Backlash Over Sydney Sweeney Campaign: 'It Was Always About the Jeans' appeared first on Where Is The Buzz | Breaking News, Entertainment, Exclusive Interviews & More. Solve the daily Crossword
CNN
4 hours ago
- CNN
Sydney Sweeney's American Eagle ad campaign sparks controversy
American Eagle's ad campaign featuring actress Sydney Sweeney has generated plenty of buzz and controversy for its tagline "Sydney Sweeney has great jeans," which sparked a debate about race, Western beauty standards, and the backlash to 'woke' American politics and culture. CNN's Elizabeth Wagmeister reports.
