Comparing Rangers, Devils, Islanders Starting Goalies
(Don't ask me to pick a winner now; it's still July.)
This past year only the Devils gained the postseason while both the Isles and Blueshirts missed. Next fall all three of the clubs will retain their top goalkeepers Jacob Markstrom in Newark, Igor Shesterkin in Manhattan and Ilya Sorokin on the Island.
To understate the issue, they bear watching.
Markstrom, obtained from Calgary, did what he was supposed to do; he gave the Devils just enough de luxe stopping to get them into the real season, alias the playoffs.
Shesterkin disappointed. Period: Sorokin was overworked and too often injured to be a positive factor.
A Few Things You Should Know About Rangers And Other NHL Friends THE GERARD GALLANT MYSTERY: The Maven is not sure about You, but I still can't figure out why Chris Drury ever fired Gerard Gallant. I liked the guy as player, as coach and as an individual. I bring him up now because Double G has signed on in the KHL – believe it or not – with the Kunlun team in China which plays in the K. (Thank You, Jim Cerny of Forever Blueshirts.)
What can we expect going forward? For the answer to that The Maven imported my Vice President In Charge Of Goalie Knowledge, the eminent Mel Melzer. Take it away,
Mel: "All three Met goalies are in remarkably similar situations," Melzer says. "We're talking about elite talents, but who have yet to truly cement their legacies in the postseason. Shesterkin already claimed a Vezina Trophy which meant that for one year at least he was the league's best. Ditto for Markstrom. But that's ancient history.
"Even though Sorokin has no Vezina to brag about ,he has been consistently elite. He was hobbled by a team weakened by injuries all season. Still, his performances have shown that he's on the Markstrom-Shesterkin level."
What's missing in each case?
Melzer: "What ties them together is not just raw ability but the need to evolve from being 'great goalies' into the guy who wins when it matters most. Playoff greatness still eludes them. It's not a matter of skill, it's a mindset shift that's necessary.
"Until that shift happens, we're left with tantalizing potential that hasn't translated into springtime success."
Because of the natural New York-New York rivalry between the Rangers and Islanders, "Who's Better?" debates rage on between the respective fan bases. With that in mind, The Maven asked Mel to pick a winner.
"Stylistically, Shesterkin and Sorokin mirror one another. Each is instinctive, agile and technically sound; not to mention emotionally composed. Watching Igor or Ilya in peak form is like a master class in modern goaltending." (Hmmm. No winner here.)
What about Markstrom? Is he better than the two Russians?
"The Swede brings a different flavor," Mel explains. "He has that towering frame and an authoritative presence. When he's on, he can look utterly unbeatable."
The issue here is that he has not been "on" enough.
"Let's face it," Mel concludes, "potential only gets you so far. It didn't the Rangers into the playoffs nor the Islanders and the Devils were gone faster than you can say 'Stop the puckl, Jake!'"
Then, a pause: "The pressure on all three is mounting. The 2025-26 season – especially the playoffs – will be a defining chapter for all three!"
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Julio Rodriguez Makes History With Fourth Straight 20-20 Season
Julio Rodriguez homered to become the first player in major league history with 20 or more home runs and 20 or more stolen bases in each of his first four seasons, and the Seattle Mariners beat the Texas Rangers 5-4 on Sunday. Rodriguez hit a two-run shot in the third inning — his 100th career homer — and the slugging and speedy center fielder also added his 21st stolen base of the season after singling in the fifth inning. Jorge Polanco added a solo shot in the second and shortstop J.P. Crawford smacked a two-run blast in the fourth against Rangers starter Jacob deGrom (10-4), who became the fastest pitcher in major league history to reach 1,800 career strikeouts by games and innings on Sunday. The Rangers kept things close by pushing across three runs against Mariners starter Logan Evans (5-4), but only tallied one run against the Mariners bullpen before closer Andres Munoz locked down his 25th save of the season. Reporting by The Associated Press. Want great stories delivered right to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports account, and follow leagues, teams and players to receive a personalized newsletter daily!
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
The Hockey Maven Picks His Five Favorite Rangers
Anybody can like a star; it's the easiest thing in the world. But only a special few can root hard for the lesser lights. The Maven happens to be one of them. So, here's the summertime edition of "My Five Favorite Rangers." By the way, no agreement on your part is necessary. After all, we can agree to disagree, can't we? (Please say yes, or I might just might shed a tear.) 1. WILL CUYLLE: I especially like guys who come out of nowhere and suddenly emerge as useful characters. This 23-year-old, 6-3, 210 pounder out of Toronto is more than useful. He hits; hits some more, scores and coach Sullivan only wishes he had ten more like him. Plus, More-Than-Willing Will has emerged as a key figure in "The New Core." (What's not to like?) 2. JONNY BRODZINSKI: Ham Lake, Minnesota's gift to Manhattan was listed as "fifth center" a year ago. That was another way of saying, "Enjoy, Hartford, Pal." And, if you really wanna know the truth, 32-year-old Brod would have been perfectly happy, working with young Wolf Pack prospects. But Jonny was such a successful fill-in that management preferred him with the Big Club. (He should be a fixture this year.) 3. BRADEN SCHNEIDER: Unobtrusively, and without any fuss or fanfare this model of a solid, all-round defender should be regarded as the Number Two blue liner right behind Adam Fox. Just 24, Schneid has reached his prime simply by doing the right things at his position; as opposed to K'Andre Miller who was listed #2 a year ago. (We found out what a mistake that was, didn't we?) Promise For The Rangers Or Failure? Who Do You Want To Believe? Let's not kid ourselves, at this point of midsummer it's impossible how the Rangers will fare in the fall, winter or spring next season. 4. ADAM EDSTROM: The Swede's buddy, Matt Rempe, could take some lessons from his alter ego skyscraper. Adam doesn't do what Matt does. Edstrom doesn't get suspended; he doesn't do crazy, illegal board checks and he plays smart. Rempe should have spent the summer taking lessons from Edstrom. Right now it appears that Adam is a sure thing in terms of making the varsity. The Remper? (No guarantees at this time.) 5. JONATHAN QUICK: The S.O.S. Man, Long Jon has become the backup goalie's backup goalie. He's also commodore-in-chief behind the scenes, especially in the clubhouse. (Quite frankly, if the spirit moved him. Quckie could shout "Hallelujah" and play two more seasons.)
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
The 10 greatest goals of Penguins captain Sidney Crosby's career
When you think of the Pittsburgh Penguins these days, you probably think negative thoughts. Rebuilding. Rough times. The glory days in the rear-view mirror. Still, you think of Sidney Crosby, and all of the associated special memories. The captain is still going strong and, because he turns 38 on Thursday, this week's articles will all focus on one of the greatest hockey players of all time. Advertisement To start off Crosby Week, I'm going to rank his 10 greatest goals. Now, 'great' can mean a lot of things, so for this ranking, I mostly considered the degree of difficulty, importance, and how memorable the goal was. If I were speaking to someone 100 years from now — and hey, assuming the internet exists 100 years from now, maybe I am — these are the 10 goals I'd pick to articulate Crosby's greatness. Crosby scored a goal in Arizona during his rookie year while falling down. You'll never see another goal quite like it. Crosby skated through the entire Rangers team — literally — while scoring one of the great goals of his career in 2006. Crosby whacked a puck not once, but twice, out of midair in a brilliant effort against the Canadiens. It was opening day in Major League Baseball, so Crosby showed off his swing. His shot clanged off the post in overtime. He then somehow whacked the rebound out of midair — he had the presence of mind to wait until the puck dropped low enough so it wouldn't go as a high stick on the puck — and buried it home. Everyone in the building was speechless after this one. Crosby went sliding on the ice to catch up with a Mark Recchi pass and scored one of the great highlight-reel goals of his career. One of the fascinating statistics in hockey history is that Mario Lemieux, Gordie Howe and Mark Messier never won a postseason game in overtime. Wayne Gretzky did it only once. Crosby, too, has lit the lamp in overtime only once in his storied career. But it couldn't have come at a much bigger moment. The Penguins lost Game 1 of the Eastern Conference final against Tampa Bay in 2016 and blew a 2-0 lead on home ice in Game 2, sending the game to overtime. In net for the Lightning was a somewhat unknown but freakishly talented rookie named Andrei Vasilevskiy. Advertisement Crosby took a feed from Bryan Rust in overtime and whipped a shot past the Tampa Bay goaltender to even the series and give Crosby one up on Lemieux, his former landlord and his team's former owner. Right around the time Connor McDavid took the crown from Crosby as the world's greatest hockey player, Crosby reminded the young star of his greatness. With the score knotted at 5 in overtime in Edmonton, Crosby danced around two Oilers and, with McDavid helplessly watching from only a few feet away, finished off one of the great goals of his career. The goal was classic Crosby: It required exquisite edge work, hockey IQ, determination and a backhand that will stand the test of time. Even many of the Edmonton faithful politely applauded the effort. One of the joys of watching Crosby regularly is observing how elevated his hockey IQ is compared to other players. It's amazing to see the curiosity in his game as he experiments with something new. Back in 2017, when he was putting the finishing touches on his second Rocket Richard Trophy, Crosby very calmly shot a puck from an impossible angle off of Henrik Lundqvist's mask and into the net. He did it purposely, which adds an extra layer to one of his more incredible goals. Lundqvist was slightly annoyed after the game that Crosby would shoot a puck off his mask on purpose. Crosby was slightly annoyed that Lundqvist was annoyed. The Penguins-Rangers rivalry has always been a good one, and this moment only added to it. Crosby and Alex Ovechkin waged a war for the ages in the 2009 postseason. Each superstar scored eight goals in the second-round meeting between the Penguins and Capitals. But it was Crosby who notched two in the deciding Game 7 victory on Washington ice. With the game all but over in the third period, Crosby stripped Ovechkin of the puck and scored on a breakaway. Advertisement It was one of the most symbolic moments of Crosby's career, as he almost always found a way to rise to the occasion against his biggest rival, Ovechkin. These days, shootouts are something of a yawn fest. But that certainly wasn't the case in 2005. Crosby's first season marked the NHL's first time using shootouts to determine victories. His first shootout goal couldn't have been more historic. After all, it was the first time the Penguins ever won a game in a shootout, it was Crosby's first shootout goal, and it came on the night when Lemieux scored his final NHL goal. You got your money's worth if you attended this game. Lemieux was stopped on his shot, but Crosby then unleashed a backhand rocket that became one of the signature goals of his career. Given the circumstances, this is one of the greatest goals I've ever witnessed. The Penguins were down 3-2 in the 2016 Eastern Conference final heading into Game 6 in Tampa. That morning, Crosby and Evgeni Malkin sat quietly beside one another in the Penguins locker room, the final two people in the room after the morning skate. The pressure on them was immense. The Penguins hadn't won the Stanley Cup in seven years. They took a 2-0 lead, then Crosby scored the eventual winner on a brilliant individual effort that left Amalie Arena quiet. It was classic Crosby, as he displayed an initial back-check burst, and then showed the kind of edge work and determination that only he can. This was the night that Crosby decided he hated the Philadelphia Flyers. Derian Hatcher knocked out a few of his teeth, which the officials didn't deem worthy of a penalty. Crosby was then given a penalty for running his mouth to those officials. All the while, the Philadelphia crowd was having great fun taunting the 18-year-old phenom. Advertisement Crosby proceeded to set up a Ryan Malone goal and then score one of his own. Then, the game went to overtime, and Doc Emrick's legendary call: 'Crosby, the game on his stick' reverberates all of these years later. Crosby scored and didn't even smile as he skated toward his teammates. He's been taking it out on Philadelphia ever since. Well, Crosby scored on a one-handed backhand in Buffalo. I haven't a clue what else to say about this goal. Simply brilliant. You know a guy is great when the most famous goal in hockey history only ranks as his second greatest goal. Apologies to Canada, but I have to rank this one No. 1. Crosby hadn't played in almost a year because of a concussion that threatened his career. On his second shift, he erupted through the Islanders and scored a goal that Pittsburgh will never forget. If you can read lips, well, you know how excited he was. He was back. He was as good as ever. He was as competitive as ever. His sense of theater remained. Normal players don't miss that much time and do something like that on their second shift back. Great players don't even do that. The greatest players of all time do. (Photo from 2011 Islanders game: Justin K. Aller / Getty Images)
